One who plays with matches should not be surprised if the fire burns his hands.
Israel suffers from missiles sent on civilian population for more than
7 years.
The Hamas is hiding behind weemen and children while bombing
civilians in Israel. The behavior of this terorist group leads to these
results.
I think there is no need to use the word terrorist, because in my opinion there is no suitable definition for this word in this circumstances. I mean you have to look at the reasons why people behave like a terrorist. Then i think you wont be surprised.
I am not defending any kind of violence, but violence leads to violence.
I entered this web site in order to practise Turkish, (I
try to learn the language). I do not want to have a debate here,
but I cannot leave the debate as it is:
you forget basic facts:
a) Israel have left Gaza and right away the Hamas
took over while killing many Palestinians that opposed this act.
b) For years they hide after civilians while sending rokets from
populized areas, and when Israel retaliates trying to hit the
missile launchers, sometimes (or many times) civilians are hurt.
If roket launches stop - there will be no retaliations from Israel.
c) the same happend in Lebanon: Israel left and the other TERORIST
group- Hizballa attected a patrol killing (and kidnapping the bodies
of dead soldiers). Israel´s retaliation was hard, again because of the
thousands of rokets sent on us.
one cannot ask a country not to defend it´s population, and luckily
we are strong enough to give war back.
would your governments not react the same in situation like this?
one always sympethize with the weak side, but one should consider all the facts
.
yeah, these pictures confirm that hamas sets their misilles in apartments! but wait I see nothing inside of those thorn buildings. where are the misilles?
a) a we occupied the "palestinian terittory" in 1967 because of
attects on us by our neighbours, (1967 war).
b) Egypt, Jordan signed peace treaty and got all their territiries back.
c) Unfortunatly the Palestinians has no rein, right now they are
composed of groups fighting between themselves and ther is nobody to talk to,
as has been throuout many years.
d) you do not see missiles in the ruins ??? I think that you choose to ignor
facts:
As in Lebanon (by Hizballa), rockets are hidden in basements of buildings
among civil population and launched from there. and while attacking the terrorist missile
launchers - the resrevours of their explosives that explode there make this damage.
again: one who plays with matches shoul think about the outcome.
It was Israel who started the war in 1967. there had not been any attacks against Israel before the Israeli jets bombed the military bases in Egypt.
and saying that Hamas sets their misilles in the basements of apartments and launces them from there is not just a lie but also a funny lie. launching a misille from the basement of an apartment would be like commiting suicide by jumping out of the window of a basement flat.
we don`t ignore "the facts", and we are aware of the fact that Israel is full of sick minded fanatics. just read the comments on ynetnews. that`s quite enough to see how your people is full of hatred against all muslims. No wonder you have statemen like ariel sharon the genocider.
we don`t ignore "the facts", and we are aware of the fact that Israel is full of sick minded fanatics. just read the comments on ynetnews. that`s quite enough to see how your people is full of hatred against all muslims. No wonder you have statemen like ariel sharon the genocider.
That´s so unlike Muslims - no sick minded fanatics there No suicide bombers, no terrorist acts on the whole planet. And Muslims are famous for their love of Jews Tami, don´t use arguments that are easily transferable to your favourite team.
That´s so unlike Muslims - no sick minded fanatics there No suicide bombers, no terrorist acts on the whole planet. And Muslims are famous for their love of Jews Tami, don´t use arguments that are easily transferable to your favourite team.
did I say there is not any muslims who hate jews. there are so many of them, but you can see how well the hatred against muslims is established in israel just by reading their newspapers. Honestly I have never seen such racist and hateful "news" and comments on any news site before.
Let’s talk about justice
David Moria, whose son was killed by terrorists, has no sympathy for Gazans who celebrated in streets
This is one of the main reasons I have no respect for religions.
have you ever got kicked out of a church AE? my father and I were kicked out of a cemevi (that`s where alevis worship in) when I was 9 years old because I was being disrespectful! I enjoyed every bit of it though!
have you ever got kicked out of a church AE? my father and I were kicked out of a cemevi (that`s where alevis worship in) when I was 9 years old because I was being disrespectful! I enjoyed every bit of it though!
Hehehe you rebel
No I have never been kicked out of a church! I only used to go as a child and was a good little girl in those days...
These days I just go to them for weddings and funerals.
did I say there is not any muslims who hate jews. there are so many of them, but you can see how well the hatred against muslims is established in israel just by reading their newspapers. Honestly I have never seen such racist and hateful "news" and comments on any news site before.
You gave characteristics of a whole nation in a simplified generalisation like you always do forgetting that it works for both sides. It´s like in a boxing match you were criticising one boxer for having a penis and testosterone abundance. Talk about numbers, history and facts, don´t go into cheap rethorics especially if your argument against Jews works for argument against Muslims as well. Internet discussion boards and newspapers can get pretty anti-Jewish as well. They´ve an ongoing conflict for some rough 6,000 years and during that time both sides have committed about the same murders. It´s not like there´s an innocent nation attacked by blood-hungry other nation, it´s a war that´s gotten out of proportion, a war both sides have added to
You gave characteristics of a whole nation in a simplified generalisation like you always do forgetting that it works for both sides. It´s like in a boxing match you were criticising one boxer for having a penis and testosterone abundance. Talk about numbers, history and facts, don´t go into cheap rethorics especially if your argument against Jews works for argument against Muslims as well. Internet discussion boards and newspapers can get pretty anti-Jewish as well. They´ve an ongoing conflict for some rough 6,000 years and during that time both sides have committed about the same murders. It´s not like there´s an innocent nation attacked by blood-hungry other nation, it´s a war that´s gotten out of proportion, a war both sides have added to
don`t you have anything better to do dd? I`m not feeling like responding to your posts now, they don`t make much sense anyway!
You gave characteristics of a whole nation in a simplified generalisation like you always do forgetting that it works for both sides. It´s like in a boxing match you were criticising one boxer for having a penis and testosterone abundance. Talk about numbers, history and facts, don´t go into cheap rethorics especially if your argument against Jews works for argument against Muslims as well. Internet discussion boards and newspapers can get pretty anti-Jewish as well. They´ve an ongoing conflict for some rough 6,000 years and during that time both sides have committed about the same murders. It´s not like there´s an innocent nation attacked by blood-hungry other nation, it´s a war that´s gotten out of proportion, a war both sides have added to
yes, both sides have added to this conflict, but the Jewish side is the one who caused everything, the other side is just powerless desparate people having nothing to defend themselves.
c) the same happend in Lebanon: Israel left and the other TERORIST
group- Hizballa attected a patrol killing (and kidnapping the bodies
of dead soldiers). Israel´s retaliation was hard, again because of the
thousands of rokets sent on us.
In 2006, Israel bombed Lebanon reaching beirut destroying almost all infrastructure (electricity, briges, etc etc) in the country. The reason for this attak as claimed by israelis is that Hizballa kidnapped 2 israeli soldiers.
and yet after all the killing and destruction hizballa grew stronger. All the dead were civilians and no hizballa members were killed.
On the other hand, in May 2007, hizballa attacked the lebanese mountains mainly inhabited by Druze. Civilians carrying whatever personal arms they had in hand defended their homes and were able not only to chase them out but to kill 300 of them including the right hand of nasrallah , Naser ahmad aytawi nicknamed aboul fadl. This man was responsible for destroying by himslef 7 israeli tanks and shooting one israeli helicopter in 2006 in a battle called kalawiya in wadi al hujayr.
I am telling you this just to show you that if Israel REALLY wanted to exterminate hizballa they would be able to do so.
In my opinion, they just wanted to destroy a country that is getting on his feet and prospering, they only needed an excuse and nasralla gave it to them.
It does not suite israel to see countries in the region having stability and economical prosperity why else would they bomb the north of the country where there are no hizballa or attacking beirut or even the mountains. Their aim is destruction.
No one in israel will ever live in peace unless the palestinian cause is solved and palestinians get to live free and in dignity. The palestinian issue is the source of all problems and instability in the region and the only one responsible for this is Israel. at least that is what I think.
Of the water available from West Bank aquifers, Israel uses 73%, West Bank Palestinians use 17%, and illegal Jewish settlers use 10%.
While 10-14% of Palestine’s GDP is agricultural, 90% of them must rely on rain-fed farming methods. Israel’s agriculture is only 3% of their GDP, but Israel irrigates more than 50% of its land.
Three million West Bank Palestinians use only 250 million cubic meters per year (83 cubic meters per Palestinian per year) while six million Israelis enjoy the use of 1,954 million cubic meters (333 cubic meters per Israeli per year), which means that each Israeli consumes as much water as four Palestinians. Israeli settlers are allocated 1,450 cubic meters of water per person per year.
Israel consumes the vast majority of the water from the Jordan River despite only 3% of the river falling within its pre-1967 borders. Israel now diverts one quarter of its total water consumption through its National Water Carrier from the Jordan River, whereas Palestinians have no access to it whatsoever due to Israeli closures.
“There is no reason for Palestinians to claim that just because they sit on lands, they have the rights to that water.”
– Mr. Katz-Oz, Israel’s negotiator on water issues [1]
International Law
Under international law it is illegal for Israel to expropriate the water of the Occupied Palestinian Territories for use by its own citizens, and doubly illegal to expropriate it for use by illegal Israeli settlers [2].
Also under international law, Israel owes Palestinians reparations for past and continuing use of water resources. This should include interest due to loss of earnings from farming.
Israeli Actions
Israel does not allow new wells to be drilled by Palestinians and has confiscated many wells for Israeli use. Israel sets quotas on how much water can be drawn by Palestinians from existing wells.
When supplies of water are low in the summer months, the Israeli water company Mekorot closes the valves which supply Palestinian towns and villages so as not to affect Israeli supplies. This means that illegal Israeli settlers can have their swimming pools topped up and lawns watered while Palestinians living next to them, on whose land the settlements are situated, do not have enough water for drinking and cooking.
Israel often sells the water it steals from the West Bank back to the Palestinians at inflated prices.
During the war of 1967, 140 Palestinian wells in the Jordan Valley were destroyed to divert water through Israel’s National Water Carrier. Palestinians were allowed to dig only 13 wells between 1967 and 1996, less than the number of wells which dried up during the same period due to Israel’s refusal to deepen or rehabilitate existing wells.
The Gaza strip relies predominately on wells that are being increasingly infiltrated by salty sea water because Israel is over-pumping the groundwater. UN scientists estimate that Gaza will have no drinkable water within fifteen years.
Settlers
In Madama village 50km north of Jerusalem settlers from Yizhar settlement have repeatedly vandalized the villager’s only source of water. They have poured concrete into it, vandalized the connecting pipes and even dropped disposable diapers and other hazardous waste into the springs. Three villagers have been attacked by settlers while trying to repair the water source [3].
Constant settler attacks on the community of Yanoun, Nablus governorate, located next to the Itamar settlement, peaked in October 2002 when masked settlers charged into the village with dogs and caused significant damage to the water network, several roof tanks, and the local spring, which is considered to be the main source of water for the community. The main line supplying water to the community from the main spring, as well as the pump, reservoir, fittings and valves were all damaged by settlers. Residents of the community were forced to buy water from tankers from the neighboring community. Tanker access was very difficult due to Israeli closures and checkpoints as well as settler threats and terror which included shootings, beatings, and harassment [4].
Water and the Wall
Many of the most important underground wellsprings in the West Bank are located just to the east of the Green Line dividing Israel from Palestine. Israel has built the Wall not only to annex land but also to annex many of these wells in order to divert water to Israel and illegal West Bank settlements.
The Wall is not only an Apartheid Wall, but also a water wall. Some of the largest Israeli settlements (such as Ariel and Qedumin) are built over the Western mountain aquifer, directly in the middle of the northern West Bank agricultural districts, and this is exactly where the wall cuts deepest into Palestinian territory to surround and annex this vital water source.
The building of the Wall has caused the village of Falamya in Qalqiliya district to lose its main source of water. In Jayyous, a village near Falamya, all of its seven water wells have been annexed or destroyed by the Apartheid Wall.
In the West Bank, around 50 groundwater wells and over 200 cisterns have been destroyed or isolated from their owners by the Wall. This water was used for domestic and agricultural needs by over 122,000 people. To build the Wall, 25 wells and cisterns and 35,000 meters of water pipes have also been destroyed [5].
In 2003, the losses incurred by Palestinian farmers due to the Wall diverting water resources has been 2,200 tons of olive oil, 50,000 tons of fruit, and 100,000 tons of vegetables [6].
The Wall is obstructing many water run-off flows in the Qalqiliya region that normally divert water to prevent flooding. During heavy rains in February 2005, Israeli soldiers refused to open drainage pipes in Qalqiliya, which led to heavy flood damage to crops and homes there. The Wall also caused severe flooding in Zububa and other villages.
Under the conditions brought about by the siege imposed by Israeli occupation forces, civilians in the occupied territories are suffering from lack of access to necessary resources for the maintenance of their daily needs and basic health. We have reached a state of emergency in the water sector in the Occupied Territories. We must call for an immediate end to the siege upon the water sector.
This is one of the main reasons I have no respect for religions. Even here, all we see is hate wars...
yes, i imagine how people come out after their sunday services spreading hate wars in IOW. yes, we daily watch them burning cars, demolishing the streets, cities.
yes, both sides have added to this conflict, but the Jewish side is the one who caused everything, the other side is just powerless desparate people having nothing to defend themselves.
yes, i imagine how people come out after their sunday services spreading hate wars in IOW. yes, we daily watch them burning cars, demolishing the streets, cities.
I deleted my comment, I decided that despite its brilliance, I should not attempt at humor in this thread. (Consider yourself lucky Femm, XOX).
yes, both sides have added to this conflict, but the Jewish side is the one who caused everything, the other side is just powerless desparate people having nothing to defend themselves.
Oh, I didn´t know that! I thought that the innocent side had something to do with Hamas which is a terrorist organisation. I thought it was about lack of proportion but there are bad folks on both sides. Thanks for making it clear that there´s a flock of peace-loving Palestinians and evil, warmongering Jews
What pisses me off the most about this whole thinmg, is Syria´s attitude towards Egypt, calling us traitors and stuff, the whole arab world thinks egypt set this up with Israel, caus ethe Israeli lady thing (what is she?/) announced while on a visist in egypt that theyll be bombing, theyre saying that we should go into war with israel, what they dont get is that egypt has been fighting for palestine since 1948 in the palestine war (huuuuuuge losses) in1967 for syria, and lots of other time, the only time egypt wnt into war for itself was in 1973 and that was BECAUSE of wht happened in 1967, we lost 120 000 soldiers, and u know what, we dont have the resources or capability to go into war, were freegin POOOOOOOOR! ( what are u gonna do about the truth? Miht as well admit it )
Were doing the most that we can do, palestenians are entering egypt to get medical traetment fro free, and the blood donation peole for Gaza are everywhere in the streets, and people stand behind them in linesssss, palestenian want to enter egypt but we cant let them all come in , no matter how sory i feel for them, i wish they all could, but we dont have the reources to help them , they have no where to stay, we wont be able to handle these huge capacities, and then theyll make war bases from here and hamas ´ll satrt bombing here, and israel ´ll say, well, youve got our enemies and well be the only losing side in the end!
In school we all came wearing those palestenian thingies, th black and white triangle things they put on their backs ( no idea what theyre called!)
ANYWAY!
oh yeah i remeberd smthg!
When on the news they were talkign to this Israeli offcial and they said they wont stop bombing, the lady asked her why, she said they killed our civilians (Hamas, who have nthg to do with the innocent civilians!) the ;ady told her, well how many did their missles kill? whats the no? she wouldnt answer her, the lady kept telling her, u killed and injured (No.) and made (no.) homelss etc etc, the lady never answered, she just said we have the right to defend ourselves, why in the world are they refusing immediate truth?
Why are they usin all their resources and huge missles and ships etc etc so much and all at once?
To gain time of course! To take over as much land as possible until they finally accept the truth, so in the end they dont look bad!
Poor people!!!
One of our teachers his wife is palestenian, if u saw how he was youd cry! He actually cried in the middle of the session, i was gonna cry! His wife´s relatives died!!!
In 2006, Israel bombed Lebanon reaching beirut destroying almost all infrastructure (electricity, briges, etc etc) in the country. The reason for this attak as claimed by israelis is that Hizballa kidnapped 2 israeli soldiers.
and yet after all the killing and destruction hizballa grew stronger. All the dead were civilians and no hizballa members were killed.
On the other hand, in May 2007, hizballa attacked the lebanese mountains mainly inhabited by Druze. Civilians carrying whatever personal arms they had in hand defended their homes and were able not only to chase them out but to kill 300 of them including the right hand of nasrallah , Naser ahmad aytawi nicknamed aboul fadl. This man was responsible for destroying by himslef 7 israeli tanks and shooting one israeli helicopter in 2006 in a battle called kalawiya in wadi al hujayr.
I am telling you this just to show you that if Israel REALLY wanted to exterminate hizballa they would be able to do so.
In my opinion, they just wanted to destroy a country that is getting on his feet and prospering, they only needed an excuse and nasralla gave it to them.
It does not suite israel to see countries in the region having stability and economical prosperity why else would they bomb the north of the country where there are no hizballa or attacking beirut or even the mountains. Their aim is destruction.
No one in israel will ever live in peace unless the palestinian cause is solved and palestinians get to live free and in dignity. The palestinian issue is the source of all problems and instability in the region and the only one responsible for this is Israel. at least that is what I think.
And now – after three decades of Hosni Mubarak – can Mubarak (or "La Vache Qui Rit", as he is still called in Cairo)
Ok loooooool! Thats true
restrain the anger of his people? The answer, of course, is that Egyptians and Kuwaitis and Jordanians will be allowed to shout in the streets of their capitals – but then they will be shut down, with the help of the tens of thousands of secret policemen and government militiamen who serve the princes and kings and elderly rulers of the Arab world.
TRUE
Egyptians demand that Mubarak open the Rafah crossing-point into Gaza, break off diplomatic relations with Israel,
TRUE
even send weapons to Hamas
FALSE!!!!
when he comes and lives here and sits with us then he cans ay what he wants!
i)To admit that Egypt can´t even open its sovereign border without permission from Washington tells you all you need to know about the powerlessness of the satraps that run the Middle East for us.
PAthetic! Yet TRUE
ii)To admit that Egypt can´t even open its sovereign border without permission from Washington tells you all you need to know about the powerlessness of the satraps that run the Middle East for us.
The true disgrace of Egypt, however, is not in its response to the slaughter in Gaza. It is the corruption that has become embedded in an Egyptian society where the idea of service – health, education, genuine security for ordinary people – has simply ceased to exist.
TRUE!! AND This siw aht ppl complain abput! Taht our souls mean nthg to0t hem! They look at us like animals (the government!1)
It´s a land where the first duty of the police is to protect the regime, where protesters are beaten up by the security police, where young women objecting to Mubarak´s endless regime – likely to be passed on caliph-like to his son Gamal, whatever we may be told – are sexually molested by plain-clothes agents, where prisoners in the Tora-Tora complex are forced to rape each other by their guards.
NO, no, i think im being pretty honest here, this sint right, i thought thats what they used to say about SAddam, but probably his son Gamal will be the next ruler :S
There has developed in Egypt a kind of religious facade in which the meaning of Islam has become effaced by its physical representation. Egyptian civil "servants" and government officials are often scrupulous in their religious observances – yet they tolerate and connive in rigged elections, violations of the law and prison torture. A young American doctor described to me recently how in a Cairo hospital busy doctors merely blocked doors with plastic chairs to prevent access to patients. In November, the Egyptian newspaper Al-Masry al-Youm reported how doctors abandoned their patients to attend prayers during Ramadan.
Its partially true, about how the public now is seeing Islam in the wrong way, and how much weve changed, it was just an article in the papers recently, but tghis guy is exaggerating.... Im SOOOOOOO SAD!
And amid all this, Egyptians have to live amid daily slaughter by their own shabby infrastructure. Alaa al-Aswani wrote eloquently in the Cairo paper Al-Dastour that the regime´s "martyrs" outnumber all the dead of Egypt´s wars against Israel – victims of railway accidents, ferry sinkings, the collapse of city buildings, sickness, cancers and pesticide poisonings – all victims, as Aswani says, "of the corruption and abuse of power". Opening the Rafah border-crossing for wounded Palestinians – the Palestinian medical staff being pushed back into their Gaza prison once the bloodied survivors of air raids have been dumped on Egyptian territory – is not going to change the midden in which Egyptians themselves live.
woooooooooow! how true is that, its soo sad, its exactly what i was aying about how cheap our souls are, the government doesnt give a damn! !!
Sayed Hassan Nasrallah, the Hizbollah secretary general in Lebanon, felt able to call on Egyptians to "rise in their millions" to open the border with Gaza, but they will not do so. Ahmed Aboul Gheit, the feeble Egyptian Foreign Minister, could only taunt the Hizbollah leaders by accusing them of trying to provoke "an anarchy similar to the one they created in their own country."
But he is well-protected. So is President Mubarak.(im guessing u know by whom)
Egypt´s malaise is in many ways as dark as that of the Palestinians. Its impotence in the face of Gaza´s suffering is a symbol of its own political sickness.
ok... now im crying!!!!! CAuse it ssooooo true! I knew that it was true before, btu its like i had to hear it from somewhere else to make it hurt even more!I ahve nooo comment other than F U MUBARAK! This is all ur fault! Life wa sgreat b4 u came! I hope u see thsia dn come and arest me or smthg1 ( ITS NOT fUNNY!!!!)
Early in the morning of April 9, 1948, commandos of the Irgun (headed by Menachem Begin) and the Stern Gang attacked Deir Yassin, a village with about 750 Palestinian residents. The village lay outside of the area to be assigned by the United Nations to the Jewish State; it had a peaceful reputation. But it was located on high ground in the corridor between Tel Aviv and Jerusalem. Deir Yassin was slated for occupation under Plan Dalet and the mainstream Jewish defense force, the Haganah, authorized the irregular terrorist forces of the Irgun and the Stern Gang to perform the takeover.
In all over 100 men, women, and children were systematically murdered. Fifty-three orphaned children were literally dumped along the wall of the Old City, where they were found by Miss Hind Husseini and brought behind the American Colony Hotel to her home, which was to become the Dar El-Tifl El-Arabi orphanage.
Part of the struggle for self-determination by Palestinians has been to tell the truth about Palestinians as victims of Zionism. For too long their history has been denied, and this denial has only served to further oppress and deliberately dehumanize Palestinians in Israel, inside the occupied territories, and outside in their diaspora.
Some progress has been made. Westerners now realize that Palestinians, as a people, do exist. And they have come to acknowledge that during the creation of the state of Israel, thousands of Palestinians were killed and over 700,000 were driven or frightened from their homes and lands on which they had lived for centuries.
Deir Yassin Remembered seeks similar progress on behalf of the victims of the Deir Yassin Massacre . . .
The massacre at Deir Yassin is one of some two dozen documented massacres of Palestinian civilians by Zionist forces seeking to transform Palestine into a Jewish state. If the import of catastrophes were gauged only in numbers of people slaughtered, Deir Yassin may not have taken on its central role in the Palestinian national consciousness. However, the terror at Deir Yassin triggered a mass flight of Palestinians who feared for their own lives. When Israel was established sixty years ago this May, more than 700,000 Palestinians lost their homes and belongings, their farms and businesses, their towns and cities. Jewish militias, and later, the Israeli army, drove them out. Israel rapidly moved Jews into the newly-emptied Palestinian homes. This tragic event and its consequences lie at the core of the Palestinian/Israeli problem.
1. What happened in the Palestinian village of Deir Yassin and why does it matter today?
In the early morning of April 9, 1948, three Zionist militias - the Haganah, Irgun and Stern Gang — attacked the Palestinian village of Deir Yassin, located west of Jerusalem. More than 100 men, women and children were massacred. Some were mutilated and raped before being murdered. Twenty-five men from the village were paraded through Jerusalem and then executed in a nearby quarry. Those able to escape fled to East Jerusalem.
Word of the terror attacks spread rapidly, causing many Palestinians to flee, fearing for their lives. Within a year of the massacre, Deir Yassin, which had been emptied of Palestinians, was re-populated with Jewish immigrants and its name was removed from the map.
For Palestinians, Deir Yassin became the symbol of the sudden loss of their homes and homeland and the near destruction of their society, a situation which endures until today. When Israel was established sixty years ago, more than 700,000 Palestinians were exiled and 78 percent of the land of historic Palestine was lost.
Today, Palestinian refugees number nearly four million, out of a total population of approximately ten million. They are still deprived of their internationally-recognized right to return to their homeland. In the West Bank, Israel continues to seize land for Israeli-only settlements and Israeli-only roads.
2. Who carried out the massacre?
The Haganah, which became the Israeli army, fired mortars at the village while the Irgun and Stern Gang attacked from close range. At the time of the massacre, David Ben-Gurion, Israel´s 1st prime minister, directed Haganah policy; Menachem Begin, Israel´s 6th prime minister, led the Irgun; and Yitzhak Shamir, Israel´s 7th prime minister, was a leader of the Stern Gang.
3. What resulted from the Deir Yassin massacre?
As news of the massacre spread, the ensuing terror triggered the mass flight of Palestinians. A few days after the attacks, in fact, the Irgun asserted that the incident advanced "terror and dread among the Arabs in all the villages around, in Al Maliha, Qaluniya and Beit Iksa a panic flight began …" The flight of Palestinian refugees fit into the plans of Zionist military and political leaders at the time. During the first week of April, a concerted campaign - known as Plan Dalet - to systematically expel Palestinians from areas sought for the soon-to-be-founded state of Israel went into effect. Zionist forces conducted eight major military operations against Palestinian cities and villages between April 1st and May 15th when Israel declared independence and Arab states intervened in response to the growing refugee crisis. Some 250,000 Palestinians had been expelled by then.
4. Was Deir Yassin an isolated incident?
No. While Deir Yassin may be the most infamous, Israeli historian Benny Morris documents 24 massacres of Palestinians conducted by Zionist, and then Israeli, forces in 1948. According to Morris, "In some cases four or five people were executed, in others the numbers were 70, 80, 100. There was also a great deal of arbitrary killing. Two old men are spotted walking in a field - they are shot. A woman is found in an abandoned village - she is shot. There are cases such as the village of Dawayima [in the Hebron region], in which a column entered the village with all guns blazing and killed anything that moved. The worst cases were Saliha (70-80 killed), Deir Yassin (100-11, Lod (25, Dawayima (hundreds) and perhaps Abu Shusha (7… The fact is that no one was punished for these acts of murder. Ben-Gurion silenced the matter. He covered up for the officers who did the massacres."
The Irgun and Stern Gang also attacked British and United Nations institutions and officers who they believed stood in the way of the Zionist enterprise in Palestine. The Irgun was responsible for the bombing of the King David Hotel, which was used as British military headquarters, in Jerusalem in 1946. Ninety-one people were killed. The Stern Gang assassinated Lord Moyne, the British minister of state for the Middle East, in 1944, attempted to assassinate Harold MacMichael, the High Commissioner of Palestine, in 1944 and assassinated Count Folke Bernadotte, the United Nations representative in the Middle East, in 1948.
5. What was the total destruction and how it is still relevant today?
In total, at least 450 Palestinian towns and villages were depopulated due to Zionist military attacks or fear of such attacks. Most of these were demolished. By the end of 1948, more than 700,000 Palestinians - two-thirds of the Palestinian population - were exiled and their society was destroyed. Even today, a Jew from anywhere in the world is welcome to settle in Israel, while Palestinians with the keys and deeds to their seized homes do not enjoy the right to return.
Despite that US should tell us whether we open the borders or not,i dont agree that we open our borders totally infront of them.
à mean,yes we help of course,give medical help,food,welcome injured people in our hospitals,gives them the help that they need,give money,other recources...etc what ever
But we shouldnt open our borders openly
Gaza is problem made by Ãsrael as invader,and that is exactly what Ãsrael wants.
Palestinians leave there and go some where else.
We shouldnt help Ãsrael in doing so...
They attack us now for not opening the borders,but later they will see that we were right about it.
Ãsrael wants make it our problem...where its actually not.
Ãts a problem of land Ãsrael occupys by force and people Ãsrael trys to evacuate them.
Actually Doudi,we are not a poor country,we have many recourse indeed but not used well.
We went through many wars enough to know that war is hell,and its not something ones seek it
But if its forced upon us ,then we would be where we should be.
One who plays with matches should not be surprised if the fire burns his hands.
Israel suffers from missiles sent on civilian population for more than
7 years.
The Hamas is hiding behind weemen and children while bombing
civilians in Israel. The behavior of this terorist group leads to these
results.
Plays with matches ?!
Mmmm,well,as far as i know they were already burning there inside,thats why they try to find way out!
Let me remind you that you left Gaza and blocking it from the whole world so its people die there
And again let me remind you this,Hamas was the elected government of palestine which Ãsrael refused
They dont hide behinde women and children,you are fighting them in their land,between their homes..so sure there will be women and children there !
They are not an organized army as you are,they dont have weapons to fight in an organised war
Mmmmm,btw how many Ãsraeli civilian have been died through the 7 years if i may ask ?!
Quoting inbalit
you choose to ignor the facts:
a) a we occupied the "palestinian terittory" in 1967 because of
attects on us by our neighbours, (1967 war).
b) Egypt, Jordan signed peace treaty and got all their territiries back.
Look,let´s not fool ourselves here
Where was Ãsrael before 1948 then?!
Ask any Ãsraeli where did you come from,and you will hear many diffent answers
Ask any palestinian where did you and your family came from
You will hear just 1 answer !
So,let´s not talk about whose to blame here
Ãts not a very old history,Ãsrael is just 60 yrs old
So dont try to blame the victims here.
Let´s deal with the facts that we already have,you should both learn how to live together,side by side
And that only would be,by giving the Palestinians their lands acourding to the UN decision
And btw,we, Egypt took our land back after we went to war...not before that ,you didnt give it to us in exchange of peace or something without splitting blood there and signing a peace treaty!
Oh, I didn´t know that! I thought that the innocent side had something to do with Hamas which is a terrorist organisation. I thought it was about lack of proportion but there are bad folks on both sides. Thanks for making it clear that there´s a flock of peace-loving Palestinians and evil, warmongering Jews
As far as I´m concerned, I don´t see ANY excuse for stealing someone´s land and all valuable resources, kicking them out of their homes and naming them "terrorists" for resistance!
I think that Hamas is a similar phenomenon to PKK, except more dramatic and most Turkish people seem to understand why it came to existance.
For example, Condoleezza Rice, having observed that more than 300 Gazans were dead, said: "We are deeply concerned about the escalating violence. We strongly condemn the attacks on Israel and hold Hamas responsible."
Someone should ask her to comment on teenage knife-crime, to see if she´d say: "I strongly condemn the people who´ve been stabbed, and until they abandon their practice of wandering around clutching their sides and bleeding, there is no hope for peace."
good observation! I´ve been thinking the same when I was listening to the news today!
For example, Condoleezza Rice, having observed that more than 300 Gazans were dead, said: "We are deeply concerned about the escalating violence. We strongly condemn the attacks on Israel and hold Hamas responsible."
Someone should ask her to comment on teenage knife-crime, to see if she´d say: "I strongly condemn the people who´ve been stabbed, and until they abandon their practice of wandering around clutching their sides and bleeding, there is no hope for peace."
good observation! I´ve been thinking the same when I was listening to the news today!
A Danish man of Palestinian origin has been arrested on suspicion of shooting and wounding two Israeli salesmen at a shopping centre in Odense in Denmark.
Police said they were unsure what the motive was, but Danish media have speculated it may have been a protest against Israeli air raids in Gaza.
The 27-year-old suspect turned himself in. He reportedly denies trying to kill the men but admits carrying a gun.
The men were shot on Wednesday while selling hair products.
One was hit in the arm and the other in the leg.
They were both still in hospital on Thursday but their injuries were not life-threatening, Reuters news agency reported.
Police said the pair had been in Denmark for about a week.
The attack came on the fifth day of Israeli air strikes against Hamas targets in the Gaza Strip, which Israel says were provoked by Palestinian rocket attacks.
Four Israelis have been killed by Palestinian rockets fired into Israel since the campaign began on Saturday, while medical sources say more than 400 Palestinians have now been killed in Gaza.
a source here in case LIR wants to persecute me again (because of a rule that was made to satisfy alameda)
The article that caused the UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian Territories to be DENIED ENTRY to Israel 2 weeks ago…he was predicting exactly what we are seeing today…more death and destruction and occupation.
And what rough beast, its hour come round at last, Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born? William Butler Yeats, The Second Coming
There is little doubt that the Nazi Holocaust was as close to unconditional evil as has been revealed throughout the entire bloody history of the human species. Its massiveness, unconcealed genocidal intent, and reliance on the mentality and instruments of modernity give its enactment in the death camps of Europe a special status in our moral imagination. This special status is exhibited in the continuing presentation of its gruesome realities through film, books, and a variety of cultural artifacts more than six decades after the events in question ceased. The permanent memory of the Holocaust is also kept alive by the existence of several notable museums devoted exclusively to the depiction of the horrors that took place during the period of Nazi rule in Germany.
Against this background, it is especially painful for me, as an American Jew, to feel compelled to portray the ongoing and intensifying abuse of the Palestinian people by Israel through a reliance on such an inflammatory metaphor as ´holocaust.´ The word is derived from the Greek holos (meaning ´completely´ and kaustos (meaning ´burnt´, and was used in ancient Greece to refer to the complete burning of a sacrificial offering to a divinity. Because such a background implies a religious undertaking, there is some inclination in Jewish literature to prefer the Hebrew word ´Shoah´ that can be translated roughly as ´calamity,´ and was the name given to the 1985 epic nine-hour narration of the Nazi experience by the French filmmaker, Claude Lanzmann. The Germans themselves were more antiseptic in their designation, officially naming their undertaking as the ´Final Solution of the Jewish Qestion.´ The label is, of course, inaccurate as a variety of non-Jewish identities were also targets of this genocidal assault, including the Roma and Sinti(´gypsies), Jehovah Witnesses, gays, disabled persons, political opponents.
Is it an irresponsible overstatement to associate the treatment of Palestinians with this criminalized Nazi record of collective atrocity? I think not. The recent developments in Gaza are especially disturbing because they express so vividly a deliberate intention on the part of Israel and its allies to subject an entire human community to life-endangering conditions of utmost cruelty. The suggestion that this pattern of conduct is a holocaust-in-the-making represents a rather desperate appeal to the governments of the world and to international public opinion to act urgently to prevent these current genocidal tendencies from culminating in a collective tragedy. If ever the ethos of ´a responsibility to protect,´ recently adopted by the UN Security Council as the basis of ´humanitarian intervention´ is applicable, it would be to act now to start protecting the people of Gaza from further pain and suffering. But it would be unrealistic to expect the UN to do anything in the face of this crisis, given the pattern of US support for Israel and taking into account the extent to which European governments have lent their weight to recent illicit efforts to crush Hamas as a Palestinian political force.
Even if the pressures exerted on Gaza were to be acknowledged as having genocidal potential and even if Israel´s impunity under America´s geopolitical umbrella is put aside, there is little assurance that any sort of protective action in Gaza would be taken. There were strong advance signals in 1994 of a genocide to come in Rwanda, and yet nothing was done to stop it; the UN and the world watched while the 1995 Srebrenica massacre of Bosnians took place, an incident that the World Court described as ´genocide´ a few months ago; similarly, there have been repeated allegations of genocidal conduct in Darfur over the course of the last several years, and hardly an international finger has been raised, either to protect those threatened or to resolve the conflict in some manner that shares power and resources among the contending ethnic groups.
But Gaza is morally far worse, although mass death has not yet resulted. It is far worse because the international community is watching the ugly spectacle unfold while some of its most influential members actively encourage and assist Israel in its approach to Gaza. Not only the United States, but also the European Union, are complicit, as are such neighbors as Egypt and Jordan apparently motivated by their worries that Hamas is somehow connected with their own problems associated with the rising strength of the Muslim Brotherhood within their own borders. It is helpful to recall that the liberal democracies of Europe paid homage to Hitler at the 1936 Olympic Games, and then turned away tens of thousands of Jewish refugees fleeing Nazi Germany. I am not suggesting that the comparison should be viewed as literal, but to insist that a pattern of criminality associated with Israeli policies in Gaza has actually been supported by the leading democracies of the 21st century.
To ground these allegations, it is necessary to consider the background of the current situation. For over four decades, ever since 1967, Gaza has been occupied by Israel in a manner that turned this crowded area into a cauldron of pain and suffering for the entire population on a daily basis, with more than half of Gazans living in miserable refugees camps and even more dependent on humanitarian relief to satisfy basic human needs. With great fanfare, under Sharon´s leadership, Israel supposedly ended its military occupation and dismantled its settlements in 2005. The process was largely a sham as Israel maintained full control over borders, air space, offshore seas, as well as asserted its military control of Gaza, engaging in violent incursions, sending missiles to Gaza at will on assassination missions that themselves violate international humanitarian law, and managing to kill more than 300 Gazan civilians since its supposed physical departure.
As unacceptable as is this earlier part of the story, a dramatic turn for the worse occurred when Hamas prevailed in the January 2006 national legislative elections. It is a bitter irony that Hamas was encouraged, especially by Washington, to participate in the elections to show its commitment to a political process (as an alternative to violence) and then was badly punished for having the temerity to succeed. These elections were internationally monitored under the leadership of the former American president, Jimmy Carter, and pronounced as completely fair.
Carter has recently termed this Israeli/American refusal to accept the outcome of such a democratic verdict as itself ´criminal.´ It is also deeply discrediting of the campaign of the Bush presidency to promote democracy in the region, an effort already under a dark shadow in view of the policy failure in Iraq.
After winning the Palestinian elections, Hamas was castigated as a terrorist organization that had not renounced violence against Israel and had refused to recognize the Jewish state as a legitimate political entity. In fact, the behavior and outlook of Hamas is quite different. From the outset of its political Hamas was ready to work with other Palestinian groups, especially Fatah and Mahmoud Abbas, to establish a ´unity´ government. More than this, their leadership revealed a willingness to move toward an acceptance of Israel´s existence if Israel would in turn agree to move back to its 1967 borders, implementing finally unanimous Security Council Resolutions 242 and 338.
Even more dramatically, Hamas proposed a ten-year truce with Israel, and went so far as to put in place a unilateral ceasefire that lasted for eighteen months, and was broken only to engage in rather pathetic strikes mainly taking place in response to Israeli violent provocations in Gaza. As Efraim Halevi, former head of Israel´s Mossad was reported to have said, ´What Isreal needs from Hamas is an end to violence, not diplomatic recognition.´ And this is precisely what Hamas offered and what Israel rejected.
The main weapon available to Hamas, and other Palestinian extremist elements, were Qassam missiles that resulted in producing no more than 12 Israeli deaths in six years. While each civilian death is an unacceptable tragedy, the ratio of death and injury for the two sides in so unequal as to call into question the security logic of continuously inflicting excessive force and collective punishment on the entire beleaguered Gazan population, which is accurately regarded as the world´s largest ´prison.´
Instead of trying diplomacy and respecting democratic results, Israel and the United States used their leverage to reverse the outcome of the 2006 elections by organizing a variety of international efforts designed to make Hamas fail in its attempts to govern in Gaza. Such efforts were reinforced by the related unwillingness of the defeated Fatah elements to cooperate with Hamas in establishing a government that would be representative of Palestinians as a whole. The main anti-Hamas tactic relied upon was to support Abbas as the sole legitimate leader of the Palestinian people, to impose an economic boycott on the Palestinians generally, to send in weapons for Fatah militias and to enlist neighbors in these efforts, particularly Egypt and Jordan. The United States Government appointed a special envoy, Lt. Gen. Keith Dayton, to work with Abbas forces, and helped channel $40 million to buildup the Presidential Guard, which were the Fatah forces associated with Abbas.
This was a particularly disgraceful policy. Fatah militias, especially in Gaza, had long been wildly corrupt and often used their weapons to terrorize their adversaries and intimidate the population in a variety of thuggish ways. It was this pattern of abuse by Fatah that was significantly responsible for the Hamas victory in the 2006 elections, along with the popular feelings that Fatah, as a political actor, had neither the will nor capacity to achieve results helpful to the Palestinian people, while Hamas had managed resistance and community service efforts that were widely admired by Gazans.
The latest phase of this external/internal dynamic was to induce civil strife in Gaza that led a complete takeover by Hamas forces. With standard irony, a set of policies adopted by Israel in partnership with the United States once more produced exactly the opposite of their intended effects. The impact of the refusal to honor the election results has after 18 months made Hamas much stronger throughout the Palestinian territories, and put it in control of Gaza. Such an outcome is reminiscent of a similar effect of the 2006 Lebanon War that was undertaken by the Israel/United States strategic partnership to destroy Hezbollah, but had the actual consequence of making Hezbollah a much stronger, more respected force in Lebanon and throughout the region.
The Israel and the United States seemed trapped in a faulty logic that is incapable of learning from mistakes, and takes every setback as a sign that instead of shifting course, the faulty undertaking should be expanded and intensified, that failure resulted from doing too little of the right thing, rather than is the case, doing the wrong thing. So instead of taking advantage of Hamas´ renewed call for a unity government, its clarification that it is not against Fatah, but only that "[w]e have fought against a small clique within Fatah," (Abu Ubaya, Hamas military commander), Israel seems more determined than ever to foment civil war in Palestine, to make the Gazans pay with their wellbeing and lives to the extent necessary to crush their will, and to separate once and for all the destinies of Gaza and the West Bank.
The insidious new turn of Israeli occupation policy is as follows: push Abbas to rely on hard-line no compromise approach toward Hamas, highlighted by the creation of an unelected ´emergency´ government to replace the elected leadership. The emergency designated prime minister, Salam Fayyad, appointed to replace the Hamas leader, Ismail Haniya, as head of the Palestinian Authority. It is revealing to recall that when Fayyad´s party was on the 2006 election list its candidates won only 2% of the vote. Israel is also reportedly ready to ease some West Bank restrictions on movement in such a way as to convince Palestinians that they can have a better future if they repudiate Hamas and place their bets on Abbas, by now a most discredited political figure who has substantially sold out the Palestinian cause to gain favor and support from Israel/United States, as well as to prevail in the internal Palestinian power struggle.
A Danish man of Palestinian origin has been arrested on suspicion of shooting and wounding two Israeli salesmen at a shopping centre in Odense in Denmark.
Canim, Palestinians´ land and homes were STOLEN from them by Israel, does that make ANY difference to you!?
As far as I´m concerned, I don´t see ANY excuse for stealing someone´s land and all valuable resources, kicking them out of their homes and naming them "terrorists" for resistance!
I think that Hamas is a similar phenomenon to PKK, except more dramatic and most Turkish people seem to understand why it came to existance.
A Danish man of Palestinian origin has been arrested on suspicion of shooting and wounding two Israeli salesmen at a shopping centre in Odense in Denmark.
Canim, Palestinians´ land and homes were STOLEN from them by Israel, does that make ANY difference to you!?
i think i have spoken hundreds of times on this issue. and i think you should gain some knowledge on this subject before accusing someone for stealing.
canim, where were those so called palestinians when israel was established in 1915 and declared a nation in 1948?
can you answer this question? if you can, then im ready to debate.
israel exists and will carry on as a state no matter what others think.
you just have to admit its existance and live in peace, if you cant admit it then theres something wrong with your head.
i think i have spoken hundreds of times on this issue. and i think you should gain some knowledge on this subject before accusing someone for stealing.
canim, where were those so called palestinians when israel was established in 1915 and declared a nation in 1948?
can you answer this question? if you can, then im ready to debate.
israel exists and will carry on as a state no matter what others think.
you just have to admit its existance and live in peace, if you cant admit it then theres something wrong with your head.
I think, if I am not wrong, i gave you the population of palestine (a document from ottoman archives) just before 1915 Femme..
Dont you remember that?
The question is where were those jews before 1948!!!
i think i have spoken hundreds of times on this issue. and i think you should gain some knowledge on this subject before accusing someone for stealing.
canim, where were those so called palestinians when israel was established in 1915 and declared a nation in 1948?
can you answer this question? if you can, then im ready to debate.
israel exists and will carry on as a state no matter what others think.
you just have to admit its existance and live in peace, if you cant admit it then theres something wrong with your head.
Of course we could talk about this, but I don´t debate with evangelizers. You are not honest on this issue canim. And you choose to demonize all muslims and not accept the fact that one of the big reasons why the Arab/muslim world is what it is right now, is western politics. They don´t hate us because "we are rich and free" (huge ), as the Fox and friends propaganda likes to say.
Of course we could talk about this, but I don´t debate with evangelizers. You are not honest on this issue canim. And you choose to demonize all muslims and not accept the fact that one of the big reasons why the Arab/muslim world is what it is right now, is western politics. They don´t hate us because "we are rich and free" (huge ), as the Fox and friends propaganda likes to say.
then i have nothing to talk about with you. goodbye.
Riot police called out in London as protest ends in skirmishes
Riot police were dispatched to the Israeli embassy in London last night as a day of protests across Europe degenerated into ugly skirmishes.
In London Israeli flags were set ablaze and surging crowds were penned back by police with shields and batons. Some protesters were in tears, claiming they were being stopped from leaving peacefully, and organisers said they would complain about police heavy-handedness. Others, growing more aggressive as news of Israel´s ground invasion spread, threw missiles while police tried to drive them back. Late into the evening, several hundred were still staring down officers outside the embassy.
The London ambulance service said it had helped one man with a head injury and others with minor bruises after sending a team of 25 to the scene.
Tens of thousands initially took to the streets, even as Israeli forces were firing shells from the border of Gaza. In London, where the largest rally was held, Trafalgar Square turned to a sea of black, white, red and green – Palestinian national colours – as what organisers claimed were up to 55,000 people showed up in the largest British demonstration for the Palestinian cause. Police claimed the size of the protest was far lower.
In the crowd was the singer Annie Lennox, the comedian Alexei Sayle, Tony Benn and George Galloway. Lennox told the crowd: "We are looking at a huge human rights tragedy in front of us. The idea of an air assault combined with a ground war in such a tightly packed area as Gaza is unimaginable. It will be a bloodbath. Hopefully now we will see dialogue, dialogue, dialogue."
The thrust of the protest was aimed at the British government´s inaction over the Israeli attacks on Gaza, as the onslaught started its second week. One marcher, Omar Lemrini, 45, helped to carry a fake coffin covered in images of dead civilians and children. "This is the second Holocaust," he said. "It´s a question of conscience now."
Some 30 organisations, including the British Muslim Initiative, the Stop the War Coalition and the Palestine Solidarity Campaign, joined forces for the protest. Hemmed in by police, the marchers resorted to the symbolic throwing of shoes into Downing Street. Hundreds of old shoes were hurled over barriers and gates to represent the Palestinian lives lost in the bombing. The gesture echoed the protest by Iraqi journalist Muntadar al-Zaidi, who threw his shoes at President Bush last month in protest at US "war crimes".
David Carr, 45, a nurse, contorted his face in fury as he picked up his battered brown shoe and tossed it over the railings: "I helped search for the people who were injured in the London bomb blast, so I know what it means," he said. Two people broke through the police barrier to make a dash for Downing Street.
The protests were mirrored elsewhere with marches in France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Spain, Holland and Turkey. In Edinburgh and Glasgow, around 1,000 were involved in marches which police said passed peacefully. In Paris, 20,000 demonstrators descended on the city centre chanting "Israeli murder".
UNITED NATIONS – The United States late Saturday blocked approval of a U.N. Security Council statement calling for an immediate cease-fire between Israel and Gaza´s Hamas rulers, diplomats said.
Egypt´s U.N. Ambassador Maged Abdelaziz said it was regrettable that one permanent council member — a clear reference to the U.S. — refused to accept any statement at a time when "the aggression is escalating and more people are dying and the military attack on the ground is at its full scale."
More than 480 Palestinians have been killed and nearly 3,000 injured in Gaza, and four people have been killed in Israel.
Britain conquered Palestine from the Turks in 1917-18. First Her Majesty´s Government promised Palestine to the Jews in the Balfour Declaration in 1917, and then again in the League of Nations Mandate for Palestine of 1922, in which it solemnly accepted as "a sacred trust of civilization" to "be responsible for placing the country under such political, administrative and economic conditions as will secure the establishment of the Jewish national home." Then it repudiated that promise in a "White Paper" of 1939, which announced her intention to allow only 75,000 Jewish immigrants into Palestine over the next five years (this as World War II and the Holocaust was just beginning) and after that to allow no further Jewish immigration without Arab consent. The White Paper also placed severe restrictions on the purchase of land by Jews. And it promised the Palestinian Arabs that Palestine would become an independent Arab state within ten years. All this was in flagrant violations of the League of Nations Mandate for Palestine; the League of Nations Mandates Commission noted this, and refused to ratify the White Paper. Britain implemented it anyway -- to the extent of refusing to admit to Palestine 750 Jews who had managed to escape Nazi Europe in a leaky boat while the Holocaust was in full swing. The Jews were forced to turn back into the human-shark-infested waters of the Black Sea, where their leaky crate was torpedoed, and all but one of them killed.
Other Jews who managed to reach the shores of Palestine were deported by the British Navy to the remote island of Mauritius and kept in a detention camp, where many of them died of disease before finally being released after the end of the war. This British measure was strangely reminiscent of an earlier Nazi plan to deport the Jews of Europe to Madagascar, a larger island in the Indian Ocean not far from Mauritius. Still the British detained other Jews who managed to board ships bound for Palestine for years in camps on Cyprus. This was the way His Majesty´s Government kept its promises to the Jews.
Having already promised Palestine to both the Jews and the Palestinian Arabs, Britain after World War II promised it again, this time to Syria! Secret British correspondence, recently discovered by an Israeli scholar, not in the archives of Britain but in those of France, which intercepted British and Syrian communications through espionage, reveals that the British promised to hand over Palestine to Syria in return for making Britain Syria´s "protector" to replace France. The British even assisted the Syrians to carry out a massacre of French civilians and soldiers in order to force France out of Syria.
Britain encouraged the Arab states to form an "Arab League" as World War II came to an end. A British representative sat in on the League´s meetings and raised no objections as the Arab states planned to invade Palestine -- even though Palestine was still under British control!
In 1947, Britain referred Palestine to the United Nations and asked it to find a solution to the conflict between Jews and Arabs in Palestine that Britain had done so much to foster through its contradictory promises to both sides. When the United Nations General Assembly adopted a resolution recommending that Palestine be partitioned into separate and independent Jewish and Arab states, His Majesty´s Government, through its representative in the United Nations, solemnly promised to help implement the resolution, even though it had not voted for it.
Instead, the British sabotaged the resolution in every way possible. It refused even to allow the commission that had been appointed by the United Nations General Assembly to oversee implementation of the partition resolution into the country. On the other hand, it permitted the Arab states to send troops into Palestine under the guise of "volunteers," even before the British administration had completed its withdrawal from the country. It stood aside and did nothing to preserve order as war raged throughout the country and thousands of both Jews and Arabs were killed, even though it nominally retained responsibility for the administration of Palestine until May 15, 1948. Worst of all, it withdrew its administration without appointing or recognizing any government, Jewish or Arab, to take its place, or organizing any kind of successor administration. In an unprecedented act in the history of colonialism, the British simply withdrew, leaving the country that they had misgoverned for thirty years in total chaos. One British author has called this bizarre act an "experiment in anarchy." Another has characterized British policy in Palestine as "divide and lose."
Britain´s two-faced machinations did not prevent Israel from winning the independence that the Jews had been promised, but only at the cost of thousands of lives, and with no help whatsoever from the promise-bearing great power. However, Israel has had to live in a constant state of siege from neighbors who remain at war with her, and who still refuse to allow her the "secure and recognized borders" enjoyed by all other sovereign states in the world.
The Palestinian Arabs never got the state that Britain promised them. Syria never "received" Palestine in accordance with Britain´s secret promise, either. First incited to go to war for Palestine, and then left to shift for themselves by their forked-tongued British ‘friends," the Palestinian and Syrian Arabs are still fighting Israel for the land that Britain once promised each of them.
Britain, for her part, has done absolutely nothing to encourage the Arab states to make peace with Israel. Instead, its inflammatory press incessantly incites the Arabs to continue their war of terror against the Jews. The British Foreign Office has done nothing to discourage the British gutter press from indulging in this incendiary propaganda and misinformation campaign. And the BBC, a government owned and controlled station with close ties to the Foreign Office, has actively participated in the hostile propaganda and incitement against Israel, in both its Arabic and English
Over 400 Palestinians have been killed and some 1,700 wounded since the beginning of IDF Operation Cast Lead last Saturday. The offensive targets Hamas in the Strip.
Earlier in the week, a seven-year-old Gaza boy who suffered a serious head wound in IAF air strikes was rushed through the Erez Crossing and taken to Schneider Children´s Medical Center in Petah Tikva.
The boy, whose transfer was facilitated by the Peres Peace Center, was in critical condition in the intensive care unit on Wednesday night.
Meanwhile, Physicians for Human Rights-Israel, which favors the transfer of Gaza civilians hurt in the bombings, said the Palestinian Authority is unwilling to pay for their medical care in Israel because Hamas is responsible.
The PHR-Israel has urged the PA to facilitate such transfers immediately and argue later about who would finance the treatment to save their lives.
Three other wounded children were also transferred via the Erez Crossing, with help from UNRWA.
Twenty Gazans suffering from serious illnesses unrelated to the fighting were allowed through on Wednesday for treatment in Israeli hospitals.
Britain conquered Palestine from the Turks in 1917-18. First Her Majesty´s Government promised Palestine to the Jews in the Balfour Declaration in 1917, and then again in the League of Nations Mandate for Palestine of 1922, in which it solemnly accepted as "a sacred trust of civilization" to "be responsible for placing the country under such political, administrative and economic conditions as will secure the establishment of the Jewish national home." Then it repudiated that promise in a "White Paper" of 1939, which announced her intention to allow only 75,000 Jewish immigrants into Palestine over the next five years (this as World War II and the Holocaust was just beginning) and after that to allow no further Jewish immigration without Arab consent. The White Paper also placed severe restrictions on the purchase of land by Jews. And it promised the Palestinian Arabs that Palestine would become an independent Arab state within ten years. All this was in flagrant violations of the League of Nations Mandate for Palestine; the League of Nations Mandates Commission noted this, and refused to ratify the White Paper. Britain implemented it anyway -- to the extent of refusing to admit to Palestine 750 Jews who had managed to escape Nazi Europe in a leaky boat while the Holocaust was in full swing. The Jews were forced to turn back into the human-shark-infested waters of the Black Sea, where their leaky crate was torpedoed, and all but one of them killed.
Other Jews who managed to reach the shores of Palestine were deported by the British Navy to the remote island of Mauritius and kept in a detention camp, where many of them died of disease before finally being released after the end of the war. This British measure was strangely reminiscent of an earlier Nazi plan to deport the Jews of Europe to Madagascar, a larger island in the Indian Ocean not far from Mauritius. Still the British detained other Jews who managed to board ships bound for Palestine for years in camps on Cyprus. This was the way His Majesty´s Government kept its promises to the Jews.
Having already promised Palestine to both the Jews and the Palestinian Arabs, Britain after World War II promised it again, this time to Syria! Secret British correspondence, recently discovered by an Israeli scholar, not in the archives of Britain but in those of France, which intercepted British and Syrian communications through espionage, reveals that the British promised to hand over Palestine to Syria in return for making Britain Syria´s "protector" to replace France. The British even assisted the Syrians to carry out a massacre of French civilians and soldiers in order to force France out of Syria.
Britain encouraged the Arab states to form an "Arab League" as World War II came to an end. A British representative sat in on the League´s meetings and raised no objections as the Arab states planned to invade Palestine -- even though Palestine was still under British control!
In 1947, Britain referred Palestine to the United Nations and asked it to find a solution to the conflict between Jews and Arabs in Palestine that Britain had done so much to foster through its contradictory promises to both sides. When the United Nations General Assembly adopted a resolution recommending that Palestine be partitioned into separate and independent Jewish and Arab states, His Majesty´s Government, through its representative in the United Nations, solemnly promised to help implement the resolution, even though it had not voted for it.
Instead, the British sabotaged the resolution in every way possible. It refused even to allow the commission that had been appointed by the United Nations General Assembly to oversee implementation of the partition resolution into the country. On the other hand, it permitted the Arab states to send troops into Palestine under the guise of "volunteers," even before the British administration had completed its withdrawal from the country. It stood aside and did nothing to preserve order as war raged throughout the country and thousands of both Jews and Arabs were killed, even though it nominally retained responsibility for the administration of Palestine until May 15, 1948. Worst of all, it withdrew its administration without appointing or recognizing any government, Jewish or Arab, to take its place, or organizing any kind of successor administration. In an unprecedented act in the history of colonialism, the British simply withdrew, leaving the country that they had misgoverned for thirty years in total chaos. One British author has called this bizarre act an "experiment in anarchy." Another has characterized British policy in Palestine as "divide and lose."
Britain´s two-faced machinations did not prevent Israel from winning the independence that the Jews had been promised, but only at the cost of thousands of lives, and with no help whatsoever from the promise-bearing great power. However, Israel has had to live in a constant state of siege from neighbors who remain at war with her, and who still refuse to allow her the "secure and recognized borders" enjoyed by all other sovereign states in the world.
The Palestinian Arabs never got the state that Britain promised them. Syria never "received" Palestine in accordance with Britain´s secret promise, either. First incited to go to war for Palestine, and then left to shift for themselves by their forked-tongued British ‘friends," the Palestinian and Syrian Arabs are still fighting Israel for the land that Britain once promised each of them.
Britain, for her part, has done absolutely nothing to encourage the Arab states to make peace with Israel. Instead, its inflammatory press incessantly incites the Arabs to continue their war of terror against the Jews. The British Foreign Office has done nothing to discourage the British gutter press from indulging in this incendiary propaganda and misinformation campaign. And the BBC, a government owned and controlled station with close ties to the Foreign Office, has actively participated in the hostile propaganda and incitement against Israel, in both its Arabic and English
UNITED NATIONS – The United States late Saturday blocked approval of a U.N. Security Council statement calling for an immediate cease-fire between Israel and Gaza´s Hamas rulers, diplomats said.
Egypt´s U.N. Ambassador Maged Abdelaziz said it was regrettable that one permanent council member — a clear reference to the U.S. — refused to accept any statement at a time when "the aggression is escalating and more people are dying and the military attack on the ground is at its full scale."
More than 480 Palestinians have been killed and nearly 3,000 injured in Gaza, and four people have been killed in Israel.
what can be said here.... clearly, there is no god
That is worse than DRESDEN, at least people could flee there, but this is unspeakable, you comment is correct, Catwoman, NEREDE ALLAH???
Do Israel pilots feel happy killing innocent women and children?
OH, YES, THEY ARE, RABBIS TURNED ON LOUSSPEAKERS AND FELT HAPPY WITH ALL THE OTHER FANATICS
Do Israel pilots feel happy killing innocent women and children?
A Palestinian in Gaza chronicles life under Israeli bombardment
Palestinians survey the aftermath of an Israeli missile strike on the Rafah refugee camp in Gaza. Photograph: Khalil Kamra/AP
Saturday 27 DecemberI go to visit friends in the Block J neighbourhood in Rafah in the south of the Gaza Strip. While I am in a friend´s house, my phone rings. It´s a friend from Gaza City, calling for a chat. Suddenly I hear the sound of an explosion at his end. At the same time I hear an explosion in Rafah too. Just outside, somewhere near. My friend says: "Fida, they are attacking nearby." I say: "They are attacking here too."
I run into the street and everybody is running, children and grown-ups, all looking to see if their relatives and friends are alive. It is the time for children to go to school for the second shift, after the first shift finishes at 11.30am.Naama is aged 13. This is what she tells me: "I was sitting in the classroom with my friends when the attack happened. We were scared and we ran out of our school. Our headmaster asked us to go home. We saw fire everywhere."
People are looking at the remains of a police station. There are still bodies under the wreckage. It is scary because the attack isn´t over, and from where we are we can see an Israeli airplane attacking another police station.
At the hospital, I speak to a wounded police officer, aged 39. "We were at the police station," he said. "The Israeli planes came and suddenly the building collapsed on us. I saw four dead bodies near me. They were in pieces. Outside there were more bodies. Everyone was shouting. I lost consciousness and then found myself in hospital."
Later I am at home with my family. We´ve just received a phone call on our land line. It´s the Israeli defence ministry, and they say that any house that has guns or weapons will be targeted next, without warning and without any announcement. Just to let you know, we don´t have any weapons in our house. If we die please defend my family.
Sunday 28 December
I wake up at 7am after an Israeli F-16 attack. Our house is shaking. We all try to imagine what has happened, but we want to at least know where the attack was. It is so scary. We try to open the main door to our flat, but it´s stuck shut after the attack. I have to climb out of the window to leave the house. I am shocked when I find out our neighbour´s pharmacy was the target. It is just 60 metres from our house. They targeted a pharmacy. I still can´t believe it.
Om Mohammed says: "They [Israeli forces] attack everywhere. They have gone crazy. The Gaza Strip is just going to die ... it´s going to die. We were sleeping. Suddenly we heard a bomb. We woke up and we didn´t know where to go. We couldn´t see through the dust. We called to each other. We thought our house had been hit, not the street. What can I say? You saw it with your own eyes. What is our guilt? Are we terrorists? I don´t carry a gun, neither does my girl.
"There´s no medicine. No drinks, no water, no gas. We are suffering from hunger. They attack us. What does Israel want? Can it be worse than this? I don´t think so. Would they accept this for themselves?
"Look at the children. What are they guilty of? They were sleeping at 7am. All the night they didn´t sleep. This child was traumatised during the attack. Do they have rockets to attack with?"
Monday 29 December
The Israeli army is destroying the tunnels that go from Rafah into Egypt. For the past year and a half the Israeli government has intensified the economic blockade of Gaza by closing all the border crossings that allow aid and essential supplies to reach Palestinians in Gaza. This forced Palestinians to dig tunnels to Egypt to survive. From our house we can hear the explosions and the house is shaking.At night we can´t go out. No one goes out. If you go out you will risk your life. You don´t know where the bombs will fall. My mother is so sad. She watches me writing my reports and says: "Fida, will it make any difference?"
Before the attack started we got some food aid from the EU. It´s not much, but it´s enough, we´re not starving. But some of our friends have nothing. My mum warns me: "Fida, don´t leave the house, it´s too dangerous outside." Then she goes out to share our food with the neighbours who have nothing.
Wednesday 31 December
11.40pm: a powerful air strike somewhere nearby. I was sleeping but the blast wakes me up. I see my mum looking from the window. She points at one of the refugee camps. "The attack was there," she said.
I went back to sleep – not because I don´t care, but because I can´t deal with it. If the attack was really aimed at one of the camps that means hundreds are going to be injured or even killed, the houses destroyed. I really can´t imagine it.
Thursday 1 January
In the morning I get up early and call a friend who lives in Alshabora camp. He confirms the attack had hit there and I go to meet him.
It looks like an earthquake. Many houses have been damaged, and many people have been wounded. The people who had escaped injury were trying to clean the place up – they have nowhere else to go. But the biggest shock is when I ask about the target. It was the children´s playground.
"We heard a strong explosion happen, but with all the smoke and the dust we couldn´t see well, and the electricity was off," I am told by a small child.
"We saw everything fall down – the window broke on us. We went downstairs, and people were saying that the playground´s been targeted. This park is not a member of Hamas, it´s a park for playing. It´s for civilians – so why did they attack it?," asks one 12-year-old girl who lives nearby.
The target was a civilian area – but there was no warning, not one phone call from the Israeli army to tell civilians to beware.
I visit the main hospital in Rafah. There are so many injured people, most of them children. In one ward, I meet four children aged five or six. They are in deep shock. They can´t speak, they just look at you.
Only one child could say his name: "Abdel Rahman". That´s all he can say. Otherwise, he just stares. He´s five. His ear was wounded by shrapnel, his head is covered by bandages.
There is a 16-year-old girl also suffering from shrapnel injuries. Three of her brothers were killed; all her family were injured. She looks like a zombie and says nothing at all. Her mother is dying in the intensive care unit.
The hospital manger, Abu Youssef Alnajar, gives the statistics for 1 January: two dead – a young man aged 22 and a woman aged 33; 59 injured – 16 children, 18 women and the rest old people. Most of them had been sleeping when the bombs dropped.
I go back home and the first thing I do is take a shower. I feel really upset after what I have seen. As always I am trying to cope with the situation but sometimes it is too much to deal with.
A short message to the pilots in the Israeli F-16s: does it make you feel happy to kill Palestinian children and women? Do you feel it´s your duty? Killing every child and woman, man and teenager in Gaza? I don´t know what exactly you feel, what exactly you think, but please think of your mother and sister, your son and daughter.
Friday 2 January
I am in the hospital again. An ambulance crew has been called out to help an injured man somewhere near the ruins of the old Gaza airport. He´s a civilian, one of the bedouin who tend their sheep in that area. Four shepherds saw an explosion and went to investigate – when they arrived at the scene there was a second bomb and they were injured. An ambulance managed to rescue three of the men. But one of their friends is still there, bleeding.
The ambulance crew are afraid to go back for him. The wounded man is just 50 metres away from the green line so they are afraid the Israeli soldiers will target them.Outside there are still planes in the air. I have just heard a big explosion on the border area.
• Fida Qishta is a freelance Palestinian television producer and writer based in Gaza´s southern township of Rafah
Since 1991, the U.S. has released the radioactive atomicity equivalent of at least 400,000 Nagasaki bombs into the global atmosphere. That is 10 times the amount released during atmospheric testing which was the equivalent of 40,000 Hiroshima bombs. Thus, the U.S. has permanently contaminated the global atmosphere with radioactive pollution having a half-life of 2.5 billion years.Imagine what it has done to the atmosphere and environs of Yugoslavia, Afghanistan and Iraq.
DU weapons are very effective kinetic energy penetrators, but are even more effective bio-weapons. On the battlefield, DU weaponry has three effects on living systems: it is a heavy metal "chemical" poison, it is a "radioactive" poison and it has a "particulate" effect due to the very tiny size of the particles— 0.1 microns and smaller.Cancer starts with one alpha particle under the right conditions. One gram of DU is the size of a period in this sentence and releases 12,000 alpha particles per second.
Today, more than one out of every three veterans from the first Gulf War is permanently disabled. Terry Jemison of the Dept. of Veterans Affairs said that of the 592,561 discharged veterans from the 1991 war in Iraq, 179,310 are receiving disability compensation and another 24,763 cases are pending. In August of 2004, Jemison stated in that the number of Gulf-era veterans on medical disability has reached 518,000 and that the number of those who have died from “Gulf War Syndrome” is estimated at 10,000.
The "epigenetic damage" (damage to DNA) done by DU has resulted in many grossly deformed children born in areas where tons of DU have contaminated the environment and the local population. According to the scientists, these malformations of humans will continue for at least the next FOUR BILLION YEARS, based on the half-life projections of the contaminants in DU. In southern Iraq, where scientists are reporting five times higher levels of gamma radiation in the air, disfiguring and deadly cancers, leukemia, birth defects, diabetics and death are increasing exponentially.When children are born in Iraq, the mothers ask not “Is my child a boy or girl?”They ask “Is my precious child normal?”
An untold number of American children have also been born with severe birth defects as a result of DU contamination.In some studies of our soldiers who had normal babies before the war, a highly significant percent of their post-war babies are born with severe birth defects - missing brains, eyes, organs, legs and arms – Thalidomide resurrected.
DU is the Trojan horse of nuclear war - a silent, constant presence that keeps “gifting” – and keeps killing. There is no way to clean it up, and no way to turn it off.Its deadly effects last to eternity. Sad to say, because of our DOD’s fixation on the use of DU weaponry, areas in Iraq, Yugoslavia and Afghanistan are now uninhabitable
A line from one of America’s favorite hymns, “O Beautiful for Spacious Skies,” seems particularly appropriate here:“America, America, God mend thine every flaw/Confirm thy soul in self-control/Thy liberty in Law.”
Residents in areas under fire – for example in northern Gaza where the Israeli military focused a major incursion around the towns of Beit Lahiya, Jabaliya and Beit Hanoun – were prevented from leaving the besieged territory. The UN Relief and Works Agency reported that 3,000 internally displaced Gazans had arrived at seven shelters around the Strip. Oxfam said last night that a paramedic from an ambulance service it funds was killed in Beit Lahiya and two other medics injured while trying to evacuate an injured person. The ambulance had been shelled, Oxfam said
Reinforcing the Israeli government´s earlier rejection of international ceasefire calls, Israel´s veteran President Shimon Peres told the US news network ABC: "We don´t intend either to occupy Gaza nor to crush Hamas, but to crush terror. And Hamas needs a real and serious lesson. They are now getting it."
Yesterday´s deaths followed the worst single group of civilian casualties on Saturday night, just before the ground offensive, when 15 Palestinians were killed and more than 25 were injured in the bombing of the Ibrahim Al Makadima Mosque in Beit Lahiya. The Israeli military has not yet produced an official explanation of the incident, though officials said that two Hamas gunmen outside the mosque had been targeted and that the attack on them had triggered "secondary explosions".
Israel Has No Intention of Granting a Palestinian State
If Hamas Did Not Exist
By JENNIFER LOEWENSTEIN
Let us get one thing perfectly straight. If the wholesale mutilation and degradation of the Gaza Strip is going to continue; if Israel’s will is at one with that of the United States; if the European Union, Russia, the United Nations and all the international legal agencies and organizations spread across the globe are going to continue to sit by like hollow mannequins doing nothing but making repeated “calls” for a “ceasefire” on “both sides”; if the cowardly, obsequious and supine Arab States are going to stand by watching their brethren get slaughtered by the hour while the world’s bullying Superpower eyes them threateningly from Washington lest they say something a little to their disliking; then let us at least tell the truth why this hell on earth is taking place.
The state terror unleashed from the skies and on the ground against the Gaza Strip as we speak has nothing to do with Hamas. It has nothing to do with “Terror”. It has nothing to do with the long-term “security” of the Jewish State or with Hizbullah or Syria or Iran except insofar as it is aggravating the conditions that have led up to this crisis today. It has nothing to do with some conjured-up “war” – a cynical and overused euphemism that amounts to little more the wholesale enslavement of any nation that dares claim its sovereign rights; that dares assert that its resources are its own; that doesn’t want one of the Empire’s obscene military bases sitting on its cherished land.
This crisis has nothing to do with freedom, democracy, justice or peace. It is not about Mahmoud Zahhar or Khalid Mash’al or Ismail Haniyeh. It is not about Hassan Nasrallah or Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. These are all circumstantial players who have gained a role in the current tempest only now that the situation has been allowed for 61 years to develop into the catastrophe that it is today. The Islamist factor has colored and will continue to color the atmosphere of the crisis; it has enlisted the current leaders and mobilized wide sectors of the world’s population. The primary symbols today are Islamic – the mosques, the Qur’an, the references to the Prophet Muhammad and to Jihad. But these symbols could disappear and the impasse would continue.
There was a time when Fatah and the PFLP held the day; when few Palestinians wanted anything to do with Islamist policies and politics. Such politics have nothing to do with primitive rockets being fired over the border, or smuggling tunnels and black-market weapons; just as Arafat’s Fatah had little to do with stones and suicide bombings. The associations are coincidental; the creations of a given political environment. They are the result of something entirely different than what the lying politicians and their analysts are telling you. They have become part of the landscape of human events in the modern Middle East today; but incidentals wholly as lethal, or as recalcitrant, deadly, angry or incorrigible could just as soon have been in their places.
Strip away the clichés and the vacuous newspeak blaring out across the servile media and its pathetic corps of voluntary state servants in the Western world and what you will find is the naked desire for hegemony; for power over the weak and dominion over the world’s wealth. Worse yet you will find that the selfishness, the hatred and indifference, the racism and bigotry, the egotism and hedonism that we try so hard to cover up with our sophisticated jargon, our refined academic theories and models actually help to guide our basest and ugliest desires. The callousness with which we in indulge in them all are endemic to our very culture; thriving here like flies on a corpse.
Strip away the current symbols and language of the victims of our selfish and devastating whims and you will find the simple, impassioned and unaffected cries of the downtrodden; of the ‘wretched of the earth’ begging you to cease your cold aggression against their children and their homes; their families and their villages; begging you to leave them alone to have their fish and their bread, their oranges, their olives and their thyme; asking you first politely and then with increasing disbelief why you cannot let them live undisturbed on the land of their ancestors; unexploited, free of the fear of expulsion; of ravishment and devastation; free of permits and roadblocks and checkpoints and crossings; of monstrous concrete walls, guard towers, concrete bunkers, and barbed wire; of tanks and prisons and torture and death. Why is life without these policies and instruments of hell impossible?
The answer is because Israel has no intention of allowing a viable, sovereign Palestinian state on its borders. It had no intention of allowing it in 1948 when it grabbed 24 per cent more land than what it was allotted legally, if unfairly, by UN Resolution 181. It had no intention of allowing it throughout the massacres and ploys of the 1950s. It had no intention of allowing two states when it conquered the remaining 22 per cent of historic Palestine in 1967 and reinterpreted UN Security Council Resolution 248 to its own liking despite the overwhelming international consensus stating that Israel would receive full international recognition within secure and recognized borders if it withdrew from the lands it had only recently occupied.
It had no intention of acknowledging Palestinian national rights at the United Nations in 1974, when –alone with the United States—it voted against a two-state solution. It had no intention of allowing a comprehensive peace settlement when Egypt stood ready to deliver but received, and obediently accepted, a separate peace exclusive of the rights of Palestinians and the remaining peoples of the region. It had no intention of working toward a just two-state solution in 1978 or 1982 when it invaded, fire-bombed, blasted and bulldozed Beirut so that it might annex the West Bank without hassle. It had no intention of granting a Palestinian state in 1987 when the first Intifada spread across occupied Palestine, into the Diaspora and the into the spirits of the global dispossessed, or when Israel deliberately aided the newly formed Hamas movement so that it might undermine the strength of the more secular-nationalist factions.
Israel had no intention of granting a Palestinian state at Madrid or at Oslo where the PLO was superseded by the quivering, quisling Palestinian Authority, too many of whose cronies grasped at the wealth and prestige it gave them at the expense of their own kin. As Israel beamed into the world’s satellites and microphones its desire for peace and a two-state solution, it more than doubled the number of illegal Jewish settlements on the ground in the West Bank and around East Jerusalem, annexing them as it built and continues to build a superstructure of bypass roads and highways over the remaining, severed cities and villages of earthly Palestine. It has annexed the Jordan valley, the international border of Jordan, expelling any ‘locals’ inhabiting that land. It speaks with a viper’s tongue over the multiple amputee of Palestine whose head shall soon be severed from its body in the name of justice, peace and security.
Through the home demolitions, the assaults on civil society that attempted to cast Palestinian history and culture into a chasm of oblivion; through the unspeakable destruction of the refugee camp sieges and infrastructure bombardments of the second Intifada, through assassinations and summary executions, past the grandiose farce of disengagement and up to the nullification of free, fair and democratic Palestinian elections Israel has made its view known again and again in the strongest possible language, the language of military might, of threats, intimidation, harassment, defamation and degradation.
Israel, with the unconditional and approving support of the United States, has made it dramatically clear to the entire world over and over and over again, repeating in action after action that it will accept no viable Palestinian state next to its borders. What will it take for the rest of us to hear? What will it take to end the criminal silence of the ‘international community’? What will it take to see past the lies and indoctrination to what is taking place before us day after day in full view of the eyes of the world? The more horrific the actions on the ground, the more insistent are the words of peace. To listen and watch without hearing or seeing allows the indifference, the ignorance and complicity to continue and deepens with each grave our collective shame.
The destruction of Gaza has nothing to do with Hamas. Israel will accept no authority in the Palestinian territories that it does not ultimately control. Any individual, leader, faction or movement that fails to accede to Israel’s demands or that seeks genuine sovereignty and the equality of all nations in the region; any government or popular movement that demands the applicability of international humanitarian law and of the universal declaration of human rights for its own people will be unacceptable for the Jewish State. Those dreaming of one state must be forced to ask themselves what Israel would do to a population of 4 million Palestinians within its borders when it commits on a daily, if not hourly basis, crimes against their collective humanity while they live alongside its borders? What will suddenly make the raison d’etre, the self-proclaimed purpose of Israel’s reason for being change if the Palestinian territories are annexed to it outright?
The lifeblood of the Palestinian National Movement flows through the streets of Gaza today. Every drop that falls waters the soil of vengeance, bitterness and hatred not only in Palestine but across the Middle East and much of the world. We do have a choice over whether or not this should continue. Now is the time to make it.
Jennifer Loewenstein is the Associate Director of the Middle East Studies Program at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. She can be reached at amadea311@earthlink.net
For Fares Akram, The Independent´s reporter in Gaza, the Israeli invasion became a personal tragedy when he discovered his father was one of the first casualties of the ground war
The phone call came at around 4.20pm on Saturday. A bomb had been dropped on the house at our small farm in northern Gaza. ..
But shortly before sunset on Saturday, .. my father´s life extinguished at the age of 48. ... It was one of those F16 airstrikes that killed my father.
..."Just a pile of flesh," my uncle, who found him in the rubble, said later with brutal honesty.
....
My father, Akrem al-Ghoul, was no militant. Born in Gaza and educated in Egypt, he was a lawyer and a judge who worked for the Palestinian Authority. After Hamas took over, he quit and turned to agriculture. Dad´s father, Fares, who had been driven out of his home in what is now Israeli Ashkelon in 1948, had bought the land in the 1960s.
During the second intifada and until the Israelis withdrew from Gaza in 2005, the farm was taken over by Israeli settlers, but after 2005 we went there every holiday. ........
My grief carries no desire for revenge, which I know to be always in vain. But, in truth, as a grieving son, I am finding it hard to distinguish between what the Israelis call terrorists and the Israeli pilots and tank crews who are invading Gaza. What is the difference between the pilot who blew my father to pieces and the militant who fires a small rocket? I have no answers but, just as I am to become a father, I have lost my father.
I think you are right on that..That is the reason I am trying to give a brief summary
i can brief on behalf of you a man is beating a boy in boys family´s house and all " so called" modern ( muslim and non-muslim) neighbours do is just watching it.
Brazilian cartoonist Carlos Latuff creates artworks that call on the world to condemn Israeli holocaust of Gaza / Nepos Libertas´s blog
Carlos Latuff´s statement: I´d like to beg all viewers to spread this image anywhere, as a way to expose Israeli war crimes against Palestinians. Use it on t-shirts, posters, banners. Reproduce it in zines, papers, magazines, and make it visible everywhere. Here is the high-resolution version for printing purposes: Thank you in the name of every suffering Palestinian. http://latuff2.deviantart.com/
UN fails to issue even a demand for Israel to halt attacks on Gaza
Gaza, January 4, 2009 (Ramattan) – The UN Security Council has failed to reach an agreement on a statement demanding the immediate withdrawal of Israeli forces from Gaza.
The council held an emergency meeting late on Saturday night after Israel started a ground invasion.
The gathering followed UN Secretary-General Ban Ki Moon´s condemnation of the Israeli attacks.
He called for an "immediate" ceasefire of the hostilities which have claimed the lives of at least 460 Palestinians.
However, French Ambassador Jean-Maurice Ripert, who presides over the Security Council, said no formal agreement had been reached.
Libya submitted a draft statement that expressed "serious concern" about the ground invasion and called for an immediate ceasefire.
But the document was rejected, as it made no mention of the ongoing rocket attacks against Israel by Hamas, the Palestinian Islamist group that controls Gaza.
As Israel´s closest ally, the United States regularly vetoes resolutions it sees as too critical of the Jewish state.
On Friday, President Bush made clear he would not condemn an Israeli ground offensive.
à think it it would be much easier in The UN Security Council if it was about condemning the Gazian people for being killed by the Ãsraeli´s army using the american´s weapons !
why does everybody send links? dont you know nobody cares about links
It is actually the "source" of the materials that are important not the internet links (although it does provide the source) as when quoting anyones writings / articles etc. Otherwise you can get done for breaching copyright or plagiarism. (Ciko with an "h" ?? )
The bottom line is simple and obvious - the Zionist jews dont want peace, they want all the land without Arabs.
Ok, you´ll all hate me for that but I can´t bite my tongue here. In spite of the fact that I do condem Israeli attacks I can´t fail to see that there are two sides to this conflict and neither of them is peace loving. The issue here is taht Israel is way better armed and makes inexcusable and unproportional use of their force. I object to the propaganda of peaceful Palestinians, children-loving Hamas and violent Israel on their crusade to destroy all Arabs. That´s a simplification
Lessluv posted a really interesting article here, one that makes you thinks about causes and reasons, not one using cheap compassion. It´s easy to take pics of dead people and cities in ruins and say - Look, that´s our tragedy. Sure, it is a tragedy but it´s also PR. Think about why such things happen, have happened and will happen and then realise we learn nothing from history. Puting vinegar and soda together was bound to cause a stir up, now continue blaming one side for all
Ok, you´ll all hate me for that but I can´t bite my tongue here. In spite of the fact that I do condem Israeli attacks I can´t fail to see that there are two sides to this conflict and neither of them is peace loving. The issue here is taht Israel is way better armed and makes inexcusable and unproportional use of their force. I object to the propaganda of peaceful Palestinians, children-loving Hamas and violent Israel on their crusade to destroy all Arabs. That´s a simplification
Lessluv posted a really interesting article here, one that makes you thinks about causes and reasons, not one using cheap compassion. It´s easy to take pics of dead people and cities in ruins and say - Look, that´s our tragedy. Sure, it is a tragedy but it´s also PR. Think about why such things happen, have happened and will happen and then realise we learn nothing from history. Puting vinegar and soda together was bound to cause a stir up, now continue blaming one side for all
time to stand hand by hand against to all humanity crimes more then ever,by taking of our nationality,ethnicty ,cultural or beliefs shirts,otherwise all of us will suffocate in bloods of innocent kids and babies!!!!!
My sympathies are almost entirely with the Patastinians, however WHAT REALLY ANNOYS ME about this conflict is the attitude of muslims, who consider them to be "their people". I am quite certain that whatever the politics might be, muslims will always take the side of muslims. I have muslim friends who have openly admitted this to me. I remember Canli´s words... "we are burying our dead".
Siding with a particular religion, regardless of the issue, is something that I just can´t comprehend as is considering them to be "my people". What the hell is Islam teaching people if this is their attitude? It truly sickens me as i t implies that tragedies carry LESS importance if the victims are not muslims.
I am certain I am not alone in thinking that when there is tragedy, the religion or race of those affected is the LAST thing on my mind.
There are three churches searving 2000 christians linving in Ghaza strip. Christians are indeed a minority among the 1,3 million inhabitants. Many Palestinian christians are leaving and many had their land confiscated by israel in 1948. (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/4514822.stm)
In my opinion, most of the palestinian christians belong to the middle/upper class so they left when the situation was unbearable; Israel´s violence and acts of injustice on one hand and the rise of muslim fanaticism on the other hand.
Palestine is special for muslims mainly because of jerusalem and al aqsa mosque. May be thats why muslims around the world consider palestinians as "their people".
It is indeed that religion is the last thing on ones mind when there is tragedy, to quote TheAenigma.
However, when most tragedies in the world nowadays happen to people who belong to the same religion, namely islam, one might understand why all muslims side up together.
The israeli attacks represent a massive collective punishment against the 1.3 million people of Gaza and thus, under international law, constitute a war crime, violating Israel’s obligations as Occupying Power under the Geneva Conventions.
vallahi it is a tragedy. Israel never complied with international law. So many UN resolutions have been made against Israel and nothing happened. They invaded Lebanon and were responsible for the massacres in sabra and Shatila, and the whole world watched.
We have to admit it, Israel is a super power. Zionist Jews are influential in the US and in Europe. As a consequence, Israel is invincible and has a free hand to do whatever it pleases, ...... at least for now.
One thing is sure however, violence breeds violence.
There are three churches searving 2000 christians linving in Ghaza strip. Christians are indeed a minority among the 1,3 million inhabitants. Many Palestinian christians are leaving and many had their land confiscated by israel in 1948. (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/4514822.stm)
In my opinion, most of the palestinian christians belong to the middle/upper class so they left when the situation was unbearable; Israel´s violence and acts of injustice on one hand and the rise of muslim fanaticism on the other hand.
Palestine is special for muslims mainly because of jerusalem and al aqsa mosque. May be thats why muslims around the world consider palestinians as "their people".
It is indeed that religion is the last thing on ones mind when there is tragedy, to quote TheAenigma.
However, when most tragedies in the world nowadays happen to people who belong to the same religion, namely islam, one might understand why all muslims side up together.
The israeli attacks represent a massive collective punishment against the 1.3 million people of Gaza and thus, under international law, constitute a war crime, violating Israel’s obligations as Occupying Power under the Geneva Conventions.
vallahi it is a tragedy. Israel never complied with international law. So many UN resolutions have been made against Israel and nothing happened. They invaded Lebanon and were responsible for the massacres in sabra and Shatila, and the whole world watched.
We have to admit it, Israel is a super power. Zionist Jews are influential in the US and in Europe. As a consequence, Israel is invincible and has a free hand to do whatever it pleases, ...... at least for now.
One thing is sure however, violence breeds violence.
Ok, you´ll all hate me for that but I can´t bite my tongue here. In spite of the fact that I do condem Israeli attacks I can´t fail to see that there are two sides to this conflict and neither of them is peace loving. The issue here is taht Israel is way better armed and makes inexcusable and unproportional use of their force. I object to the propaganda of peaceful Palestinians, children-loving Hamas and violent Israel on their crusade to destroy all Arabs. That´s a simplification
Lessluv posted a really interesting article here, one that makes you thinks about causes and reasons, not one using cheap compassion. It´s easy to take pics of dead people and cities in ruins and say - Look, that´s our tragedy. Sure, it is a tragedy but it´s also PR. Think about why such things happen, have happened and will happen and then realise we learn nothing from history. Puting vinegar and soda together was bound to cause a stir up, now continue blaming one side for all
Ok, I see that you are trying to see ´both sides of the story´, but you are not supporting this with any facts! What is your basis for this??? This whole conflict has started with dirty politics of exploitation and humiliation. Nothing can overshadow that!!!
There are three churches searving 2000 christians linving in Ghaza strip. Christians are indeed a minority among the 1,3 million inhabitants. Many Palestinian christians are leaving and many had their land confiscated by israel in 1948. (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/4514822.stm)
In my opinion, most of the palestinian christians belong to the middle/upper class so they left when the situation was unbearable; Israel´s violence and acts of injustice on one hand and the rise of muslim fanaticism on the other hand.
i wonder why did you bring the case of forgotten palestinian christians? since when anyone was interested in them? strange enough no one paid attention when they are killed and persecuted by palestine muslims. or as tami would say its ok when muslim terrorists kill, but its not ok for israel to a self defence.
Palestine is special for muslims mainly because of jerusalem and al aqsa mosque. May be thats why muslims around the world consider palestinians as "their people".
It is indeed that religion is the last thing on ones mind when there is tragedy, to quote TheAenigma.
i think a deeper dive into history wouldnt hurt you. this all bloody story started with the alleged nightmare vision journey of mohammed to jerusalem which nobody knows for sure if it really happen.
However, when most tragedies in the world nowadays happen to people who belong to the same religion, namely islam, one might understand why all muslims side up together.
however, when theres any tragedy most of other religions show their compassion to the tragedies happening all over the world, they dont divide into our-not our thing. this is hardly an excuse to justify the real attitude of muslims to others.
The israeli attacks represent a massive collective punishment against the 1.3 million people of Gaza and thus, under international law, constitute a war crime, violating Israel’s obligations as Occupying Power under the Geneva Conventions.
and palestinian constant un-ending attacks to israel represent what? peace?
vallahi it is a tragedy. Israel never complied with international law. So many UN resolutions have been made against Israel and nothing happened. They invaded Lebanon and were responsible for the massacres in sabra and Shatila, and the whole world watched.
what a speech! why i never hear any condemnation from any muslim when they constantly blow up their neighbours in every corner of the world, be it america, europe or asia? why dont you muslims never write such a text or show your protest when thousands of sudanese were mass murdered? or are they less valuable to you?
We have to admit it, Israel is a super power. Zionist Jews are influential in the US and in Europe. As a consequence, Israel is invincible and has a free hand to do whatever it pleases, ...... at least for now.
i have to admit you dont know what you wrote.
One thing is sure however, violence breeds violence.
There will come a day ...
now this sounds like a call for a revenge. yes, there will be time when stones and trees will speak "heres a jew behind me, come and kill" according to the holy book of peaceful victims of great zionist conspiracy.
My sympathies are almost entirely with the Patastinians, however WHAT REALLY ANNOYS ME about this conflict is the attitude of muslims, who consider them to be "their people". I am quite certain that whatever the politics might be, muslims will always take the side of muslims. I have muslim friends who have openly admitted this to me. I remember Canli´s words... "we are burying our dead".
Siding with a particular religion, regardless of the issue, is something that I just can´t comprehend as is considering them to be "my people". What the hell is Islam teaching people if this is their attitude? It truly sickens me as i t implies that tragedies carry LESS importance if the victims are not muslims.
I am certain I am not alone in thinking that when there is tragedy, the religion or race of those affected is the LAST thing on my mind.
à dont know what do you expect me to deny here !
To be a humanitarian,and to show that i dont side with a particular religion shouldnt i say the words our people where they are already OURS?!
Ãm sorry,you may agree or not,but that is how it is,they are OUR people
Since many years ago,changing the borders wont deny them or us this,there are roots,family ties between many of us.
Our blood watered that land defending it through the years,and i tried to explain that to you before !
This was about thousand of years before BC
And this is through the Ottoman Empire time
And in between there was Salah Eldin,Mohamed Ali..and so many others through the history.
So you want me to deny all this and deal with the tragedy as its not ours?!
Sorry,but it is,because they are OURpeople...and we we are burying our deads!
I think it´s not fair to blame Muslims to side with each other, but it´s indeed not fair for Muslims to not side with victims of other conflicts. The best example is Turkish people not empathizing for Kurds, but empathizing for Palestinians. It´s all propaganda and self interest... no room for truth and real justice.
Kurds,and Ãranians are Muslims,so according to you and AE,i should also call them our people.
You are contradicting yourself here !
They are sure our brothers and sisters in humanity,muslims like us ´majority´...but they are not our people.
The maps i provided was only to show how deep the roots are.
But actually i dont need the maps to say if they are ours or not,as i said,bordered are different now,but that doesnt change the facts
I dont think I am contradicting myself at all here..
I am sure most of Iranians think the same as you. I mean they think ´our brothers are being killed´ too.
Same goes for the pakistani people..
Most of those ´our brothers´ rethoric is coming from the religious perspective.
Those people were not thinking the same when millions of muslims died in irak iran war..
Why?
Because there was not a christian army or a jews army performing the killing.
So AE had the right point there..
Most of those cries are coming out because ´jews are killing the muslims´.
When muslims kill eachother in the same place people dont cry like that..do they?
You also say that you did not fight against eachother but dont forget how many palestinians killed by Jordan in 1970.. So you did have wars between eachother..
Has anybody who supports isreal or people who starts talking ´but hamas is doing this and that´ tried to think themselves as Palestinians ?
Forget the religion piece of it..Religions come and go..100 years later, majority of people wont be believing god/allah etc..
But try to think yourselves as Palestinians..
Lets us, Turks try it..
Say that Hittites came back to Anatolia (they were the occupants at the time) and said that that is their country, after 2000 years..
and kicked you out of your homes , your lands..
Then started to use your homes and settled on your soil
placed us into refugee camps and put wals around us
some of you escaped to other countries and lived in the refugee camps there
Then all other countries like US EU supports Hittites
Even your best neighbours dont not support you
A little piece of land given to you by the UN and even that land is occupied..and nobody in the world cared about it.
All this injustice has gone on and on for last 60 years..
And you see your family members your mother, father, your childeren are suffering and fighting with the life while Hittites are having a comfortable life with the help of other powerful nations
the entire world recognizes them and not you
and you see this everyday and live with it
you get humuliated at the check points in your own soil everyday
and when you persue your rights everybody labels you as terrorist
Has anybody who supports isreal or people who starts talking ´but hamas is doing this and that´ tried to think themselves as Palestinians ?
Forget the religion piece of it..Religions come and go..100 years later, majority of people wont be believing god/allah etc..
But try to think yourselves as Palestinians..
Lets us, Turks try it..
Say that Hittites came back to Anatolia (they were the occupants at the time) and said that that is their country, after 2000 years..
and kicked you out of your homes , your lands..
Then started to use your homes and settled on your soil
placed us into refugee camps and put wals around us
some of you escaped to other countries and lived in the refugee camps there
Then all other countries like US EU supports Hittites
Even your best neighbours dont not support you
A little piece of land given to you by the UN and even that land is occupied..and nobody in the world cared about it.
All this injustice has gone on and on for last 60 years..
And you see your family members your mother, father, your childeren are suffering and fighting with the life while Hittites are having a comfortable life with the help of other powerful nations
the entire world recognizes them and not you
and you see this everyday and live with it
you get humuliated at the check points in your own soil everyday
and when you persue your rights everybody labels you as terrorist
I dont think I am contradicting myself at all here..
I am sure most of Iranians think the same as you. I mean they think ´our brothers are being killed´ too.
Same goes for the pakistani people..
Most of those ´our brothers´ rethoric is coming from the religious perspective.
Those people were not thinking the same when millions of muslims died in irak iran war..
Why?
Because there was not a christian army or a jews army performing the killing.
So AE had the right point there..
Most of those cries are coming out because ´jews are killing the muslims´.
When muslims kill eachother in the same place people dont cry like that..do they?
You also say that you did not fight against eachother but dont forget how many palestinians killed by Jordan in 1970.. So you did have wars between eachother..
No handsom,you are contradicting yourself.
You said i call palestinians our people because they are muslims,and asked me why dont i call kurds,Ãranians also our people .
According to that logic,i should also call them our people,and you doubt that i do
See?messy ,eh ?
Thats why i said you are contradicting yourself.
As i said in previous posts,to me,to us ´Egyptians´ Palestinians are our people,regardless of religion.
You know,today is the Christmas here 7/1
And the christmas eve is tonight,celebrating it in churches,where they expect it will be flammable this year,with many protestors and many demands to the Pope too because of Gaza
So they also side with Muslims there,or with the christians in Gaza ?!!!
They just side with OUR People in Gaza.
Ãts really that simple !
As for Jordan needless to say how deep the roots are there,or the number of the Palestinians,but just small thing...Queen Rania is also Palestinian!
Has anybody who supports isreal or people who starts talking ´but hamas is doing this and that´ tried to think themselves as Palestinians ?
But try to think yourselves as Palestinians..
Lets us, Turks try it..
à think Turks already know that.
But im with you..
Why doesnt anyone try it.
Even better...
Ãf you are sitting in your own home,then came some armed few people and kicked you out of your home,and fire at some of your family
Some run away to the neighbours to hide
Some Stayed at the terrace,and try to entered
And keep knocking.
Neighbours call the police,but the police was already corruptedgot paid by the armed men
So,they say,let things as they are.
And when you try to fight your way back..to your own home
Even by throwing stones at the windows
They call the police,and police condemn you ...and the armed people,fire at you..claiming they are defending themselves,and you are a thief,terrorist,try to break in !
........"And I write the following without the slightest doubt: we´ll hear all these scandalous fabrications again. We´ll have the Hamas-to-blame lie – heaven knows, there is enough to blame them for without adding this crime – and we may well have the bodies-from-the-cemetery lie and we´ll almost certainly have the Hamas-was-in-the-UN-school lie and we will very definitely have the anti-Semitism lie. And our leaders will huff and puff and remind the world that Hamas originally broke the ceasefire. It didn´t. Israel broke it, first on 4 November when its bombardment killed six Palestinians in Gaza and again on 17 November when another bombardment killed four more Palestinians".
i unconsciously see Palestenians ( muslim or non-muslim) or Balkan People "as our people". it is probably historical background. and i dont understand what is wrong with it. how can you ignore cultural and historic affinity?
Quoting CANLI
He said i am siding up with Palestinians and call them our people just for being Muslims.
At same time he doesnt think i call Kurds and Ãranians our people..Kurds and Ãranians are also muslims
Ãf what he said first was right,then what he said second would be wrong and vice versa.
Dr . Mads Gilbert, a Norwegian doctor in Gaza, tells Sky News that the number of civilians injured and killed in Gaza proves that Israel is deliberately attacking the population.
“Just a little bit more than an hour ago the Israelis bombed the central fruit market in Gaza city and we had a mass influx of about 50 injured and between 10 and 15 killed. At the same time they bombed an apartment house with children playing on the roof and we had a lot of children also. So this is really like speaking from the dumps of Inferno, it’s like hell here now, and it’s been bombing all night. Until now close to 500 people have been killed and the number of casualties is getting to 2,500 of which 50% are children and women.
Are your hospitals reaching capacity? Can you deal with these people?
We have been doing surgery around the clock. I have just talked with one of my colleagues in the ICU (Intensive Care Unit), he´s not been sleeping for three days and the hospital is completely overcrowded, we are running 6 - 7 Ors (Operating Rooms) and there are injuries you just don’t want to see in this world… children coming in with open abdomens and legs cut off. We just had a child that we had to amputate both legs and an arm. And their only crime is being civilians and Palestinians living in Gaza. The relief now is not more doctors and more drugs; the relief now is to stop the bombing immediately, this cannot go on, it’s a disaster.
You’ve talked about the civilians, the women, the children, the men who aren’t involved in this, but are you also getting casualties that are Hamas fighters?
To be honest, we came on New Year’s Eve in the morning. I’ve seen one military person among the tenths… I mean hundreds that we’ve seen and treated, so anybody who tries to portrait this as a totally clean war against another army are lying. This is an all-out war against the civilian Palestinian population in Gaza, and we can prove that with numbers. And you have to remember that the average age of the Gaza inhabitants is 17 years, it’s a very young population, and 80% are living below the poverty limit of the UN. So this is a poor and very young people, and they are able to escape absolutely nowhere, because they cannot flee like other populations can in war time, because they are fenced in and they are in a cage, so they’re bombing 1.5 million people in a cage… young people, poor people and, you know, you cannot separate between the civilians and the fighters in such a situation.”
........"And I write the following without the slightest doubt: we´ll hear all these scandalous fabrications again. We´ll have the Hamas-to-blame lie – heaven knows, there is enough to blame them for without adding this crime – and we may well have the bodies-from-the-cemetery lie and we´ll almost certainly have the Hamas-was-in-the-UN-school lie and we will very definitely have the anti-Semitism lie. And our leaders will huff and puff and remind the world that Hamas originally broke the ceasefire. It didn´t. Israel broke it, first on 4 November when its bombardment killed six Palestinians in Gaza and again on 17 November when another bombardment killed four more Palestinians".
i suggest you first have a look on this. robert fisk may write this and that, but i doubt he states facts.
mr mads gilbert, a good samaritan from norway doesnt know the tactics of muslims. they hide behind civilians, they hide their weapons in the mosques, schools, and even hospitals. they dont evacuate civilians out of fire line but opposite they push them to the front line.
they train little children and young women to become martyrs. if they themselves dont protect their families and ready to offer them as targets, front line heros, victims in front page. then why do expect that enemies should care for them?
mr mads gilbert, a good samaritan from norway doesnt know the tactics of muslims. they hide behind civilians, they hide their weapons in the mosques, schools, and even hospitals. they dont evacuate civilians out of fire line but opposite they push them to the front line.
they train little children and young women to become martyrs. if they themselves dont protect their families and ready to offer them as targets, front line heros, victims in front page. then why do expect that enemies should care for them?
mr mads gilbert, a good samaritan from norway doesnt know the tactics of muslims. they hide behind civilians, they hide their weapons in the mosques, schools, and even hospitals. they dont evacuate civilians out of fire line but opposite they push them to the front line.
they train little children and young women to become martyrs. if they themselves dont protect their families and ready to offer them as targets, front line heros, victims in front page. then why do expect that enemies should care for them?
mr mads gilbert, a good samaritan from norway doesnt know the tactics of muslims. they hide behind civilians, they hide their weapons in the mosques, schools, and even hospitals. they dont evacuate civilians out of fire line but opposite they push them to the front line.
they train little children and young women to become martyrs. if they themselves dont protect their families and ready to offer them as targets, front line heros, victims in front page. then why do expect that enemies should care for them?
i really think that you should apologize for this, at least as a token of respect for them:
The meeting of Israel´s security Cabinet comes a day after France and Egypt sketched a proposal to stop the fighting. The initiative was spurred on by an Israeli mortar strike near a United Nations school the U.N. says killed 40 Palestinians.
The U.S. has endorsed the proposal. Israel has yet to give its response.
Israeli officials, speaking on condition of anonymity because no decision has been made, say Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and his top ministers will consider the proposal today or whether to press ahead with the 12-day operation meant to stop rocket fire into Israel.
Israel has killed more than 600 Palestinians in the fighting.
The United Nations agency dealing with Palestinian refugees says it´s certain that Hamas militants were not using its school to attack Israeli troops.
Israel said militants fired mortar shells at its troops from outside the school, drawing return fire.
Christopher Guinness of the U.N. Relief and Works Agency said today ``UNWRA is 99.9 percent certain there were no militants or military activity in its school.´´
i unconsciously see Palestenians ( muslim or non-muslim) or Balkan People "as our people". it is probably historical background. and i dont understand what is wrong with it. how can you ignore cultural and historic affinity?
Quoting CANLI
He said i am siding up with Palestinians and call them our people just for being Muslims.
At same time he doesnt think i call Kurds and Ãranians our people..Kurds and Ãranians are also muslims
Ãf what he said first was right,then what he said second would be wrong and vice versa.
Thats contradiction.
I never said that anything wrong with it..
I was trying to show the religious elements, religious sidelining in those feelings.
The latest figures from Palestinian health officials say 205 children are among some 600 people who have died in the Gaza war. In the chaos, there are no statistics for how many are among the at least 2,900 injured.
...
He talks of a boy he treated five years ago. Grappling in the dark after his house was hit in an airstrike on a Hamas militant next door, he felt something wet.
"He realised it was the flesh of his sister who was blown into pieces. He was in such a state. He couldn´t eat or smell meat for three years after that. I am sure he will suffer some kind of long-term psychological impact."
i think i dont share your thoughts. sorry to hurt your feelings. tami is right i dont have to. its my personal opinion on this issue.
Quoting thehandsom
The latest figures from Palestinian health officials say 205 children are among some 600 people who have died in the Gaza war. In the chaos, there are no statistics for how many are among the at least 2,900 injured.
...
He talks of a boy he treated five years ago. Grappling in the dark after his house was hit in an airstrike on a Hamas militant next door, he felt something wet.
"He realised it was the flesh of his sister who was blown into pieces. He was in such a state. He couldn´t eat or smell meat for three years after that. I am sure he will suffer some kind of long-term psychological impact."
i am terribly sorry, but when children are killed, other "personal opinions" seem just a mockery of common sense.....
me too, sorry for those children that were used as shelters. children are innocent, they were supposed to be evacuated from the war place and kept in havens. but adult palestinians didnt give even a little thought to that, because usually to the nature of culture and religion children in there have no bigger importance than the religion and its ideology.
On reading Canli vs Thehandsom...should I call all atheists my people? Or, bearing in mind the extent of Poland in the past, are all those easterners MY PEOPLE too? I´m getting lost who´s with me and who isn´t
i think canli has reached her goal. you are supposed to feel so according to the scenario. read her posts to hairy and you start feeling dizzy. this is how she often sneaks out from the direct answer.
i think canli has reached her goal. you are supposed to feel so according to the scenario. read her posts to hairy and you start feeling dizzy. this is how she often sneaks out from the direct answer.
It might be a language thing, I don´t speak Arabic but perhaps it is more evasive than English or Polish whose logic I am used to
yeah right. you have saved her. im sure her cake with which she bribed you has still a great influence on you.
Well..you know me - I´d do ANYTHING for sweets everybody has a weak spot and this is mine - torture me, hit me, verbally abuse me - I will never change my mind. Serve me a plate of cake and I´ll nod to your every word
Well..you know me - I´d do ANYTHING for sweets everybody has a weak spot and this is mine - torture me, hit me, verbally abuse me - I will never change my mind. Serve me a plate of cake and I´ll nod to your every word
canli is too smart, she knows which string to pull. i knew that too and hairy our best dudu still doesnt know how to get your msn.
i wonder why did you bring the case of forgotten palestinian christians? since when anyone was interested in them? strange enough no one paid attention when they are killed and persecuted by palestine muslims. or as tami would say its ok when muslim terrorists kill, but its not ok for israel to a self defence.
The conflict between Israel and Palestine is not a religeous one i.e. it is not a conflict between Jews and Muslims as Israelis want and like to show. It is a conflict between one nation (that includes muslims and christians) that had its land confiscated and a group people who share the same religion, namely judaism, imported from all over the world.
May be you are not interested in christian palestinians but there are many of us who are interested in them.
i think a deeper dive into history wouldnt hurt you. this all bloody story started with the alleged nightmare vision journey of mohammed to jerusalem which nobody knows for sure if it really happen.
If you too dive more deeper into history you find also that this all bloody story started when jews decided to claim a land that is not really theirs based on a story told in the old testament. Nobody really knows that was true!
They have been digging for years trying to find any ruins of king solomon´s temple and still they found nothing. May be it is in Uganda , Theodor Herzl should have accepted the british proposal afterall to establish the jewish state there. He founded the jewish state in Basle as he said himself, the only thing left was to find the land!
however, when theres any tragedy most of other religions show their compassion to the tragedies happening all over the world, they dont divide into our-not our thing. this is hardly an excuse to justify the real attitude of muslims to others.
You are right on this one but it happens that this is human nature. we sympathize more with the ones that are close to us in a way or another.
and palestinian constant un-ending attacks to israel represent what? peace?
Well, Israel surrounds them and puts them under seige, controls their movements. they dont have the right to have an airport, or a seaport. Israel controls their water, and it even steals it from the west bank and when they retaliate we ask them to do so "peacefully"!!
what a speech! why i never hear any condemnation from any muslim when they constantly blow up their neighbours in every corner of the world, be it america, europe or asia? why dont you muslims never write such a text or show your protest when thousands of sudanese were mass murdered? or are they less valuable to you?
I dont agree with their methods and I condemn all kinds of violence and many of us in lebanon protested against the janjawid and the sudanese government. Human life is valuable.
i have to admit you dont know what you wrote.
That is your opinion. However I think you jump fast into conclusions. Whenever you see someone defending the palestinian cause you think he is a muslim. If I do the same as you do,I would say you are a jew or a mormon. But I dont
I am not a muslim, never been one and I dont intend to convert!
now this sounds like a call for a revenge. yes, there will be time when stones and trees will speak "heres a jew behind me, come and kill" according to the holy book of peaceful victims of great zionist conspiracy.
woow...you do hate muslims and islam that much dont you?
yes there will come a day when the weak shall be strong and also a day when everyone understands that they need to live peacefully together because in a war no one gains everyone looses. I speak this out of experience. We had all kinds of wars in Lebanon and at the end we all lost dear ones and we all had at one time or another our homes bombed or even destroyed.
The conflict between Israel and Palestine is not a religeous one i.e. it is not a conflict between Jews and Muslims as Israelis want and like to show. It is a conflict between one nation (that includes muslims and christians) that had its land confiscated and a group people who share the same religion, namely judaism, imported from all over the world.
its not true. every muslim who fights, fights in the cause of allah. in islam a land once invaded and islamised cannot be taken away, this is how the palestine will never agree for peace and will never agree with the state of israel.
its not jews who portray so, its muslims show it, they are in religious conflict with every neighbouring nations/religions.
May be you are not interested in christian palestinians but there are many of us who are interested in them.
it has nothing to do with my interest. its just your manipulation. palestinian christians suddenly in the centre of attention. why didnt you bring up their case earlier if you were so keen on them?
If you too dive more deeper into history you find also that this all bloody story started when jews decided to claim a land that is not really theirs based on a story told in the old testament. Nobody really knows that was true!
wow, im amused by your knowledge. so you deny the facts that they were murdered by romans and scattered away? pls, im not interested in pathetic fairy tales circled among muslims.
They have been digging for years trying to find any ruins of king solomon´s temple and still they found nothing. May be it is in Uganda , Theodor Herzl should have accepted the british proposal afterall to establish the jewish state there. He founded the jewish state in Basle as he said himself, the only thing left was to find the land!
then you should educate yourself with historical facts. the temple was ruined totally by the order of titus.
here educate yourself: a link to first temple destroyed by babylonians
You are right on this one but it happens that this is human nature. we sympathize more with the ones that are close to us in a way or another.
yes, but non-muslims are seem to be then less human according to your description.
Well, Israel surrounds them and puts them under seige, controls their movements. they dont have the right to have an airport, or a seaport. Israel controls their water, and it even steals it from the west bank and when they retaliate we ask them to do so "peacefully"!!
i thought it was israel that is surrounded by arabs
to have an airport to smuggle more professional terrorists including weapon from afghanistan, pakistan, iran, iraq, saudi and egypt?
I dont agree with their methods and I condemn all kinds of violence and many of us in lebanon protested against the janjawid and the sudanese government. Human life is valuable.
well, i never heard your condemnation then, so i didnt hear any condemnation from any other muslim users when there are constant terror attacks carried out by muslims on almost everyday basis. they say they carried out more than thousands of attacks since 9/11. people even dont count terrorism before 9/11 anymore. they lost the count.
That is your opinion. However I think you jump fast into conclusions. Whenever you see someone defending the palestinian cause you think he is a muslim. If I do the same as you do,I would say you are a jew or a mormon. But I dont
i really dont care what you would call me. people call me all pathetic names. it really doesnt matter. you are from lebanon, a muslim country. and even if you are atheist you will always side up with muslims just like our turkish members here who declare themselves as atheists. its just a culture based on strong religious ties.
I am not a muslim, never been one and I dont intend to convert!
i really dont care for this.
woow...you do hate muslims and islam that much dont you?
aww, you are smart, you guessed it.
i do hate their mentality and culture (most of them are not to blame, but it irritates me that they never question their religion, oh, i forgot, they are not allowed by mohammed). yes i hate islam, i never tried to hide it. theres nothing really to love in it.
yes there will come a day when the weak shall be strong and also a day when everyone understands that they need to live peacefully together because in a war no one gains everyone looses. I speak this out of experience. We had all kinds of wars in Lebanon and at the end we all lost dear ones and we all had at one time or another our homes bombed or even destroyed.
i cant really say what will happen in the future, im not a prophet.
i doubt if there ever be peace. not that i wish so, but looking at the history of human kind i hesitate to state so.
its not true. every muslim who fights, fights in the cause of allah. in islam a land once invaded and islamised cannot be taken away, this is how the palestine will never agree for peace and will never agree with the state of israel.
its not jews who portray so, its muslims show it, they are in religious conflict with every neighbouring nations/religions.
I didnt know they islamize the land I thought they islamize the people!
I think if the palestinians were given a real chance to establish their sovrenty they are ready to live in peace side by side with Israel.
then you should educate yourself with historical facts. the temple was ruined totally by the order of titus.
hmm if it is a fact that it was TOTALLY destroyed as you say , then why would the Israelis do excavations under the Al Aqsa mosque looking for ruins!!!!
Then it is true all their aim is destruction and mainly destroying the mosque!
.
yes, but non-muslims are seem to be then less human according to your description
I cannot see how you came with this conclusion! everyone tends to sympathize with his close one whether he admits it or not.
i thought it was israel that is surrounded by arabs
to have an airport to smuggle more professional terrorists including weapon from afghanistan, pakistan, iran, iraq, saudi and egypt?
Yes indeed Israel is surrounded by arabs who are doing nothing. Not a single bullet goes from the syrian borders to Israel, nor from egyptian nor jordanians. Tourists from Israel come and go to Jordan as they please. The only exception is Lebanese borders and that is due to the fact that Israel is still occupying a lebanese land without excuse, sheb´a farms thus giving an alibi to Hizballa to keep attacking north of Israel. If they just withdraw from our land and then judge whether there will be peace on the borders or not!!
So you think palestinians are better without airports and seaports and they should pass by Israeli checkpoints everyday and yet do nothing!?
We´re condmening them before they do anything. No wonder palestinians sided up with Hamas!! If one keeps thinking they are terrorist no matter what they say or do even of they sit down for peace negociations then they better become terrorist, just to go with their reputation at least
.
well, i never heard your condemnation then, so i didnt hear any condemnation from any other muslim users when there are constant terror attacks carried out by muslims on almost everyday basis. they say they carried out more than thousands of attacks since 9/11. people even dont count terrorism before 9/11 anymore. they lost the count.
I never heard your condemnation for Sabra and Shatila neither!
I condemn violence and I dont have to repeat it and reply to every post talking about islamists terrorists!
i really dont care what you would call me. people call me all pathetic names. it really doesnt matter. you are from lebanon, a muslim country. and even if you are atheist you will always side up with muslims just like our turkish members here who declare themselves as atheists. its just a culture based on strong religious ties.
Here you are completely wrong. lebanon is NOT a muslim country never was and never will be. Lebanon is 50% muslims and 50% christians with all in all 18 different religeous sects. the president is ALWAYS maronite christian and the chief of staff of the army is always maronite christian and the head of secret services is always maronite christian. It is stated in the law. The islamic law has no valor except for marriages,divorces and inheritence for muslim citizens only. How would it be a muslim country then!!
I am not an atheist. I belong to one of these 18 religeous sects and I dont side up with muslims.
Apparently you are not from the region so you dont know the details of the middle east.
An Israeli would never call lebanon a muslim country. You are just blindly siding up with Israel may be based on "strong religeous ties".
aww, you are smart, you guessed it.
i do hate their mentality and culture (most of them are not to blame, but it irritates me that they never question their religion, oh, i forgot, they are not allowed by mohammed). yes i hate islam, i never tried to hide it. theres nothing really to love in it.
YOu dont know much about Islam. One of the basics in Islam is "doubt" and there is an islamic saying that goes like "doubt is the way to truth" (al shak howa tareeq alyaqeen) الشك هو طريق اليقين .
May be the muslims you met never question their religion but you havent met all muslims have you!?
i cant really say what will happen in the future, im not a prophet.
i doubt if there ever be peace. not that i wish so, but looking at the history of human kind i hesitate to state so
I am sure there will be peace one day. Many Israeli civilians realized this and do protest against war. I hope politicians will understand this soon. else we will be all doomed in an endless war in the region.
me too, sorry for those children that were used as shelters. children are innocent, they were supposed to be evacuated from the war place and kept in havens. but adult palestinians didnt give even a little thought to that, because usually to the nature of culture and religion children in there have no bigger importance than the religion and its ideology.
SPEECHLESS!!!!IM COMPLETELY AND UTTERLY SPEECHLESS!!!!
me too, sorry for those children that were used as shelters. children are innocent, they were supposed to be evacuated from the war place and kept in havens. but adult palestinians didnt give even a little thought to that, because usually to the nature of culture and religion children in there have no bigger importance than the religion and its ideology.
Hmm, Israel withdrew 3 years ago from the Gaza strip in order to instill peace..since then Hamas has sent over 3 thousand missles into Israel within the last year targeting civilians. Can´t really comprehend why anyone is questioning Israel´s actions...Your not suggesting they need to peacefully discuss this sitting at the kitchen table now...just a little too late for that.
"The Palestinian-Israeli conflict is not just an issue of military occupation and Israel is not a country that was established normally. Apartheid is a crime against humanity. Israel has deprived millions of Palestinians of their liberty and property. It has perpetuated a system of gross racial discrimination and inequality. It has systematically incarcerated and tortured thousands of Palestinians, contrary to the rules of international law. It has waged a war against a civilian population, in particular children ... Palestinians are not struggling for a "state" but for freedom, liberation and equality, just like we were struggling for freedom in South Africa ..." --Nelson Mandela, March 2001
QUOTING ISMAIL KHATIB, FATHER OF AHMED KHATIB
"I hope we can live a peaceful life without the killing of children. My children and the Palestinian children in the camp are dreaming of a life in peace and freedom." -- Ismail Khatib, father of Ahmed Khatib, an 11 year old boy shot in the head by an Israeli sniper, upon donating his son´s organs to save the lives of Jewish children.
I didnt know they islamize the land I thought they islamize the people!
im pretty sure you know little about islam like many many muslims.
I think if the palestinians were given a real chance to establish their sovrenty they are ready to live in peace side by side with Israel.
i think palestinians wasted a lot chances given to them, spitting onto the kind hand. im 100%sure arabs will never let palestinians live in peace. palestinian arabs are pawns in the hand of wealthy spoiled by oil other arabs.
hmm if it is a fact that it was TOTALLY destroyed as you say , then why would the Israelis do excavations under the Al Aqsa mosque looking for ruins!!!!
oh, because, jews are smart, they excavate everything, they have found many interesting basements underneath jerusalem. btw, i heard they did excavations near al-aqsa not under it. and why did you bring this up? has it any significanse to this topic?
Then it is true all their aim is destruction and mainly destroying the mosque!
duh, tell me what part of it was destroyed?
.
I cannot see how you came with this conclusion! everyone tends to sympathize with his close one whether he admits it or not.
im singing in the rain, im singing in the rain.
Yes indeed Israel is surrounded by arabs who are doing nothing. Not a single bullet goes from the syrian borders to Israel, nor from egyptian nor jordanians.
oh my, what happent? did they learn a lesson from the past?
Tourists from Israel come and go to Jordan as they please. The only exception is Lebanese borders and that is due to the fact that Israel is still occupying a lebanese land without excuse, sheb´a farms thus giving an alibi to Hizballa to keep attacking north of Israel. If they just withdraw from our land and then judge whether there will be peace on the borders or not!!
Five years after gaining independence, Lebanon joined the Arab League in invading Israel within hours after its independence.[23][24]. It took over logistical support of the Arab Liberation Army after it found itself cut off from its bases in Syria while going on an attack on the newly proclaimed Jewish State.[24] The Lebanese military gained nothing during the war, and the Israeli army managed to conquer territory west of the Naphtali Mountains.[23] After the defeat of the Arab Liberation Army in Operation Hiram,[25] Lebanon accepted an armistice with Israel on 23 March 1949 and the conquered territory was returned. During the war, about 100,000 Palestinian refugees fled to Lebanon (here starts all your troubles).
a war with israel was a mistake and a curse. lebanon will bear the consequences for very long, i reckon.
So you think palestinians are better without airports and seaports and they should pass by Israeli checkpoints everyday and yet do nothing!?
of course, there are lots of suicide bombers there, young boys from poor families and young women with a damaged reputation. they must be better checked.
they anyway smuggle weapon and terrorists underground and imagine if they had open airports they would have nuclear weapon by this time. israeli checkpoints caught lots of humanitarian aid trucks full of weapon instead of sugar or flour just from europe.
We´re condmening them before they do anything. No wonder palestinians sided up with Hamas!! If one keeps thinking they are terrorist no matter what they say or do even of they sit down for peace negociations then they better become terrorist, just to go with their reputation at least
i personally have condemned them after what they did. as i said im not a prophet to predict the future. most of them now regret for siding up with terrorists, you sure know that or french tv is censored?
I never heard your condemnation for Sabra and Shatila neither!
I condemn violence and I dont have to repeat it and reply to every post talking about islamists terrorists!
im not talking about the violence happent 20 years ago. if i follow your thinking, i too didnt hear you condemning the holocaust done on jews. but i dont follow your way of thinking.
Here you are completely wrong. lebanon is NOT a muslim country never was and never will be. Lebanon is 50% muslims and 50% christians with all in all 18 different religeous sects. the president is ALWAYS maronite christian and the chief of staff of the army is always maronite christian and the head of secret services is always maronite christian. It is stated in the law. The islamic law has no valor except for marriages,divorces and inheritence for muslim citizens only. How would it be a muslim country then!!
ooooo, i dont agree with you. this description belongs to lebanon of 40-50 years ago.
listen to this brave lady, she doesnt hide like you and doesnt hide her identity.
I am not an atheist. I belong to one of these 18 religeous sects and I dont side up with muslims.
you can keep your identity to yourself, you act like alameda. your secret doesnt attract me. what to be guessed? you are either druze or maronite. but do i care? we are anyway very different.
Apparently you are not from the region so you dont know the details of the middle east.
An Israeli would never call lebanon a muslim country. You are just blindly siding up with Israel may be based on "strong religeous ties".
apparently you are an expert of middle east and "jews" keep your mysterious details to yourself
an israeli can call lebanon whatever, not my business.
im siding up with a common sense. or maybe vai vai i may have jewish roots thats why i feel religious ties? i dont have enough money to do the genetic tests
YOu dont know much about Islam. One of the basics in Islam is "doubt" and there is an islamic saying that goes like "doubt is the way to truth" (al shak howa tareeq alyaqeen) الشك هو طريق اليقين
"They alone seek leave of thee (not to participate in jihad) who believe not in Allah and the Last Day and whose hearts feel doubt, so in their doubt they waver" (Qur´an, al-Tauba 45).
Many scholars have stated that the diseases of the heart, or the doubt and suspicions that one allows into one´s heart, are more dangerous for a person´s faith than lusts and desires. This is because lusts and desires may be satisfied at some time yet the person still knows them to be wrong and he may control himself and repent and give up that evil deed. On the other hand, the doubts and suspicions may linger in the heart, with no cure, until the person finally leaves Islam entirely or continues to practice Islam while, in fact, in his heart he does not have the true faith.
basically, muslims are not allowed to question and doubt about allah.
May be the muslims you met never question their religion but you havent met all muslims have you!?
it seems you have met them all? all millions of them dont argue with me, i will trap you with your own words.
I am sure there will be peace one day. Many Israeli civilians realized this and do protest against war. I hope politicians will understand this soon. else we will be all doomed in an endless war in the region.
here, i again have to side with a common sense. many israeli civilians? apparently again you have met many israelis? those who protest against every action of israel are the orthodox jews.
well, lets say that politicians understood something, how would they end this conflict?
you should finally open your eyes: theres no solution to this conflict.
Hmm, Israel withdrew 3 years ago from the Gaza strip in order to instill peace..since then Hamas has sent over 3 thousand missles into Israel within the last year targeting civilians. Can´t really comprehend why anyone is questioning Israel´s actions...Your not suggesting they need to peacefully discuss this sitting at the kitchen table now...just a little too late for that.
Are you saying that your conscience is clear about Israel going in and killing 700 people (including many civilians, many childeren)?
you are saying that you do NOT show any remorse when you see blown up childeren´s pictures?
you are not sorry even a little?
So it is alright for you they kill 700 in 10 days for missles which killed only handful of israelies during 3 years (I dont know exactly how many Israelies got killed because of that)?
Are you saying that your conscience is clear about Israel going in and killing 700 people (including many civilians, many childeren)?
you are saying that you do NOT show any remorse when you see blown up childeren´s pictures?
you are not sorry even a little?
So it is alright for you they kill 700 in 10 days for missles which killed only handful of israelies during 3 years (I dont know exactly how many Israelies got killed because of that)?
israel is not responsible for the actions of hamas and other terror supporting neighbours who use palestinian civilians as targets. end of story.
The Yesha Rabbinical Council announced in response to an IDF attack in Kfar Qanna that "according to Jewish law, during a time of battle and war, there is no such term as ´innocents´ of the enemy."
All of the discussions on Christian morality are weakening the spirit of the army and the nation and are costing us in the blood of our soldiers and civilians," the statement said. (Efrat Weiss)
Hmm, Israel withdrew 3 years ago from the Gaza strip in order to instill peace..since then Hamas has sent over 3 thousand missles into Israel within the last year targeting civilians. Can´t really comprehend why anyone is questioning Israel´s actions...Your not suggesting they need to peacefully discuss this sitting at the kitchen table now...just a little too late for that.
Straight Fox news propaganda. Israel withdrew their military from OCCUPIED territory! A territory THEY occupied! Do you see the cause and effect there? Israel has violated international laws there!!!
Are you saying that your conscience is clear about Israel going in and killing 700 people (including many civilians, many childeren)?
you are saying that you do NOT show any remorse when you see blown up childeren´s pictures?
you are not sorry even a little?
So it is alright for you they kill 700 in 10 days for missles which killed only handful of israelies during 3 years (I dont know exactly how many Israelies got killed because of that)?
Hmm, Israel withdrew 3 years ago from the Gaza strip in order to instill peace..since then Hamas has sent over 3 thousand missles into Israel within the last year targeting civilians. Can´t really comprehend why anyone is questioning Israel´s actions...Your not suggesting they need to peacefully discuss this sitting at the kitchen table now...just a little too late for that.
I have watched this conflict for years, it is NOT getting better. The tactics used by Israel and Hamas are not working. There has to be a better way!
Almost a thousand lives have been lost is a very gruesome manner.....and that doesn´t even begin to address the matter of the thousands maimed. This is not a road to peace.
I hang my head in shame for the disgrace this conflict has visited on humanity, and any participation I may have had in it.
In the end, the reasons for the conflict get lost. Each side has their own version and unfortunately, that is the way in the world of conflict. What CANNOT get lost is the fact that thousands of innocent people are being killed.
Opposing sides will never agree on who is at fault, not Israeli’s or Palestinian’s, the US or the UN or the warring factions at TC. Who is at fault does not really matter right now, not when so many innocent people are dying. What matters is that it must stop…and it will…there will be a cease fire in time. But we have seen this before and I think the one thing we can all agree on is that it will start up again.
I am absolutely mortified and disgusted that my country shot down the UN proposal to call for a cease fire (even though, in my opinion, the UN is completely worthless, but that’s another story)!
How many more lives must be lost in the name of land?
i think palestinians wasted a lot chances given to them, spitting onto the kind hand. im 100%sure arabs will never let palestinians live in peace. palestinian arabs are pawns in the hand of wealthy spoiled by oil other arabs.
What chances,? to always live under israeli control! chekpoints everywhere.
to have settlements sprout like mushrooms between palestinian villages and land and water confiscated everyday by israelis?
you call this a fair chance given by a kind hand?
oh, because, jews are smart, they excavate everything, they have found many interesting basements underneath jerusalem. btw, i heard they did excavations near al-aqsa not under it. and why did you bring this up? has it any significanse to this topic?
and it is a matter of great significance because there is a fear that the foundations of the mosque will be destabilized. may be they are smart but that does´nt give thim the right to excavate under the mosque, the land is not theirs!
This has a significance to this topic to show you that Israelis dont want peace, they keep on stiring up troubles here and there. They know the significance of the mosque to muslims and yet they deliberately excavate "under" the mosque.
oh my, what happent? did they learn a lesson from the past?
may be they did so they decided it is better to live in peace instead of continuing with this uggly war forever thus saving lives. Let´s hope the israelis learn as well. one can learn from the defeat of the others no?
During the war, about 100,000 Palestinian refugees fled to Lebanon (here starts all your troubles).
Exactly, thats where all the troubles started, when the palestinians were kicked out of their homes and land by israelis and they had to go to the neighbouring countries.
What do you expect to happen to all the people who were displaced, vanish in the nature or drown in the sea!
a war with israel was a mistake and a curse. lebanon will bear the consequences for very long, i reckon.
as long as the palestinian issue is not solved all neighbouring countries will suffer. In lebanon there are around 400 thousand palestinian refugees living in camps. Much more (I dont have exact numbers) are refugees living in camps in syria and jordan.
of course, there are lots of suicide bombers there, young boys from poor families and young women with a damaged reputation. they must be better checked.
they anyway smuggle weapon and terrorists underground and imagine if they had open airports they would have nuclear weapon by this time. israeli checkpoints caught lots of humanitarian aid trucks full of weapon instead of sugar or flour just from europe.
I havent heard of this news, but you may be right.
again, i am sure if palestinians were given freedom and the possibility to live decently on their land you wouldnt hear of any suicide bombers again.
i personally have condemned them after what they did. as i said im not a prophet to predict the future. most of them now regret for siding up with terrorists, you sure know that or french tv is censored?
luckily the french TV is not censored and the french were the ones who took the picture few years ago of that israeli soldier deliberately shooting at a helpless boy hiding behind a barrel with his father trying to protect him. here is a reminder
he was not a suicide bomber he was just a child coming back from school but to israelis all palestinian kids are potential suicide bombers no?
im not talking about the violence happent 20 years ago. if i follow your thinking, i too didnt hear you condemning the holocaust done on jews. but i dont follow your way of thinking.
We condemn the holocaust every second of the day believe me, first because it was inhuman injust and barbaric, and also because it gave a reason to some jews to badly treat others and have a feeling of superiority. The sad thing is that no one can answer back because they would call you anti-semite and that is a crime you know. anti muslim or anti arab is not a crime on the contrary it is a virtue nowadays!
ooooo, i dont agree with you. this description belongs to lebanon of 40-50 years ago.
listen to this brave lady, she doesnt hide like you and doesnt hide her identity.
Your lady gabriel definitely twist the facts but then you are free to believe her.
Her parents were with what we call "the army of south lebanon" mainly a group of people "shi´a, druze and maronites" who collaborated with the israelis. After the israeli withdrawal from south lebanon fewyears ago (except from shib´a farms) most of them fled either to israel or to the states for fear of being brought to trial for treason.
we are anyway very different.
Indeed we are and that is what makes the world beautiful, the diversity.
basically, muslims are not allowed to question and doubt about allah.
There are many school of thought in Islam.
One great philosopher and scholar is "al-ghazzali" (1058-1111) who belived that doubt is the only way to truth and in this matter he did anticipate Descartes. If you are interested in widening up your philosophical knowledge here is the link.
here, i again have to side with a common sense. many israeli civilians? apparently again you have met many israelis?
Yes indeed I did and I have good friends among them. Too bad I cannot always communicate with them as much as I please because in my country it might be viewed as a "collaboration with the enemy"
you should finally open your eyes: theres no solution to this conflict.
Hmm, Israel withdrew 3 years ago from the Gaza strip in order to instill peace..since then Hamas has sent over 3 thousand missles into Israel within the last year targeting civilians. Can´t really comprehend why anyone is questioning Israel´s actions...Your not suggesting they need to peacefully discuss this sitting at the kitchen table now...just a little too late for that.
I find this an incredible statement and indicates the level of brainwashing or lack of reasonable media coverage that goes on in the USA. Israels actions are doing nothing but propergating Hamas and may be Hezbollah after hearing todays news.
"Des responsables militaires israéliens ont évoqué dans des médias locaux l´acte isolé d´un groupe d´extrêmistes palestiniens, écartant la piste du Hezbollah. La milice chiite a ensuite fait clairement savoir au gouvernement libanais, où il compte un ministre, qu´il n´était pas impliqué dans les tirs "
The Pope´s justice minister, Cardinal Renato Martino, has sharply criticised Israel´s actions and likened the Gaza Strip to a "big concentration camp".
For those critics here of Israel..what would you suggest they do when they are constantely being attacked via missles almost on a daily basis. We are talking 3 thousand missles in a period of 12 months here...let´s do the math 8.52 missles a day and you question them defending themselves. My views have nothing to do with the media, I haven´t even entertained the media. To me this is common sense. Yes, innocent people die but as you know Israel has very sofisticated techonology. They are targeting strategic Hamas operation sites. Unlike Hamas who are targeting civilians. The Palestinians are harboring a terror organization which have announced over and over their intent to destroy Israel and the destruction of the Jews. You can´t negotiate with people that have this mentality. Do you really think any of your countries would sit back and allow this? I would hope not. I don´t agree with alot of Israel´s policies or decisions but I certainly can´t blame them for defending themselves. You won´t ever see peace until these people start valueing their own childrens lives more. Once that happens then their is some hope for peace.
To me this is common sense. Yes, innocent people die but as you know Israel has very sofisticated techonology. They are targeting strategic Hamas operation sites. Unlike Hamas who are targeting civilians.
Qana massacre, april 18 2006 (Lebanon)
Israeli artillery hit the area of a UN compound near Qana; Of the 800 Lebanese civilians who had taken refuge in the compound to escape the fighting, 106 were killed and around 116 injured
Israeli artillery hit the area of a UN compound near Qana; Of the 800 Lebanese civilians who had taken refuge in the compound to escape the fighting, 106 were killed and around 116 injured
After investigation, Amnesty international concluded, "the IDF intentionally attacked the UN compound.."
Response of Israel, the compound was hit "due to incorrect targeting based on erroneous data."
Israel is not any different from Hamas, They are targetting civilians.
You really think Israel would be targeting a UN Compound... Unlike Hamas yesterday who shot off several missles from a UN School and put innocent civilians on top of the roof to deter any retaliation.
You really think Israel would be targeting a UN Compound... Unlike Hamas yesterday who shot off several missles from a UN School and put innocent civilians on top of the roof to deter any retaliation.
The UN told that this claim of Israel is plain lie.
The meeting of Israel´s security Cabinet comes a day after France and Egypt sketched a proposal to stop the fighting. The initiative was spurred on by an Israeli mortar strike near a United Nations school the U.N. says killed 40 Palestinians.
The U.S. has endorsed the proposal. Israel has yet to give its response.
Israeli officials, speaking on condition of anonymity because no decision has been made, say Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and his top ministers will consider the proposal today or whether to press ahead with the 12-day operation meant to stop rocket fire into Israel.
Israel has killed more than 600 Palestinians in the fighting.
The United Nations agency dealing with Palestinian refugees says it´s certain that Hamas militants were not using its school to attack Israeli troops.
Israel said militants fired mortar shells at its troops from outside the school, drawing return fire.
Christopher Guinness of the U.N. Relief and Works Agency said today ``UNWRA is 99.9 percent certain there were no militants or military activity in its school.´´
You really think Israel would be targeting a UN Compound... Unlike Hamas yesterday who shot off several missles from a UN School and put innocent civilians on top of the roof to deter any retaliation.
Yes I truely believe so. International organizations and after investigation said they did it deliberately. so it doesnt matter what I think, they actually did it.
When they cannot say there was a terrorist firing missles at them from that location they say technical error. The end result is that hundreds of civilians are being killed.
Christopher Guinness of the U.N. Relief and Works Agency said today ``UNWRA is 99.9 percent certain there were no militants or military activity in its school.´´
Here is an excuse for Israel, there is 0.1% chance that a terrorist was actually in the UN school therefore the death of 40 civilians is justified...end of the matter!!!!
guinness should work better on his math next time!
Here is an excuse for Israel, there is 0.1% chance that a terrorist was actually in the UN school therefore the death of 40 civilians is justified...end of the matter!!!!
guinness should work better on his math next time!
Interesting the same group claims IT DID happen and now it looks like the number of civilians were also reduced...
Israeli troops kill U.N. truck driver at Gaza crossing
"14h15: Le chauffeur d´un convoi humanitaire des Nations Unies abattu par l´armée israélienne"
JERUSALEM — Israeli soldiers opened fire Thursday on a truck attempting to deliver humanitarian aid to the beleaguered Gaza Strip, killing one United Nations-contracted driver and seriously wounding another, U.N. officials said.
The Israeli army has admitted privately to the UN that no firing came from a Gaza school where 42 people died on Tuesday after being hit by Israeli mortars, officials of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (Unrwa) disclosed last night.
Publicly, the Israeli army claims that the school, which was providing shelter for around 350 people, was being used by Hamas fighters to carry out attacks. Unrwa officials said they were fully confident this was not the case.
The International Committee of the Red Cross accused Israel of failing in its international obligations after its staff were met with "shocking" scenes.
One medical team found 12 bodies in a shelled house, and alongsidethem four very young children, too weak to stand, waiting by their dead mothers, the ICRC said.
Aid workers had been denied access to the site for days, it added.
"This is a shocking incident," Pierre Wettach, ICRC head for Israel and the Palestinian territories said in a statement.
"The Israeli military must have been aware of the situation but did not assist the wounded. Neither did they make it possible for us or the Palestinian Red Crescent to assist the wounded."
For those critics here of Israel..what would you suggest they do when they are constantely being attacked via missles almost on a daily basis. We are talking 3 thousand missles in a period of 12 months here...let´s do the math 8.52 missles a day and you question them defending themselves. My views have nothing to do with the media, I haven´t even entertained the media. To me this is common sense. Yes, innocent people die but as you know Israel has very sofisticated techonology. They are targeting strategic Hamas operation sites. Unlike Hamas who are targeting civilians. The Palestinians are harboring a terror organization which have announced over and over their intent to destroy Israel and the destruction of the Jews. You can´t negotiate with people that have this mentality. Do you really think any of your countries would sit back and allow this? I would hope not. I don´t agree with alot of Israel´s policies or decisions but I certainly can´t blame them for defending themselves. You won´t ever see peace until these people start valueing their own childrens lives more. Once that happens then their is some hope for peace.
Teaschip, do you understand the basic fact taht all the territory where there is Israel right now, used to be Palestinian´s? There used to be THEIR homes there! Israel announced itself on somebody else´s land (violating all international laws!!!), and then deported or killed people who lived around it, and then embraced an expentionist policy. Do you understand this basic underlying problem here? To not want Israel on that territory is a pretty normal desire in this sort of circumstances, don´t you think? You would respond in the same exact way if this was you!
Between the time of partition and the declaration of Israel on 78% of historic Palestine in 1948, the newly formed Jewish state had depopulated (through massacres, expulsion orders, and fear tactics) over 400 villages and made refugees of at least 726,000 Palestinians (see U.N.).
The Pope´s justice minister, Cardinal Renato Martino, has sharply criticised Israel´s actions and likened the Gaza Strip to a "big concentration camp".
Correspondents say his words mark the Vatican´s toughest comments since Israel began its offensive with intensive air attacks 12 days ago.
Teaschip, do you understand the basic fact taht all the territory where there is Israel right now, used to be Palestinian´s? There used to be THEIR homes there! Israel announced itself on somebody else´s land (violating all international laws!!!), and then deported or killed people who lived around it, and then embraced an expentionist policy. Do you understand this basic underlying problem here? To not want Israel on that territory is a pretty normal desire in this sort of circumstances, don´t you think? You would respond in the same exact way if this was you!
Between the time of partition and the declaration of Israel on 78% of historic Palestine in 1948, the newly formed Jewish state had depopulated (through massacres, expulsion orders, and fear tactics) over 400 villages and made refugees of at least 726,000 Palestinians (see U.N.).
www.ifamericansknew.org
As usual people are dodging my questions I pose here. What I completely understand are the present facts here. Israel has been vacant from this land for 3 years now. However, this terrorist organization continues to send missles over into Israel. What do you expect they do? Now you have Hezbulah another terrorist group double tagging them...It´s interesting all the sympathy people have for the palestinians, no mention about Hamas who would like Israel and their people wipped off of the face of this earth. If the Palestinians want to blame anyone for innocent lives being lost they need to look in their own homeland and take efforts to stop these terrorist organizations that are killing their own people.
The Israeli army has admitted privately to the UN that no firing came from a Gaza school where 42 people died on Tuesday after being hit by Israeli mortars, officials of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (Unrwa) disclosed last night.
Publicly, the Israeli army claims that the school, which was providing shelter for around 350 people, was being used by Hamas fighters to carry out attacks. Unrwa officials said they were fully confident this was not the case.
nice try catwoman but, if you check out the first posts in this thread, you will see that I clearly describe hamas as a terrorist group. still nice try.
nice try catwoman but, if you check out the first posts in this thread, you will see that I clearly describe hamas as a terrorist group. still nice try.
you clearly sound like a hamas terrorist lover to me.
The Yesha Rabbinical Council announced in response to an IDF attack in Kfar Qanna that "according to Jewish law, during a time of battle and war, there is no such term as ´innocents´ of the enemy." ................
If there has ever been a time for prayer, this is that time.
If there has ever been a place forsaken, Gaza is that place.
Lord who is the creator of all children, hear our prayer this accursed day. G-d whom we call Blessed, turn your face to these, the children of Gaza, that they may know your blessings, and your shelter, that they may know light and warmth, where there is now only blackness and smoke, and a cold which cuts and clenches the skin.
Almighty who makes exceptions, which we call miracles, make an exception of the children of Gaza. Shield them from us and from their own. Spare them. Heal them. Let them stand in safety. Deliver them from hunger and horror and fury and grief. Deliver them from us, and from their own.
Restore to them their stolen childhoods, their birthright, which is a taste of heaven.
Remind us, O Lord, of the child Ishmael, who is the father of all the children of Gaza. How the child Ishmael was without water and left for dead in the wilderness of Beer-Sheba, so robbed of all hope, that his own mother could not bear to watch his life drain away.
Be that Lord, the G-d of our kinsman Ishmael, who heard his cry and sent His angel to comfort his mother Hagar.
Be that Lord, who was with Ishmael that day, and all the days after. Be that G-d, the All-Merciful, who opened Hagar´s eyes that day, and showed her the well of water, that she could give the boy Ishmael to drink, and save his life.
Allah, whose name we call Elohim, who gives life, who knows the value and the fragility of every life, send these children your angels. Save them, the children of this place, Gaza the most beautiful, and Gaza the damned.
In this day, when the trepidation and rage and mourning that is called war, seizes our hearts and patches them in scars, we call to you, the Lord whose name is Peace:
Bless these children, and keep them from harm.
Turn Your face toward them, O Lord. Show them, as if for the first time, light and kindness, and overwhelming graciousness.
Look up at them, O Lord. Let them see your face.
And, as if for the first time, grant them peace.
With thanks to Rabbi Levi Weiman-Kelman of Kol HaNeshama, Jerusalem.
Throughout the 11 days of Israel´s pummeling of Gaza, live coverage of the war hasn´t made it into most American living rooms.
That´s because Israel, America´s staunch ally, isn´t allowing journalists to enter Gaza while Al Jazeera, called anti-American and pro-terrorist by many in Washington, is the only network broadcasting live images from Gaza to the world.
The 350 reporters who descended on Israel when the conflict began are stuck at the border between Israel and Gaza. Israel says that opening border crossings to journalists would put their soldiers in danger, but many have accused them of trying to control the story. Instead of giving their viewers up-close pictorial evidence of what is occurring in Gaza, television networks have been restricted to showing their viewers plumes of smoke as they rise in the distance.
But Al Jazeera, the Qatari network that has previously undergone attacks and had its reporters arrested by the U.S. military, remains typically defiant. While other networks are increasingly severed from Gaza as phone lines are cut and 75 percent of the territory is without electricity, Al Jazeera is bringing its approximately 140 million English- and Arabic-speaking viewers live images of bombings, tanks rolling through Gaza´s farmland, and interviews with civilians and aid workers inside Gaza city.
Like all of the networks, Al Jazeera gives constant hard-hitting interviews with politicians and analysts from Israel, the West Bank, and the rest of the Arab world. But while others can only balance pundits with more pundits, Al Jazeera has been taking the viewer to the scene to weigh the words of politicians against the reality on the ground.
Take Israel´s claim that there is no humanitarian crisis in Gaza. After showing an Israeli politician writing off the assertion of the existence of a humanitarian disaster, Al Jazeera cut to the Al Shifa hospital, the largest in all of Gaza. There, we saw that there were not enough medical supplies and civilians lying on bloody hospital beds told us that their lives were not only being crippled by bombs falling on their houses, but by the extreme lack of water and food for the people cowering inside them.
One man, as he held his dead, pale faced 7-month-old son in his arms, said, "We were in our house for three days before the bombs fell on us. We called for the Red Cross and humanitarian groups, but no one was able to reach us…We have no one but God."
Israeli officials continue to assert that they are allowing in humanitarian aid by opening the border, but as Al Jazeera´s Ayman Moheyaldin reported from the inside, "The point is not that you open the crossings to allow in 30 to 40 trucks, but that you keep them open and allow a continuous amount of goods to enter for a sustainable amount of time."
The problem isn´t only that supplies can´t get in. People still can´t get out. Most are left searching hopelessly for safety while their stories remain trapped within Gaza´s walls.
"There is nowhere safe in Gaza," an enraged John Ging, head of the UN Relief and Works Agency in Gaza, told Al Jazeera´s Sherine Tadros in front of the Al Shifa hospital today. Those words came after the Israeli Defense Forces bombed a UN school that was being used as a refuge. Later in the day, a second UN school was struck by the Israelis, killing at least 40. "Everyone here is terrorized and traumatized and they have the right to be because there is no safe haven…This violence needs to stop now. Neither side can wait for the other to stop first," he said.
While Al Jazeera might be the only channel reporting from inside Gaza, scores of channels across the Middle East are airing constant commentary as well as images of wailing women, dead children, and burning buildings on loop. On the Syrian satellite station Al-Sham, for example, a pro-Hezbollah series about Israel´s occupation of south Lebanon was alternated with a 20-minute musical piece sung over images of dead babies, American soldiers kicking men in orange jumpsuits, a naked Arab man with a bag over his head running from American military dogs, stone-throwing Palestinian children, and endless footage of blood-soaked Palestinians and Iraqis. The song´s chorus, "The heart of humanity has died. It died between us brothers. Maybe we forgot one day that all Arabs are brothers," reflects the deep anger that people are feeling toward the inaction of Arab governments here.
By and large, media here is "all Gaza, all the time," and the more people see and hear about what is going on there, the angrier they seem to get. As I rode a bus into the Palestinian refugee camp, Yarmouk, a few days ago, the Syrian radio station was taking calls. A woman screamed into the airwaves, "The people of Gaza don´t need food; they need guns to resist the Israelis!" The bus remained silent, full of straight-faced, clench-jawed passengers.
Many went home and watched the ground invasion live a couple of hours later in night vision-green on Al Jazeera. Since then, the death toll has climbed to at least 598, according to Al Jazeera, with 2,700 injured.
Meanwhile, the world´s only live coverage of the tragedy is kept away from American eyes. While Al Jazeera English competes with CNN and BBC as one of the largest networks in the world, no major American cable provider has been willing to carry the channel since it launched in 2006. Some say cable providers are squeamish about working with a channel popularly perceived in the United States as giving airtime to terrorists.
But Al Jazeera is finding its way around the problem. Today, Americans hungry for inside coverage of Gaza can download Livestation, a free program that will let viewers watch Al Jazeera English among other international networks. Defiant as always, Al Jazeera might break through another media blackout, and into American homes.
For those who still believe the Israeli lie that they are not targeting civilians, and that if they do target civilians, then those civilians (including infants) must be "terrorists," this is a recount of the butchery displayed by the US-funded Israeli military earlier this week.
According to surviving members of the al-Samouni family, on Sunday of this past week, Israeli soldiers ordered approximately 100 members of the extended al-Samouni family to gather into one single house in the town of Zeitoun near Gaza City. Just after dawn the following morning, knowing that the house was filled with civilians including mothers with infants and children, the Israeli military repeatedly shelled the house, killing approximately 70 members of the family.
As reported in the Telegraph.co.uk, "A handful of survivors, some wounded, others carrying dead or dying infants, made it on foot to Gaza´s main north-south road before they were given lifts to hospital. Three small children were buried in Gaza City that afternoon."
Actually when you look at the way they look at the events, Teas and Tami´s ideas are exactly the same.
If you replace the countries from usa/israel to Turkey or other way round in their posts, you will think they are coming from the same person
or are they?
long lost brother - sister thing?
Interesting, I have never commented here that I thought the PKK were NOT terrorists. The only problem I had with Turkey going into Northern Iraq after the PKK was simply due to the U.S. trying to build stability in this region. Turkey has every right to defend themselves against any known terrorists organization, including the PKK. I have absolutely no sympathy for terrorism.
I believe everyone has a right to defend themselves whether it´s personally or as a country. I am not that mother who tells their child to withstand the beatings from a bully. First of course to try to work it out by communicating, but if that doesn´t work he needs to defend himself. Call me a terrible mother if you wish..sadly we don´t live in a utopia.
As the death toll from Israel´s war on Gaza continues to climb, Mohammed Ali, an advocacy and media researcher for Oxfam who lives in Gaza City, will be keeping a diary of his feelings and experiences.
Are we not human?!
The air, the sea and the earth in Gaza City are now occupied by the Israeli military. They occupy Gazans´ minds, nerves and ears too.
In a bid to stop my children twitching, jerking, trembling and waking at every sound of an attack during their few hours of sleep and their many waking hours, I put cotton wool in their ears - it has not worked.
I wonder what damage is being done to my children´s tiny hearts. Theirs are not as big as mine, they can cope less with the stress that is being put on them.
For those critics here of Israel..what would you suggest they do when they are constantely being attacked via missles almost on a daily basis. We are talking 3 thousand missles in a period of 12 months here...let´s do the math 8.52 missles a day and you question them defending themselves. My views have nothing to do with the media, I haven´t even entertained the media. To me this is common sense. Yes, innocent people die but as you know Israel has very sofisticated techonology. They are targeting strategic Hamas operation sites. Unlike Hamas who are targeting civilians. The Palestinians are harboring a terror organization which have announced over and over their intent to destroy Israel and the destruction of the Jews. You can´t negotiate with people that have this mentality. Do you really think any of your countries would sit back and allow this? I would hope not. I don´t agree with alot of Israel´s policies or decisions but I certainly can´t blame them for defending themselves. You won´t ever see peace until these people start valueing their own childrens lives more. Once that happens then their is some hope for peace.
Your American media is brainwashing... they are not showing any real news about the region... check out www.aljazeera.net/english to get the news.
People here who are giving pro-israili comments, please learn the history of the region, the real problems... why people go to the extremes to firing rockets everyday... do you think it is possible that nobody hears them until they do so... Israel state was founded in 1948, and Hamas was established in 1993... Do you think 45 years of waiting is not enough... Israel had the chance to correct things, but they simply did not want to.. Instead they brought in more Jews to settle in this new occupied country, and kept on reducing the living standards of the Palestininians.
Currently more than 850 people have died. more than 250 children, around 150 women, elderly, aid workers, medical staff, journalist... Your CNN does not even say this aloud, just show the number on the background for a second or so... and tell proudly how many militant Israel has killed today... yesterday they said 50.. I think they had member cards from Hamas with them...
One more thing, how would you feel, if someone comes and settles in your home, and moves all your family into one bedroom, and you can not go out for shopping if they don´t allow you, no matter if you need or not, you can not go to holiday to another city, your kids can not study in any college they like to... and you stay in that one little bedroom for 45 years with limited supply, and no freedom... I really wonder...
Please, search the reality and then make a comment if you must.
Your American media is brainwashing... they are not showing any real news about the region... check out www.aljazeera.net/english to get the news.
People here who are giving pro-israili comments, please learn the history of the region, the real problems... why people go to the extremes to firing rockets everyday... do you think it is possible that nobody hears them until they do so... Israel state was founded in 1948, and Hamas was established in 1993... Do you think 45 years of waiting is not enough... Israel had the chance to correct things, but they simply did not want to.. Instead they brought in more Jews to settle in this new occupied country, and kept on reducing the living standards of the Palestininians.
Currently more than 850 people have died. more than 250 children, around 150 women, elderly, aid workers, medical staff, journalist... Your CNN does not even say this aloud, just show the number on the background for a second or so... and tell proudly how many militant Israel has killed today... yesterday they said 50.. I think they had member cards from Hamas with them...
One more thing, how would you feel, if someone comes and settles in your home, and moves all your family into one bedroom, and you can not go out for shopping if they don´t allow you, no matter if you need or not, you can not go to holiday to another city, your kids can not study in any college they like to... and you stay in that one little bedroom for 45 years with limited supply, and no freedom... I really wonder...
Please, search the reality and then make a comment if you must.
You are right, there is very little information in the corporate media, but it is not impossible to learn more about the reality of the situation, if one really wants to.
There is a growing awarness of the situation and many demonstrations have been held against this situation in the USA and the whole world recently. IOW teaschip only speaks for herself, not all Americans.
I recently saw a documentary on Jewish partisans during WWII. It was very interesting, and it shed some light on the current situation. We have to consider the fact that these people (that generation) are the ones who built Israel. They were traumatized, suffering from what is now called Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. They never received treatment, and have continued in the flight or fight mentality. I thnk this is very much at the root of the problem.I have read that it takes at least 10 generations to work through cultural PTSD.
Now we have the Palestinians suffering through the same thing. Unless we figure out how to deal with the problem of cultural PTSD, we will have this cycle continue.
How many of the high level Israeli politicians were part of, what was then considered a terrorist organization, the Irgun?
"Soon after World War II, Winston Churchill said "we should never have stopped immigration before the war", but that the Irgun were "the vilest gangsters" and that he would "never forgive the Irgun terrorists."
It´s not very easy to get any real info on what´s going on since Israel has completely blocked access to Gaza for foreign press. I wonder why they are so desperate to prevent objective journalism of any kind....
It´s not very easy to get any real info on what´s going on since Israel has completely blocked access to Gaza for foreign press. I wonder why they are so desperate to prevent objective journalism of any kind....
The only international English Language media group in Gaza is Al Jazeera... www.aljazeera.net/english
And Israel does not allow any journalist to go in, and terrorizes the aid groups so that they give up their mission and stay out of Gaza is not to allow any official group to find any proof against them... as though it has been confirmed by the UN senior Executive that they are using white phosphorus, they need evidence to show that it is used on the civil population.. and believe me, until they get in Gaza, all the evidence will be cleared out....
How sad... yesterday, a UNRWA spokesman said on Al Jazeera that people are burning their furniture to cook food for themselves.. 2/3 of population (1 million people) is without electricity, and 1/2 of the population (750.000 people) are without water...
But of course, no official group is there to report it.....
By the way, for the people who support the Israeli cause, and thinking Hamas is responsible for the killing of the people:
If somebody hijacks a plane (of course Hamas is not a hijacker), do you blast the whole plane with the passengers in it for a couple of people??????? No, you don´t.
It´s not very easy to get any real info on what´s going on since Israel has completely blocked access to Gaza for foreign press. I wonder why they are so desperate to prevent objective journalism of any kind....
Robert Fisk: Keeping out the cameras and reporters simply doesn´t work
An Open Letter to Our American Colleagues in the Midst of the Massacre in Gaza
by Marcy Newman and Rania Masri / January 10th, 2009
On December 28th, Israel bombed the Islamic University of Gaza (IUG), with American-made F-16s, ten times destroying six buildings including research laboratories and a female dormitory. IUG, like all Palestinian universities in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, has no political affiliation.
...........
Israel’s attack on education
Is Israel an apartheid state?
What American Academics can do about Israeli Apartheid
Your American media is brainwashing... they are not showing any real news about the region... check out www.aljazeera.net/english to get the news.
People here who are giving pro-israili comments, please learn the history of the region, the real problems... why people go to the extremes to firing rockets everyday... do you think it is possible that nobody hears them until they do so... Israel state was founded in 1948, and Hamas was established in 1993... Do you think 45 years of waiting is not enough... Israel had the chance to correct things, but they simply did not want to.. Instead they brought in more Jews to settle in this new occupied country, and kept on reducing the living standards of the Palestininians.
Currently more than 850 people have died. more than 250 children, around 150 women, elderly, aid workers, medical staff, journalist... Your CNN does not even say this aloud, just show the number on the background for a second or so... and tell proudly how many militant Israel has killed today... yesterday they said 50.. I think they had member cards from Hamas with them...
One more thing, how would you feel, if someone comes and settles in your home, and moves all your family into one bedroom, and you can not go out for shopping if they don´t allow you, no matter if you need or not, you can not go to holiday to another city, your kids can not study in any college they like to... and you stay in that one little bedroom for 45 years with limited supply, and no freedom... I really wonder...
Please, search the reality and then make a comment if you must.
Oh yes I forgot how fair and balanced the infamous aljazeera is.. I know the history of Israel and the Palestinians, you certainly don´t have to educate me on this topic. I actually know more than I care to. If you can rationalize and justify the rockets showering down upon the Israelis on an everyday basis, more power to you. The Palestinians elect Hamas a known terror organization to reign over them. The same group who has repeatedly made known the intent to destroy Israel and eliminate the Jews. Then they question why there isn´t peace in their region... Search your own reality and ask why the ME never backs Israel?
Oh yes I forgot how fair and balanced the infamous aljazeera is..
admit it teas, you are a brainwashed bed fat amerikan.
btw, one thing makes me wonder. how come all free western press (that brainwashes you bed amerikans) arent allowed to gazza and holy al-jazeera is allowed?
A return through both time and space to their ancestral homeland
The Land of Israel was never devoid of Jews, although at times she numbered only in the tens of thousands. This was because the land was virtually uninhabitable when the Jews once again began their God-given right AND duty to return en masse to the land of their forefathers (the Zionist Movement) in the 1880s. The silly rhetoric about a massive Arab presence being overrun by “invading Jews” is quickly dispelled by Mark Twain, who visited the area in 1867. From his book, “The Innocents Abroad”… “A desolate country whose soil is rich enough, but is given over wholly to weeds… a silent mournful expanse…. a desolation…. we never saw a human being on the whole route…. hardly a tree or shrub anywhere. Even the olive tree and the cactus, those fast friends of a worthless soil, had almost deserted the country.”
The Jews did not displace anyone, because very few of the people who were there actually owned the land. Most were absentee owners residing elsewhere. Another fact hardly mentioned by the “new historians” is that the arriving Jews never threw anyone off any land. All land was purchased legally from the original owners… whether they be from “Palestine” itself or elsewhere. Furthermore, top dollar was paid for this land which, in many cases, was uninhabited and hardly more than swamp land and rocky terrain. Only about 120,000 Arabs resided in an area that now comprises the State of Israel, Jordan and the so-called “West Bank” [Judea and Samaria] in between. By 1890, the number of Jews who had settled in Palestine reached 50,000 and, by 1907, numbered 100,000. In Jerusalem alone the Jews numbered more than 25,000, out of a total population in the city of only 40,000 Jews, Christians and Arabs. The Arabs did, however, constitute a majority over the sparsely populated countryside abutting Jerusalem.
From 1888 until 1915 there were about six locust plagues that made the land nearly uninhabitable. In the 1915 locust plague alone some 40,000 people died and large numbers of Jews and Arabs left the land. Those that returned did not do so until about 1922 when the Zionist money to reclaim the land started coming in and a pipe line was laid. Then both Arabs and Jews started to come in in large numbers.
Palestine’s early Jewish Zionists were idealistic pioneers who arrived in pre-state Israel with every intention of living in peace alongside their Arab neighbors and upgrading the quality of life for all of the land’s inhabitants. These pre-Israel Zionists (and later, Israelis) had tried to develop peacefully for the dual benefit of Jews and Arabs in the land. But the Arab leadership always, starting in the earliest days, took the low road of insisting that the only solution was for the Jews to get out, even if that meant continued poverty and stagnation. When Arab demands were not met, they always resorted to violence.
The vast majority of Arabs came to the area after these early Zionist pioneers began draining the malaria-infested swamps (above photo) and plowingthe land! In doing so, these Jews created the economic opportunities and medical availabilities which attracted Arabs from both surrounding territories and far-away lands! In fact, over 90% of the Arabs migrated there within the last one hundred years. Most of the Arabs in “Palestine” were interlopers and squatters originating from Syria, Jordan, Egypt, Iraq and other lands who simply took possession of pieces of land. So much for their unfounded claims that they have been there since “time immemorial!” These Arabs came from disorganized collections of tribes with a tradition of constantly terrorizing each other and trying to seize land from their neighbors. Many of them were social outcasts and criminals who could not find jobs in their own countries so they searched for their luck elsewhere. Unfortunately, those Arab immigrants imported into the Holy Land their age-old culture of terrorizing neighbors in order to seize land. In fact, today’s Arab “Palestinians”, let by Arafat and his PLO (sanitized to the PA, or Palestinian Authority…which is nothing more than A Network of Murderers Masquerading As Government!) are still nothing more than street thugs, bullies and ‘Little Saddams’ found elsewhere throughout most of the most Arab world.
Yet while the returning Jews were highly motivated to restore the land, the Arabs seethed with envy and hatred for they lacked both the leadership to inspire and motivate them for they were, in fact, historical strangers to this land! Unlike the Jews, those Arabs who immigrated there had no ancient attachments to or historical memories of this homeland … this ancient Land of the JEWS!
The real problem facing those Arabs today is not the lack of a homeland. The historical root-cause of their problem and frustration is the fact that the countries they came from have not agreed to accept them back in. This is why so many of them live, up until today, in refugee camps, in neighboring Arab countries, lacking fundamental civil rights. In their frustration they feel that the only hope and choice they have is to try and steal someone else’s country!
In Conclusion:
There was no “Arab Palestinian” history before the Arabs manufactured one shortly after 1948, and then especially after the June 1967 Arab-Israeli War! In an interview with the Dutch newspaper “Trau” (March 31, 1977), PLO executive committee member Zahir Muhsein said, “The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct ‘Palestinian people’ to oppose Zionism. It is also been a “conceptual” war for ownership of the term “Palestinian” which has been transferred over to the Arabs whereas, before 1967, “Palestine” has always been synonymous with Eretz Israel and the Land of Israel.
Archeological sites to this very day continue to yield artifacts with Hebrew writing, not some fictitious “Palestinian” or Arabic text! The so-called “Palestinian” Arabs were simply then, as they are now, Arabs no different culturally, historically or ethnically from other Arabs living in any of the 24 Arab countries from which they emigrated. The suggestion that the “Palestinians” are some sub-group of Arabs with their own unique identity is pure fiction! Great propaganda… but still pure fiction! And had not the Arabs continued to brainwash generation upon generation into believing this HISTORICAL HOGWASH about some ancient “Arab Palestinian” ties to the Holy Land, most could have gotten themselves a real life by now with much less bloodshed and suffering for everyone concerned!
ClickHerefor more on the myth of a “Palestinian People.”
What chances,? to always live under israeli control! chekpoints everywhere.
to have settlements sprout like mushrooms between palestinian villages and land and water confiscated everyday by israelis?
you call this a fair chance given by a kind hand?
i didnt want to comment on this post. i see no point in throwing a ball to your side. i know of no hospital in arab countries where a jew can have a treatment while arabs even from palestine can be treated in israeli hospitals for free.
and it is a matter of great significance because there is a fear that the foundations of the mosque will be destabilized. may be they are smart but that does´nt give thim the right to excavate under the mosque, the land is not theirs!
This has a significance to this topic to show you that Israelis dont want peace, they keep on stiring up troubles here and there. They know the significance of the mosque to muslims and yet they deliberately excavate "under" the mosque.
i leave this out of our debate.
luckily the french TV is not censored and the french were the ones who took the picture few years ago of that israeli soldier deliberately shooting at a helpless boy hiding behind a barrel with his father trying to protect him. here is a reminder
One great philosopher and scholar is "al-ghazzali" (1058-1111) who belived that doubt is the only way to truth and in this matter he did anticipate Descartes. If you are interested in widening up your philosophical knowledge here is the link.
"O ye who believe! Ask not questions about things which if made plain to you, may cause you trouble. Some people before you did ask such questions, and on that account lost their faith." (Surah 5:101-102).
"The prophet was asked about things which he did not like, and when the questioner insisted, the Prophet got angry. (vol. 1, no. 92) The Prophet got angry and his cheeks or his face became red. (vol. 1, no. 91) "Allah has hated you...[for] asking too many questions." vol. 2, no. 555; and vol. 3, no. 591, Bukhari
admit it teas, you are a brainwashed bed fat amerikan.
btw, one thing makes me wonder. how come all free western press (that brainwashes you bed amerikans) arent allowed to gazza and holy al-jazeera is allowed?
what made israeli gov let the arab tv into gazza?
well, how about, they were there already???????
Or did you think that Israelis would allow something like that???
A return through both time and space to their ancestral homeland
The Land of Israel was never devoid of Jews, although at times she numbered only in the tens of thousands. This was because the land was virtually uninhabitable when the Jews once again began their God-given right AND duty to return en masse to the land of their forefathers (the Zionist Movement) in the 1880s. The silly rhetoric about a massive Arab presence being overrun by “invading Jews” is quickly dispelled by Mark Twain, who visited the area in 1867. From his book, “The Innocents Abroad”… “A desolate country whose soil is rich enough, but is given over wholly to weeds… a silent mournful expanse…. a desolation…. we never saw a human being on the whole route…. hardly a tree or shrub anywhere. Even the olive tree and the cactus, those fast friends of a worthless soil, had almost deserted the country.”
The Jews did not displace anyone, because very few of the people who were there actually owned the land. Most were absentee owners residing elsewhere. Another fact hardly mentioned by the “new historians” is that the arriving Jews never threw anyone off any land. All land was purchased legally from the original owners… whether they be from “Palestine” itself or elsewhere. Furthermore, top dollar was paid for this land which, in many cases, was uninhabited and hardly more than swamp land and rocky terrain. Only about 120,000 Arabs resided in an area that now comprises the State of Israel, Jordan and the so-called “West Bank” [Judea and Samaria] in between. By 1890, the number of Jews who had settled in Palestine reached 50,000 and, by 1907, numbered 100,000. In Jerusalem alone the Jews numbered more than 25,000, out of a total population in the city of only 40,000 Jews, Christians and Arabs. The Arabs did, however, constitute a majority over the sparsely populated countryside abutting Jerusalem.
From 1888 until 1915 there were about six locust plagues that made the land nearly uninhabitable. In the 1915 locust plague alone some 40,000 people died and large numbers of Jews and Arabs left the land. Those that returned did not do so until about 1922 when the Zionist money to reclaim the land started coming in and a pipe line was laid. Then both Arabs and Jews started to come in in large numbers.
Where is the source of this. You do know the forum rules, dont you?
admit it teas, you are a brainwashed bed fat amerikan.
btw, one thing makes me wonder. how come all free western press (that brainwashes you bed amerikans) arent allowed to gazza and holy al-jazeera is allowed?
what made israeli gov let the arab tv into gazza?
If I was brainwashed by our media, I would have voted for Obama then. Oh you raise a valid question here...so much for being best friends with Israeli...them traders.
Oh yes I forgot how fair and balanced the infamous aljazeera is.. I know the history of Israel and the Palestinians, you certainly don´t have to educate me on this topic. I actually know more than I care to. If you can rationalize and justify the rockets showering down upon the Israelis on an everyday basis, more power to you. The Palestinians elect Hamas a known terror organization to reign over them. The same group who has repeatedly made known the intent to destroy Israel and eliminate the Jews. Then they question why there isn´t peace in their region... Search your own reality and ask why the ME never backs Israel?
Ooops, sorry, did not realise how well educated and enlightened you are!!!!!
Well, Hamas is a terrorrist organisation according to Israel, US, Canada and EU... but to the rest of the world, it is not....
I must have been blind by watching the shot and dead children: burnt to their bones from chemical weapons.... and I guess the unfair and unbalanced Al Jazeera must have killed those 905 Palestinins to brainwash people like me... Oh, no, no, it must be the Hamas fighters under the skirts of the women who have killed all these people... and I think it was Hamas who shot the UN Ambulance Driver, and it was Hamas who does not allow Humanitariam aid, Journalists, and UN Human Rights officials into Gaza... Oh, now I heard that Hamas is this time hiding under Shifa Hospital in Gaza... I think now Hamas will kill those thousand of people in the hospital...
You really are well aware of all the facts... well done!!!!!!
Please keep on sharing your deep knowledge with all of us!!!!
Well, Hamas is a terrorrist organisation according to Israel, US, Canada and EU... but to the rest of the world, it is not....
Great observation Merih.. Of course it´s not...nor is the Taliban.
If you see Hamas as an organization that is a last resort of poor and desparate people´s way to defend themselves from and imperialist, militarist state, then yes -- you won´t see it as a terrorist organization. Taliban is different, don´t try to put them together as if they were similar.
So why exactly is Hamas a terrorist organization and Israel isn´t? Israel killed more civilians, broke all international laws, established settlements on invaded territory, demolishes palestinians´ houses, is a racist state.... who is worse really?
And who gives the US the right to decide who is terrorrist and who is not... you know what, today they are running these policies on the countries they don´t share interests... one day it will come back to you... may be it already did!!!!
Look at US, they are the only country who used the nuclear weapon brutally on civilians, and they are the deciding party to say who can have it...
And just to make things clear, are you saying it is not acceptable to send rockets while some people are occupying your land (by the way, nobody dies) but it is acceptable to kill 905 people and and injure more than 4500 people is okay?????
My dear friend, please let us know WHO CREATED AND ARMED TALIBAN?????? And they were not terrorrists then??????
How about the United Arab Emirates who financially supported them. Let´s not forget Saudie Arabia along with Pakistan. If you want to blame Clinton and Carter you can add them in the mix. What´s with all of your unnecessary exclaimation & question marks my dear friend?
And just to make things clear, are you saying it is not acceptable to send rockets while some people are occupying your land (by the way, nobody dies) but it is acceptable to kill 905 people and and injure more than 4500 people is okay?????
Maybe you have forgotten they left this land nearly 3 years ago. So come on tell me more justification for sending three thousand rockets in the last year into Israel?
How about the United Arab Emirates who financially supported them. Let´s not forget Saudie Arabia along with Pakistan. If you want to blame Clinton and Carter you can add them in the mix. What´s with all of your unnecessary exclaimation & question marks my dear friend?
I was curious if you also had enough information on the topic, and I can see you have...
It was US who financially, technically supported them, because of Russia.. not because they liked Afghanis at that time or the Pakistanis, but it was totally because of the fear that USSr (then) could extend to the warm seas...
And suddenly they became the enemies.. and terrorists.. isn´t it funny...
If you will be alive then to see, one day you will see who actually did the 9/11...
Maybe you have forgotten they left this land nearly 3 years ago. So come on tell me more justification for sending three thousand rockets in the last year into Israel?
Well, I can see how much you know about the history... In 1948 the british gifted some territory, almost 45% of the land to these people without acknowledging the Palestinians.. and they kept on extending their territories since then... now Palestinians are almost left with a 10% of the land they owned..
So, leaving a little bit of land is not actually enough.
Maybe you have forgotten they left this land nearly 3 years ago. So come on tell me more justification for sending three thousand rockets in the last year into Israel?
They did not leave the land, they withdrew SOME military, and walled off the area, strictly controlling any traffic. One of the conditions for cease-fire was that Israel tears down the fences around Gaza, which they have not done, apparently Hamas thought that it was pointless to keep on staying quiet.
And... it´s funny to make these rockets sound so grave, considering that they haven´t killed anyone!
I was curious if you also had enough information on the topic, and I can see you have...
It was US who financially, technically supported them, because of Russia.. not because they liked Afghanis at that time or the Pakistanis, but it was totally because of the fear that USSr (then) could extend to the warm seas...
And suddenly they became the enemies.. and terrorists.. isn´t it funny...
If you will be alive then to see, one day you will see who actually did the 9/11...
Sorry Merih I don´t buy into your conspiracy theories and never will.
Sorry Merih I don´t buy into your conspiracy theories and never will.
My only question would be:
How can you so blindly believe in everything you hear? Don´t you ever think, well killing 905 people in a fenced area where there are no safe havens is not okay?
It´s not a conspiracy theory, it´s a FACT that it´s the US that has created Taliban.
First of all it is not a FACT that the U.S. created the Taliban. If you happen to recall the Taliban had announced themselves as a legitimate Afgan force that wanted to get rid of corruption in Afgan. The Taliban today was we know it has gone in a different direction. So you want to blame the U.S. If you want to shift blame..you certainly can look at Pakistan for building and training this political force.
First of all it is not a FACT that the U.S. created the Taliban. If you happen to recall the Taliban had announced themselves as a legitimate Afgan force that wanted to get rid of corruption in Afgan. The Taliban today was we know it has gone in a different direction. So you want to blame the U.S. If you want to shift blame..you certainly can look at Pakistan for building and training this political force.
The honor for training, funding and arming totally goes to US.. and calling me ignorant, and telling that Pakistan trained and built them shows who is ignorant... Mujaheddin, turned Taliban, turned Al-Qaida was originally founded by US. For your information, Pakistan only supported them and fought along with them so that Russia may not get the land of Afghanistan as Pakistan happens to be right at the bottom of Afghanistan.
You bet Amerikans, don´t you read any book, search anything or try to learn something from other sources other your juicy media
The honor for training, funding and arming totally goes to US.. and calling me ignorant, and telling that Pakistan trained and built them shows who is ignorant... Mujaheddin, turned Taliban, turned Al-Qaida was originally founded by US. For your information, Pakistan only supported them and fought along with them so that Russia may not get the land of Afghanistan as Pakistan happens to be right at the bottom of Afghanistan.
You bet Amerikans, don´t you read any book, search anything or try to learn something from other sources other your juicy media
I can see you do your own selective reading yourself. The Taliban were muslim refugee´s studing in Pakaistan schools, receiving assistance from Pakistans Intelligence. There members grew to include Mujaheddin. Just like any Islamic Fundametalist groups, they were going to form a pure islamic state...and we know what that means no more rights for woman, public executions, imprisonments. One again you fail to recognize it was Pakistan who created the Taliban, Saudi Arabia who financed them and UA Emirates who laundred them money. So what´s your theory on this one...ok we got a pipeline out of it. We are harvesting the biggest poppey crops.
FYI..if Pakistan only supported them and fought along with them so that Russia may not get the Afghan land..why do they still habor them today.
I can see you do your own selective reading yourself. The Taliban were muslim refugee´s studing in Pakaistan schools, receiving assistance from Pakistans Intelligence. There members grew to include Mujaheddin. Just like any Islamic Fundametalist groups, they were going to form a pure islamic state...and we know what that means no more rights for woman, public executions, imprisonments. One again you fail to recognize it was Pakistan who created the Taliban, Saudi Arabia who financed them and UA Emirates who laundred them money. So what´s your theory on this one...ok we got a pipeline out of it. We are harvesting the biggest poppey crops.
FYI..if Pakistan only supported them and fought along with them so that Russia may not get the Afghan land..why do they still habor them today.
Teas I do wonder how the US seem to be told a completely different story in most political topics compared to the rest of the world
I think you have more censorship than you realise..... it seems only Jimmy Carter has access to the truth
Do you seriously deny that the US didn´t create the Taliban?
If you want to see it that way? Or perhaps you could see it as him being the only one brave enough to speak out, despite the nervousness in congress to upset all those lovely wealthy jews. Perhaps you have not seen the propaganda that the Jewish fundraisers get up to (completely undisputed) where they openly admit that each dollar donated will help push further into Palastinian soil.
Teas I do wonder how the US seem to be told a completely different story in most political topics compared to the rest of the world
I think you have more censorship than you realise..... it seems only Jimmy Carter has access to the truth
Hmm, that´s interesting typically we are not at the center or forefront of most political controversy. I guess it´s all of our brainwashing media. Yeah, Jimmy Carter our great former president who won the nobel peace prize. Listen to him!
If you want to see it that way? Or perhaps you could see it as him being the only one brave enough to speak out, despite the nervousness in congress to upset all those lovely wealthy jews. Perhaps you have not seen the propaganda that the Jewish fundraisers get up to (completely undisputed) where they openly admit that each dollar donated will help push further into Palastinian soil.
i definetly see it that way. he is a pro-palestinian luckily former president. its hardly a braveness to freely speak up your mind in US senate. you can speak whatever propaganda you like and wealthy jews wont kill you for daring to stand up against them. as you see your hero carter is still alive.
as for pushing the palestinian soil, it was guilt of arabs. they shouldnt have started wars against jews.
I can see you do your own selective reading yourself. The Taliban were muslim refugee´s studing in Pakaistan schools, receiving assistance from Pakistans Intelligence. There members grew to include Mujaheddin. Just like any Islamic Fundametalist groups, they were going to form a pure islamic state...and we know what that means no more rights for woman, public executions, imprisonments. One again you fail to recognize it was Pakistan who created the Taliban, Saudi Arabia who financed them and UA Emirates who laundred them money. So what´s your theory on this one...ok we got a pipeline out of it. We are harvesting the biggest poppey crops.
FYI..if Pakistan only supported them and fought along with them so that Russia may not get the Afghan land..why do they still habor them today.
Here teaschip....read this book, if you dare. It shows exactly how this happened.....much better than the movie...
"I always, always, whenever a plane goes down, I always fear it is one of our missiles. Most of all I wanted to bloody the Red Army. I think the bloodying thereof had a great deal to do with the collapse of the Soviet Union."[16] He now surmises that some of the weapons probably wound up in the hands of the Taliban regime, which took over and is now harboring Saudi fugitive Osama bin Laden, the prime suspect in the September 11 attacks. "I feel guilty about it," he said. "I really do." "Those things happen," Wilson said of wartime weapons that wind up in the wrong hands. "How are you going to defeat the Red Army without a gun? You can´t blame the Marines for teaching Lee Harvey Oswald how to shoot." Wilson, who did not seek re-election to Congress in 1996 after serving 24 years, now believes he could have worked harder to steer Afghanistan away from the course that led it to today. "The part that I´ll take to my grave with guilt is that . . . I didn´t stay the course and stay there and push and drive the other members of Congress nuts pushing for a mini-Marshall Plan," he said. "And I let myself be frustrated and discouraged by the fact that (the Afghan) leadership was so fragmented that we were unable to do the things we needed to do, like clear the mines, like furnish them millions of tons of fertilizer to be able to replant the crops."
Of course there is.. as long as the white House and Israel says okay... ha ha ha ha
Absolutely true. I recently learned that there is a lovely, neoconservative organization called Campus Watch, which is monitoring what is being taught in schools about the Middle East and israeli conflict. They recently pushed a law that stops government funding to universities that teach ANY anti-Israel information! So... there is your freedom!
The Lobby also monitors what professors write and teach. In September 2002, for example, Martin Kramer and Daniel Pipes, two passionately pro-Israel neoconservatives, established a website (Campus Watch) that posted dossiers on suspect academics ... This transparent attempt to blacklist and intimidate scholars prompted a harsh reaction and Pipes and Kramer later removed the dossiers."
I hope you now found out! Yes, there is very little freedom in the media to sway from the official version of truth.
i didnt know that amerikans had no access to the internet and i didnt know that all amerikan media was censored by wealthy evil jews that was an eye-opener, thank you
then i feel sorry for you guys. perhaps then you poor and brainwashed honest amerikans should consider to move out to more free and open countries to enjoy full freedom?
i didnt know that amerikans had no access to the internet and i didnt know that all amerikan media was censored by wealthy evil jews that was an eye-opener, thank you
then i feel sorry for you guys. perhaps then you poor and brainwashed honest amerikans should consider to move out to more free and open countries to enjoy full freedom?
Absolutely true. I recently learned that there is a lovely, neoconservative organization called Campus Watch, which is monitoring what is being taught in schools about the Middle East and israeli conflict. They recently pushed a law that stops government funding to universities that teach ANY anti-Israel information! So... there is your freedom!
The Lobby also monitors what professors write and teach. In September 2002, for example, Martin Kramer and Daniel Pipes, two passionately pro-Israel neoconservatives, established a website (Campus Watch) that posted dossiers on suspect academics ... This transparent attempt to blacklist and intimidate scholars prompted a harsh reaction and Pipes and Kramer later removed the dossiers."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campus_Watch
Scary...... but kind of confirms what I thought...
Absolutely true. I recently learned that there is a lovely, neoconservative organization called Campus Watch, which is monitoring what is being taught in schools about the Middle East and israeli conflict. They recently pushed a law that stops government funding to universities that teach ANY anti-Israel information! So... there is your freedom!
The Lobby also monitors what professors write and teach. In September 2002, for example, Martin Kramer and Daniel Pipes, two passionately pro-Israel neoconservatives, established a website (Campus Watch) that posted dossiers on suspect academics ... This transparent attempt to blacklist and intimidate scholars prompted a harsh reaction and Pipes and Kramer later removed the dossiers."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campus_Watch
is it a fact or is it a wannabe fact? is there such law or is this a wannabe law?
Absolutely true. I recently learned that there is a lovely, neoconservative organization called Campus Watch, which is monitoring what is being taught in schools about the Middle East and israeli conflict. They recently pushed a law that stops government funding to universities that teach ANY anti-Israel information! So... there is your freedom!
The Lobby also monitors what professors write and teach. In September 2002, for example, Martin Kramer and Daniel Pipes, two passionately pro-Israel neoconservatives, established a website (Campus Watch) that posted dossiers on suspect academics ... This transparent attempt to blacklist and intimidate scholars prompted a harsh reaction and Pipes and Kramer later removed the dossiers."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campus_Watch
Ah yes.... Daniel Pipes...in 2004 Pipes was temporatily appointed by GW to the board of the US Institute for Peace
Pipes´ approach to Middle East policy has been criticized as neo-conservative, orientalist, right-wing Zionist, and Islamophobic.
Favors profiling and internment of Muslims in the United States
For years, it has been my position that the threat of radical Islam implies an imperative to focus security measures on Muslims. If searching for rapists, one looks only at the male population. Similarly, if searching for Islamists (adherents of radical Islam), one looks at the Muslim population. And so, I was encouraged by a just-released Cornell University opinion survey that finds nearly half the U.S. population agreeing with this proposition. Specifically, 44 percent of Americans believe that government authorities should direct special attention toward Muslims living in the United States, either by registering their whereabouts, profiling them, monitoring their mosques or infiltrating their organizations. That´s the good news; the bad news is the near-universal disapproval of this realism. Leftist and Islamist organizations have so successfully influenced public opinion that polite society shies away from endorsing a focus on Muslims. In the United States, this intimidation results in large part from a revisionist interpretation of the evacuation, relocation and internment of ethnic Japanese during WWII
Ãf we have excuse,or like to believe we have excuse,´like it or not´
What is US government,and people excuse for that ?!
Just a question to the Americans...what/who are your government/leaders?!
Who is ruling you ?!!!
Israel´s Olmert: Rice embarrassed over UN vote
JERUSALEM – Israel´s prime minister said Monday that Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice was embarrassed by orders to abstain from voting last week on a U.N. truce resolution for Gaza that she helped arrange.
Israel had argued that the Security Council measure calling for a halt to the Gaza fighting — which passed Thursday in a 14-0 vote with the U.S. abstaining — was unworkable because it did not guarantee Israel´s security.
Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said he called President George W. Bush to seek an abstention from the U.S., a key Israeli ally at the United Nations.
"I said: ´Get me President Bush on the phone,´" Olmert said in a speech in the southern Israeli city of Ashkelon. "They said he was in the middle of giving a speech in Philadelphia. I said I didn´t care: ´I need to talk to him now.´ He got off the podium and spoke to me."
Olmert said he argued that the United States should not vote in favor, and the president then called Rice and told her not to do so.
i read it and i didnt understand it. who wrote it? you?
Check it out, and please tell me this is a lie too.
i dont understand this too
By the way way Femme, you think I am a she is because i told you so.. what if I told you now that I am a he????
well, in our previous discussions you were talking about turkish housewifes and it sounded you were one you talked about your mother.
i donno i concluded all these from your posts.
oh, you are playing the same game like your sisters alameda and cedars.
in fact i think i dont care, i even didnt care to check the profiles. i always look at posts, i always judge from the posts.
if you told me that you were HE, i would think you were male.
so are you denying that you are female now?
You people are used to believe what you are told. Never bother to check it out personally.
i do check out things that i need to, like the background of authors of some articles, i compare info and check with encyclopedias. but i dont bother to check out if you are female or male, muslim or not muslim, if you have a pic uploaded or not. because i talk with your posts not with your profile. if you didnt post here anything i wouldnt even know of your existence.
Weren´t those same countries who were condemning some countries ´ours´ and giving Türkiye hard time in joining the EU for violating the human rights ?!
à wonder what is their understnding to the human rights then ?!!
The resolution, drafted by Arab, Asian and African countries, called for an international mission to be sent immediately to the Gaza Strip to investigate Israel´s actions.
A resolution condemning Israel´s military offensive in Gaza has been adopted by the UN Human Rights Council.
The non-binding resolution, approved in Geneva on Monday, said Israel´s operation had "resulted in massive violations of human rights of the Palestinian people".
More than 900 Palestinians have died during the fighting, many of them women and children, and a further 4,100 have been wounded.
At least 25,000 have been displaced due to the ongoing bombardment, but are unable to flee the overcrowded territory as crossing points remain closed.
oh, you are playing the same game like your sisters alameda and cedars.
It seems I am in your "ligne de mire"
Since you mentioned my name I better answer you. I am not playing any games.
I simply replied to your famous sentence "you muslims..." you use with everyone defending palestinians or saying something good about islam. You directly conclude that this person is muslim so I told you that this is not the case. That´s all.
Since you mentioned my name I better answer you. I am not playing any games.
I simply replied to your famous sentence "you muslims..." you use with everyone defending palestinians or saying something good about islam. You directly conclude that this person is muslim so I told you that this is not the case. That´s all.
mmmm... i absolutely agree with you
you are on a list (in one bag) with alameda and merih
I simply replied to your famous sentence "you muslims..." you use with everyone defending palestinians or saying something good about islam. You directly conclude that this person is muslim so I told you that this is not the case. That´s all.
Quoting femmeous
mmmm... i absolutely agree with you
you are on a list (in one bag) with alameda and merih
As far as Palestinians/Isreal is concerned, I will be in the same bag as Alameda and Merih!!
this such a shameless bombing which is done in front of a whole world like which was done in iraq....I think this is just a part of the plan which we called BOP( great middle eastern project)... all the countries especially the ones who is pioneer in defending the human rights just shutting up and watching it....i think its bcos they think the people in palestines and iraq is not human so they dont have human rights as well....so there is no problem.... nobody knows the number of the killings in iraq and palestine ....no matter they r civilians or not....they r human beings....
this such a shameless bombing which is done in front of a whole world like which was done in iraq....I think this is just a part of the plan which we called BOP( great middle eastern project)... all the countries especially the ones who is pioneer in defending the human rights just shutting up and watching it....i think its bcos they think the people in palestines and iraq is not human so they dont have human rights as well....so there is no problem.... nobody knows the number of the killings in iraq and palestine ....no matter they r civilians or not....they r human beings....
i ll continue later
This is absolute crap and sounds like typical Turkish paranoia - I am surprised at you!
this such a shameless bombing which is done in front of a whole world like which was done in iraq....I think this is just a part of the plan which we called BOP( great middle eastern project)... all the countries especially the ones who is pioneer in defending the human rights just shutting up and watching it....i think its bcos they think the people in palestines and iraq is not human so they dont have human rights as well....so there is no problem.... nobody knows the number of the killings in iraq and palestine ....no matter they r civilians or not....they r human beings....
i ll continue later
i agree that it is a part of that project but i dont think western think peole in Iraq or Palestine are not human.
admit it teas, you are a brainwashed bed fat amerikan.
btw, one thing makes me wonder. how come all free western press (that brainwashes you bed amerikans) arent allowed to gazza and holy al-jazeera is allowed?
what made israeli gov let the arab tv into gazza?
to you both, long live the "free western press" for which you make an apology...
This is absolute crap and sounds like typical Turkish paranoia - I am surprised at you!
the people who made this project...not the people who is living in western world....i know many people and have many friends who is completely against these bombings and war....this is about the politics...no matter many of us doesnt wana agree...why usa still supporting israel?
the people who made this project...not the people who is living in western world....i know many people and have many friends who is completely against these bombings and war....this is about the politics...no matter many of us doesnt wana agree...why usa still supporting israel?
oh dear i feel sorry for you. why do you keep watching those evil western tv?
are you a masochist?
May be... or may be I am a very simple dumb person, who look for truth and just in everything.
Unlike some of us who does not feel any pain when they see people, children and women getting murdered... or prefer to believe the lies to be able to sleep at night.
You know what, to see the truth and feel the pain of others, you don´t need to be an American or Palestinian, woman or man, black or white, muslim, or jew.. you just need to be a human.
You know what, to see the truth and feel the pain of others, you don´t need to be an American or Palestinian, woman or man, black or white, muslim, or jew.. you just need to be a human.
And you know, I really think that most people do that.. it´s just our sick politicians that use us for their own profits and in order to get away with their murderous policies they just brainwash us with fear of one another... It seems that most people are really tryiing to reach out..
May be... or may be I am a very simple dumb person, who look for truth and just in everything.
duh, stop exaggerating! or you are not exaggerating?
Unlike some of us who does not feel any pain when they see people, children and women getting murdered... or prefer to believe the lies to be able to sleep at night.
You know what, to see the truth and feel the pain of others, you don´t need to be an American or Palestinian, woman or man, black or white, muslim, or jew.. you just need to be a human.
well, i often see no compassion and no pain expressed by muslims when non-muslims are killed in a terror acts carried out by muslims in the cause of allah. i hear silence. when i speak about honor killings i again dont hear any sorrow from muslims too, they get busy justifying their religion, tradition and culture.
and when muslims are killed you demand from all of us cry, tear our hair, scratch our faces (but wait a minute, most westerners do so). excuse me, when theres a war i move my children out of the war scene. when london was bombed by hitler, they sent their children away from london. it is something normal you want to protect your children. but in a muslim world it is upside down. children are the first line soldiers.
May be... or may be I am a very simple dumb person, who look for truth and just in everything.
Unlike some of us who does not feel any pain when they see people, children and women getting murdered... or prefer to believe the lies to be able to sleep at night.
You know what, to see the truth and feel the pain of others, you don´t need to be an American or Palestinian, woman or man, black or white, muslim, or jew.. you just need to be a human.
How can anybody find above disagreeable?
Quote:
when theres a war i move my children out of the war scene.
Where can they send their childeren?!!!
It is one of the most populated area in the world..
They can not get out (they have been under blockade from sea/air/land) ..They can not run away..They can not hide..
They are caged there like animals waiting to be slaughtered.
It is one of the most populated area in the world..
They can not get out (they have been under blockade from sea/air/land) ..They can not run away..They can not hide..
They are caged there like animals waiting to be slaughtered
israeli army has been sending messages to civilians to stay away from the targets. i think if they really wanted their children away from the war they would smuggle them as they smuggle weapon/terrorists and arab journalists.
hairy, its not so as you paint it here, when israel was hitting hizbollah the other year we heard the same news and the same scenes we watched, are you saying that lebanese too had no where to go or nowhere to hide?
i absolutely know their mentality, they will sacrifice everything (their favorite sacrifice is children) in order to paint israel a monster. they have no respect for children and women.
israeli army has been sending messages to civilians to stay away from the targets. i think if they really wanted their children away from the war they would smuggle them as they smuggle weapon/terrorists and arab journalists.
hairy, its not so as you paint it here, when israel was hitting hizbollah the other year we heard the same news and the same scenes we watched, are you saying that lebanese too had no where to go or nowhere to hide?
i absolutely know their mentality, they will sacrifice everything (their favorite sacrifice is children) in order to paint israel a monster. they have no respect for children and women.
I would like to make something clear for you... it seems you don´t get it... there are no buildings signed as Hamas Headquarters... The leaflets tell them to stay away from targets.. Please you tell me how can they understand if a person is a fighter or not while they are gathering their things, and holding their children and running away in fear.. do you thinks the fighter wears Neon caps so that the public can recognise themmm.. and how in the world does the Israeli tanks and planes know who is the target...
These people have literally nowhere to hide.. last wekk 40 people died in a UN school, which the coordinates were given to israel... Israel not only bombed it, but then said sorry.. we did a mistake... They informed an extended family of 100 peopleto move into one building, and then bombed it within 24 hours...
And please show me on person who will put their children under the fire... do you think you are the only wise person to take your children out of the room if there is a war scene??? Do you realise your luxury???
I did not again tell you if I am Muslim or not... And we all did cry when 911 happened for the lives lost... But you need to be brave to be objective... to forget those people were Muslims, or Christians, or Jews... I have spent many days of my life thinking about the Jews in the 2nd World War, and the Holocaust... But I do seriously believe, you are so brainwashed that you find out the religion or race of the victim to cry or to feel for someone... What a shame for humanity...
I do hope with all my heart you never see your children shot in their beds while sleeping, no matter what you are, and no matter what the reason is and I do definitely not wish it for anyone else... But people like you, who even discriminate to feel sorry for others, are the ones who are polarising the world, and calling the discriminated people to terrorise.. because you don´t even listen.
israeli army has been sending messages to civilians to stay away from the targets. i think if they really wanted their children away from the war they would smuggle them as they smuggle weapon/terrorists and arab journalists.
hairy, its not so as you paint it here, when israel was hitting hizbollah the other year we heard the same news and the same scenes we watched, are you saying that lebanese too had no where to go or nowhere to hide?
i absolutely know their mentality, they will sacrifice everything (their favorite sacrifice is children) in order to paint israel a monster. they have no respect for children and women.
Your absoutely correct here femme. As I have said before until these people start valueing their own childrens life there will NEVER be peace in this region.
And we all did cry when 911 happened for the lives lost... But you need to be brave to be objective... to forget those people
Then tell me why you can simply find hundreds of pictures showing people celebrating in the streets after 911, including palestinians..
I am not here to defend or protect them.. and everybody is reponsible for their own conduct.. I am sure of my own.. I would recommend you to the same thing... Be fair at least to yourself.
Your absoutely correct here femme. As I have said before until these people start valueing their own childrens life there will NEVER be peace in this region.
So if I tell you stay away from the target, you are saying that you will understand what is the target... You must be very clever..
excuse me, when theres a war i move my children out of the war scene. when london was bombed by hitler, they sent their children away from london. it is something normal you want to protect your children.
They can´t remove their children from the war scene, let alone themselves. Gaza is a closed area and Israel is in control of the borders, which are currently closed. There´s no safe place in Gaza at all. So where are they supposed to go?
They can´t remove their children from the war scene, let alone themselves. Gaza is a closed area and Israel is in control of the borders, which are currently closed. There´s no safe place in Gaza at all. So where are they supposed to go?
Dear Azade, she and others fail to understand this fact.. they had the luxury to send their children away from London.. but they can not imagine a place where you are locked inside and not allowed to go out of that area... So the question to her should be:
What if London was under siege and occupation and there was no way to go out, then what?
They can´t remove their children from the war scene, let alone themselves. Gaza is a closed area and Israel is in control of the borders, which are currently closed. There´s no safe place in Gaza at all. So where are they supposed to go?
well, i think its not so as you describe. where the hell they got the weapon and how the heck terrorists appear there if the borders are that tight?
Dear Azade, she and others fail to understand this fact.. they had the luxury to send their children away from London.. but they can not imagine a place where you are locked inside and not allowed to go out of that area... So the question to her should be:
What if London was under siege and occupation and there was no way to go out, then what?
dear merih, dont say she and others. so far its only me and teas who are pro-israeli. all others are pro-palestenians
well, i think its not so as you describe. where the hell they got the weapon and how the heck terrorists appear there if the borders are that tight?
do you remember hearing in your news channel that they are bombing the tunnels... and come on, can you ask a baby to crawl all along and run away.. and of course the end of the road goes to Egypt, and as you can imagine you can not enter in some country without visa and so...
I am not here to defend or protect them.. and everybody is reponsible for their own conduct.. I am sure of my own.. I would recommend you to the same thing... Be fair at least to yourself.
Please... enough with your recommendations and aggressive approach. You are no better justifying terrorists behavior that kill people, than I am defending those that kill in return. So you can make all of your sacarastic snied comments here and continue your crusade. You are not going to change my mind how I view things, nor do I have a desire to change your´s. So what´s your point?
do you remember hearing in your news channel that they are bombing the tunnels... and come on, can you ask a baby to crawl all along and run away.. and of course the end of the road goes to Egypt, and as you can imagine you can not enter in some country without visa and so...
thats well said, none of arab neighbours will want poor palestinians. and if they let them in they stay in camps in tents. it must be out of love.
You are no better justifying terrorists behavior that kill people,
I dont see anyone justifying terrorists. However, the word "terrorist" is very subjective and depends on how you view a situation.
Nobody is born a terrorist, they are created out of desperation, hate and sometimes a feeling of helplessness. You have to solve that problem before you solve terrorism. Killing terrorists is not the answer because there are always more to replace them.
As DD said, one man´s terrorist is another man´s freedom fighter......
The US "gun ho" approach to shooting anything that moves will never counter terrorism.
Please... enough with your recommendations and aggressive approach. You are no better justifying terrorists behavior that kill people, than I am defending those that kill in return. So you can make all of your sacarastic snied comments here and continue your crusade. You are not going to change my mind how I view things, nor do I have a desire to change your´s. So what´s your point?
you should upload a pic of yours that you tear your hair and scratched face painted with blood. they love blood, she wants you see suffering, because you are a bad fat brainwashed amerikan, a daughter of uncle sam.
Please... enough with your recommendations and aggressive approach. You are no better justifying terrorists behavior that kill people, than I am defending those that kill in return. So you can make all of your sacarastic snied comments here and continue your crusade. You are not going to change my mind how I view things, nor do I have a desire to change your´s. So what´s your point?
This is just a forum luv.. we are exchanging our views.. don´t be mad.
I dont see anyone justifying terrorists. However, the word "terrorist" is very subjective and depends on how you view a situation.
Nobody is born a terrorist, they are created out of desperation, hate and sometimes a feeling of helplessness. You have to solve that problem before you solve terrorism. Killing terrorists is not the answer because there are always more to replace them.
As DD said, one man´s terrorist is another man´s freedom fighter......
That´s the problem..on how people view terrorism to begin with. The description you just gave describes millions of people who are on anti-depressants.
Please... enough with your recommendations and aggressive approach. You are no better justifying terrorists behavior that kill people, than I am defending those that kill in return. So you can make all of your sacarastic snied comments here and continue your crusade. You are not going to change my mind how I view things, nor do I have a desire to change your´s. So what´s your point?
I am not saying it is okay to send rockets every now and then... but keep in mind, those rockets have not killed anyone until today, while Israel army fighting in Gaza has killed more 1000 people until now.. you don;t have to be a genious to understand how disproportionate it is... come on they don´t even have an army... just those fighters.
That´s the problem..on how people view terrorism to begin with. The description you just gave describes millions of people who are on anti-depressants.
Just try... just for ONCE....to take yourself away from your nice comfortable ordinary surburban all-American life and imagine that you home is, daily, inch by inch being taken away from you and backed by the biggest power in the world. Just, for once, imagine what it is like to feel so desperate and helpless in a situation that you would die to change it.
That would make you a freedom fighter....until you woke up in your nice comfortable bed and found you had been dreaming you were a terrorist...
whatever, im glad that im not you. im not with you. im not into backward people.
OOpss, are you angry???? How did you find out that I am backward... is it because I value human life more than you? or would you like to explain what do you mean by backward people?
That´s the problem..on how people view terrorism to begin with. The description you just gave describes millions of people who are on anti-depressants.
So, what do we learn from here... Justice is very important... and every person deserves a fair treatment.
Merih, while I greatly sympathize with the Palistenian cause, I do not approve of making this a Jew problem. The problem is with the Israeli governent policies. There are many diverse views in Israel. In fact, there is more criticism of their govermental policies there than in the US. There are Jews who want peace and put their lives on the line to attain it. There are many Israeli peace groups.
OOpss, are you angry???? How did you find out that I am backward... is it because I value human life more than you? or would you like to explain what do you mean by backward people?
nope, im not angry at all. opposite, i enjoy this. carry on, pls
Hahaha, great outlook. They can continue to beat you up and you will rise...what a trooper.
im absolutely calm. im really not angry with anyone.
israel has anyway lost the media war long before it was declared to be a state.
the whole world is pro-palestinian. i dont understand why merih is not satified with the western media? the whole western media does a good job for arabs. it was never popular to be a pro-israeli.
im absolutely calm. im really not angry with anyone.
israel has anyway lost the media war long before it was declared to be a state.
the whole world is pro-palestinian. i dont understand why merih is not satified with the western media? the whole western media does a good job for arabs. it was never popular to be a pro-israeli.
I have also realized they are the most aggressive when posting...makes sense now.
A Palestinian besieged in the Khuza´a area, in south-eastern Gaza, reported today that Israeli soldiers shot a woman waving a white flag and civilians who were fleeing a bombed house on army orders, killing at least three and wounding others. (B´Tselem)
Merih, while I greatly sympathize with the Palistenian cause, I do not approve of making this a Jew problem. The problem is with the Israeli governent policies. There are many diverse views in Israel. In fact, there is more criticism of their govermental policies there than in the US. There are Jews who want peace and put their lives on the line to attain it. There are many Israeli peace groups.
Corruption, greed hardness of heart exists in every society. One does not know what is in their soul until opportunity presents itself.
Like all peoples, there are good Jews and bad Jews. There are those who make valuable contributions to the whole world, and those who don´t.
Obviously Alameda, the problem is not a Jew problem, like 911 was not a Muslim problem.. There are always good people and bad people in every religion, race and country...
"Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it, just as it obliterated others before it." (The Martyr, Imam Hassan al-Banna, of blessed memory).
"There is no solution for the Palestinian question except through Jihad. Initiatives, proposals and international conferences are all a waste of time and vain endeavors."
"Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it, just as it obliterated others before it." (The Martyr, Imam Hassan al-Banna, of blessed memory).
"There is no solution for the Palestinian question except through Jihad. Initiatives, proposals and international conferences are all a waste of time and vain endeavors."
Well, are you saying that nobody tried anything but suddenly started firing rockets into Israel... I think this jihad approach is wrong... but if you don´t do just to others , this is what happens at the end.
And that is what exactly the western countries do.. Look at US, they said we have proof that Iraq has nuclear weapons.. they killed thousands, thousands of them killed, but they found nothing. Then they said, sorry, but stilled hanged Saddam, and they said they want to bring democracy to Iraq and give them a humanitarian life... So why don´t they worry for Palestine when it comes to doing just? Because it was not just what they did in Iraq in the first place.
It is very funny. You think it is okay, a country in an other continent will go to another continent, declare war, kill thousands, declare anyone who resist them terrorist, is OKAY, but not the Palestinians..
"Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it, just as it obliterated others before it." (The Martyr, Imam Hassan al-Banna, of blessed memory).
"There is no solution for the Palestinian question except through Jihad. Initiatives, proposals and international conferences are all a waste of time and vain endeavors."
Teaschip....you didn´t read my post earlier....here read...if you dare...
To put it in a nutshell.......the problem is the Israelis have taken over the Palestinians land (with a lot of help from others, most notably the British in the early days) and are continueing to expand, leaving the Palestinians no place to live.
There is no defined border to Israel. The idea is Eretz Israel is the border of Israel. Of course, those who live in those lands don´t like it.
The Likud party does not accept the idea of a Palestinian state...period.
The ´Peace & Security´ chapter of the Likud Party platform “flatly rejects the establishment of a Palestinian Arab state west of the Jordan river.” The chapter continues: “The Palestinians can run their lives freely in the framework of self-rule, but not as an independent and sovereign state.
Hamas does not accept the state of Israel either.......so there you have a problem. I think Hamas has revised it´s ideas in the last few years to the acceptance of Israel within certain confines.
After years of pograms, the Spanish Inquisition, the Holocost and other hideous incidents, the Jewish people wanted a "homeland"....The present day location was chosen due to historic roots...The Promised Land.....the only problem was....there were people living on it.
"Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it, just as it obliterated others before it." (The Martyr, Imam Hassan al-Banna, of blessed memory).
"There is no solution for the Palestinian question except through Jihad. Initiatives, proposals and international conferences are all a waste of time and vain endeavors."
Teaschip....you didn´t read my post earlier....here read...if you dare...
To put it in a nutshell.......the problem is the Israelis have taken over the Palestinians land (with a lot of help from others, most notably the British in the early days) and are continueing to expand, leaving the Palestinians no place to live.
There is no defined border to Israel. The idea is Eretz Israel is the border of Israel. Of course, those who live in those lands don´t like it.
The Likud party does not accept the idea of a Palestinian state...period.
The ´Peace & Security´ chapter of the Likud Party platform “flatly rejects the establishment of a Palestinian Arab state west of the Jordan river.” The chapter continues: “The Palestinians can run their lives freely in the framework of self-rule, but not as an independent and sovereign state.
Hamas does not accept the state of Israel either.......so there you have a problem. I think Hamas has revised it´s ideas in the last few years to the acceptance of Israel within certain confines.
After years of pograms, the Spanish Inquisition, the Holocost and other hideous incidents, the Jewish people wanted a "homeland"....The present day location was chosen due to historic roots...The Promised Land.....the only problem was....there were people living on it.
Claims have been received by the BBC and an Israeli human rights group that Israeli troops have fired on Gaza residents trying to escape the conflict area.
[...] "They told us you all have to go to the centre of the town, where the school is.
"We put the women first, and we put our children on our shoulders, with white bandanas on their heads.
"When we were walking, with the women first, they saw soldiers and they started to shout to them, to tell them ´we have children, we have children´. They started to shoot us. My aunt was killed with a bullet in her head."
There is fire everywhere in Gaza... they have no Fire extinguishing facilities... people are trapped in their houses...
UN shelter and warehouse was hit... the aid sent for the Palestinians are burnings.
Not confirmed yet, but reports are coming in saying a hospital with 500 patients in it was also hit...
What is the excuse? Isn´t it a genocide? What is the world waiting for?
Are you kidding ?!
You forgot the rules ?!!!
Of course its not genocide untill big boys say it is !
Big boys who abstained and voted against the resolution of the UN Human Rights Council.
And when will they say ?!
Hmmm,actually they wont,no matter how many soul died there
What the world is waiting for ?
hmmmmmm
Well,waiting for israel to come to its sense alone all by itself,and know what it´s doing is bad and no good for good and humanitarian country like it ´they know it will,they have trust in it´ and stop the killing without they have to do or say anything may annoye israel or harm their intrests with it
Hospital name is Al Quds,and its one of the Palestinians Red Crescent hospitals,numbers of patients and medical crew almost 500,no more further detail for now
And they also bomb also Al Þrook tower,its bulding for the Media ´Fox,Arabiya,ROYTERS..etc! and some others...you can guess why they bomb it !
Edited:
Also bombing another building for the UNRWA,and even BanKi-moon. Secretary-General of the United Nations in there !
i wana give a list of israeli n american products which we use everyday ....but that would be a huuuge list..
I´m all for the list! Do post it if you make it. Maybe it´ll help us to buy American products here, in the USA, instead of the ones made by people in other countries to whom American jobs were outsourced.
GuesswhoIam - I have deleted your post as I think the first paragraph was extremely offensive. If you care to pm me or another admin/mod saying that you will remove it then we can reinstate the rest of the post.
I´m all for the list! Do post it if you make it. Maybe it´ll help us to buy American products here, in the USA, instead of the ones made by people in other countries to whom American jobs were outsourced.
GuesswhoIam - I have deleted your post as I think the first paragraph was extremely offensive. If you care to pm me or another admin/mod saying that you will remove it then we can reinstate the rest of the post.
yaw, yaw, thats a shame. i protest against deleting such posts!
I´m all for the list! Do post it if you make it. Maybe it´ll help us to buy American products here, in the USA, instead of the ones made by people in other countries to whom American jobs were outsourced.
anything you use in America is produced in the other parts of the world especially China. It`s cool if you`re planning not to consume any product.
anything you use in America is produced in the other parts of the world especially China. It`s cool if you`re planning not to consume any product.
I try my best to avoid buying things made in China, since you can pretty much count on it being crap. But your right..almost everything here is made in China. I will say that the products I have bought made in Turkey, have been made very well.
I try my best to avoid buying things made in China, since you can pretty much count on it being crap. But your right..almost everything here is made in China. I will say that the products I have bought made in Turkey, have been made very well.
I agree with you on chinese products. I remember last year´s scandal concerning mattel toys dye and the risk they had on children´s health.End of 2008 we had the melamin scandal.
The problem is that they dont put "made in china" on the products of multinational companies such as nestle, unilever, ....etc etc So in order to track down the product one can look at the barcode, the first 3 digits of the barcode is the country code wherein the product was made.
Sample all barcodes that start with 690.691.692 until 695 are all MADE IN CHINA. 471 is Made in Taiwan
00 ~ 13 USA & CANADA 30 ~ 37 FRANCE 40 ~ 44 GERMANY 50 ~ UK 76 ~ Switzerland and Lienchtenstein 628 ~ Saudi-Arabien 629 ~ United Arab Emirates 740 ~ 745 - Central America All 480 Codes are Made in the Philippines. 869 Turkey
Turkish products (cloths, kitchenware) We buy in france are quite good.
I agree with you on chinese products. I remember last year´s scandal concerning mattel toys dye and the risk they had on children´s health.End of 2008 we had the melamin scandal.
The problem is that they dont put "made in china" on the products of multinational companies such as nestle, unilever, ....etc etc So in order to track down the product one can look at the barcode, the first 3 digits of the barcode is the country code wherein the product was made.
Sample all barcodes that start with 690.691.692 until 695 are all MADE IN CHINA. 471 is Made in Taiwan
00 ~ 13 USA & CANADA 30 ~ 37 FRANCE 40 ~ 44 GERMANY 50 ~ UK 76 ~ Switzerland and Lienchtenstein 628 ~ Saudi-Arabien 629 ~ United Arab Emirates 740 ~ 745 - Central America All 480 Codes are Made in the Philippines. 869 Turkey
Turkish products (cloths, kitchenware) We buy in france are quite good.
Interesting list, where did you find it? Can you provide a link to this information? The pet food problem was with foods that were did not have any indication they had any products made in China. Companies use parts from other countries. In the pet food case, it was the gluten that contained something that was deadly in particular to cats.
A film explaining the root cause of the palestinian israeli problem. Story told by christians, jews and muslims. Story also told by israeli soldier, a lady, who enterred Akka in 1948 (acre, akko, )
The film also shows that israeli persecuted christians and forced them to leave their homes. Another proof that the conflict was never a jew vs. muslim nor arab vs non arabs.
I think it is very interesting and worth taking the time to watch it all.
So in order to track down the product one can look at the barcode, the first 3 digits of the barcode is the country code wherein the product was made.
Sample all barcodes that start with 690.691.692 until 695 are all MADE IN CHINA. 471 is Made in Taiwan
00 ~ 13 USA & CANADA 30 ~ 37 FRANCE 40 ~ 44 GERMANY 50 ~ UK 76 ~ Switzerland and Lienchtenstein 628 ~ Saudi-Arabien 629 ~ United Arab Emirates 740 ~ 745 - Central America All 480 Codes are Made in the Philippines. 869 Turkey
Turkish products (cloths, kitchenware) We buy in france are quite good.
00 ~ 13 USA & CANADA 30 ~ 37 FRANCE 40 ~ 44 GERMANY 50 ~ UK 76 ~ Switzerland and Lienchtenstein 628 ~ Saudi-Arabien 629 ~ United Arab Emirates 740 ~ 745 - Central America All 480 Codes are Made in the Philippines. 869 Turkey
Turkish products (cloths, kitchenware) We buy in france are quite good.
FALSE !
Quoting alameda
Interesting list, where did you find it? Can you provide a link to this information?
I agree with you on chinese products. I remember last year´s scandal concerning mattel toys dye and the risk they had on children´s health.End of 2008 we had the melamin scandal.
The problem is that they dont put "made in china" on the products of multinational companies such as nestle, unilever, ....etc etc So in order to track down the product one can look at the barcode, the first 3 digits of the barcode is the country code wherein the product was made.
Sample all barcodes that start with 690.691.692 until 695 are all MADE IN CHINA. 471 is Made in Taiwan
00 ~ 13 USA & CANADA 30 ~ 37 FRANCE 40 ~ 44 GERMANY 50 ~ UK 76 ~ Switzerland and Lienchtenstein 628 ~ Saudi-Arabien 629 ~ United Arab Emirates 740 ~ 745 - Central America All 480 Codes are Made in the Philippines. 869 Turkey
Turkish products (cloths, kitchenware) We buy in france are quite good.
I´m all for the list! Do post it if you make it. Maybe it´ll help us to buy American products here, in the USA, instead of the ones made by people in other countries to whom American jobs were outsourced.
But what they are not considering also by boycotting our products, you will also be hurting and affecting businesses and people´s jobs in your own country.
I agree with you on chinese products. I remember last year´s scandal concerning mattel toys dye and the risk they had on children´s health.End of 2008 we had the melamin scandal.
The problem is that they dont put "made in china" on the products of multinational companies such as nestle, unilever, ....etc etc So in order to track down the product one can look at the barcode, the first 3 digits of the barcode is the country code wherein the product was made.
Sample all barcodes that start with 690.691.692 until 695 are all MADE IN CHINA. 471 is Made in Taiwan
00 ~ 13 USA & CANADA 30 ~ 37 FRANCE 40 ~ 44 GERMANY 50 ~ UK 76 ~ Switzerland and Lienchtenstein 628 ~ Saudi-Arabien 629 ~ United Arab Emirates 740 ~ 745 - Central America All 480 Codes are Made in the Philippines. 869 Turkey
Turkish products (cloths, kitchenware) We buy in france are quite good.
"No it doesn´t. The 3-digit prefix code indicates which numbering organization has allocated the bank of numbers to the company. For example, a company may have it´s headquarters in South Africa. The EAN organization in South Africa has the code "600", but all the products of the company may be manufactured in England. The English-made products would still have the "600" prefix code. The prefix code is a way to have 70-plus EAN member organizations issuing numbers without having to worry about duplicate numbers........
GS1 Prefixes do not provide identification of country of origin for a given product. They simply provide number capacity to different countries for assignment from that location to companies who apply. Those companies in turn may manufacture products anywhere in the world. "
In addition, there is the problem of a lot of deception regarding country of origin labeling. For instance in the USA there is a label stating Made in USA, when in fact it could have been actually manufactured in a US territory or other entity and only had the minimal finishing touches applied in the US. For example Hand Knit does not really mean hand knit, the item could have been mostly machine knitted and finished by hand, thus earning the "hand knit" label.
With the pet food scandal, there was NO WAY to know any of the ingredients in the pet food were from China, without extensive research being done. It was only when a lot of pets started dying, and independent research was done, it was exposed that some ingredients were from China.
My partial solution is to buy as local as possible.
I agree with you on chinese products. I remember last year´s scandal concerning mattel toys dye and the risk they had on children´s health.End of 2008 we had the melamin scandal.
The problem is that they dont put "made in china" on the products of multinational companies such as nestle, unilever, ....etc etc So in order to track down the product one can look at the barcode, the first 3 digits of the barcode is the country code wherein the product was made.
Sample all barcodes that start with 690.691.692 until 695 are all MADE IN CHINA. 471 is Made in Taiwan
00 ~ 13 USA & CANADA 30 ~ 37 FRANCE 40 ~ 44 GERMANY 50 ~ UK 76 ~ Switzerland and Lienchtenstein 628 ~ Saudi-Arabien 629 ~ United Arab Emirates 740 ~ 745 - Central America All 480 Codes are Made in the Philippines. 869 Turkey
Turkish products (cloths, kitchenware) We buy in france are quite good.
You know, Genuida and Girleegirl, the situation in Gaza is hardly a joke. The information in the article Cedars posted, while not perfect, it does offer a start....
You know, Genuida and Girleegirl, the situation in Gaza is hardly a joke. The information in the article Cedars posted, while not perfect, it does offer a start....
Can we get back on topic?
Look Miss high-and-mighty, neither of us have said the situation is a joke so get off your high horse! There is nothing wrong with adding a smiley face and a light comment to a very tense and disturbing topic. I´m quite sure everyone can get around it and move on to their arguing.
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip – Israel shelled the United Nations headquarters in the Gaza Strip on Thursday, engulfing the compound and a warehouse in fire and destroying thousands of pounds of food and humanitarian supplies intended for Palestinian refugees.
Another Israeli bombardment on Thursday killed the Hamas security chief.
U.N. workers and Palestinian firefighters, some wearing bulletproof jackets, struggled to douse the flames and pull bags of food from the debris after the Israeli attack, which was another blow to efforts to ease the humanitarian crisis in the Gaza Strip. Dense smoke billowed from the compound.
You know, Genuida and Girleegirl, the situation in Gaza is hardly a joke. The information in the article Cedars posted, while not perfect, it does offer a start....
Can we get back on topic?
offfffffffff !!
Can you show me where in the whole thread I was making fun of the Gaza situation??
GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip – Israel shelled the United Nations headquarters in the Gaza Strip on Thursday, engulfing the compound and a warehouse in fire and destroying thousands of pounds of food and humanitarian supplies intended for Palestinian refugees.
Another Israeli bombardment on Thursday killed the Hamas security chief.
U.N. workers and Palestinian firefighters, some wearing bulletproof jackets, struggled to douse the flames and pull bags of food from the debris after the Israeli attack, which was another blow to efforts to ease the humanitarian crisis in the Gaza Strip. Dense smoke billowed from the compound.
Let me guess... the UN headquarters was packed with Hamas leaders. Just like the hospital the other day
I guess she is not listening to any of us... and here I was thinking your word had more validity
I didn´t get through the rest of these posts...how disappointing to see this isn´t accurate. I had just tried to look up the bar code on my vitaminwater..
There are four Geneva Conventions, signed August 12, 1949, and the two additional Protocols of June 8, 1977. These treaties are all fully indexed on this site.
In addition, there are many other international treaties which govern the conduct of war or establish human rights standards which are not indexed here.
GuesswhoIam - I have deleted your post as I think the first paragraph was extremely offensive. If you care to pm me or another admin/mod saying that you will remove it then we can reinstate the rest of the post.
Let me guess... the UN headquarters was packed with Hamas leaders. Just like the hospital the other day
Good guessing,but the spoksman added that they also were shoting the Ãsraeli army !
Even that Barak actually apologized and said it was a mistake !
Same exactly as the Media tower,at the BBC news,in the report the reporter there,went out from the building,and walked in the street,and the side street too,to show us there is no fighters there
And that they can come and go as they want,not as the israeli army claim that the building is under control of Hamas
Then,they interview the army spokesman,and asked him why has the army bomb the Þrook tower ´one of Media towers´ and if they are going to be targeted to bombing from israel
He said,there are Hamas fighters there and building is under control of Hamas
They said,but you saw,in live broadcast its not !
He said we have our information
Ãt ÃS under Hamas control !
And what ever under Hamas control is target to us
The interviewer said even if there are reporters,civilians in it
He said it is Hamas mistake,they take civilians as shields,and it is war crime by Hamas
the reporter said..there is NO Hamas there...couldnt you see,they come and go as they want ?!
We ´BBC´ will hold israeli army responsible of the safty of the reporters
Spokesman,said its Hamas responsibility if we bomb not our...they take civilians as shields !
Ãsrael is fighting terrorism there...Livni said !
But what they are not considering also by boycotting our products, you will also be hurting and affecting businesses and people´s jobs in your own country.
Who said that ?!
Ãts considered!
Ãt will be a good lesson for them ´businessmen and people in our countries´ not to make business with those companies!
Ãf they insist..then they only have themselves to blame if their business got hurt or affected.
Firing 155mm shells into the center of Gaza City, whatever the target, will likely cause horrific civilian casualties. By using this weapon in such circumstances, Israel is committing indiscriminate attacks in violation of the laws of war.
Marc Garlasco, senior military analyst at Human Rights Watch
Effect of 155mm Artillery Indiscriminate in Populated Areas
January 16, 2009
(Jerusalem, January 16, 2009) - Israel´s use of heavy artillery in residential areas of Gaza City violates the prohibition under the laws of war against indiscriminate attacks and should be stopped immediately, Human Rights Watch said today. A Human Rights Watch researcher on the Israel-Gaza border on January 15, 2009, observed Israel´s repeated use in the center of Gaza City of 155mm artillery shells, which inflict blast and fragmentation damage up to 300 meters away.
"Firing 155mm shells into the center of Gaza City, whatever the target, will likely cause horrific civilian casualties," said Marc Garlasco, senior military analyst at Human Rights Watch. "By using this weapon in such circumstances, Israel is committing indiscriminate attacks in violation of the laws of war."
According to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA), Israel yesterday shelled the relief organization´s main compound in Gaza City, wounding three people. UNRWA believes that white phosphorus used in the attack set part of the compound on fire. Up to 700 city residents had fled there in the morning to seek refuge after intense fighting in the area. The Human Rights Watch researcher also witnessed ground-burst 155mm white phosphorus strikes in Gaza City.
"We warned the Israelis hour by hour through the night of the vulnerabilities here as the shells came closer and closer, and shrapnel was coming into the compound on a regular occasion," John Ging, UNWRA´s Gaza director of operations, told the media. "Nonetheless, we have now been subjected to these direct hits."
Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert apologized for the attack, but said Israeli forces had come under fire from the UN compound. "It is absolutely true that we were attacked from that place, but the consequences are very sad and we apologize for it," he said.
The death toll from yesterday´s military operations remains unknown, but media reports quoted Gaza health officials as saying that 70 people had died (the reports make no distinction between civilian and combatant casualties). As of January 14, 1,013 Palestinians had died, including 322 children and 76 women, according to the Gazan Ministry of Health. An additional 4,560 Palestinians reportedly have been wounded, including 1,600 children and 678 women.
The attacks on Gaza City occurred after the Israel Defense Force (IDF) had warned Gaza´s residents to flee to city centers. According to the Israeli government, on January 3, the IDF began broadcasting warnings that told people, among other things, that "For your own safety, you are required to leave your homes immediately and move to the city centers." Despite these warnings, the IDF has launched attacks against the Gaza city center, causing civilian casualties.
"Israel warned civilians to go to city centers and later shelled the center of Gaza City with a weapon that should never be used in densely populated areas," Garlasco said.
According to media reports and aid groups, Israeli forces today also fired upon a hospital and an international media center. The World Health Organization (WHO) told Human Rights Watch that Israeli shells had struck the al-Quds hospital in the Tel al-Hawa neighborhood, setting it on fire. The fire was extinguished, but about 100 patients had to be evacuated. Between 150 and 500 patients were in the hospital at the time, WHO said.
Israeli fire also hit the al-Shurouq tower, which houses media outlets such as Reuters, al-Arabiyya Television, and al-Hayat newspaper, causing substantial damage and wounding at least two journalists, including one who worked for the Abu Dhabi television channel. Media organizations had provided the Israeli military with the GPS locations of all their offices. Israeli forces told the media that they had come under fire from the building. It is not clear if Israeli forces hit the building using artillery or tank shells.
Human Rights Watch is unable to conduct full investigations into alleged laws of war violations by either side because of Israel´s continuing denial of access to Gaza.
Hamas and other Palestinian armed groups have also violated the laws of war by continuing to fire unguided Qassam and Grad rockets at population centers in Israel. A Human Rights Watch researcher on the Gazan border yesterday saw the firing of a Qassam rocket that hit outside Sderot, causing no injuries. Such rockets have killed three Israeli civilians and injured at least 78 since December 27.
International humanitarian law, or the laws of war, prohibits indiscriminate attacks. Indiscriminate attacks are of a nature to strike military objectives and civilians or civilian objects without distinction. Examples of indiscriminate attacks are those that are not directed at a specific military objective or that use weapons that cannot be directed at a specific military objective. Prohibited indiscriminate attacks include area bombardment, which are attacks by artillery or other means that treat as a single military objective a number of clearly separated and distinct military objectives located in an area containing a concentration of civilians and civilian objects.
The expected lethal radius for a 155mm high explosive projectile, such as the artillery the IDF is currently using in Gaza City, is reportedly between 50 and 150 meters and the expected casualty radius is between 100 and 300 meters. IDF officials have previously said that the error radius for a 155mm shell is usually 25 meters. Therefore, if the IDF fires shells as close as 100 meters to populated areas, it greatly increases the likelihood of civilian casualties.
Cease artillery attacks using weapons such as 155mm artillery in situations and locales where the degree of weapon targeting accuracy and the shells´ casualty radius do not allow for attacks that can discriminate between civilians and combatants.
Cease artillery attacks in or near populated areas that are likely to cause civilian harm that is excessive compared to the expected military advantage.
Ensure that all artillery attacks are directed at a genuine military objective, and not overly expansive conceptions of "area denial" that are inconsistent with international humanitarian law. Cease any attacks as soon as it becomes known that they are not being directed at a genuine military objective or are not distinguishing between combatants and civilians.
Ensure, in cooperation with Palestinian counterparts, that effective communications mechanisms are in place to relay promptly information on attacks threatening civilian harm, and take appropriate measures to reduce the threat to civilians when such information is provided.
Collect and analyze data regarding Palestinian civilian casualties from artillery shelling in order to assess the harm to civilians caused by the use of artillery in particular locales and situations, and thus to base targeting decisions on a proper weighing of foreseeable civilian harm.
At same time reports coming alive from there they are still firing at Gaza despite of their own declaration.
As usual !
Cease the fire while occupying Gaza is nothing really except a game !
Because they know resistance wont stop of course as long as the army still on their lands,so they will fire again..and say ..see? it wasnt us who started it !
Actually it doesnt matter how do they look or anyone else when it comes to the Palestinians interest
But if they accept it they and Palestinian will BE beaten !
israel is already there in Gaza,took over their lands,and as one of the Palestinians there said,´they are just 20 m away,when they want to fire at us again they will ! ´
They dont have home,no country,no land,and still under siege and add to the over 1200 died and 5400 injured !
So,those people paid their lives for nothing ?!!!
Ãt is Hamas and all the resistance responsibility infront of the palestinians NOT to accept !
Except under an agreenment between both sides that grant both sides their rights.
The US agreement and the EU protecting israel welfares in the upper sea were israel´s prize for killing those 1200 soul
They are protecting israel,the one who actually doesnt need protection..
The question,in return what the EU did/do to protect the palestinians ?!
We cant say israel neither the US or the EU didnt achieve anything so far...can we ?!
´Tungsten bombs´ leave Israel´s victims with mystery wounds
As it declares a unilateral ceasefire, Jerusalem faces a UN call for a war crimes investigation
Two children were killed yesterday when Israeli tanks shelled a UN school in which families were sheltering, leading a UN spokesman, Chris Gunness, to say: "There has to be an investigation to determine whether a war crime has been committed." The call was dismissed by an Israeli foreign ministry spokesman, Yigal Palmor, who said: "These claims of war crimes are not supported by the slightest piece of evidence." But among numerous allegations of disproportionate use of force, questions are also multiplying about the use of unconventional weapons by Israel, including a new type of bomb that causes injuries that doctors have not seen before, and which they find impossible to treat.
The Israeli Prime Minister, Ehud Olmert, claimed in a televised address last night that the military operation had "fully attained" its goals, "and beyond". Israel had declared the ceasefire in response to an appeal from the Egyptian President, Hosni Mubarak, but troops would remain for now in Gaza, and Hamas would be "surprised again" if it attacked.
But even though Mr Olmert said Hamas had been "beaten badly", rockets landed in Israel a few minutes before he spoke. Despite the desperate state of Gaza´s population, Hamas leaders said they would continue to fight for an end to Israel´s closure of crossing points into the territory and a withdrawal of the Israeli forces.
Mr Mubarak invited the Palestinian President, Mahmoud Abbas, and the French President, Nicolas Sarkozy, to discuss Gaza in Sharm el-Sheikh today. The UN Secretary-General, Ban Ki-moon, said he might attend, and Gordon Brown is among other leaders due to take part.
Although Mr Olmert´s announcement was only a first step towards halting the conflict in Gaza, the UN is not the only international body insisting that inquiries must be held as soon as possible into the tactics and weapons used by Israel. Erik Fosse, a Norwegian doctor who worked in Gaza´s hospitals during the conflict, said that Israel was using so-called Dime (dense inert metal explosive) bombs designed to produce an intense explosion in a small space. The bombs are packed with tungsten powder, which has the effect of shrapnel but often dissolves in human tissue, making it difficult to discover the cause of injuries.
Dr Fosse said he had seen a number of patients with extensive injuries to their lower bodies. "It was as if they had stepped on a mine, but there was no shrapnel in the wounds," he said. "Some had lost their legs. It looked as though they had been sliced off. I have been to war zones for 30 years, but I have never seen such injuries before." However, the injuries matched photographs and de[script]ions in medical literature of the effects of Dime bombs.
"All the patients I saw had been hit by bombs fired from unmanned drones," said Dr Fosse, head of the Norwegian Aid Committee. "The bomb hit the ground near them and exploded." His colleague, Mads Gilbert, accused Israel of using the territory as a testing ground for a new, "extremely nasty" type of explosive. "This is a new generation of small explosive that detonates with extreme power and dissipates its power within a range of five to 10 metres," he said.
According to military databases, Dime bombs are intended for use where conventional weapons might kill or injure bystanders – to kill combatants in a house, for example, without harming people next door. Instead of being made from metal, which sprays shrapnel across a wide area, the casing is carbon fibre. Part of the motive for developing the bombs was to replace the use of depleted uranium, but Dr Fosse said the cancer risk from tungsten powde was well known. "These patients should be followed up to see if there are any carcinogenic effects," he said.
While the loudest controversy has been over accusations that white phosphorus was illegally used, other foreign doctors working in Gaza have reported injuries they cannot explain. Professor Mohammed Sayed Khalifa, a cardiac consultant from Sudan, said that two of his patients had had uncontrollable bleeding. "One had a chest operation, and continued bleeding even after having been given large quantities of plasma," he said. "The other had what seemed to be a minor leg injury, but collapsed with profuse bleeding. Something was interfering with the clotting process. I have never seen such a thing before."
Dr Ahmed Almi, an Egyptian cardio-thoracic consultant at al-Nasser hospital in Khan Younis in southern Gaza, said he had seen a number of patients with inexplicable injuries. A boy of 14 had a small puncture wound in his head, but extensive damage to his brain, making it impossible to save his life. "I don´t know the nature or type of these weapons that make a very small [entry wound] and go on and make massive destruction in the tissues," he said.
Israeli military representatives have refused to confirm or deny using specific weapons, but insist that all Israel´s weapons comply with international law. Neither white phosphorus nor Dime bombs are illegal, but campaigners say the way they have been used, especially in Gaza´s densely packed urban areas, could constitute a war crime.
A Palestinian woman with severe facial injuries from a Dime bomb
In a letter on behalf of Arab ambassadors accredited in Austria, the Saudi ambassador, Prince Mansour al-Saud, expressed "our deep concern regarding the information … that traces of depleted uranium have been found in Palestinian victims".
The BBC is continuing to resist pressure over its decision not to air an appeal for aid to Gaza, as the Archbishop of York joined its critics.
In a statement, he said: "This situation is akin to that of British military hospitals who treat prisoners of war as a result of their duty under the Geneva convention.
"They do so because they identify need rather than cause.
"This is not an appeal by Hamas asking for arms but by the Disasters Emergency Committee asking for relief. By declining their request, the BBC has already taken sides and forsaken impartiality."
"The danger for the BBC is that this could be interpreted as taking a political stance on an ongoing story."
I think the BBC are showing very clearly where their politic stance lies
The BBC is continuing to resist pressure over its decision not to air an appeal for aid to Gaza, as the Archbishop of York joined its critics.
<[script] src="../../js/tiny_mce/themes/advanced/langs/en.js" type="text/java[script]">[script]>
>In a statement, he said: "This situation is akin to that of British military hospitals who treat prisoners of war as a result of their duty under the Geneva convention.
"They do so because they identify need rather than cause.
"This is not an appeal by Hamas asking for arms but by the Disasters Emergency Committee asking for relief. By declining their request, the BBC has already taken sides and forsaken impartiality."
"The danger for the BBC is that this could be interpreted as taking a political stance on an ongoing story."
I think the BBC are showing very clearly where their politic stance lies
To be honest, it showed to some extent in the reports by Jeremy Bowen. But at the same time, why is Israel not stumping up for some of this and also where is President Mahmoud Abbas in all of this??? Keeping a low profile being a Fatah man.
So at least the war weakened Hamas´s political control of Gaza, right? Not so much.
So then, the Israeli military boasted that it destroyed 60% of the tunnels whereby Gazans smuggle food, medicine and other goods into Gaza (the Israelis say they bring in explosives for rocket-making as well; but since rockets can be made from simple materials and petroleum products, and since the rockets are so primitive, they can´t be bringing in very good explosives). So at least, the Israeli war on the people of Gaza permanently reduced the capacity of those tunnels, right? Naw, the Gazans are working Caterpillar backhoes to rebuild the tunnels, already!
On the other hand, if the ceasefire holds, I suppose that this weekend will witness the last big demonstrations. And then the US Congress will go back to giving the Israeli military $30 billion in arms, and Israeli colonization of the West Bank will proceed apace, and the statelessness and expropriation of the Palestinians will worsen. And those quotidian processes won´t generate any headlines or massive protests, and they will proceed inexorably because no one is pressuring the US congress day to day except the Israel lobbies.
An earlier Rasmussen poll found that 44% of Americans supported the war and 41% opposed it. That may be an artifact of the way the question was asked. Americans like Israelis (and I am among them), so if you ask them if they support the Israelis or the Palestinians, you get a skewed answer. The question is whether this war was a good idea, or was prosecuted honorably. Moreover, there was a big difference among political parties, with only 45% of Democrats supporting the Gaza War. (I´ll bet you a lot of the opposition to the war within the party came from Jewish American liberals).
CNN has a lot of gall, since their coverage was completely one-sided and helped produce the results found in the poll. I can remember that they had Michael Oren on in uniform, speaking for the Israeli army, a Sunday afternoon. But they had no Palestinian policeman from Gaza. And then Oren dishonestly published an op-ed in the LA Times without identifying himself as being active duty Israeli military. This is a guy who claims to tell us the balanced historical narrative of the 1967 war or of American-Muslim relations? CNN never agressively challenged the lies of Israeli spokesmen the way British journalists did. And, of course, American channels seldom interviewed journalists based inside Gaza.
No wonder millions of Americans went to Aljazeera English on the Web for the other side of the story. By the way, the argument that Aljazeera English is not carried by the satellite television companies in the US because of lack of interest is ridiculous. They carry stations in obscure languages for which the audience must be tiny. I get Aljazeera Arabic; would the English really be less watched? Aljazeera English was most likely kept off because the Bushies made threats behind the scenes. The Obama administration should open up the airwaves.
But anyway, even a 60-30 split in the US for Israel in a war strikes me as not such great news for Tel Aviv. Surely in 1967 it was almost 100 percent in favor. And Rasmussen was probably closer to the truth with 44/41, which is in American terms an absolute disaster for Israeli public relations.
I fear the Israeli public is going to elect that maniac Binyamin Netanyahu on Feb. 10, and that will be the complete end of any 2-state solution, and we just have to live with a horrific Apartheid for decades, which will cause more conflict and further poison much of the world against the United States. (The Right-Zionists have been complaining about me wanting to put America first. For that I don´t apologize.)
This is not an accusation, nor is it directed at any particular member, but I do remember the general outpouring of "personal" grief felt by muslim TC members during the height of the Gaza attacks recently. Emotive phrases of "these are OUR people" and "they are killing US" were being used frequently. There was a general feeling that anyone from the west could not possible understand the depth of the grief they felt, even though we were also horrified.
I can only presume that those people are sending aid to assist the people of Gaza and ensure that they can rebuild their homes?
That´s so unlike Muslims - no sick minded fanatics there No suicide bombers, no terrorist acts on the whole planet. And Muslims are famous for their love of Jews Tami, don´t use arguments that are easily transferable to your favourite team.
This is not an accusation, nor is it directed at any particular member, but I do remember the general outpouring of "personal" grief felt by muslim TC members during the height of the Gaza attacks recently. Emotive phrases of "these are OUR people" and "they are killing US" were being used frequently. There was a general feeling that anyone from the west could not possible understand the depth of the grief they felt, even though we were also horrified.
I can only presume that those people are sending aid to assist the people of Gaza and ensure that they can rebuild their homes?
They donate to Israel much more than that amount to ensure the destruction of Palestine. Why don`t you read the comments below the news, btw. I`m sure you will like them as much as you like this news.
They donate to Israel much more than that amount to ensure the destruction of Palestine. Why don`t you read the comments below the news, btw. I`m sure you will like them as much as you like this news.
Yeah I know the US donate MILLIONS to Israel - it was an example though. And... you didn´t actually answer my question
This is not an accusation, nor is it directed at any particular member, but I do remember the general outpouring of "personal" grief felt by muslim TC members during the height of the Gaza attacks recently. Emotive phrases of "these are OUR people" and "they are killing US" were being used frequently. There was a general feeling that anyone from the west could not possible understand the depth of the grief they felt, even though we were also horrified.
I can only presume that those people are sending aid to assist the people of Gaza and ensure that they can rebuild their homes?
Yes, we send aids trying to help people in Gaza, we´ve sent Doctors and materials and not just now i may add, but right after that inhuman war started!
We TRY to ensure that they can rebuild their homes.
Ãts not easy actually, we /me as a person want to help the people of Gaza, we/i dont want the money/materials we donate go to anyone else except them !
We aim really to help, not to use the money to favorite a part over another !
We are not a rich country, and of course nor rich people
Yes, we send aids trying to help people in Gaza, we´ve sent Doctors and materials and not just now i may add, but right after that inhuman war started!
We TRY to ensure that they can rebuild their homes.
Ãts not easy actually, we /me as a person want to help the people of Gaza, we/i dont want the money/materials we donate go to anyone else except them !
We aim really to help, not to use the money to favorite a part over another !
We are not a rich country, and of course nor rich people
This is not an accusation, nor is it directed at any particular member, but I do remember the general outpouring of "personal" grief felt by muslim TC members during the height of the Gaza attacks recently. Emotive phrases of "these are OUR people" and "they are killing US" were being used frequently. There was a general feeling that anyone from the west could not possible understand the depth of the grief they felt, even though we were also horrified.
I can only presume that those people are sending aid to assist the people of Gaza and ensure that they can rebuild their homes?
Emotive phrases of "these are OUR people" and "they are killing US" were being used frequently.
Sometimes when English is not one´s first language, it may be difficult to express an emotion. I remember reading the posts and I interpreted the above quote as a sign of the strength of the empathy. I never, for one moment, interpreted it as anything else. I think that, sometimes, when tragedy occurs close to home (whoever we are and wherever we are from) it hits harder. That is not to say we are not touched and saddened by what happens further afield. From what I remember of the posts, I don´t remember getting "the general feeling" that people in the west would not be so horrified. Is this "general feeling" the general feeling of people saying that people from the west would not be so horrified or was it the "general feeling" you interpreted?
I haven´t been back to check the thread, but I don´t remember this "general feeling".
Quoting: TheAenigma
I can only presume that those people are sending aid to assist the people of Gaza and ensure that they can rebuild their homes?
I don´t understand your logic here. It´s as if you are assuming the people who expressed their grief are spouting only words and not taking any action.
I don´t know about you, but I always think that to talk about how much aid/donation/voluntary help one gives to good causes is rather like "blowing one´s own trumpet" and it´s not something I for one want to do. It doesn´t have to be written here as a proof of one´s concern for a tragedy. I personally don´t think spouting about the individual aid one gives to a cause helps that cause. This is not the same as highlighting the work that organisations do and this does help to get the message out there.
Why are you always so eager to put a negative slant on certain issues? People felt a genuine grief, why try to interpret it as something it wasn´t? Oh well, if it´s your opinion, it´s your opinion I guess and you have every right to post it. Enjoy. . .
btw you have quite a knack for sanctimony at times
Edited (3/7/2009) by peacetrain
[Grrr the layout is all cock-eyed]
Why are you always so eager to put a negative slant on certain issues? People felt a genuine grief, why try to interpret it as something it wasn´t? Oh well, if it´s your opinion, it´s your opinion I guess and you have every right to post it. Enjoy. . .
btw you have quite a knack for sanctimony at times
I think you credit me with too much integrity in my posts. I just look for trouble mostly - unfortunately Canli was not in the mood to play
From sanctimony to idiocy in one simple step. Congratulations Aenigma!
This is why I don´t enjoy arguing with you PT - you have no argument, just silly name calling and your rather lame efforts at psychology. I can respect an opponant, but not your playground games.
Perhaps you spend too much time around school children?
I agree. It´s a shame you had to use a tragic event to try and get a rise out of someone.
This is just a cheap statement. You spend too much time around kids. I am reminded of the expression, "in a flat country, a hillock thinks it is a mountain"
This is why I don´t enjoy arguing with you PT - you have no argument, just silly name calling and your rather lame efforts at psychology. I can respect an opponant, but not your playground games.
Perhaps you spend too much time around school children?
I´ve already expressed my argument. Calling your posts idiotic does not constitute name calling. You are anything but an idiot, which makes it all the more shameful when you make light of a serious subject. Psychology? I don´t understand what you´re trying to say. But don´t worry, I understand well enough how you like to steer towards the lighthearted once you´ve realised your not on to a winner. I think Canli replied to you well enough for you to understand your error.
Spending too much time with children? I consider it an honour. You would be surprised how mature and honourable a group of 6 year olds can be. They absolutely do not resort to tactics seen here. They have more sense than we adults have .
I think Canli replied to you well enough for you to understand your error.
She knows the point I was making...she knows what I was hinting at. I just decided to accept her answer gracefully because I do not want another muslim/christian/east/west war....
Yes, we send aids trying to help people in Gaza, we´ve sent Doctors and materials and not just now i may add, but right after that inhuman war started!
We TRY to ensure that they can rebuild their homes.
Ãts not easy actually, we /me as a person want to help the people of Gaza, we/i dont want the money/materials we donate go to anyone else except them !
We aim really to help, not to use the money to favorite a part over another !
We are not a rich country, and of course nor rich people
But STÃLL, yes we do send aid .
OK PT thinks I am happy with your answer - I was trying to be graceful.
Hmmm ok
Well, you have told me that your government send doctors and materials. I just wondered about aid from the people - "THEIR" people (to use your expression). Egypt is not a rich country you say, but everyone can spare a few pence or the price of a pack of cigarettes or some phone credit. Ok how about outside of your country. What about some of those rich Saudi oil barons? How many millions did they send? Is it true any money donated by them goes for publishing FREE qurans...
I do not want another muslim/christian/east/west war....
This isn´t true. You are back pedalling.
Quote:The Aenigma
Emotive phrases of "these are OUR people" and "they are killing US" were being used frequently. There was a general feeling that anyone from the west could not possible understand the depth of the grief they felt, even though we were also horrified.
OK PT thinks I am happy with your answer - I was trying to be graceful.
Hmmm ok
Well, you have told me that your government send doctors and materials. I just wondered about aid from the people - "THEIR" people (to use your expression). Egypt is not a rich country you say, but everyone can spare a few pence or the price of a pack of cigarettes or some phone credit. Ok how about outside of your country. What about some of those rich Saudi oil barons? How many millions did they send? Is it true any money donated by them goes for publishing FREE qurans...
I didn´t say you were happy with Canli´s answer. Don´t put words in my mouth. And what is "graceful" about adding " Boring" at the end of your reply to Canli?
Quote:The Aenigma
but everyone can spare a few pence or the price of a pack of cigarettes or some phone credit
How does this mean that they don´t also give personal donations to aid?
You can spout all you want about how you don´t want East, West, blah blah blah confrontational discussions, but the proof of who you really are and what you really are about is in the tone and content of your posts.
I think you would do better to ask your questions http://www.islamicboard.com/ rather than expect Canli to answer on all things Islam.
Next will be your usual argument about all things religious, especially Islam, and how atheists have the moral high ground.
My post is not about moral high ground - it is about putting PEOPLE before propaganda. That is the only point I am making. Anyway, whoopy doo! Saudi Arabia has pledged 1 billion, and Islamic Aid raised 3 million.
I was very interested to see the low levels of aid from muslim countries. During the tsunami, the reason for their lack of assistance was Islam - they do not want to donate money in case any part of it assists non-mulims (even non-muslim children), but I don´t understand what the problem is THIS time
Two examples of questions and answers on IslamOnline at the time, begger belief:
Name Mary -
Profession
Question It is permissible for us, as Muslims, to make du`aa’ for those human beings afflicted there even if those people include Muslims and non-Muslims?
Answer In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful.
All praise and thanks are due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon His Messenger.
Thank you.
There is no harm or prohibition to pray for those people who lost their lives in that natural disaster. However, your beloved Muslim brothers and sisters deserve more and more of prayers and du´aa’. They deserve your moral and financial assistances. You should share their sorrow and difficult time and do invoke Allah to accept them among the Shuhada’ or martyrs on the day of Judgment.
You can also read:
Du`aa’: Worship and Resort of the Helpless
Helping Disaster Victims (Special File)
Allah Almighty knows best.
Name Hakim -
Profession
Question Can we give those afflicted people a portion of our zakah money even if they are non-Muslims? How about giving them charity?
Answer In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful.
All praise and thanks are due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon His Messenger.
Thank you. The receivers of Zakah money are clearly mentioned in the Qur´an. Among them, the poor and needy people. Looking at the situation of those people who are afflicted, one can conclude that the Muslims among them fall under the category of needy people.
In this regard, those Muslims deserve to receive a portion of Zakah. As for non-Muslims, they might deserve donation or any other form of assistance but not Zakah.
Thus, Zakah should be given to poor and needy Muslims. Some non-Muslims may receive a portion of Zakah if there is hope that by giving them Zakah that might lead to their conversion into Islam. They would be then considered under the category of mu´allafati qulubuhun or those whose hearts are inclined to accept Islam.
I was very interested to see the low levels of aid from muslim countries. During the tsunami, the reason for their lack of assistance was Islam - they do not want to donate money in case any part of it assists non-mulims (even non-muslim children), but I don´t understand what the problem is THIS time
Two examples of questions and answers on IslamOnline at the time, begger belief:
Name Mary -
Profession
Question It is permissible for us, as Muslims, to make du`aa’ for those human beings afflicted there even if those people include Muslims and non-Muslims?
Answer In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful.
All praise and thanks are due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon His Messenger.
Thank you.
There is no harm or prohibition to pray for those people who lost their lives in that natural disaster. However, your beloved Muslim brothers and sisters deserve more and more of prayers and du´aa’. They deserve your moral and financial assistances. You should share their sorrow and difficult time and do invoke Allah to accept them among the Shuhada’ or martyrs on the day of Judgment.
You can also read:
Du`aa’: Worship and Resort of the Helpless
Helping Disaster Victims (Special File)
Allah Almighty knows best.
Name Hakim -
Profession
Question Can we give those afflicted people a portion of our zakah money even if they are non-Muslims? How about giving them charity?
Answer In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful.
All praise and thanks are due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon His Messenger.
Thank you. The receivers of Zakah money are clearly mentioned in the Qur´an. Among them, the poor and needy people. Looking at the situation of those people who are afflicted, one can conclude that the Muslims among them fall under the category of needy people.
In this regard, those Muslims deserve to receive a portion of Zakah. As for non-Muslims, they might deserve donation or any other form of assistance but not Zakah.
Thus, Zakah should be given to poor and needy Muslims. Some non-Muslims may receive a portion of Zakah if there is hope that by giving them Zakah that might lead to their conversion into Islam. They would be then considered under the category of mu´allafati qulubuhun or those whose hearts are inclined to accept Islam.
No it isn´t! I´m sure it´s misinterpretation, lack of perspective or extensive knowledge of the subject! (as always ) Waiting for Alameda´s links to show it´s not true that Muslims prefer to help Muslims rather than people in general
No it isn´t! I´m sure it´s misinterpretation, lack of perspective or extensive knowledge of the subject! (as always ) Waiting for Alameda´s links to show it´s not true that Muslims prefer to help Muslims rather than people in general
Of course Muslims prefer to help Muslims. Do you have a problem with that?
The analogy would be, helping one´s own family members first, not go to the family down the street.
Of course Muslims prefer to help Muslims. Do you have a problem with that?
The analogy would be, helping one´s own family members first, not go to the family down the street.
Yeap I do, it means that they do not care what happens to non-Muslims - unlike people in secular countries who send help to those who need it, not only those who have the same lifestyle.
It´s a missed analogy - you don´t know all the Muslims and I´m sure they are those who you´d hate to meet. It´s a group of people sharing one belief, not blood. Plus, in a family you do not offer bribes so that other people joined in
Yeap I do, it means that they do not care what happens to non-Muslims - unlike people in secular countries who send help to those who need it, not only those who have the same lifestyle.
It´s a missed analogy - you don´t know all the Muslims and I´m sure they are those who you´d hate to meet. It´s a group of people sharing one belief, not blood. Plus, in a family you do not offer bribes so that other people joined in
Or...put in simpler terms, you choose who is worth saving and who is worth dying. A muslim child is worth more than a non-muslim? Nice religion you have got yourself there...
I´m only going to comment on what I witness myself. In school, 50% of our children are Muslim, from India, Pakistan, Kenya, Iraq, Iran, Croatia and Serbia. We often have fundraising activities for charity and we never have trouble with lack of donations from Muslim families. In fact quite a few parents donate more than is asked for on non uniform days. They also give more often than the parents of the white indigenous children at our school. The sad thing I find about that is that those children don´t get the chance to experience what it´s like to give and be part of something. The sense of community working together is being eroded in some sectors of society in the UK.
The local muslim community also gave gifts to the childrens ward at the local hospital when it was Eid. They gave to all the children and in fact it was a logistical nightmare because the organisers had gone to the trouble of finding out the ages and gender of the children in order to match gifts as best they could. This meant a lot of last minute shopping and they also bought extra for any children that had been admitted to the hospital on the day.
Personally, the charities that I give to regularly aren´t determined by my faith entirely, but by my personal life and family experiences.
Yeap I do, it means that they do not care what happens to non-Muslims - unlike people in secular countries who send help to those who need it, not only those who have the same lifestyle.
It´s a missed analogy - you don´t know all the Muslims and I´m sure they are those who you´d hate to meet. It´s a group of people sharing one belief, not blood. Plus, in a family you do not offer bribes so that other people joined in
Please save the crocodile tears. I did NOT say "they" do not care what happens to non-muslims.
The analogy was missed by you...but it still stands.
Groups tend to help other members of the group. This is the case with any group that identifies itself as a group. The criteria for membership to the group differs from group to group.
Actually bribes in families are common....if you are a nice girl/boy you can have a new car...and so on.
Groups tend to help other members of the group. This is the case with any group that identifies itself as a group. The criteria for membership to the group differs from group to group.
Actually bribes in families are common....if you are a nice girl/boy you can have a new car...and so on.
We are not talking about helping your family out with a little money here! You are playing this down. We are talking about the fact that you are not allowed to assist the poor and needy ..and sometimes dying, if they are not muslim. If you do (like Peacetrain) then you are going against the Quran. Your prayers and money should be given to muslims only, unless there is a chance that by giving money or help, you may convert them to Islam.
Sorry but a your example about getting your son/daughter a new car does not really compare with the tsunami victims quoted in IslamOnline, where it is more a case of "if you convert to my religion you can have some food/shelter" if not, sorry but we won´t help.
The local muslim community also gave gifts to the childrens ward at the local hospital when it was Eid. They gave to all the children and in fact it was a logistical nightmare because the organisers had gone to the trouble of finding out the ages and gender of the children in order to match gifts as best they could. This meant a lot of last minute shopping and they also bought extra for any children that had been admitted to the hospital on the day.
Personally, the charities that I give to regularly aren´t determined by my faith entirely, but by my personal life and family experiences.
Great - what a wonderful person you are!
But you, and the local muslim community are going against the Quran in doing so...
If you do (like Peacetrain) then you are going against the Quran.
Is this the whole point of your rants? Wait a minute . . .
I didn´t fall into the trap you think you laid. I needn´t have told you anything at all about what I do but I kinda like to wind you up. You get so hot under the collar and begin preaching from Qur´an. You´ll be advocating Sheriah in the UK next.
p.s. If you need more information on becoming a New Muslim I have a great selection of websites you can visit and ask all the questions you want.
the more you dig the more dirt you find despite all the efforts made by people like alameda to wrap islam in beautiful colours to sell it to ignorants
Quoting Daydreamer
Yeap I do, it means that they do not care what happens to non-Muslims - unlike people in secular countries who send help to those who need it, not only those who have the same lifestyle.
It´s a missed analogy - you don´t know all the Muslims and I´m sure they are those who you´d hate to meet. It´s a group of people sharing one belief, not blood. Plus, in a family you do not offer bribes so that other people joined in
Is this the whole point of your rants? Wait a minute . . .
I didn´t fall into the trap you think you laid. I needn´t have told you anything at all about what I do but I kinda like to wind you up. You get so hot under the collar and begin preaching from Qur´an. You´ll be advocating Sheriah in the UK next.
p.s. If you need more information on becoming a New Muslim I have a great selection of websites you can visit and ask all the questions you want.
Hot under the collar? I am laughing here You love to preach what a great religion you have but seems that even you have to bend the rules sometimes eh?
Sheriah in the UK? Again, you should listen to your UK muslim peers - it is their ultimate goal. I wonder if you chose the right religion
Quoting peacetrain
p.s. If you need more information on becoming a New Muslim I have a great selection of websites you can visit and ask all the questions you want.
Seems I know more about your religion than you sweetie - that is why I wont be joining you thanks for th invitation though (I know how you are desparate to save my soul )
Quoting peacetrain
You can say what you like and stamp your feet as much as you wish Aenigma. You aren´t my judge and your rants about Islam and Muslims are worthless.
Go and stir your pasta, it´s sticking to the pan again
I think the only foot stamping is coming from you
I am not your judge, but if you declare "I am a muslim" I wonder why you then declare that you bend your religion´s rules? Why should I be upset - it is very entertaining for us!
At least Alameda defends her religion - you just want to be all things to everyone!
Seems I know more about your religion than you sweetie -
sweetie . . . hmmm oft used here through gritted teeth .
As for my preaching. I´ve never done any preaching about my faith, not here, not anywhere. People can do and think what they like about religion and faith, it´s a personal thing.
Obviously my invitation to you was tongue in cheek.
I´m only going to comment on what I witness myself. In school, 50% of our children are Muslim, from India, Pakistan, Kenya, Iraq, Iran, Croatia and Serbia.
Yep, that just about sums the UK up! Wow! I wonder how Turkish nationalists would cope with such a mix in their schools!
Please save the crocodile tears. I did NOT say "they" do not care what happens to non-muslims.
The analogy was missed by you...but it still stands.
Groups tend to help other members of the group. This is the case with any group that identifies itself as a group. The criteria for membership to the group differs from group to group.
Actually bribes in families are common....if you are a nice girl/boy you can have a new car...and so on.
I haven´t shed a tear, why would I? It is not my problem that Muslims allow helping only Muslims but gladly accept help from infidels.
It may depend on the family but mine doesn´t bribe and I wouldn´t like it to. If it is your experience to pay people to get into your family then it´s your thing. I can´t imagine paying someone to marry into the family
I haven´t shed a tear, why would I? It is not my problem that Muslims allow helping only Muslims but gladly accept help from infidels.
It may depend on the family but mine doesn´t bribe and I wouldn´t like it to. If it is your experience to pay people to get into your family then it´s your thing. I can´t imagine paying someone to marry into the family
Very true. Lately I had a discussion about being a blood or organ donor and the Muslims in the group said they won´t give blood or be an organ donor because of the chance it will go to non-Muslims but when they need it themselves, they said they would be happy to accept!
Very true. Lately I had a discussion about being a blood or organ donor and the Muslims in the group said they won´t give blood or be an organ donor because of the chance it will go to non-Muslims but when they need it themselves, they said they would be happy to accept!
I haven´t shed a tear, why would I? It is not my problem that Muslims allow helping only Muslims but gladly accept help from infidels.
It may depend on the family but mine doesn´t bribe and I wouldn´t like it to. If it is your experience to pay people to get into your family then it´s your thing. I can´t imagine paying someone to marry into the family
Where have you gotten that Muslims only allow helping Muslims? I certainly did not say that. I did say that preference would be given to Muslims. There is a difference.
An example I can give is what I actually saw at the Frankfurt airport during the 911 disaster. I was one of the many thousands of passengers stranded there. Germans came to the airport to look for people to take home with them. One German woman offered to take a European woman home with her, but there was an Afghan Muslim woman who was pregnant also stranded who obviously could use a better accomodation than an airport chair. When the woman was asked to take the Afghan woman, she turned her back and looked for another Europan. What was that? I always wondered how that Afghan woman made out. I felt so sorry for her.
How did you get to paying someone to marry into the family? Boy you sure can twist things. Give and take is how things are done. You want this, I have this...you negeotiate.
Do you think during a airplane crash, Muslims are going to check to see who is the Muslim and who is not? How could anyone tell anyway? Wearing a turban does not tell what is in the heart.
Where have you gotten that Muslims only allow helping Muslims? I certainly did not say that. I did say that preference would be given to Muslims. There is a difference.
In the post by AE who quoted it from a Muslim site - it was stated clear there whom to help andunder what circumstances
How did you get to paying someone to marry into the family? Boy you sure can twist things. Give and take is how things are done. You want this, I have this...you negeotiate.
I was using your analogy - AE´s post said that it´s ok to give money to infidels if it may lead to recruiting them. You said bribes in families are common so why do you say I´m twisting things?
Do you think during a airplane crash, Muslims are going to check to see who is the Muslim and who is not? How could anyone tell anyway? Wearing a turban does not tell what is in the heart.
I never said people don´t help others regardless of colour/religion etc. Still, they do it in spite of what religion tells them to do, not because of it
I was using your analogy ........ You said bribes in families are common so why do you say I´m twisting things?
I think it would better be called your interpretation of my analogy.........at some point your new son is going to want something, or want to do something you will not want him to do. What are you going to do? Will you beat him (I´m sure you would not do that), reason with him, (hard to do with a child) or offer a more interesting desirable (bribe) alternative?
Have you ever heard of the concept of triage? Every culture uses a triage process based on whatever criteria deemed important. That´s the way it is. Life is full of difficult decisions that seem very cruel.
I sincerley hope I am never in a situation to have to make a decision that could impact on someone´s life. In reality, we do everyday. What do we purchase? How do we dispose of our waste? What do we do with our disposable income? All these decisions, and others, impact on the lives of countless others.
OK PT thinks I am happy with your answer - I was trying to be graceful.
Hmmm ok
Well, you have told me that your government send doctors and materials. I just wondered about aid from the people - "THEIR" people (to use your expression). Egypt is not a rich country you say, but everyone can spare a few pence or the price of a pack of cigarettes or some phone credit. Ok how about outside of your country. What about some of those rich Saudi oil barons? How many millions did they send? Is it true any money donated by them goes for publishing FREE qurans...
mmmm, AE, you werent watching the news at that time it seems !
People, Egyptian sent from their own money to aid people in Gaza.
We dont say we have sent this or that, we dont show off, we dont say they are our people then gave them our back !
Actually we dont have much to show off with, we sent materials mostly from our own poor personal income to help them
We donate through The Egyptian Red Crescent and that was from the first day of the war.
And many other social services through all the country and the Unions too
That was the people, not the government, and also the Doctors who went there, they went on their own, they have signed papers saying they are responsible on what will become to them there.
Ãt was war as you know, and Ãsrael was bombing hospitals, so the goverments didnt want to send them there, they sat at Rafah gate and they refused to leave except to Gaza.
And you are asking me if we donate price of a pack of cigarettes or some phone credit ??!!!
Outside ?!
Saudi Arabia donated 1000 million$ in Kuwait Economic Summit 21/1/2009, Quatar 250 Million, Kuwait another 250 million
That was only in that Summit .
Seems you werent following the news or else you wouldnt have asked about that.
Beside, killing someone then offering aid, i wouldnt call that help actually, making a statement is more like it
I was very interested to see the low levels of aid from muslim countries. During the tsunami, the reason for their lack of assistance was Islam - they do not want to donate money in case any part of it assists non-mulims (even non-muslim children), but I don´t understand what the problem is THIS time
Two examples of questions and answers on IslamOnline at the time, begger belief:
Name Mary -
Profession
Question It is permissible for us, as Muslims, to make du`aa’ for those human beings afflicted there even if those people include Muslims and non-Muslims?
Answer In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful.
All praise and thanks are due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon His Messenger.
Thank you.
There is no harm or prohibition to pray for those people who lost their lives in that natural disaster. However, your beloved Muslim brothers and sisters deserve more and more of prayers and du´aa’. They deserve your moral and financial assistances. You should share their sorrow and difficult time and do invoke Allah to accept them among the Shuhada’ or martyrs on the day of Judgment.
You can also read:
Du`aa’: Worship and Resort of the Helpless
Helping Disaster Victims (Special File)
Allah Almighty knows best.
Name Hakim -
Profession
Question Can we give those afflicted people a portion of our zakah money even if they are non-Muslims? How about giving them charity?
Answer In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful.
All praise and thanks are due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon His Messenger.
Thank you. The receivers of Zakah money are clearly mentioned in the Qur´an. Among them, the poor and needy people. Looking at the situation of those people who are afflicted, one can conclude that the Muslims among them fall under the category of needy people.
In this regard, those Muslims deserve to receive a portion of Zakah. As for non-Muslims, they might deserve donation or any other form of assistance but not Zakah.
Thus, Zakah should be given to poor and needy Muslims. Some non-Muslims may receive a portion of Zakah if there is hope that by giving them Zakah that might lead to their conversion into Islam. They would be then considered under the category of mu´allafati qulubuhun or those whose hearts are inclined to accept Islam.
The answer here is very much clear AE, even its in your post too.
As you see, they are talking about Zakah.
Zakah is one of the 5 concept of Ãslam, where Muslims are OBLÃGED to give part of their own money to the poor.
That part is set, determined with some calculations, and conditions too.
The people who receive Zakah are also categorised, not every muslim fit to receive Zakah.
But also only Muslims receive Zakah no one else.
As alameda said, i maybe responsible of supporting member of the family, but not responsible to support neighbour for example.
But that doesnt mean, i cant help neighbour from other money than Zakah.
Meaning, if this year i should be giving 500 $ as Zakah ´after calculations´, im OBLÃGED to give that sum this year and nota penny less, and also must be giving it through that year not a day after.
The people who would receive that money as i said have some conditions but first they MUST be muslims.
Ãf there is a crises, and i want to donate money to help people ´non muslims or muslims doesnt matter´ , i can do that of course with any sum of money i wish to help, BUT other than that 500$ Zakah
Ãn Ãslam that called Sadakah, and Sadakah doesnt have condition except helping people, any people.
The people in your post wanted to take from the Zakah money and help people not under the Zakah conditions, and want to consider it Zakah...it wont be Zakah, it will be Sadakah, and they can do it of course, but that also would mean they still have to pay their Zakah.
à hope i was clear in my explanation.
Ãts something like internal social system, made so muslims help one another in the society.
So we pay it according to its conditions, and if we want to pay sadakah, we also can do it and we will be rewarded for that too.
I´m only going to comment on what I witness myself. In school, 50% of our children are Muslim, from India, Pakistan, Kenya, Iraq, Iran, Croatia and Serbia.
Yep, that just about sums the UK up!
Please clarify. In what way does it sum up the UK?
Edited (3/9/2009) by peacetrain
[the quotes aren´t shown when I add a comment !!!!??????]
Edited (3/9/2009) by peacetrain Edited (3/9/2009) by peacetrain
The answer here is very much clear AE, even its in your post too.
As you see, they are talking about Zakah.
Zakah is one of the 5 concept of Ãslam, where Muslims are OBLÃGED to give part of their own money to the poor.
That part is set, determined with some calculations, and conditions too.
The people who receive Zakah are also categorised, not every muslim fit to receive Zakah.
But also only Muslims receive Zakah no one else.
As alameda said, i maybe responsible of supporting member of the family, but not responsible to support neighbour for example.
But that doesnt mean, i cant help neighbour from other money than Zakah.
Meaning, if this year i should be giving 500 $ as Zakah ´after calculations´, im OBLÃGED to give that sum this year and nota penny less, and also must be giving it through that year not a day after.
The people who would receive that money as i said have some conditions but first they MUST be muslims.
Ãf there is a crises, and i want to donate money to help people ´non muslims or muslims doesnt matter´ , i can do that of course with any sum of money i wish to help, BUT other than that 500$ Zakah
Ãn Ãslam that called Sadakah, and Sadakah doesnt have condition except helping people, any people.
The people in your post wanted to take from the Zakah money and help people not under the Zakah conditions, and want to consider it Zakah...it wont be Zakah, it will be Sadakah, and they can do it of course, but that also would mean they still have to pay their Zakah.
à hope i was clear in my explanation.
Ãts something like internal social system, made so muslims help one another in the society.
So we pay it according to its conditions, and if we want to pay sadakah, we also can do it and we will be rewarded for that too.
I am not your judge, but if you declare "I am a muslim" I wonder why you then declare that you bend your religion´s rules?
At least Alameda defends her religion - you just want to be all things to everyone!
I don´t believe I gave any example of rule bending. I gave you an example of how Muslims donate to the wider community, in my experience, which I suppose was my way of defending. But actually, I have no need to defend Islam to anyone, let alone you. You can tie yourself in knots, skimming websites for surface knowledge in order to try and score points but it doesn´t matter a jot. If you want to ridicule people for their beliefs, go ahead. It says more about you as a person than anything else you might want it to say. You have your belief or not as the case may be and you have your causes that you are interested in, not a problem.
Now I suppose you will reply with a negative tirade about Islam. You accuse people of preaching about Islam, when all they try to do is give you examples in reply to some of your posts. It´s not preaching. You are a more prolific preacher than anyone here (and I know how proud you are of that). I think it´s actually a waste of breath for anyone to try and discuss these issues with you, because, actually you´re not really interested. Your only aim is to ridicule. It´s also very difficult to discuss in depth here because of the nature of the medium. Direct conversation is always much more fluid than words on a screen. A great deal of meaning is easily lost and it´s also so time consuming. I know you know this too.
I will only ever make reference to personal experience here and I will not get involved in in depth discussions about Islam, for the reasons I have stated above. I have nothing to hide, if I had I wouldn´t declare my belief. You can try and analyse what I say as much as you like and you can print it here, but I really am not bothered what you think because you don´t matter to me.
Now I have spent too much time on you in the last few days. You made me break one of my own personal rules!!! Well I guess that will keep you happy and contented for a while at least
The answer here is very much clear AE, even its in your post too.
As you see, they are talking about Zakah.
Zakah is one of the 5 concept of Ãslam, where Muslims are OBLÃGED to give part of their own money to the poor.
That part is set, determined with some calculations, and conditions too.
The people who receive Zakah are also categorised, not every muslim fit to receive Zakah.
But also only Muslims receive Zakah no one else.
As alameda said, i maybe responsible of supporting member of the family, but not responsible to support neighbour for example.
But that doesnt mean, i cant help neighbour from other money than Zakah.
Meaning, if this year i should be giving 500 $ as Zakah ´after calculations´, im OBLÃGED to give that sum this year and nota penny less, and also must be giving it through that year not a day after.
The people who would receive that money as i said have some conditions but first they MUST be muslims.
Ãf there is a crises, and i want to donate money to help people ´non muslims or muslims doesnt matter´ , i can do that of course with any sum of money i wish to help, BUT other than that 500$ Zakah
Ãn Ãslam that called Sadakah, and Sadakah doesnt have condition except helping people, any people.
The people in your post wanted to take from the Zakah money and help people not under the Zakah conditions, and want to consider it Zakah...it wont be Zakah, it will be Sadakah, and they can do it of course, but that also would mean they still have to pay their Zakah.
à hope i was clear in my explanation.
Ãts something like internal social system, made so muslims help one another in the society.
So we pay it according to its conditions, and if we want to pay sadakah, we also can do it and we will be rewarded for that too.
Canli thank you for you very patient answer Actually (of course) what you say is almost completely right. May I just correct you on one point about your religion? You made the comment that only muslims are allowed to receive Zakah. In fact, you are allowed to give non-musilms Zakah in an emergency, where the matter is life or death. However, the culture remains "we don´t give money to non-muslims, only our Islam family", as Alameda was happy to declare!
Despite Peacetrain´s concerns that I am trying to attack Islam, I am actually not. I am just amazed at how little many muslims (even fervent converted ones!) know about their own religion! It is a shame that so many take on the antiquated practises of other cultures and think it is part of Islam. I can understand why men would want to keep the status quo, but I do wonder about the women! For example, ask any Professor of Islamic Studies what the meaning of obeying your husband is and they will reply that it is symbolic and not relevent to modern times. It is only of significance in prayer. However, ask many muslim men of its meaning, and you will get a completely different answer
Even dear Peacetrain had to wait until she received the comfort of your back-up before replying - mostly with just psychological assumptions about me Anyway she will need to calm down after all her huffing and puffing ...
I don´t believe I gave any example of rule bending. I gave you an example of how Muslims donate to the wider community, in my experience, which I suppose was my way of defending. But actually, I have no need to defend Islam to anyone, let alone you. You can tie yourself in knots, skimming websites for surface knowledge in order to try and score points but it doesn´t matter a jot. If you want to ridicule people for their beliefs, go ahead. It says more about you as a person than anything else you might want it to say. You have your belief or not as the case may be and you have your causes that you are interested in, not a problem.
Yes I ridicule people for their "beliefs" because you are all following distorted versions and have man made practises. No religion seems to agree within itself. You call yourselves "family" but all have varying degrees of understanding of the same religion - you mix antiquated cultural practises with religious ones, you cannot agree on any aspect in fact, until you are attacked and then you become a big "family"! Religion, and your interpretation of it, depends only on the mere fact of geographical location at birth with the few exceptions of "converted" ones like you.
Ask a simple question about a particular religion and you may get 100s of different replies. An intellectural will have a different answer to an uneducated one. A Saudi will have a different view to a Turk..... and so it goes.
How can you have faith, when you have no clear understanding or agreement? You can answer "but my faith is private and personal to me". It is not - it affects the whole world...
Despite Peacetrain´s concerns that I am trying to attack Islam, I am actually not. I am just amazed at how little many muslims (even fervent converted ones!) know about their own religion! It is a shame that so many take on the antiquated practises of other cultures and think it is part of Islam. I can understand why men would want to keep the status quo, but I do wonder about the women! For example, ask any Professor of Islamic Studies what the meaning of obeying your husband is and they will reply that it is symbolic and not relevent to modern times. It is only of significance in prayer. However, ask many muslim men of its meaning, and you will get a completely different answer
+ 10000 very true, and it is sad that the ones who know very little about their own religion have ruled Islam world
Canli thank you for you very patient answer Actually (of course) what you say is almost completely right. May I just correct you on one point about your religion? You made the comment that only muslims are allowed to receive Zakah. In fact, you are allowed to give non-musilms Zakah in an emergency, where the matter is life or death. However, the culture remains "we don´t give money to non-muslims, only our Islam family", as Alameda was happy to declare!
Despite Peacetrain´s concerns that I am trying to attack Islam, I am actually not. I am just amazed at how little many muslims (even fervent converted ones!) know about their own religion! It is a shame that so many take on the antiquated practises of other cultures and think it is part of Islam. I can understand why men would want to keep the status quo, but I do wonder about the women! For example, ask any Professor of Islamic Studies what the meaning of obeying your husband is and they will reply that it is symbolic and not relevent to modern times. It is only of significance in prayer. However, ask many muslim men of its meaning, and you will get a completely different answer
Even dear Peacetrain had to wait until she received the comfort of your back-up before replying - mostly with just psychological assumptions about me Anyway she will need to calm down after all her huffing and puffing ...
Yes I ridicule people for their "beliefs" because you are all following distorted versions and have man made practises. No religion seems to agree within itself. You call yourselves "family" but all have varying degrees of understanding of the same religion - you mix antiquated cultural practises with religious ones, you cannot agree on any aspect in fact, until you are attacked and then you become a big "family"! Religion, and your interpretation of it, depends only on the mere fact of geographical location at birth with the few exceptions of "converted" ones like you.
Ask a simple question about a particular religion and you may get 100s of different replies. An intellectural will have a different answer to an uneducated one. A Saudi will have a different view to a Turk..... and so it goes.
How can you have faith, when you have no clear understanding or agreement? You can answer "but my faith is private and personal to me". It is not - it affects the whole world...
Canli thank you for you very patient answer Actually (of course) what you say is almost completely right. May I just correct you on one point about your religion? You made the comment that only muslims are allowed to receive Zakah. In fact, you are allowed to give non-musilms Zakah in an emergency, where the matter is life or death. However, the culture remains "we don´t give money to non-muslims, only our Islam family", as Alameda was happy to declare!
Despite Peacetrain´s concerns that I am trying to attack Islam, I am actually not. I am just amazed at how little many muslims (even fervent converted ones!) know about their own religion! It is a shame that so many take on the antiquated practises of other cultures and think it is part of Islam. I can understand why men would want to keep the status quo, but I do wonder about the women! For example, ask any Professor of Islamic Studies what the meaning of obeying your husband is and they will reply that it is symbolic and not relevent to modern times. It is only of significance in prayer. However, ask many muslim men of its meaning, and you will get a completely different answer
Even dear Peacetrain had to wait until she received the comfort of your back-up before replying - mostly with just psychological assumptions about me Anyway she will need to calm down after all her huffing and puffing ...
You are quite knowledgable Aenigma...thus you must know that in order to be considered a Muslim one only has to utter the shehadah.
أشهد أن لا إله إلاَّ الله و أشهد أن محمد رسول الله
ašhadu al lā ilāha illa l-Lāh, wa ašhadu anna muammadar rasūlu l-Lāh
Of course this is to be sincerely from the heart. Everything springs from that. Some are highly educated, some are not. but at least all Muslims agree on that.
As to what I said, you have it wrong. "we don´t give money to non-muslims, only our Islam family", as Alameda was happy to declare!
Here is what I actually said:
"Of course Muslims prefer to help Muslims. Do you have a problem with that?
The analogy would be, helping one´s own family members first, not go to the family down the street."
I did not anywhere say charity is denied to others.
Hmmm so you don´t want to talk about this subject anymore?
Aenigma, I gave details of a personal experience of how Muslims at my school join in with charitable fundraising in my school, throughout the year. From there, you went on your own personal crusade and Canli clarified aspects of Zakat and Sadaqa as a response.
If you bemoan the fact that Muslims don´t do enough goodwill acts then I might post an example I have seen in the news (yes . . . there´s not enough reporting about them . . . it doesn´t sell newspapers) or I might give you a personal experience of mine. Anything further than that, I am not prepared to discuss and I don´t care about your view of me or your accusations about me because it doesn´t alter anything in my life.
Of course I´m huffing and puffing, it comes to us all here from time to time and I don´t mind admitting it.
So. . . no, I don´t wish to talk about the subject anymore and something tells me I´m an idiot for even replying to you now.
So, having established that I´m fed up with this and your pleased about it, perhaps we can let it die a death (once you´ve responded).
"Phew!" (I always wanted to say this)
Quote:The Aenigma
(PS Dont forget any lesson or meeting plans tomorrow will you? )
Canli thank you for you very patient answer Actually (of course) what you say is almost completely right. May I just correct you on one point about your religion? You made the comment that only muslims are allowed to receive Zakah. In fact, you are allowed to give non-musilms Zakah in an emergency, where the matter is life or death. However, the culture remains "we don´t give money to non-muslims, only our Islam family", as Alameda was happy to declare!
Despite Peacetrain´s concerns that I am trying to attack Islam, I am actually not. I am just amazed at how little many muslims (even fervent converted ones!) know about their own religion! It is a shame that so many take on the antiquated practises of other cultures and think it is part of Islam. I can understand why men would want to keep the status quo, but I do wonder about the women! For example, ask any Professor of Islamic Studies what the meaning of obeying your husband is and they will reply that it is symbolic and not relevent to modern times. It is only of significance in prayer. However, ask many muslim men of its meaning, and you will get a completely different answer
Even dear Peacetrain had to wait until she received the comfort of your back-up before replying - mostly with just psychological assumptions about me Anyway she will need to calm down after all her huffing and puffing ...
Actually, Zakah is a very sensitive issue to us, thats why you find people tend to the safer side.
You already can give Sadakah and will be rewarded by it too, so why putting yourself into doubts ?
That is how many of us think, unless in times when you want to give the money to spesific place or person, and your Zakah money is a large sum or something, so you start asking if i gave it to that place or that person will it be considered Zakah ?
à also would partly agree with you on that, they are not many muslims, but still they are sum, and at same time its something not special to muslims only, you would find it same with others too.
Ãn here Christians are same as muslims too in many cases although it has nothing to do with Christianity.
they are copies of mohammad. they love mohammad so much that they are acting exactly like him.
Well, i wish if they were !
For example, he was helping his wives at houseworks, he has confident in his wife and consulted/share her even war plans where he didnt share with his friends
He didnt take his wife´s money and her money belonged only to her
And so many examples actually.
When men read about them they say nooo, its a weak hadith not strong one, and they refuse to believe or i may say accept.
à remember when women were having some debat about houseworks and how its their duties as same as its men´s duty and not a favor, and after publishing the things about housework and Rasul SAV in Hawa´a magazine ´Ev´ an Ãmam woman said it and some Ãmams ´men´ assured it.
Men were against it and said its just going with the feminist wave that the country having it.
Ãf they help in housework, they are doing women a favor not actually doing something they should do !
So, nooo, they are NOT acting exactly like him..i wish they were !