General/Off-topic |
|
|
|
Columns Criticism thread :)
|
20. |
07 Jul 2009 Tue 09:01 pm |
That´s exactely what columnist do the majority of the time. They take a piece in the news and elaborate their opinions supported by actual events. I don´ t see how thehandsom is any different. It is up to thehandome to select his topics, not you or I. And it´s up to the reader whether or not they enjoy reading his columns. So far thehandsome has had more publicity than any other columnist, he would do well at the New York Times...
|
|
21. |
07 Jul 2009 Tue 09:22 pm |
That´s exactely what columnist do the majority of the time. They take a piece in the news and elaborate their opinions supported by actual events. I don´ t see how thehandsom is any different. It is up to thehandome to select his topics, not you or I. And it´s up to the reader whether or not they enjoy reading his columns. So far thehandsome has had more publicity than any other columnist, he would do well at the New York Times...
............and when they do they clearly state WHAT is their opinion and what is fact.....and that is not what theH has done. Of course he should select his topics......but he doesn´t have the stomach to take any criticism for what he says....IOW...some would call that "chicken".......
Yes, he would fit right up there with Judith Miller....ooops she´s not reporting for the New York Times now...seems her credibility has been squandered.
|
|
22. |
07 Jul 2009 Tue 09:31 pm |
Bet he is loving all this attention!!
|
|
23. |
07 Jul 2009 Tue 09:41 pm |
Bet he is loving all this attention!!
I´m sure he is
|
|
24. |
11 Jul 2009 Sat 11:14 pm |
you are very funny!
always trying to find a solution.
it would be better if he add a note under his column
like--> "comments are on forum"
|
|
25. |
11 Jul 2009 Sat 11:25 pm |
I am really disappointed I can´t comment under column but I think I can see theh point..subconsciously he exposes himself for criciticism and loves it..just a kind of masochism .otherwise he would not do that..ehh,theh grow up and accept things..the way they are..
|
|
26. |
12 Jul 2009 Sun 10:29 am |
I am really disappointed I can´t comment under column but I think I can see theh point..subconsciously he exposes himself for criciticism and loves it..just a kind of masochism .otherwise he would not do that..ehh,theh grow up and accept things..the way they are..
Agree, except I don´t agree with the subconsciously bit; more deliberate then he becomes the victim. Writing comment to TC members in the column?? ............ unprofessional. If you have something to say have the guts to say it in the public forum.
|
|
27. |
12 Jul 2009 Sun 01:12 pm |
what a cooperation
someone is writing a column on main page.
other one is opening comment page in forum instead of him
|
|
28. |
14 Jul 2009 Tue 03:43 pm |
Agree, except I don´t agree with the subconsciously bit; more deliberate then he becomes the victim. Writing comment to TC members in the column?? ............ unprofessional. If you have something to say have the guts to say it in the public forum.
Did we make a rule against it? It was a generalised comment mentioning no names (not that he needed to) - and who says that mentioning names in a ´column´ is ´unprofessional´ anyway? Professional newspaper columnists do it all the time - both directly and indirectly.
If there was a part of thehandsom´s latest column I would criticise it´s the joke - I´m afraid Turkish humour still eludes me! I think he should appoint lessluv sub-editor for the jokes
Edited (7/14/2009) by lady in red
[not a complaint - a criticism!]
|
|
29. |
14 Jul 2009 Tue 07:54 pm |
I always look forward to the thehandsomes columns..
|
|
30. |
14 Jul 2009 Tue 11:34 pm |
If there was a part of thehandsom´s latest column I would criticise it´s the joke - I´m afraid Turkish humour still eludes me! I think he should appoint lessluv sub-editor for the jokes
I didn´t like to admit I didn´t get it () I can only imagine that it was really funny at the time.....but got lost in translation.......
Fee for editing jovial writings........hmmm Priceless
|
|
|