Thank you.

You asked :   “Based on what? Is this in your opinion?” 

There are a lot of Film Critics and experts  in the world. 

Have you  read some of these persons?

I have read some of them and their analysis on cinema art. 

Do you know these movie stars?

Have you seen their films? 

They are really movie stars. 

I have seen some movies from Rudolph Valentino, Greta Garbo, Vivien Leigh, Olivia de Havilland, Susan Hayward, Ava Gardner, Marilyn Monroe, Joan Crawford, Audrey Hepburn, Clark Gable, Sophia Loren, Vittorio De Sica, Brigitte Bardot, Deborah Kerr, Charlie Chaplin, 

Robert Taylor, Sarah Miles, Staward Granger, Katherine Hepburn, Lana Turner, Simone signoret, Catherine Deneuve, Romy Schneider, Alain Delon, Jeane Moreau, Jean Gabin, Natalie Wood, James Dean, Tippi Hedren, Laurence Harvey, Richard Burton, Grace Kelly, William Holden,Jennifer Jones,   Elisabeth Taylor (liz), etc to  Jullance Moore, Jane Seymour, Demi Moore, Catherine Zeta-Jones, Jodie Foster, Cate Blanchett, Hilary Swank, Meryl Streep… 

THE 15 MOST BEAUTIFUL MOVIE STARS OF ALL TIME =

Greta Garbo

Hedy Lamarr

Gene Tierney

Bette Davis

Vivien Leigh

Susan Hayward

Ava Gardner

Lauren Bacall

Ingrid Bergman

Sophia Loren

Marilyn Monroe

Catherine Deneuve

Elizabeth Taylor

Linda Evans

Catherine Zeta-Jones

Sandra Bullock

That´s okay-you´re entitled to your opinion though one man´s meat is another man´s poison as they say. I recently went with my friend to see ´Up in the air´ starring George Clooney which had,in general,rave reviews. We hated it!

I realise this post was for Sonunda but I still wanted to comment  The list that ptaszek posted on your behalf seems very out of date.  At a glance I can only see a dozen or so under 50 years old! Not that some of them weren´t very good in their day and some have stood the test of time but I think film-making has moved on a bit since 1960!  And strange that the top 7 are all Valentino movies - is it a film critic´s list or is it yours?  If it´s yours are you a big Valentino fan? 

Yilgun is right,he has the right to post whatever he wants and it is none business.Especially mine.I do apologise  you Yilgun!!!!!

What does it mean... Have I told you a negative word like you…Are you a judge…Your negative words belong to you of course…And negative  words violate Turkish Language Class Rules. We should follow these rules.

You should have thanked me!?

Is this for me or ptaszek?  

 I think it is for both of us.Anyway I modified my post as I think Yilgun got offended and hurt.Apologies again.

Well I don´t think I said anything offensive or rude in mine but I do defend my right to think the length of the list is a bit ridiculous! (a word I didn´t actually use).  And as Trudy said earlier - there are a LOT of movie threads floating around!

 Well,I don´t think I said offensive things ,either,but perhaps these are cultural differences that caused such  Yilgun´s reaction.I simply don´t want him to feel bad of unwanted criticism.He is a sensitive and intelligent young person and I only hope he will understand that nobody here criticises his personality and him as a person.

I am also proud of his last post,it means he develops and knows how to express his opinions.Waiting for more such kind ones in the future.

Some people are very diplomatic...

P.S.

I apologize for any misunderstanding because of cultural differences among us and among some countries.

And whats with all the Tarzan movies?