General/Off-topic |
|
|
|
Racism in TC
|
1. |
01 Mar 2007 Thu 09:39 pm |
I want to make a comment about the racist abuse that frequently goes on in the chat room – always by the same 2 or 3 people who I could name but don't think I need to as I am sure most people know who they are. I think we non-Turks are quite aware of Turkish feelings toward the PKK (for which they have very good reasons) but does this give these people the right to verbally attack any Kurdish person who happens to venture onto the site? Quite obviously I don't have enough Turkish to follow everything that's said but the vitriolic nature of the comments is obvious - even to someone with a minimal grasp of the Turkish language – and many comments are made in English so leave us in no doubt as to what is going on.
I don’t know how many people witnessed last night's confrontation – as I did – from outside the chat room. This seemed to be more of a two-way 'discussion' than usual but soon got totally out of control until the intervention of two of the more obviously intelligent and certainly less belligerent members of TC calmed the situation down a bit. Politics and religion are supposedly no-go areas in TC and posts in the forums have been removed and members given warnings for this reason – so why are they deemed acceptable in the chat room? I think admin and the moderators need to keep a closer eye on what goes on in there.
We are supposed to have freedom of speech in the UK but if anyone was heard to verbally abuse a member of another ethnic group in this way they could face serious consequences. For many years the UK was under attack from the IRA and recently from Muslim extremist terrorists – however no right-thinking person is going to abuse every Irish or Muslim person they come across as a 'bomber' or 'terrorist'. Yet, seemingly, to some Turks, every member of the Kurdish race is seen as a terrorist or terrorist sympathizer although not all of them make their feelings quite so clear in quite such an unpleasant way. If you question this attitude the answer is usually 'You're not Turkish - you wouldn't understand'.
Well okay, I'm not and maybe I don't but if these people want a platform for racial abuse and harassment could they please find it somewhere else and not on this site which – in case they’ve forgotten - is supposed to be for people who want to improve their LANGUAGE skills and would maybe also like to enjoy a pleasant multi-national chat from time to time without feeling they are in the middle of a race war.
|
|
2. |
01 Mar 2007 Thu 09:53 pm |
Quoting lady in red: I want to make a comment about the racist abuse that frequently goes on in the chat room – always by the same 2 or 3 people who I could name but don't think I need to as I am sure most people know who they are. I think we non-Turks are quite aware of Turkish feelings toward the PKK (for which they have very good reasons) but does this give these people the right to verbally attack any Kurdish person who happens to venture onto the site? Quite obviously I don't have enough Turkish to follow everything that's said but the vitriolic nature of the comments is obvious - even to someone with a minimal grasp of the Turkish language – and many comments are made in English so leave us in no doubt as to what is going on.
I don’t know how many people witnessed last night's confrontation – as I did – from outside the chat room. This seemed to be more of a two-way 'discussion' than usual but soon got totally out of control until the intervention of two of the more obviously intelligent and certainly less belligerent members of TC calmed the situation down a bit. Politics and religion are supposedly no-go areas in TC and posts in the forums have been removed and members given warnings for this reason – so why are they deemed acceptable in the chat room? I think admin and the moderators need to keep a closer eye on what goes on in there.
We are supposed to have freedom of speech in the UK but if anyone was heard to verbally abuse a member of another ethnic group in this way they could face serious consequences. For many years the UK was under attack from the IRA and recently from Muslim extremist terrorists – however no right-thinking person is going to abuse every Irish or Muslim person they come across as a 'bomber' or 'terrorist'. Yet, seemingly, to some Turks, every member of the Kurdish race is seen as a terrorist or terrorist sympathizer although not all of them make their feelings quite so clear in quite such an unpleasant way. If you question this attitude the answer is usually 'You're not Turkish - you wouldn't understand'.
Well okay, I'm not and maybe I don't but if these people want a platform for racial abuse and harassment could they please find it somewhere else and not on this site which – in case they’ve forgotten - is supposed to be for people who want to improve their LANGUAGE skills and would maybe also like to enjoy a pleasant multi-national chat from time to time without feeling they are in the middle of a race war.
|
+1000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 Fortunately I missed last night's show but have unfortunately been witness to and target of racist attacks in the chatroom. It's lamentable that such narrow minded thinking still occurs in 2007 and even more so on this lovely site. However, it only highlights the ignorance of those individuals who claim to be so 'enlightened'.
|
|
3. |
01 Mar 2007 Thu 09:56 pm |
+ 100000 etc. Lady in Red, you said it so well!
|
|
4. |
01 Mar 2007 Thu 09:58 pm |
I was watching as well and I witnessed it!
|
|
5. |
01 Mar 2007 Thu 10:52 pm |
I couldn't agree with you more LIR! Nor could I have expressed it so well. I have witnessed many ugly conversations in the chat room too, not just racism but disgusting 'chat' about other TC members here too.
It needs close moderating...
|
|
6. |
01 Mar 2007 Thu 11:03 pm |
When you see such conversations in the chat room, please copy the conversation text in the chat room and send it to me in a private message or through the contact page.
Conversations in the chat room are not stored in the system, so I can't go back and look at past conversations. Please report to me any abuse of the chat room or the website in general. Racism will definitely not be tolerated.
|
|
7. |
01 Mar 2007 Thu 11:10 pm |
I also missed last nights racial argument but nevertheless I have seen my fair share and also been attacked too. All I can say is that I agree with LIR 100%!!!
Quite frankly it's rediculous!
Also when people talk in another languages other than English or Turkish please can they not be shouted at for it.
e.g.
"THIS IS A TURKISH WEBSITE LOOK ABOVE OR ARE YOU BLIND!?!"
Yes it is true, this is a Turkish website for learning Turkish or even Turks use it for learning English but there are other nationalities trying to learn these languages as well!
In chat there have been Spanish, Polish, Russians, Hungarians, English, Turkish, Arabs etc and they have all had conversation with others in their 1st language not just from the two nationalities (English and Turkish) and some people find it easier to learn another language whilst studying it in their own, not through another foreign language!
Dilara (I think) was helping Spanish people learn Turkish (had a forum on it) because it was easier for them to understand it and she got great thanks for it because it helped them a lot. So yes it may be a Turkish learning class but come on! people are learning it from different languages!
|
|
8. |
02 Mar 2007 Fri 01:45 am |
I too witnessed this argument- if you can call it that - it was more a slanging match, the people involved may find this amusing and entertaining but i certainly do not. It spoils the pleasure of using this site.
I agree completely with the comments made by LIR (well said). Get these idiots off this site, so it can be used and enjoyed by us normal people.
|
|
9. |
02 Mar 2007 Fri 01:48 am |
Congratulations, gilly! This is your first post! So, welcome to TC!
|
|
10. |
02 Mar 2007 Fri 02:02 pm |
Lady in red, my respect!
You said it so well!
|
|
11. |
02 Mar 2007 Fri 04:04 pm |
Quoting AllTooHuman: Congratulations, gilly! This is your first post! So, welcome to TC!
|
First post??? This cant be right..
|
|
12. |
02 Mar 2007 Fri 04:52 pm |
RESPECT
|
|
13. |
02 Mar 2007 Fri 05:42 pm |
then the 'victim' in all of this stated that he was and still does support the PKK group, thats when my pity waned drastically..
|
|
14. |
02 Mar 2007 Fri 06:09 pm |
Quoting robyn : then the 'victim' in all of this stated that he was and still does support the PKK group, thats when my pity waned drastically.. |
You can disagree, you can discuss, but having another opinion can NEVER be an excuse for racism!
|
|
15. |
02 Mar 2007 Fri 06:10 pm |
Quoting robyn : then the 'victim' in all of this stated that he was and still does support the PKK group, thats when my pity waned drastically.. |
So that makes it ok? He deserved it? While attitudes like this exist, so will groups like the PKK....
|
|
16. |
02 Mar 2007 Fri 06:13 pm |
no,as most people know here, okkes is kurdish.I personally could not give two hoots about the whole kurdish/turkish debate but when it comes to people supporting TERRORIST groups that have murdered innocent civilians, children etc i have no sympathy, think of it whatever you will because I could never condone someone supporting groups such as PKK, Al Qaeda, IRA etc etc.
|
|
17. |
02 Mar 2007 Fri 06:16 pm |
Quoting robyn : no,as most people know here, okkes is kurdish.I personally could not give two hoots about the whole kurdish/turkish debate but when it comes to people supporting TERRORIST groups that have murdered innocent civilians, children etc i have no sympathy, think of it whatever you will because I could never condone someone supporting groups such as PKK, Al Qaeda, IRA etc etc. |
Then you are as fundamentalist as them! Personally I would love the chance to talk to someone who supports such an extreme group and discuss their thoughts and feelings. Until people TALK and stop HATING these groups will flourish as more and more people continue to feel like outcasts in society.
|
|
19. |
02 Mar 2007 Fri 08:00 pm |
Quoting KeithL: Quoting AllTooHuman: Congratulations, gilly! This is your first post! So, welcome to TC!
|
First post??? This cant be right.. |
You read my mind exactly :-S
|
|
20. |
02 Mar 2007 Fri 09:45 pm |
Quoting robyn : then the 'victim' in all of this stated that he was and still does support the PKK group, thats when my pity waned drastically.. |
As I said robyn, I think the Turkish obviously have very good reasons for the way they feel towards the PKK and I wouldn't be defending someone who admitted to being PKK.
However, as this particular member was abused from the second he announced that he was Kurdish how do you know he didnt just think that attack was the best form of defence?
Also, you know I wasn't just referring to the conversation on Wednesday night but to the fact that this happens all the time against Kurds - and always started by the same Turkish racists.
|
|
21. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 10:05 am |
|
|
23. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 03:31 pm |
First, I must confess I did not witness the forum dicussion mentioned here, but after having read some exchanges of replies generated by certain topics, I must say that "understanding the other" is sometimes a problem here, raised by the lack of understanding of a simple thing: the main preocupation of those involved in a discussion should not lie in trying to change each other, radically and quickly; rather, it should lie in correctly interpreting the differences between us, standing up to these differences, and understanding them...
|
|
24. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 03:49 pm |
The difference is that the racist discussion took place in chat room NOT on the forum, juliacernat. When people post on the forum they put their name to their post and express their OPINION. I was not aware of any post recently where people were "trying to change each other, radically and quickly"??!?
|
|
25. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 04:11 pm |
my comment meant to be a call for understanding- or, at least for making an effort to understand each other-... and I think it could work both in the forum discussions and in the chat room
|
|
26. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 04:21 pm |
I think most people here do try to be understanding of cultural and religious differences. However, there will be some subjects which people feel very strongly about. Why should they have to tone down their opinion for the benefit of people who shy away from conflict? A difference of opinion does NOT have to mean disrespecting anothers views or attacking someone personally.
From my own personal stance, I always endeavour to start my posts with "I think" or "in my opinion" - I rarely claim my opinion to be 'fact'.
This is a discussion forum - are you suggesting we must not express our opinions or, must in some way make them less conflicting?
|
|
27. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 04:38 pm |
I was not trying to underestimate the difference of opinions or the expressing of ideas/feelings/thoughts, but I think an effort of understanding would help-in many cases-to avoid that an argumentative diffence of opinions turn into a clash of opinions.
|
|
29. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 04:51 pm |
Quoting lady in red: Quoting robyn : then the 'victim' in all of this stated that he was and still does support the PKK group, thats when my pity waned drastically.. |
As I said robyn, I think the Turkish obviously have very good reasons for the way they feel towards the PKK and I wouldn't be defending someone who admitted to being PKK.
However, as this particular member was abused from the second he announced that he was Kurdish how do you know he didnt just think that attack was the best form of defence?
Also, you know I wasn't just referring to the conversation on Wednesday night but to the fact that this happens all the time against Kurds - and always started by the same Turkish racists. |
Yes I am aware of the racism in chatroom by the same culprits Lady in Red, as I have been at the other end of receiving the racist nonsense from the very same members. I don't think he was saying he supported PKK just because they were being racist as he seemed to believe the PKK never killed civilians etc etc and said he would stop supporting them if he knew they had done such...
Anyway I just wanted to make the point that I am not racist and I don't like racism but for some people to suggest we should talk to terrorists is political correctness gone mad in my opinion.I'll say no more because we are not supposed to discuss politics here and sorry for digressing on your topic Lady in Red
|
|
30. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 04:57 pm |
Quoting robyn : but for some people to suggest we should talk to terrorists is political correctness gone mad in my opinion. |
Why is that so radical? Incidently I actually said "talk to people who SUPPORT terrorists", not the terrorists themselves, but now you come to mention it, why not? They are an invisible "enemy" and at the core is usually a power-hungry and affluent individual. They then recruit from the poor and discontented to increase their numbers. Suicide bombers, for example, are young vulnerable and easily influenced people who have been targeted and brain-washed into thinking they are doing "good". You hate them? I feel as sorry for them as the people they kill
For example Robyn, the numbers of young muslims who support extreme (terrorist) activities in the UK has increased drastically in the last year. Are you suggesting that we ignore them, hate them, kill them? Would it not be more productive to listen to them and try to work out the reasons why they are driven to support such extreme measures, why they hate us, why they are so unhappy with their lives?
Politically correct you say? NO! Just a peaceful solution to this increasing problem.
|
|
31. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 05:56 pm |
it seems like it's hard enough to agree on how to approach this problem... never mind solving it .
|
|
32. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 06:08 pm |
|
|
33. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 06:12 pm |
Quoting vineyards: Yeah, let's go to a pub altogether  |
vineyards, I really liked your previous post, brilliantly said
|
|
34. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 06:13 pm |
Quoting vineyards: Yeah, let's go to a pub altogether  |
Yes! The solution to all the world's evil. The more you drink, the less you start to care !!
PS Mine's a rum and coke please
|
|
35. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 06:17 pm |
|
|
36. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 06:20 pm |
Quoting vineyards: In addition to what I previously said, we must actually be talking about ethnic hatred which is of course quite different from racism. |
How?
|
|
37. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 06:21 pm |
Quoting aenigma x: Yes! The solution to all the world's evil. The more you drink, the less you start to care !!
PS Mine's a rum and coke please  |
Aenigma, we didn't agree on who will pay yet, not so quick dear . I also thought that we won't drink ourselves, we'll just get drunk those who argue with each other...
|
|
38. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 07:33 pm |
Quoting aenigma x: Quoting vineyards: In addition to what I previously said, we must actually be talking about ethnic hatred which is of course quite different from racism. |
How?  |
How for sure? I feel that ethinic hatred is maybe worse than so called racism, which often ends up with a genocide. I could quote a few but I am on my way to the pub!
|
|
39. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 09:05 pm |
Quoting libralady: Quoting aenigma x: Quoting vineyards: In addition to what I previously said, we must actually be talking about ethnic hatred which is of course quite different from racism. |
How?  |
How for sure? I feel that ethinic hatred is maybe worse than so called racism, which often ends up with a genocide. I could quote a few but I am on my way to the pub! |
I dont know why you distinguish between the too. Ethnic and racial hatred are BOTH racism surely?
|
|
40. |
03 Mar 2007 Sat 09:39 pm |
whether considered the same or not ...they are both equally abhorent
|
|
41. |
04 Mar 2007 Sun 12:45 am |
Quoting vineyards: In addition to what I previously said, we must actually be talking about ethnic hatred which is of course quite different from racism. |
I don't understand why everybody just jumped on vineyards because of this post, again without any explanation on why you don't agree with him. This is a very interesting question to think about - what is the difference between ethnic hatred and racism. Obviously these are different issues, but how exactly are they different is a very interesting question. Maybe some or most of the manifestations of these two problems are very similar, but they are still two different issues.
|
|
42. |
04 Mar 2007 Sun 01:13 am |
Quoting catwoman: I don't understand why everybody just jumped on vineyards because of this post, again without any explanation on why you don't agree with her. |
I think you misunderstood me, Catwoman. My question "why" was a genuine question. I am ignorant of the difference between ethnic and racial hatred.
I dont DO jumping!
|
|
43. |
04 Mar 2007 Sun 01:15 am |
Quoting aenigma x: I think you misunderstood me, Catwoman. My question "why" was a genuine question. I am ignorant of the difference between ethnic and racial hatred.
I dont DO jumping!  |
Please don't be offended Aenigma, it just came across to me this way.
|
|
44. |
04 Mar 2007 Sun 01:17 am |
Quoting catwoman: Quoting aenigma x: I think you misunderstood me, Catwoman. My question "why" was a genuine question. I am ignorant of the difference between ethnic and racial hatred.
I dont DO jumping!  |
Please don't be offended Aenigma, it just came across to me this way. |
No I am not offended - because my humour is generally sarcastic I can't complain that people always assume I am this way!!!
If you re-read both my posts without sarcasm you will see that they were genuine questions.
|
|
45. |
04 Mar 2007 Sun 01:23 am |
Ok, ok... there are now two genuine questionees of this interesting question. Thanks for clarification Aenigma .
|
|
46. |
04 Mar 2007 Sun 01:33 am |
and the same thing occurred tonight with a different kurdish person(without involving pkk) surprise surprise.
|
|
47. |
04 Mar 2007 Sun 01:40 am |
|
|
49. |
04 Mar 2007 Sun 01:51 am |
This is how was racism is considered in the U.S. Racism in the U.S. is considered to be a dislike/negative concept of one person based on their ethnicity, which in turn leads to a refusal or denial of opportunities to advancement-jobs/education, inability to live comfortably-violence/harassment/threat of bodily harm. Racism has to do with power to keep an individual or group of individuals from pursuing their hopes, dreams, aspiration and from aquiring or maintaining basic rights and priviledges that members in other ethnic groups enjoy. So while we use racism interchangeably wtih prejudice or even ethnic hatred...until prejudice or ethnic hatred becomes a systematic action it is not racism.
That is my understanding of racism based on readings and lectures from Prof. Pedro Noguera former U.C. Berkely faculty. I am sure that others have defined it differently. Too, common usage has rendered these terms as synonyms. And as in all languages, terms and their connotations change from speaker to speaker year after year!
|
|
50. |
04 Mar 2007 Sun 10:25 am |
Quoting robyn : and the same thing occurred tonight with a different kurdish person(without involving pkk) surprise surprise. |
I hope you reported it, as admin requested.
|
|
51. |
04 Mar 2007 Sun 03:37 pm |
Quoting aenigma x: Quoting libralady: Quoting aenigma x: Quoting vineyards: In addition to what I previously said, we must actually be talking about ethnic hatred which is of course quite different from racism. |
How?  |
How for sure? I feel that ethinic hatred is maybe worse than so called racism, which often ends up with a genocide. I could quote a few but I am on my way to the pub! |
I dont know why you distinguish between the too. Ethnic and racial hatred are BOTH racism surely?  |
I distinguish between the two only to point out that they share the same country, fellow country men! I don't see a difference, may be a poor use of words.
|
|
52. |
04 Mar 2007 Sun 03:45 pm |
|
|
53. |
04 Mar 2007 Sun 03:52 pm |
Quoting vineyards: They are different from one another to the extent of the difference between them. I am not implying one is innocent and the other brutal. My use may be wrong but is essentially centers around the notion that ethnic hatred is sparked by armed dispute and takes place violently. Whereas racism is almost perpetual.
I used the example of Americans hating the guts of japs as they called them,and attempting organized attacks on them and German Americans during the WWII to show that it does not last. |
It is strange that you used American examples while the most obvious ones to me would be the "cleansing" of the Jews during World War II and the bosnian muslims during the 1980s!
|
|
54. |
04 Mar 2007 Sun 04:57 pm |
|
|
55. |
04 Mar 2007 Sun 06:06 pm |
Quoting vineyards: You are right. I just picked one example. Maybe not the best example. |
There are plenty to choose from..... so dont think you made a mistake, you could have said the ethnic cleansing in Darfur, or Rwanda .............
|
|
|