General/Off-topic |
|
|
|
Cult of Virginity
|
20. |
14 Jul 2007 Sat 07:47 pm |
Dear Deli_Kizin
I agree most of your post. The quote you made is just seen as the words of Allah which lead extermists to this crooked system. It is nothing but lie about Allah, some so-called religious leaders always giving fatwa as they know better than Allah. People try to interpret Kuran through false beliefs/hadiths which totally contradicts with Kuran so it is seen there are many interpretations of Islam. It is not the fault of Islam but the fault of seyhs, cult/religious leaders. I think this is the biggest problem of today Islamic world, people who do not use their brain-intellect, hire their minds to their religious leaders and worship their leaders or prophet instead of God. Let me tell you an ironic reality of Salman Rushdie, you know there is also a fatwa given against Salman Rushdie, but the book he published “satanic verses†is not originated by Salman Rushdie(I think he named his book falsely, maybe satanic hadiths more suitable), it was taken from the stories of Tabari(923) and Ibn Sa’d(845) which seen big scholars in Islamic world(ironic huh?), it is also a tradition among christian missionaries and conservative christians to vilify the Islam through centuries and the phrase “satanic verses†firstly used by English missionary belligerent Sir William Muir(surprisingly he was also a sir ). So Salman Rushdie is maybe the last person to be blamed , muslims(especially extremists) should look at themselves firstly, how did they create this crooked system?.
|
|
21. |
14 Jul 2007 Sat 09:26 pm |
Quoting aenigma x: Thank you DK. Your post made me wonder on another subject. I don't speak for myself, but have to admit there is a degree of anti-muslim feeling in the UK which has been fuelled by the frequent reports of terrorist acts and murders here being carried out "in the name of Allah".
In my limited understanding of Islam, I believe it to be very anti-violence. I am curious as to how other muslims feel when they read reports of these acts being carried out in Allah's name?
I know what it is to have to watch violent acts I disagree with being carried out in the name of "England" in Iraq and other places, so my question is not intended to fuel an argument about whose culture is worse than whose!
|
Islam condems violance, scriptures are very clear about this issue. The problem is the man. Most of the muslim countries are poor, people are uneducated, easy to manipulate, especially if you can give them something to follow, an idea, a hope, hook them with something and they are yours ready to follow your own ideas in the name of anything ...
Even in scriptures, it is stated many times that being a muslim is not a free ticket to Paradise, moreover it is clearly stated that any creation with any religion or no religion, including jews, cristians, etc.. ; Who found the God in their hearts and souls and minds; who does good deeds, are welcomed to the kingdom of The God.
|
|
22. |
14 Jul 2007 Sat 09:43 pm |
Quoting armegon: Dear Deli_Kizin
I agree most of your post. The quote you made is just seen as the words of Allah which lead extermists to this crooked system. It is nothing but lie about Allah, some so-called religious leaders always giving fatwa as they know better than Allah. People try to interpret Kuran through false beliefs/hadiths which totally contradicts with Kuran so it is seen there are many interpretations of Islam. It is not the fault of Islam but the fault of seyhs, cult/religious leaders.
|
I want to add something ironic and very meaningful I guess
In Quran, even the The Prophet Muhammed (peace upon his soul) was warned by The God, because he was trying to explain things from the scripture. In a versus he was warned not to explain things because his duty is only to deliver the message not to explain it. And the God refers himself as the teacher of Quran, stating that every versus is explained in the book itself with a method that makes sure that the message itself is clear for anybody who wants to learn.
|
|
23. |
15 Jul 2007 Sun 02:03 am |
Quoting HomeSick: @armegon:
I agree most of the things written here But I need to underline one thing, The beginning of Islam was during Prophet Abraham's time, He was the first.
And also again ironically, Quran tells about sects and hadits in many suras, rejects them, and warn people about them.
|
I agree with you Homesick, i know Abraham called "haneef" in Kuran, i did not say anything contraversial to your comments. Read my comments again...
|
|
24. |
15 Jul 2007 Sun 02:21 am |
Quote:
I agree with you Homesick, i know Abraham called "haneef" in Kuran, i did not say anything contraversial to your comments. Read my comments again... |
Oh my bad, I misunderstood your comment, I am sorry. I should be spending more time reading comments than rushing myself into replying I guess
|
|
25. |
15 Jul 2007 Sun 05:16 am |
This has been a very interesting conversation thus far.
However, I'd like to comment regarding the cult of virginity that exists in various cultures, including Christian and Muslim.
First, it is just about impossible to determine one's virgin state if the proof is seen to be bleeding on the wedding night by the bride. There is a problem with this is that all virgins do not bleed.
Even if the lady does bleed, is it because she was a virgin, or did she have had plastic surgery to repair a hymen?
In other words, I think much too much attention is placed on purely physical attributes.
The very tragic result is lives are ruined based on faulty expectations and information.
It reminds me of a story about a man who went to some villages and taught people about fire. He taught them how to start, how to use fire and he then went on his way.
Some years later he visited the same villages and found in one village they had fire on an alter and the worshiped it. The next village their object of worship was the veneration of the "fire bringing god", the last village the people actually cooked their food, heated their homes with fire. They took great care in how they used the fire and were careful to put it out when they were finished.
This story reminds me of the cult of the virgin. What is a virgin?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgin
|
|
26. |
15 Jul 2007 Sun 07:13 am |
Quoting alameda: It reminds me of a story about a man who went to some villages and taught people about fire. He taught them how to start, how to use fire and he then went on his way.
Some years later he visited the same villages and found in one village they had fire on an alter and the worshiped it. The next village their object of worship was the veneration of the "fire bringing god", the last village the people actually cooked their food, heated their homes with fire. They took great care in how they used the fire and were careful to put it out when they were finished.
This story reminds me of the cult of the virgin. |
Thank you Alameda, I like the analogy of this story. Seems like some societies completely misunderstood what it is that they are trying to achieve. Even if their behavior destroys people's, but especially women's lives, it's so hard to change this mentality .
|
|
27. |
15 Jul 2007 Sun 07:15 am |
I love happy faces makes me kind of happy,too!
|
|
28. |
15 Jul 2007 Sun 07:16 am |
Quoting HomeSick: I love happy faces makes me kind of happy,too!
|
And what is your view on the cult of virginity?
|
|
29. |
15 Jul 2007 Sun 07:31 am |
Quoting catwoman: And what is your view on the cult of virginity? |
I know, I know.. You want me to put pressure on them
But seriously, I have no idea at all since virginity means nothing to me. I know the issue but cannot understand it ;How har I try, nothing, nothing at all, cannot understand.
You love a woman for millions of different reasons and yet make an issue from such a thing. Not healty , not normal , at least for me.
|
|
30. |
15 Jul 2007 Sun 07:36 am |
Quoting HomeSick: You love a woman for millions of different reasons and yet make an issue from such a thing. Not healty , not normal , at least for me. |
How wonderfully captured HomeSick!
|
|
|