Welcome
Login:   Pass:     Register - Forgot Password - Resend Activation

Turkish Class Forums / Turkey

Turkey

Add reply to this discussion
Moderators: libralady, sonunda
A Cultural Question
(23 Messages in 3 pages - View all)
[1] 2 3
1.       TimRoy
27 posts
 29 Dec 2005 Thu 01:16 pm

I get the feeling I might already be able to guess some of the answer, but I'd rather hear it from actual Turks.

One thing I've noticed over time from talking to my Turkish friends from high school and from a Turkish woman I met earlier this year is that Turks seem to compartmentalize anything from the Ottoman era as being done by "someone else." "That was the Ottoman Empire..."

Yes, it was effectively a different country, but wasn't it more or less the same "people?" By this I mean, weren't the Ottomans Turks?

To me, coming from a European/American perspective this is rather curious. Italians seem rather proud of their Roman forebearers (though perhaps the historical distance makes this easier). I was intrigued when I found out I was a rather distant descendant of a european Emperor (not Roman). I have a difficulty understanding why today's Turks seem to want to distance themselves from the Ottoman Empire.

Of course, the one counter-argument that I could come up with to all of that is that the single most popular name amongst Turkish guys I went to school with was Suleiman. I think I know who they were named after.

2.       miss_ceyda
2627 posts
 29 Dec 2005 Thu 01:22 pm

thats interesting that u say that because most of the ones who i have come accross seem to have the total opposite opinion....
tell me experts... what does that mean??

3.       Deli_kizin
6376 posts
 29 Dec 2005 Thu 01:44 pm

Yes, i also had the feeling that Turks are rather proud of their country.. i've been told most of them know the history of their country damn well..

Funny thing is, ive never felt the 'urge' to learn about dutch history, but i seem to feel that i wanna learn Turkish history.. does anyone suggest a simple book about history? I got one from my boyfriend, but it's very difficult to read.. i'd rather read something easy first and then read the difficult one. i havent got much time, so i prefer to learn by small and easy pieces Once i have more time, i'll conquer the big difficult stuff

4.       Boop
785 posts
 29 Dec 2005 Thu 01:55 pm

Yes - I agree Miss C and Deli - most Turks I have met are proud to say they are "grandsons of Ottomans"

5.       TimRoy
27 posts
 29 Dec 2005 Thu 02:25 pm

Quoting Deli_kizin:

Yes, i also had the feeling that Turks are rather proud of their country.. i've been told most of them know the history of their country damn well..



Wait, don't get me wrong. Every Turk I've met has seemed VERY PROUD of their country. Turkey that is though. And perhaps it's just that Turkey has such a recent vintage as a distinct nation. There just seems to always be a bit of a disconnect from anything that happened before Ataturk founded Turkey.

Let me give a bit of perspective on what I'm saying. This Turkish woman I met mentioned that most of her family lived in Saudi Arabia. She said that they lived there because there was work there. This gave me the impression that it was akin to the Turks in Deutschland. Moving to another country for work where they perhaps weren't made to feel all that welcome (that's the impression I got from her about her family's situation).

So in a perhaps foolish attempt to appeal to her Turkish nationalism, I mentioned that at one point Turks had ruled over Saudi Arabia. At that point I got the whole "That was the Ottoman Empire, but since 19XX when Turkey was founded by..." Ataturk litany.

So is it less of a historical disconnect with the Ottoman Empire and more of the general reverence towards Ataturk? I'm not meaning to insult or aggravate anyone, I have just noticed tendencies of conversations on multiple topics with many different Turks to go in the same sorts of directions over the years.

Is it that Ataturk is the end of that part of history and the beginning of this part? Kind of like how from a European perspective on history everything is relative to Christ, inasmuch as the dating system centers upon him.

And no, I realize that Turks don't worship Ataturk as a god. I'm just pulling the best comparison I can think of for a certain individual being the turning point of history.

6.       Deli_kizin
6376 posts
 29 Dec 2005 Thu 02:36 pm

Ok, i understand you Looking forward to hear a smart answer from a smart.. ottoman? turk? anyone?

7.       TimRoy
27 posts
 29 Dec 2005 Thu 02:49 pm

From a Turk, silly. I'm fairly certain all of the Ottomans are now deceased. OK, I'm not going to put a smiley on that one.

As a footnote, most folks here in the U.S. that aren't well-educated probably don't even know that there ever was an Ottoman Empire. When they hear "Ottoman," they think of a piece of furniture.

Our "global stupidity" over here isn't necessarily intentional, we're just geographically isolated. Americans tend to look down on Mexicans and think of Canadians as Americans that say "aboot" and enjoy hockey a bit too much.

Because we tend to not travel to other countries we also tend not to learn much about them. We are a very parochial people. I'm embarrassed to admit the only other country I've ever been to is Canada. And that's because I lived around 70 miles from the border. That's one more country than about 95% of Americans have been to.

I suppose the most I can say for myself is that I'm at least interested in learning about other countries. Hence my questions here.

8.       SuiGeneris
3922 posts
 29 Dec 2005 Thu 03:20 pm

i am a Turk! and i am proud of some what my ancestors did and some sad about the other things.. but ppl need to be fine with their past and this doesnt have to affect what they will do... and this doesnt affect their looking to humanbeings.. anyway if you wanna learn about Ottoman Empires there was a book with 5 volumes and it was the most objective one i met.. and i totally recommend you to read the Kemal Atatürks "NUTUK" to learn about near past...

9.       milien
1 posts
 29 Dec 2005 Thu 04:44 pm

if you want to read more about turkish history you should read the cresent and the star. i cannot remember who it ıs by, but it gives a great perspective on turkey without being very pro or very con turkry

10.       miss_ceyda
2627 posts
 29 Dec 2005 Thu 10:40 pm

Quoting milien:

if you want to read more about turkish history you should read the cresent and the star. i cannot remember who it ıs by, but it gives a great perspective on turkey without being very pro or very con turkry



that sounds interesting.. who is the author??

(23 Messages in 3 pages - View all)
[1] 2 3
Add reply to this discussion




Turkish Dictionary
Turkish Chat
Open mini chat
New in Forums
Why yer gördüm but yeri geziyorum
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, makes perfect sense!
Etmeyi vs etmek
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much!
Görülmez vs görünmiyor
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, very well explained!
Içeri and içeriye
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much for the detailed ...
Present continous tense
HaydiDeer: Got it, thank you!
Hic vs herhangi, degil vs yok
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much!
Rize Artvin Airport Transfer - Rize Tours
rizetours: Dear Guest; In order to make your Black Sea trip more enjoyable, our c...
What does \"kabul ettiğini\" mean?
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much for the detailed ...
Kimse vs biri (anyone)
HaydiDeer: Thank you!
Random Pictures of Turkey
Most commented