Welcome
Login:   Pass:     Register - Forgot Password - Resend Activation

Turkish Class Forums / Turkish Politics

Turkish Politics

Thread locked by a moderator or admin.
Traces of stones!!
(60 Messages in 6 pages - View all)
1 [2] 3 4 5 6
10.       cynicmystic
567 posts
 19 Feb 2009 Thu 06:19 pm

I disagree with you on having to read handsom´s posts carefully simply because I consider this fellow poser (sorry I meant poster) to be extremely biased. I detest the logic of illogicality in most of his posts and arguments. I also find his tone, in most occasions, but particularly in this one, rather  insincere. His choice of words are on purpose ´charged´.  If I may take an excursion into crudity, I have noticed that it is his fine specialty to post things for the purpose of ´stirring shit´.

 

He probably knows perfectly well that the article he posted does not have much to do with the Gaza issue. He could have simply posted the article and objected to the fact that the prosecuter may be asking 25-40 years for 12 year olds, which would have been perfectly fine. I think it would be unfair to impose such harsh terms on children, but also think that they will not receive such a harsh sentence even if the prosecutors ask for it. Additionally, he posts a picture with the children showing their hands in the presence of another adult, where there are a couple of cops standing by. Then we are told that the cops are looking for traces of stones in their hands. Although he takes the time to sum up the article for us and add the picture, the link to the article in his original post does not work. So, I have to ask for it.

 

If the original article suggested that the cops were looking for traces of stones in the children´s hands, then we can all assume that this is very poor journalism, as I don´t think anyone is dumb enough to think that stones leave marks in one´s hands.

 

His post lacks coherence in other ways, too. Aside from the irrelevance of the issue to the Gaza misery, and the bogus journalism of suggesting that the Turkish cops are looking for marks or evidence of stones in children´s hands, handsom´s argument completely side-steps the fact that you will be arrested in any country, if you throw stones at the police. You will also be charged with many things ranging from assaulting a police officer, illegal protest etc, and in most cases the prosecuter will always go for the highest charges knowing well that the final decree of the judge will be way below what the prosecuter seeked in the first place - especially in a cese like this one.

 

I am not against handsom or anyone else criticizing Turkey and its policies. I criticize them myself, and disagree with many things that happen in Turkey, just as I criticize many other countries and their policies. But, I do try to be impartial. When handsom learns how to post things on the politics section without being biased and without attempting to ´stir shit´ deliberately, then I will take him seriously.

Quoting peacetrain

 

 

 I think it´s important to read theH´s post in full to get the correct meaning:

 

Quote: thehandsom

Do you know what they are doing here?


Police is checking the boys hands, if there are any ´trace of stones´ (because those young boys 10,12,14 years old threw stones to police)

 

They are arresting those kids if they see some..

 

And the prosecuters have right to ask a jail sentance for the minors from 23 years to 40 years.
Apperantly 19 minors  are in jail and still in the court from last years events.

 

We all have saddened about palestinian childeren.

Many Turks felt the same anger about Israel´s actions..

But what about these?

25-40 year jail sentence for childeren? 

Just for throwing stones?

I think it´s clear that theH is talking about the possibility of such long jail sentences ie. if the prosecutors get their way.

 

I think the comparison with the plight of children in Gaza was misguided but I understand the point he is trying to make. 

 

If the prosecutors "have the right" does that mean they have actually asked for such long sentences? 

 

If the authorities were using last year´s arrests and detentions as a deterrent, seems it didn´t work. 

 

 

11.       thehandsom
7403 posts
 19 Feb 2009 Thu 10:15 pm

 

Quoting cynicmystic

I disagree with you on having to read handsom´s posts carefully simply because I consider this fellow poser (sorry I meant poster) to be extremely biased. I detest the logic of illogicality in most of his posts and arguments. I also find his tone, in most occasions, but particularly in this one, rather  insincere. His choice of words are on purpose ´charged´.  If I may take an excursion into crudity, I have noticed that it is his fine specialty to post things for the purpose of ´stirring shit´.

 

 

 

Result of being annoyed and frasturated..And clearly trying to get personal.

Not worth replying.. 

 

Quote:

He probably knows perfectly well that the article he posted does not have much to do with the Gaza issue. He could have simply posted the article and objected to the fact that the prosecuter may be asking 25-40 years for 12 year olds, which would have been perfectly fine. I think it would be unfair to impose such harsh terms on children, but also think that they will not receive such a harsh sentence even if the prosecutors ask for it. Additionally, he posts a picture with the children showing their hands in the presence of another adult, where there are a couple of cops standing by. Then we are told that the cops are looking for traces of stones in their hands. Although he takes the time to sum up the article for us and add the picture, the link to the article in his original post does not work. So, I have to ask for it.

 

If the original article suggested that the cops were looking for traces of stones in the children´s hands, then we can all assume that this is very poor journalism, as I don´t think anyone is dumb enough to think that stones leave marks in one´s hands.

 

 

The police were doing exactly what I wrote..One of the links I gave above should prove that..

If the police were doing what I wrote, will you apologize? OK, forget the apology, will you condemn it as much as I did? 

 

Quote:

 

 

 

His post lacks coherence in other ways, too. Aside from the irrelevance of the issue to the Gaza misery, and the bogus journalism of suggesting that the Turkish cops are looking for marks or evidence of stones in children´s hands, handsom´s argument completely side-steps the fact that you will be arrested in any country, if you throw stones at the police.

Result of being annoyed and frasturated..And clearly trying to get personal.

Not worth replying.. 

 

Quote:

You will also be charged with many things ranging from assaulting a police officer, illegal protest etc, and in most cases the prosecuter will always go for the highest charges knowing well that the final decree of the judge will be way below what the prosecuter seeked in the first place - especially in a cese like this one.

 

Yes. In countries such as  Saudi arabia, Egypt,  Pakistan etc..

You should be ashamed of yourself for putting Turkey´s democracy with  those countries..

 

 

 

I am not against handsom or anyone else criticizing Turkey and its policies. I criticize them myself, and disagree with many things that happen in Turkey, just as I criticize many other countries and their policies. But, I do try to be impartial. When handsom learns how to post things on the politics section without being biased and without attempting to ´stir shit´ deliberately, then I will take him seriously.

 

 

 

Where is impartiality in my post?

did that incident I mentioned in my post happen? YES

It is upto you if you take ´your own country´s childeren taken to court and jailed´ seriously..

Well..

I do..

12.       cynicmystic
567 posts
 19 Feb 2009 Thu 10:30 pm

What the hell are you talking about in countries like Pakistan Saudi Arabia etc. Are you a moron? What do you think would happen to you if you threw stones at a police officer in the US or Britain. You should be ashamed of yourself for being so clueless. Go google police brutality in the West you chump.

 

Regarding your comment about the police doing exactly that - looking for traces of stone marks in hands... Yes, I don´t believe that. And if you are dumb enough to believe that, be my guest. Go look for some stone marks on your forehead.

Quoting thehandsom

 

 

Yes. In countries such as  Saudi arabia, Egypt,  Pakistan etc..

You should be ashamed of yourself for putting Turkey´s democracy with  those countries..

 

 

 

I am not against handsom or anyone else criticizing Turkey and its policies. I criticize them myself, and disagree with many things that happen in Turkey, just as I criticize many other countries and their policies. But, I do try to be impartial. When handsom learns how to post things on the politics section without being biased and without attempting to ´stir shit´ deliberately, then I will take him seriously.

 

 

 

Where is impartiality in my post?

did that incident I mentioned in my post happen? YES

It is upto you if you take ´your own country´s childeren taken to court and jailed´ seriously..

Well..

I do..

 

 

13.       peacetrain
1905 posts
 19 Feb 2009 Thu 11:05 pm

 

Quoting cynicmystic

 His choice of words are on purpose ´charged´.  

 

 Oh, I agree with this but that doesn´t make him unique. 

14.       thehandsom
7403 posts
 19 Feb 2009 Thu 11:12 pm

 

Quoting cynicmystic

What the hell are you talking about in countries like Pakistan Saudi Arabia etc. Are you a moron? What do you think would happen to you if you threw stones at a police officer in the US or Britain. You should be ashamed of yourself for being so clueless. Go google police brutality in the West you chump.

 

Regarding your comment about the police doing exactly that - looking for traces of stone marks in hands... Yes, I don´t believe that. And if you are dumb enough to believe that, be my guest. Go look for some stone marks on your forehead.

 

 

 

You are really lacking of brains my friend..

The police checked the childeren´s hands for ´trace of stones´. 

Yes it is unbelivable but it is true!!!

And you are a double decker dumb despite the fact that I am showing  you the picture and giving the news..

 

I have been living in the west more than you have been I think..

I know that they wont take childeren to heavy crimes court with just throwing stones to police with a possiblity of 25 years to 40 years of jail if convicted..

 

btw..I can understand you dont know Turkey that much..But I thought you would be aware of these things in western countries..

I am dissapointed again..

So you dont know much what is going on in Turkey; you dont know much what is going on in western countries..then..

why are you still arguing here?

I have checked the links I gave,,

THIS LINKS TELLS YOU THE STORY...

http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/yazarlar/11026830.asp?yazarid=91

ok? lol



Edited (2/19/2009) by thehandsom [ADDED THE LINK AGAIN. as he DID NOT READ my links..grrr :P]

15.       peacetrain
1905 posts
 19 Feb 2009 Thu 11:16 pm

Quote: thehandsom

The police were doing exactly what I wrote..One of the links I gave above should prove that..

If the police were doing what I wrote, will you apologize? OK, forget the apology, will you condemn it as much as I did?

How do you know the police were doing exactly what you wrote?  How does reading links to newspapers "prove" it?  What is the credibility of the journalism of the newspapers? What is their political standpoint?  As a non Turk I don´t know the answers and wish to be enlightened.

 

Perhaps I´m being "bloody minded". There probably is some truth to the news article (I couldn´t open the reuters link either) and I´m sure everyone would condemn the imprisonment of children for such a long period of time.  But has that actually happened?  Have you any documentation about last years imprisonments? I would be interested to read it please.

 

I still think Gaza had no place in the thread.

16.       peacetrain
1905 posts
 19 Feb 2009 Thu 11:25 pm

Quote: thehandsom

Yes. In countries such as  Saudi arabia, Egypt,  Pakistan etc..

You should be ashamed of yourself for putting Turkey´s democracy with  those countries..

This is a typical hamsterism handsomism - putting words into people´s mouths. 

 

I should think that throwing stones at the police is a criminal offence in most countries.  I´m sure the sentences aren´t as harsh as those you mention in Turkey, but then I would like to see some documentation that there are children who have been sentenced in Turkey for such a time span. So now I will go and try to find the evidence for myself.

 

btw  I understand what is meant by traces of stones to mean, residue (dust).  But not very incriminating to my mind and how would it stand up in court?

 

 



Edited (2/19/2009) by peacetrain

17.       thehandsom
7403 posts
 19 Feb 2009 Thu 11:29 pm

 

Quoting peacetrain

Quote: thehandsom

The police were doing exactly what I wrote..One of the links I gave above should prove that..

If the police were doing what I wrote, will you apologize? OK, forget the apology, will you condemn it as much as I did?

How do you know the police were doing exactly what you wrote?  How does reading links to newspapers "prove" it?  What is the credibility of the journalism of the newspapers? What is their political standpoint?  As a non Turk I don´t know the answers and wish to be enlightened.

 

Perhaps I´m being "bloody minded". There probably is some truth to the news article (I couldn´t open the reuters link either) and I´m sure everyone would condemn the imprisonment of children for such a long period of time.  But has that actually happened?  Have you any documentation about last years imprisonments? I would be interested to read it please.

 

I still think Gaza had no place in the thread.

 

 

Both columns will tell you what I wrote..

It is in Turkish but I am sure cycstic will be happy to translate that for all of us.

http://www.taraf.com.tr/haber/27941.htm

http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/yazarlar/11026830.asp?yazarid=91 

 

http://arsiv.sabah.com.tr/2009/02/06//haber,3C1C902D152E4BEB87F911791032E893.html (this story is about some convictions):

(They are the only ones I managed to find for now..)

 

A.T, (17 yo), 7 years 6 months for commiting crimes  on behalf of a terrorist organization + 1 year 8 months for making propaganda of a terrorist organization

 

S.T (13 yo)  M.M.(14 yo) and  A.B.(16 yo) 7 years 6 months for commiting crimes on behalf of  a terrorist organization

 

M.M (15) and  M.K (16) 1 year for making propaganda of a terrorist organization..

 

 

 



Edited (2/19/2009) by thehandsom

18.       peacetrain
1905 posts
 19 Feb 2009 Thu 11:34 pm

Don´t the parents have any control over these youths and what they get up to?

19.       peacetrain
1905 posts
 19 Feb 2009 Thu 11:52 pm

Some coverage of the incident in English. 

 

http://ekurd.net/mismas/articles/misc2009/2/turkeykurdistan2108.htm

 

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/7890945.stm

 

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/7891578.stm

 

this one gives some information about the detention of youths

http://www.ekurd.net/mismas/articles/misc2008/11/turkeykurdistan2024.htm



Edited (2/19/2009) by peacetrain [added a link]
Edited (2/20/2009) by peacetrain

20.       tamikidakika
1346 posts
 20 Feb 2009 Fri 12:05 am

 

Quoting peacetrain

Don´t the parents have any control over these youths and what they get up to?

 

parents? who do you think make those children attack the police?

(60 Messages in 6 pages - View all)
1 [2] 3 4 5 6
Thread locked by a moderator or admin.




Turkish Dictionary
Turkish Chat
Open mini chat
New in Forums
Why yer gördüm but yeri geziyorum
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, makes perfect sense!
Etmeyi vs etmek
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much!
Görülmez vs görünmiyor
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, very well explained!
Içeri and içeriye
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much for the detailed ...
Present continous tense
HaydiDeer: Got it, thank you!
Hic vs herhangi, degil vs yok
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much!
Rize Artvin Airport Transfer - Rize Tours
rizetours: Dear Guest; In order to make your Black Sea trip more enjoyable, our c...
What does \"kabul ettiğini\" mean?
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much for the detailed ...
Kimse vs biri (anyone)
HaydiDeer: Thank you!
Random Pictures of Turkey
Most liked