Welcome
Login:   Pass:     Register - Forgot Password - Resend Activation

Turkish Class Forums / Turkish Politics

Turkish Politics

Add reply to this discussion
censorship by admins!
(124 Messages in 13 pages - View all)
1 2 3 4 5 [6] 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
50.       catwoman
8933 posts
 07 Apr 2008 Mon 04:22 pm

Vineyards... you have a point, definitely, but you only see one side of the story. What does America and its policy have to do with this? Does that make Turkish oppression and violent assimilation policies any more acceptable? :-S
You are talking about Turkish lives lost to terrorism, Azade mentioned the fear that they live with every day. Maybe THAT would explain why are turn to violence? Yes, Turkish lives lost because of terrorism is unacceptable, but Kurdish lives are equally important.

51.       vineyards
1954 posts
 07 Apr 2008 Mon 04:25 pm

I lived in Diyarbakir three months. I know certain things.

52.       azade
1606 posts
 07 Apr 2008 Mon 06:10 pm

From my experience/surroundings/people I know, most kurds want things to quiet down, they want to lead normal lives and not having to think about PKK, they want what most turks also want. But as catwoman many times have said in various threads, the unequality that they face every day and has seen for many years is making them not believe in 'Turkey'. When they are being treated unfairly, which is a very mild word to use, they start to chant 'biji serok Apo' and want to break free from Turkey because it's the only way they can let their feelings out. Who wants to be part of and contribute to a country in which they actually are unwanted?

There's two sides to the story, and I understand the horrors of what PKK has caused, but looking back in the mirror it is obvious that if there had never been an assimilation campaign, if the kurdish people had been allowed to live their lives, speak their language etctera etctera PKK would never have existed. It's simple logic. During all these years it has gotten very brutal, it is a vicious circle of violence caused by both parts. Right now I don't have an idea about what the solution could possibly be, I want to inform people about what is happening in south east Turkey because they have been brought up to believe that kurds are simply animals that hate turks and want to break free of Turkey ("steal turkish land") just because they can. Those people need to realize that there is a reason to the current situation and that everybody, both turks and kurds, need to kick in to promote information, understanding, and untimately peace. That's what everybody wants, but many understand that violence is the solution. That is wrong.

53.       Saskia1970
70 posts
 07 Apr 2008 Mon 06:35 pm

Am I the only poster here who is in favor of an independent Kurdistan? Or am I just the only poster who dares to say this out loud?

54.       Elisabeth
5732 posts
 07 Apr 2008 Mon 07:35 pm

Quoting Saskia1970:

Am I the only poster here who is in favor of an independent Kurdistan? Or am I just the only poster who dares to say this out loud?



Maybe it is a little of both. I feel a bit torn about it myself. I can understand that the Kurds want a homeland but I am a bit confused as to why they can't make a home within another country. I guess, as an American, it is a bit strange for me. I have strong Irish and Italian roots but I am very loyal to the US and wouldn't dream of a separate Irish or Italian state (even though there are millions of both populations within the US). Maybe its not the same thing but I don't feel like the answer is for Turkey to change their eastern border.

55.       azade
1606 posts
 07 Apr 2008 Mon 09:03 pm

I am in favor of a vote.

56.       alameda
3499 posts
 07 Apr 2008 Mon 09:36 pm

Quoting vineyards:

According to Washington Times PKK is directly linked with the murders of 40 thousand people which is 13 times more than the number of lives lost to terrorism.

Turkey offered political solution by way of declaring amnesty to terrorists who promised to give up their arms. The same article signed by Bruce Fein states that 80% of all the heroin illegaly marketed in France is smuggled into the country by the PKK.

There is actually nothing to get surprized about this. We remember Ms. Mitterand who declared herself the guardian angel of Kurds, aiding at legalizing the presence of terrorists in her country. When they found out that militants would actually want to use their country as a base for illegal drug trafficking among many other mafia type crimes, they began complaining of it.

Those 40 thousand people who lost their lives were the policemen, soldiers, teachers and doctors working in the region. I have spoken to hundreds of them in the last 20 years. They kept saying: 'These Kurds treat us as friends in the daytime and fire bullets at us at night.'

My own aunt told me they took cover under a couch when the terrorists opened fire in the general direction of their house on several occasions. Their windows would be broken and there were bullet holes everywhere on their walls with small kids petrified in the middle of these appalling incidents. She told me such attacks became a routine part of their lives and that several times, they survived those attacks by narrow escapes. My uncle-in-law lost his life when he was fighting PKK terrorists. He was asking the terrorists to surrender on the megaphoe when he was shot in the forehead.

We still have people among us who claim that Turks oppress Kurds. Just youtube to find out what American police does to stop smugglers infiltrating into their soil. If the people in Azade's town are all victims, who are killing all those 40 thousand people for God's sake. Who is sheltering them? Who is secretly supporting them? Only a kid would believe that all these are happening without the involvement of large groups of Kurds. There are on the other hand peaceful Kurds as well. As a matter of fact, we should single out those and refer separately to Kurds as an ethnic group. We really wanted to do this many times in the past. All those amnesties did not produce results. This opportunistic group would like to see Turkey become a second Iraq. We will not allow this. This is not nationalism, this is patriotism.

When September 11th incidents took place an enermous wave of nationalism spreaded all accross America. Everyone including myself condemned the terrorists then. Where is the difference now? Which Kurds killed all those people? what was the reason? Turkish government initiated the largest investment of its own history in GAP which is a multibillion dollar project. The purpose was to turn barren land in the region into arable agricultural area in order to improve the local economy. For many years, Eastern provinces have been given the status of primary investment area where tax immunities and incentives are offered for potential investors. All these have been done to offset the geographical disadvantage caused by the fact that East Turkey is essentially rugged highland terrain with altitudes ranging from 1200-2200 meters-a situating making economic investment in these regions too difficult because of transportation considerations. This is an economic reality which is not easy to deal with for a country with limited resources. Add to that the fact that on several occasions the existing investments are being destroyed by the PKK -a fact which discourages people thinking of investing in the region. Today, certain roads in the region are mined by the terrorist organization. The perpetrators always have food, shelter, weapons and money to be able to perform these terrorists acts.


The PKK has a political extension called DTP. DTP leaders call Turkish military stop bombing PKK camps. They refer to Abdullah Ocalan as their President. DTP Vice President has recently made a statement in which he said, they do not consider the PKK as a terrorist organization...

Azade;
What do you expect from us should we say thank you to Apo for terrorizing our country and costing the lives of 40 thousan people?

Should we grant autonomy to Kurds? Some of them even had claims that this autonomy must be extended to Western provinces where Kurds live in great numbers.

What political solution do you suggest? Or are you looking forward to an economical solution. Should we empty all our pockets and send all our money to East. Did you know that this country suffers from a huge budget deficit for years? Did you know that the government cannot collect money on the services they bring to the region. Tremendous amounts of energy is being stolen in East Turkey, oil and drug smuggling is rampant in the region. There are certainly people benefiting from the chaotic situation there. What do you expect from the government under the circumstances.

Do you think we are very happy with the attitude of the police. We observe that it is getting better gradually. Do we revolt against our country when we are subjected to brutality. We stay here and fight against it. We know that the exact same thing is happening elsewhere in the world too.





Excellent informative post vineyards. Thank you.

The problem with terrorism is that it causes suspicion and distrust among groups of people.

We see it in the USA on a much smaller scale with white people who are afraid and over react when they see young men of a darker color. It's called driving while black or brown. The incarceration rate for none whites is much higher as they are the first suspects.

Actually I wonder if the PKK is actually a Kurdish organization at all. They seem to cause more damage to the ethnic Kurds than anyone.

As I understand, everyone in Turkey is a Turk, whatever ethnicity they are. If someone in Turkey were to call themself a Kurd, doesn't that indicate they are a citizen (or aspire to) of someplace other than Turkey? I have met many many Turks, who only a long time later I find they are Laz, Kurds, Tatars, Cherkiz or whatever. First they are Turks.

In the US, one can be a Irish American, Afro American, German American, but to call oneself German would indicate being a citizen of another place, and also having primary loyalty to that place.

57.       catwoman
8933 posts
 07 Apr 2008 Mon 10:01 pm

Actually NO, alameda. "Turkish" person doesn't necessarily mean a citizen of Turkey. According to wikipedia, it's a person whose native language is Turkish (which would exclude Kurds) but also it may refer to the Turkic tribe that migrated from central Asia, in that sense it denotes ethnicity, which is separate from Kurds.
When Kurds call themselves Kurds that means that they want a separate country? hahahahahha, this is quite funny actually!

"Irish American" is simply a politically correct term, unless it's a second, third generation living in the US, a person will not call her/himself Irish-American, but simply Irish.

The problem with Kurds is that Turkey has been trying to suppress their identity, so Kurds are holding on to it even stronger. Nothing strange about it.

58.       KeithL
1455 posts
 07 Apr 2008 Mon 10:11 pm

Quoting alameda:


Actually I wonder if the PKK is actually a Kurdish organization at all. They seem to cause more damage to the ethnic Kurds than anyone.



This is so true!!!

59.       vineyards
1954 posts
 07 Apr 2008 Mon 10:11 pm

Come on Catwoman, you rely too much on Wikipedia. There aer international norms governing such matters. The word Turk denotes exactly what the word American does.

60.       vineyards
1954 posts
 07 Apr 2008 Mon 10:12 pm


Quoting KeithL:


Quoting KeithL:

Let me ask a simple question to both of you. Do you think Turkey should give up any of its land for an independent Kurdistan?




Isn't it interesting that these two "free-thinkers" are not brave enough to answer this question!!!



haha
you never ever understood turkish politics and no knowledge at all about our history and culture..
You are embarresing as a mod to Turks here..


Which Turks Thehandsom?
P.S. I forgot to quote as usual.

(124 Messages in 13 pages - View all)
1 2 3 4 5 [6] 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Add reply to this discussion




Turkish Dictionary
Turkish Chat
Open mini chat
New in Forums
Why yer gördüm but yeri geziyorum
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, makes perfect sense!
Etmeyi vs etmek
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much!
Görülmez vs görünmiyor
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, very well explained!
Içeri and içeriye
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much for the detailed ...
Present continous tense
HaydiDeer: Got it, thank you!
Hic vs herhangi, degil vs yok
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much!
Rize Artvin Airport Transfer - Rize Tours
rizetours: Dear Guest; In order to make your Black Sea trip more enjoyable, our c...
What does \"kabul ettiğini\" mean?
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much for the detailed ...
Kimse vs biri (anyone)
HaydiDeer: Thank you!
Random Pictures of Turkey
Most commented