Welcome
Login:   Pass:     Register - Forgot Password - Resend Activation

Turkish Class Forums / Language

Language

Add reply to this discussion
confused about when accusative case should be used
(12 Messages in 2 pages - View all)
[1] 2
1.       iHeartCrouchy
74 posts
 21 Oct 2006 Sat 12:19 pm

i encountered this sentence in Rosetta Stone:

Adam portakal suyu içiyor.

apprently portakal suyu means orange juice, and i looked up the dictionary and found that "su" means both "water" and "juice", so i supposed "-yu" is the accusative case suffix...do i make sense?

but then there's numerous other sentences like "Adam su içiyor.", and no suffix is added to the object "su"...

and so i'm really confused...

sorry if my question seems stupid...

2.       aslan2
507 posts
 21 Oct 2006 Sat 12:34 pm

Quoting iHeartCrouchy:

i encountered this sentence in Rosetta Stone:

Adam portakal suyu içiyor.

apprently portakal suyu means orange juice, and i looked up the dictionary and found that "su" means both "water" and "juice", so i supposed "-yu" is the accusative case suffix...do i make sense?

but then there's numerous other sentences like "Adam su içiyor.", and no suffix is added to the object "su"...

and so i'm really confused...

sorry if my question seems stupid...


-yu is 3rd person possessive suffix. It is the only irregular word in Turkish otherwise the possessive suffix would be -su after a vowel (i.e. portakal su-su but not the case).

Treat su as "suy" when adding possessive suffixes
suy-um -- my water
suy-un -- your water
suy-u -- his/her/its water
suy-umuz -- our water
suy-unuz -- your water
su-ları -- their water

It's because in old Turkish it was "suw" (instead of su).

I read somewhere that it may be of Chinese origin. What is the word for "water" in Chinese?

3.       deli
5904 posts
 21 Oct 2006 Sat 12:39 pm

f

Quoting iHeartCrouchy:

i encountered this sentence in Rosetta Stone:

Adam portakal suyu içiyor.

apprently portakal suyu means orange juice, and i looked up the dictionary and found that "su" means both "water" and "juice", so i supposed "-yu" is the accusative case suffix...do i make sense?

but then there's numerous other sentences like "Adam su içiyor.", and no suffix is added to the object "su"...

and so i'm really confused...

sorry if my question seems stupid...

i cant explain the grammer of this i will let somone else do that
but its something to do with possessed ending
when you put two words together for example

cheese sandwich
it is peynir sandvicI
orange juice
portakal suyu,y acting as buffer to separate two vowels

usually if you need to separate vowels with these type of words you use a buffer s
but because portakal susu sounds funny they use a y
i think these type of words are called compound nouns

does it make any sense
:-S :-S

4.       deli
5904 posts
 21 Oct 2006 Sat 12:42 pm

take notice of aslan thats a much better explanation :-S

5.       iHeartCrouchy
74 posts
 21 Oct 2006 Sat 12:49 pm

Quoting aslan2:

Quoting iHeartCrouchy:

i encountered this sentence in Rosetta Stone:

Adam portakal suyu içiyor.

apprently portakal suyu means orange juice, and i looked up the dictionary and found that "su" means both "water" and "juice", so i supposed "-yu" is the accusative case suffix...do i make sense?

but then there's numerous other sentences like "Adam su içiyor.", and no suffix is added to the object "su"...

and so i'm really confused...

sorry if my question seems stupid...


-yu is 3rd person possessive suffix. It is the only irregular word in Turkish otherwise the possessive suffix would be -su after a vowel (i.e. portakal su-su but not the case).

Treat su as "suy" when adding possessive suffixes
suy-um -- my water
suy-un -- your water
suy-u -- his/her/its water
suy-umuz -- our water
suy-unuz -- your water
su-ları -- their water

It's because in old Turkish it was "suw" (instead of su).

I read somewhere that it may be of Chinese origin. What is the word for "water" in Chinese?



lol thx alot!!! i think i got it now!

in Chinese, the Pinyin (ie the Mandarin Chinese pronunciation system) for "water" is "shui", and it's pronounced like "sh-way" as in English...lol

6.       iHeartCrouchy
74 posts
 21 Oct 2006 Sat 12:52 pm

Quoting deli:

f

Quoting iHeartCrouchy:

i encountered this sentence in Rosetta Stone:

Adam portakal suyu içiyor.

apprently portakal suyu means orange juice, and i looked up the dictionary and found that "su" means both "water" and "juice", so i supposed "-yu" is the accusative case suffix...do i make sense?

but then there's numerous other sentences like "Adam su içiyor.", and no suffix is added to the object "su"...

and so i'm really confused...

sorry if my question seems stupid...

i cant explain the grammer of this i will let somone else do that
but its something to do with possessed ending
when you put two words together for example

cheese sandwich
it is peynir sandvicI
orange juice
portakal suyu,y acting as buffer to separate two vowels

usually if you need to separate vowels with these type of words you use a buffer s
but because portakal susu sounds funny they use a y
i think these type of words are called compound nouns

does it make any sense
:-S :-S



yes it does!!! thx alot!!! but i'm still confused about when to add accusative suffix to a noun acting as object...it seems in some cases it does need it and in occasions otherwise they don't...

7.       aslan2
507 posts
 21 Oct 2006 Sat 12:53 pm

Quoting iHeartCrouchy:


lol thx alot!!! i think i got it now!

in Chinese, the Pinyin (ie the Mandarin Chinese pronunciation system) for "water" is "shui", and it's pronounced like "sh-way" as in English...lol


They may be the same word indeed.

8.       deli
5904 posts
 21 Oct 2006 Sat 12:56 pm

me too, but i am bad with the grammer side of any language, i dont undersand the technical terms at all, so it is taking me much longer to learn the language,ama hic vazgecemem, cunku azimliyim

9.       aslan2
507 posts
 21 Oct 2006 Sat 01:03 pm

Quoting iHeartCrouchy:


yes it does!!! thx alot!!! but i'm still confused about when to add accusative suffix to a noun acting as object...it seems in some cases it does need it and in occasions otherwise they don't...



We show accusative suffix as -(y)i. The "y" is the buffer letter which is added after a vowel. But if you add accusative suffix after a possessive suffix it becomes -(n)i (buffer letter becomes "n")

So
Portakal su-yu -- orange juice + 3rd POSS.
Portakal su-yu-nu -- orange juice + 3rd POSS. + ACCU.

Accusative is needed when it is definite object.

Portakal suyu içmek -- drink water juice
Portakal suyunu içmek -- drink the water juice

10.       iHeartCrouchy
74 posts
 21 Oct 2006 Sat 01:49 pm

Quoting aslan2:

Quoting iHeartCrouchy:


yes it does!!! thx alot!!! but i'm still confused about when to add accusative suffix to a noun acting as object...it seems in some cases it does need it and in occasions otherwise they don't...



We show accusative suffix as -(y)i. The "y" is the buffer letter which is added after a vowel. But if you add accusative suffix after a possessive suffix it becomes -(n)i (buffer letter becomes "n")

So
Portakal su-yu -- orange juice + 3rd POSS.
Portakal su-yu-nu -- orange juice + 3rd POSS. + ACCU.

Accusative is needed when it is definite object.

Portakal suyu içmek -- drink water juice
Portakal suyunu içmek -- drink the water juice



thank you so much!!! and while we're at it, can you tell me what the suffix -(y)an is for? those suffix dictionaries have so many versions...

(12 Messages in 2 pages - View all)
[1] 2
Add reply to this discussion




Turkish Dictionary
Turkish Chat
Open mini chat
New in Forums
Crossword Vocabulary Puzzles for Turkish L...
qdemir: You can view and solve several of the puzzles online at ...
Giriyor vs Geliyor.
lrnlang: Thank you for the ...
Local Ladies Ready to Play in Your City
nifrtity: ... - Discover Women Seeking No-Strings Attached Encounters in Your Ci...
Geçmekte vs. geçiyor?
Hoppi: ... and ... has almost the same meaning. They are both mean "i...
Intermediate (B1) to upper-intermediate (B...
qdemir: View at ...
Why yer gördüm but yeri geziyorum
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, makes perfect sense!
Random Pictures of Turkey
Most commented