Welcome
Login:   Pass:     Register - Forgot Password - Resend Activation

Turkish Class Forums / Language

Language

Add reply to this discussion
nouns to verbs?
1.       hedef
363 posts
 26 Jan 2009 Mon 03:59 pm

merhaba

this might be a very simple question

 

how could transfere a noun  into a verb in turkish?

does it like english depend only on its postion in the statement?:

 

eg: Answer the following: (the word answer is a verb)

    : the following answer is.... ( the word answer here is a noun)

 

so in turkish answer=cevap  (this is the noun)

what about its verb?

 

and what does cevapla means?

or cevaplasana?

 

 

thank you very much in advance for any explaination because i sometime gets realy confuced specialy in adding the suffixes

 

 

 

2.       coldplay
11 posts
 26 Jan 2009 Mon 04:02 pm

 

Quoting hedef

merhaba

this might be a very simple question

 

how could transfere a noun  into a verb in turkish?

does it like english depend only on its postion in the statement?:

 

eg: Answer the following: (the word answer is a verb)

    : the following answer is.... ( the word answer here is a noun)

 

so in turkish answer=cevap  (this is the noun)

what about its verb?

 

and what does cevapla means?

or cevaplasana?

 

 

thank you very much in advance for any explaination because i sometime gets realy confuced specialy in adding the suffixes

when learning a new language please forget the language you know,otherwise you cant match it

 

3.       hedef
363 posts
 26 Jan 2009 Mon 04:09 pm

thank you for the advice

but how could i then understand the new language if i can´t match it or translate it with the one i know??

4.       caliptrix
3055 posts
 26 Jan 2009 Mon 04:10 pm

 

Quoting hedef

merhaba

this might be a very simple question

 

how could transfere a noun  into a verb in turkish?

does it like english depend only on its postion in the statement?:

 

eg: Answer the following: (the word answer is a verb)

    : the following answer is.... ( the word answer here is a noun)

 

so in turkish answer=cevap  (this is the noun)

what about its verb?

 

and what does cevapla means?

or cevaplasana?

 

 

thank you very much in advance for any explaination because i sometime gets realy confuced specialy in adding the suffixes

 

In English, there is no rule like that. answer is just one example for what you say, but that is not a rule. For example; "to ask" is the verb but the noun form is "the question". As you see there is no relation between them. In Turkish, there is no rule like you asked either.

 

Besides your question about the rule; cevaplamak is the verb for "to answer". Another phrase is "cevap vermek"

5.       coldplay
11 posts
 26 Jan 2009 Mon 04:15 pm

 

Quoting hedef

thank you for the advice

but how could i then understand the new language if i can´t match it or translate it with the one i know??

 

i mean turkish and english languages´ grammatical structure is totally different,thats why combination and order of words are also different

just an example

to ask=sor-mak mak is equal to To,but you write at the beginning we say in the end of the word,so when you want to make translation you cant make word translation,you can only make meaning translation...do not care what people say..

6.       hedef
363 posts
 26 Jan 2009 Mon 04:19 pm

ok

thank you caliptrix and coldplay

7.       Melek74
1506 posts
 27 Jan 2009 Tue 03:43 am

I think it is misleading and dimissive to say that there´s no rules in Turkish to form verbs out of nouns. There are certain "verb-forming" suffixes in Turkish that can be addedd to certain root words (such as nouns or adjectives) to make them into verbs, for example suffixes such as: -aþ, -la, -lan, -landýr, -laþ, -sa, etc. There´s also plenty of examples where verbs are formed out of nouns (especially those of foreign origin) by using the so called auxiliary verbs, such as etmek, vermek or olmak.

 

Whereas I do agree that it´s counterproductive to try to exactly match one language to another, and when it comes to forming verbs out of nouns it´s probably much easier to learn the verbs separately instead of trying to create them out of nouns, I do think it´s important to at least be aware of the above to be able to recognize it, in such a word, as for example cevap-la-mak, which has the -la verb forming suffix.

 

 

8.       Melek74
1506 posts
 27 Jan 2009 Tue 04:33 am

 

Quoting caliptrix

In English, there is no rule like that. answer is just one example for what you say, but that is not a rule. For example; "to ask" is the verb but the noun form is "the question". As you see there is no relation between them. In Turkish, there is no rule like you asked either.

 

Besides your question about the rule; cevaplamak is the verb for "to answer". Another phrase is "cevap vermek"

 

There´s no relation between ask and question because they are 2 different words. You can make a verb out of the noun "question", simply by sticking "to" in front of it - "to question" - and in English, most of the time you can make verbs out of nouns either by using "to" or auxiliary verbs (do, make, have, etc.). Of course in many cases you´d be making words up (I can imagine forming a verb out of the noun "liver", for example, that would make any sense), but that doesn´t mean that forming verbs out of nouns is all random in English.

9.       hedef
363 posts
 27 Jan 2009 Tue 12:42 pm

 

Quoting Melek74

I think it is misleading and dimissive to say that there´s no rules in Turkish to form verbs out of nouns. There are certain "verb-forming" suffixes in Turkish that can be addedd to certain root words (such as nouns or adjectives) to make them into verbs, for example suffixes such as: -aþ, -la, -lan, -landýr, -laþ, -sa, etc. There´s also plenty of examples where verbs are formed out of nouns (especially those of foreign origin) by using the so called auxiliary verbs, such as etmek, vermek or olmak.

 

Whereas I do agree that it´s counterproductive to try to exactly match one language to another, and when it comes to forming verbs out of nouns it´s probably much easier to learn the verbs separately instead of trying to create them out of nouns, I do think it´s important to at least be aware of the above to be able to recognize it, in such a word, as for example cevap-la-mak, which has the -la verb forming suffix.

 

thank you melek74

the suffix, that was my question. it sort of cleared out now.

 

Add reply to this discussion




Turkish Dictionary
Turkish Chat
Open mini chat
New in Forums
Crossword Vocabulary Puzzles for Turkish L...
qdemir: You can view and solve several of the puzzles online at ...
Giriyor vs Geliyor.
lrnlang: Thank you for the ...
Local Ladies Ready to Play in Your City
nifrtity: ... - Discover Women Seeking No-Strings Attached Encounters in Your Ci...
Geçmekte vs. geçiyor?
Hoppi: ... and ... has almost the same meaning. They are both mean "i...
Intermediate (B1) to upper-intermediate (B...
qdemir: View at ...
Why yer gördüm but yeri geziyorum
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, makes perfect sense!
Random Pictures of Turkey
Most commented