Welcome
Login:   Pass:     Register - Forgot Password - Resend Activation

Turkish Class Forums / Turkey

Turkey

Add reply to this discussion
Moderators: libralady, sonunda
meeting in İzmir!!!
(53 Messages in 6 pages - View all)
1 2 3 [4] 5 6
30.       LCT
25 posts
 15 May 2007 Tue 09:07 am

Quoting mltm:

Quoting LCT:

Those rallies in İstanbul, Ankara, İzmir and Manisa with the concurrent rise in nationalism scare me more than anything the AKP say.



Sorry, but then you don't know anything about Turkey.
The nationalism of Atatürk is different than the nationalism that bases on fanaticsm, supremacy or racism.
I don't find it dangerous to be nationalistic in the way of Atatürk. It's the love for the republic, country and the people, and it bases on unity of all the people who loves their country.
The nationalistic mentality who killed Hrant Dink and the one that rallied in the last few weeks are not the same.
Globalism is not dangerous but nationalism is dangerous?? Globalism has become to serve some big countries over the other countries, it has become to serve the imperialism, what we lack with this government is not just the secularism but also the real kemalist nationalism. We don't want to make sacrifice from our nation's and country's values.
If those rallies scare somebodies, let them scare.



This also scares me.
I raise a concern about something and immediately someone condemns me.

"It is obvious that you know nothing about Turkey"
said MLTM

In your attempt to patronzie me you show your own ignorance.

1. How can you have any idea about my understanding of Turkey?
2.What gives you the right to think that your understanding of Turkey is any better or more correct than mine?

I merely raised a concern.

I said "concurrent" rise of nationalism.
I do see a distinction between different types of nationalism.

The nationalism of the oppressed and the nationalism of the opressor.

The problem with the nationalism that manifests itself on the rallies in question is that they are not opressed in that way and there is no clear separation between the nationalism on the rallies and any other nationalism

Back in the early 1920s when the republic was formed the need for a strong national identity in order to cement a bulwark against the threat of imperialism was very real and wholly justified. However this is no longer the early 1920s and those conditions have long since gone.

It seems to me that the doctrine of nationalism has remained like a stuck clock.

Those on the rally focus solely on the appariton of a threat to laicism.

Before you condemn me as some defender of the AKP.

Why are those people on the rallies not attacking the AKP on questions of poverty, education and the War in Iraq?

I'll tell you...

Because the majority of those behind it are from the lower and upper middle classes and therefore do not share those concerns. They have the same position on those issues as the AKP. They are relatively comfortable and can so afford to worry about the ghost of laicism. It is the only thing they can cling to, to use as a tool to voice their fears.

The problem is that the nationalism of those on the rally and the nationalism of others is not separate. It is rather a spectrum of opinions.

I'm against anything people do in the name of nationalism.
Because it undermines us human beings. It makes you different from me and then it's them and they are not us... etc..

They were saying on the rallies.. No left.. No right let's come together a third way....

That has a very scary precedence..

Yours concerned...

31.       catwoman
8933 posts
 15 May 2007 Tue 10:25 am

Quoting mltm:

Quoting LCT:

Those rallies in İstanbul, Ankara, İzmir and Manisa with the concurrent rise in nationalism scare me more than anything the AKP say.



Sorry, but then you don't know anything about Turkey.
The nationalism of Atatürk is different than the nationalism that bases on fanaticsm, supremacy or racism.
I don't find it dangerous to be nationalistic in the way of Atatürk. It's the love for the republic, country and the people, and it bases on unity of all the people who loves their country.
The nationalistic mentality who killed Hrant Dink and the one that rallied in the last few weeks are not the same.
Globalism is not dangerous but nationalism is dangerous?? Globalism has become to serve some big countries over the other countries, it has become to serve the imperialism, what we lack with this government is not just the secularism but also the real kemalist nationalism. We don't want to make sacrifice from our nation's and country's values.
If those rallies scare somebodies, let them scare.



Yes, I agree with mltm!!! She has a good point!

LCT, I would love to have a conversation with you, but I don't see the logic behind your ideas. You're just saying that you're scared... Well, of course, the world is a scary place. A lot of bad things can accidentally happen out of innocent events, but you gotta take the risk, or live life in fear. And why are you bringing up Iraq here? Is it another one of those lame reasons you're using to support AKP? Hell, you're so worried about some people not rallying about Iraq, but you fail to see the concerns people are actually rallying against... ? Interesting selectivity. And what is so nationalistic about people not wanting an islamist for a president (in the spirit of Ataturk's ideas, since he's the founder of the republic)? That is a very good sign actually! Means that people aren't blind followers, something other countries should learn from them.
I think what mltm said was right, Turkey doesn't have to be part of the global village and you probably don't know enough about Turkey if you're saying that rallys against Gul and Erdogan will cause hatred of "others".

32.       LCT
25 posts
 15 May 2007 Tue 11:02 am

What a suprize you say I don't know enough.

Have you ever stopped to think how that comes across.

Is someone’s opinion only relevant if they have some sort of certification.

I could say the same to you.

We can all play that game but it isn't very constructive.

I never said I was scared...

quote.. It scares me...
a scary precedence..

There is a difference, you know.

As for the war in Iraq… I could accuse you of selectivity.

You do seem to be more concerned with the “so-called” threat of the “Islamists” than global imperialism. Bush and Blair have been conducting a war of terror and are still continuing yet you dismiss this as “another one of those lame reasons…”

“for supporting the AKP”…you said

Did you not read where I said “Wait before you condemn me as some defender of the AKP”

I have clear views.

I’m against war and imperialism, exploitation and oppression.

I just see the threat of alliances with Fascists as very dangerous.

CHP alongside the Işci Partisi
Işci Partisi wıth the Atatürk DüşÃ¼ncü Derneği
Atatürk DüşÃ¼ncü Derneği with Kerincsiz
Etc….all the way to the MHP.

Perhaps we could focus on the real issues as I said previously instead of getting sidetracked down a dangerous alley.

33.       azade
1606 posts
 15 May 2007 Tue 11:30 am

catwoman I have had respect for you but when it comes to this issue you're jumping peoples throats and I see no reason for that. This discussion is very flammable.

I have nothing against rallies in general, in fact I think it's the populations right to rebel if their government goes too far, but in this case it hasn't. Perhaps you'd like to know that personally I'm not for, neither against AKP. I'm well aware that people accused of being islamist and against democracy, like Gül is indeed religious but that's his personal belief and there's absolutely nothing that indicates he wants Turkey to head in the direction of extreme countries like Iran. This government has done so much when it comes to building bridges towards the EU - how can people suddenly think the opposite? There's no real threat on democracy, other than the army, in Turkey right now. If AKP party was to overthrow democracy I'd be first in line to protest, but that's simply not the case. If people are generally unhappy with the government, then so be it, elections are coming up in a short time; so elect a different party.

You mention people's right to rebel in democracy, which you're of course right about, but when you're talking about elements of democracy that apply specifically to Turkey, it makes no sense because you (generally speaking, not you specifically) can't just hide behind the word "DEMOCRACY!" when it's convenient. It's not possible to compromise it. There's various versions of democracy - like representative, direct and whatever they're called, but there was never such thing as turkish democracy. Army intervention is never democratic. I highly doubt that it's in the general population's interest because what follows it is insecurity, unstability and a very unclear picture of the future. Surely it's better to get rid of the government in a democratic way and indeed AKP will step down when another party is elected.

This is a golden chance for Turkey to show that it's a mature, democratic country, and I hope for the sake of the future that the army will not intervene. In a short time Turkey will probably have a different government and inşallah things will be back to normal in our wonderful, secular country

34.       erdinc
2151 posts
 15 May 2007 Tue 12:24 pm

Here are some pictures from İzmir rally.
http://www.ntvmsnbc.com/modules/gallery/070512izmirmiting/

35.       MrX67
2540 posts
 15 May 2007 Tue 03:37 pm

some groups trying to show as if a danger about secularism in Turkey and that make political tension higher,and i beleieve that theresn't any danger or threat about secualrism,and pity this groups calling emself with to be democratical,but seems they don't know real meaning og democracy,how come a democrat can blame other one about their beliefs or life style???a bit more tolerance and a bit more respect thats all what we need..

36.       aslı
342 posts
 15 May 2007 Tue 09:13 pm

Lct you are against of everything ı guess. You dont want to learn Turkish grammer, but you do want to speak Turkish. You are not Turk but you do know better than us, what we like, what we are. Congratulations first! Second, since when loving your country, loving your flag, loving your nation and nation's best man "Atatürk" become shame? Me and the other Turks who attend those meetings are not ashamed any of these. Better get used to it.

37.       panta rei
0 posts
 15 May 2007 Tue 09:21 pm

Quoting aslı:

You are not Turk but you do know better than us, what we like, what we are.



Who said he is not Turk? He himself?

38.       femme_fatal
0 posts
 15 May 2007 Tue 11:32 pm

Quoting erdinc:

Here are some pictures from İzmir rally.
http://www.ntvmsnbc.com/modules/gallery/070512izmirmiting/


the pictures are wonderful! thrilling!

39.       aslı
342 posts
 15 May 2007 Tue 11:37 pm

Panta rei actually he/she did. But not in this topic. Stick around the site, you will find out

40.       armegon
1872 posts
 16 May 2007 Wed 12:21 am

Quoting erdinc:

Here are some pictures from İzmir rally.
http://www.ntvmsnbc.com/modules/gallery/070512izmirmiting/



Brilliant pictures!!! Thanks erdinc

(53 Messages in 6 pages - View all)
1 2 3 [4] 5 6
Add reply to this discussion




Turkish Dictionary
Turkish Chat
Open mini chat
New in Forums
Crossword Vocabulary Puzzles for Turkish L...
qdemir: You can view and solve several of the puzzles online at ...
Giriyor vs Geliyor.
lrnlang: Thank you for the ...
Local Ladies Ready to Play in Your City
nifrtity: ... - Discover Women Seeking No-Strings Attached Encounters in Your Ci...
Geçmekte vs. geçiyor?
Hoppi: ... and ... has almost the same meaning. They are both mean "i...
Intermediate (B1) to upper-intermediate (B...
qdemir: View at ...
Why yer gördüm but yeri geziyorum
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, makes perfect sense!
Random Pictures of Turkey
Most commented