Welcome
Login:   Pass:     Register - Forgot Password - Resend Activation

Turkish Class Forums / General/Off-topic

General/Off-topic

Add reply to this discussion
Political Views Of Authors
(20 Messages in 2 pages - View all)
[1] 2
1.       gokuyum
1948 posts
 19 Jan 2011 Wed 02:31 am

Do you think we should appreciate an author´s works without considering his/her political views? How can we act if we dont like his/her ideas? There are many great authors who were/are criticised because of their political opinions by people. Some of them were/are accused of being a traitor, some of them of being a religious fanatic, some of them of being a communist and many many other things. Do you think their approaches decrease the value of their works?

 

In my opinion we should appreciate authors´ works without considering their political views. Because everything change. It can also change what is right or wrong in the future. Yesterday´s traitor can become tomorrow´s hero. Or yesterday´s fanatic can become tomorrow´´s humanist, etc... Look at the past and now you can see the examples.



Edited (1/19/2011) by gokuyum
Edited (1/19/2011) by gokuyum
Edited (1/19/2011) by gokuyum
Edited (1/19/2011) by gokuyum
Edited (1/19/2011) by gokuyum
Edited (1/19/2011) by gokuyum

2.       barba_mama
1531 posts
 19 Jan 2011 Wed 04:52 pm

It depends on what the author is writing about, and how these views influence the writing. There is a difference between a romantic novel, a thriller, or a column in a newspaper.

3.       gokuyum
1948 posts
 20 Jan 2011 Thu 12:23 am

 

Quoting barba_mama

It depends on what the author is writing about, and how these views influence the writing. There is a difference between a romantic novel, a thriller, or a column in a newspaper.

 

Let me give an example. For example Pascal was a very religious man, does that have to decrease his works´ value for an atheist?  Or for example some Norwegians think Knut Hamsun was a traitor; does that have to  make his works less valuable for Norwegians?



Edited (1/20/2011) by gokuyum

4.       vineyards
1880 posts
 20 Jan 2011 Thu 01:22 am

We know that art has almost a sacred quality. Regardless of how artists may irritate people with their works sometimes, they are given a privilaged status and anger is usually directed at those who try to restrict artist´s right to express himself. We know that Adolf Hitler was an artist too. Assuming that his works live up to artistic standards and that they are still available; should we have them on display? 

5.       alameda
3195 posts
 23 Jan 2011 Sun 02:19 am

Ha ha...so true vineyards. I know when I was much younger I used to look to "artists" with reverence, that is, until I got to know more than a few. I found they are just as likely to be jerks as anyone else. In fact, many are very egoist, thinking theirselves to be very special in all areas. Being profound and informed thinkers is not always included in the list of gifts. 

All too often, the "art" produced  has little more value that a trained animal is capable of.

 

Quoting vineyards

We know that art has almost a sacred quality. Regardless of how artists may irritate people with their works sometimes, they are given a privilaged status and anger is usually directed at those who try to restrict artist´s right to express himself. We know that Adolf Hitler was an artist too. Assuming that his works live up to artistic standards and that they are still available; should we have them on display? 

 

 

6.       barba_mama
1531 posts
 25 Jan 2011 Tue 05:07 pm

 

Quoting gokuyum

 

 

Let me give an example. For example Pascal was a very religious man, does that have to decrease his works´ value for an atheist?  Or for example some Norwegians think Knut Hamsun was a traitor; does that have to  make his works less valuable for Norwegians?

 

It depends on what is field of work is. Pascal´s math is still math. There is not intervening of God in his mathematical work, so as an atheist you should not care about Pascal´s views in other parts of his life. However, if somebody is a pedofile, and writes books about children´s psychology and their development, you SHOULD take his sexual views into mind. There is too big a chance that his sexual preferences will influence his professional views.

 

7.       barba_mama
1531 posts
 25 Jan 2011 Tue 05:11 pm

 

Quoting vineyards

We know that art has almost a sacred quality. Regardless of how artists may irritate people with their works sometimes, they are given a privilaged status and anger is usually directed at those who try to restrict artist´s right to express himself. We know that Adolf Hitler was an artist too. Assuming that his works live up to artistic standards and that they are still available; should we have them on display? 

 

Hitler´s work was not up to standard. If it was, he probably would have just kept on paiting little trees and houses. Instead, he was pissed of since he did not get the credit for his work that he thought he deserved.

You can also turn this thought around. Hitler was a vegetarian. Should we think better of Hitler now that we know he was all for animal rights?

8.       gokuyum
1948 posts
 26 Jan 2011 Wed 04:36 pm

 

Quoting barba_mama

 

 

Hitler´s work was not up to standard. If it was, he probably would have just kept on paiting little trees and houses. Instead, he was pissed of since he did not get the credit for his work that he thought he deserved.

You can also turn this thought around. Hitler was a vegetarian. Should we think better of Hitler now that we know he was all for animal rights?

 

 Who decided Hitler´s works were not up to standart? And what if someone thinks they are valuable. Should we blame him/her?

9.       gokuyum
1948 posts
 26 Jan 2011 Wed 04:38 pm

 

Quoting barba_mama

 

 

It depends on what is field of work is. Pascal´s math is still math. There is not intervening of God in his mathematical work, so as an atheist you should not care about Pascal´s views in other parts of his life. However, if somebody is a pedofile, and writes books about children´s psychology and their development, you SHOULD take his sexual views into mind. There is too big a chance that his sexual preferences will influence his professional views.

 

 

 What if a pedophile writes a book about history, does this make the book less valuable?

10.       alameda
3195 posts
 26 Jan 2011 Wed 11:11 pm

Actually, pederasty was an accepted part of Greek culture, but much of their works are considered very valuable. Read about Pederasty in Greek culture.

Is not Socrates considered an important scholar/author? The list is quite long....who ever is interested can do their own research.

Quoting gokuyum

 What if a pedophile writes a book about history, does this make the book less valuable?



Edited (1/27/2011) by alameda [spelling]

(20 Messages in 2 pages - View all)
[1] 2
Add reply to this discussion




Turkish Dictionary
Turkish Chat
Open mini chat
New in Forums
Test-4
tunci: nicely done job again Lana ! Aferin Sana..but one answer I cou...
Test-3
tunci: Nice try Lana !
İ Love YOU poem.
slavica: And who is the author of this lovely poem? You?
Yalin songs
tristerecuerdos: I like Yalin! My favorite song of his is "Son ... Lyrics: Deli o...
E to T
Inscrutable : Yemek yemekten ... musun? Did you enjoy your food (lunch)? Thank you
E to T
Inscrutable : Tunci thanks
I miss you - Eng to Turk
tristerecuerdos: Lol this is too old to actually help with. but I´m too bored.. s...
Robin Gibb dies
slavica: And their first big hit and probably the most popular: ...
A test for the beginners
tunci: In fact to prevent confusion 1. we can put comma after ... B...
turk - eng
deli: the rest I translated sometime ago ...
Test-2
Bambib: Lana- WOWWWW good for you
www.turkiyenotturkey.com
si++: I see that letter every now and then and I tought it was some ...
Random Pictures of Turkey
Add thumbnails like this to your site
Most liked
Alphabet

Turkish lesson by admin
Level: beginner
Major Vowel Harmony

Turkish lesson by admin
Level: beginner
Noun states

Turkish lesson by admin
Level: beginner
Pronouns 2

Turkish lesson by admin
Level: beginner
Quran Quran

Picture by cilek
The inside of Selimiye Camii 4 The inside of Selimiye Camii 4

Picture by Platschu
Must, Have to, Need to, Want to

Turkish lesson by admin
Level: intermediate
House and furniture

Turkish lesson by admin
Level: beginner
Vowel Rules

Turkish lesson by admin
Level: beginner
To be

Turkish lesson by admin
Level: beginner