Welcome
Login:   Pass:     Register - Forgot Password - Resend Activation

Turkish Class Forums / General/Off-topic

General/Off-topic

Add reply to this discussion
Healthcare?
(51 Messages in 6 pages - View all)
1 2 3 4 [5] 6
40.       alameda
3499 posts
 21 Aug 2009 Fri 07:47 pm

 

Quoting Daydreamer

I´ve never had any experience with the American Health Services but I´ve seen Moore´s Sicko and that made me happy I am not in that system. Since we´re discussing medical care in different countries, here are my two cents:

 

Poland - theoretically medical services are free. Everybody pays contribution to National Health Fund if they work (about 150pln=$5. This grants you free access to your GP and specialists, also free hospitalisation. Too bad specialists have contracts with the NHF for a limited number of procvedures. For instance, a dentist is contracted for 2,000 extractions a year. So, if he runs out of free extractions in April and you need to have it, you won´t be seen to. You need to look for a different dentist or pay. In practice it is only the GP that Poles go to using the public (free) system. Gyns, dentists etc are usually preferred to be seen privately. One of the reasons is that it takes you ages to have an appointment with a public specialist. Fortunately private fees are not very high, for example, a filling at the dentist´s is less than $40 (that´s why loads of Brits go to Poland to have their teeth done - the standards and services are high but the prices are low). There´s loads of bribery in hospitals, basically to make sure a relative of yours is taken proper care of, you need to give bribes to the personnel. Sad but true. Sueing a doc in Poland is hard as Medical Board consists of other doctors who hardly ever sentence one of theirs..

 

Ireland - you may have a private insurance (about €700/year/3 people family), or you may decide to be a private patient. A visit to a GP is about €50, a night in hospital in a public bed is about €60. There´s a law that says you cannot spend more than €100/month/family on medicine, everything over that sum is covered by Drugs Payment Scheme. Also, you can not spend more than €600/year for medical services like hospitalisation and all money above that is covered by the state. If you are a low-income family or are over 70 you get a medical card that entitles you to a free medical services.

 

 Sigh....sounds great!  The thing about bribery....doesn´t sound so great though.  The reality of the situation here is if you have to be in a care institution for any time, you really need an advocate (careing friend, family member or loved one) around.  That is someone to be there to see that you are getting good care. 

 

Nursing homes are the worst.  One does NOT want to go to one of those places without an advocate.  I have visited, and still visit a few people who have been in nursing homes recovering or finishing their lives.  The facilities are  horrors!  I´m not disparaging the workers, theydeserve much more than they get and should get medals for what they do, as they  are over worked and underpaid.   The enviornment is depressing, it´s not a healthy one either. It is hard just to visit them and not come out depressed.   They smell of urine and feces, someone is always screaming and you don´t know if they are having a psychotic episode or really in trouble.  One time I heard a woman screaming and screaming over and over again.  When left the person I was actually visiting to peek in her room, it turned out her bed was badly broken.  I was able to call and get help for her. 

 

You do not want to get sick or injured in the USA.  We need a better system.  From what I´ve read about Netherlands care, it´s really enviable.  We need some sort of Universal Healthcare...NOW!....actually yesterday...but now will do...We are the ONLY industrialized country without a universal health care system.

41.       Elisabeth
5732 posts
 21 Aug 2009 Fri 09:16 pm

I will agree and disagree with you alameda -

 

On getting sick or injured in the US - We do have some of the finest medical centers in the world in the US.  We have places like MD Anderson where people come from all over the world to get cancer treatments they can´t get anywhere else.  Some of our level one trauma centers set the standards for traumatic injury treatments that occur all over the world.  We are and always have been on the cutting edge of transplant surgery technology, so on and so forth.  YES, we do have a lot of things wrong but we DO have a lot of things right.  

 

On nursing homes - Nursing homes are horrendous places but not just the US.  Nursing homes have older and/or sicker patients whose families for whatever reason, can´t or won´t take care of their family members.  Many of them are bed ridden and incontinent.  They are always sad places because most people go there to die or they are recovering from a devasting illness or trauma.  Many of these patients are on Medicare/Medicaid (government run programs) which reimburse very poorly.  Nursing homes have very high overhead and can´t afford to give quality care because they don´t get very much money for doing what a lot of family members won´t do for their loved ones. 

 

Don´t misunderstand me alameda, I know we need to improve our system and there are many good aspects to the healthcare bill that is currently on the table....however, I have worked in healthcare long enough (and worked in VA and military hospitals) to know that OUR government is probably not the best suited choice to run healthcare.   The insurance industry needs to be reformed, pharmaceutical companies need to be reformed (government grants them 20 year monopoly on all new drugs!!), but I think our government is far too corrupt to take care of the people I love. 

 

I do hear you when you say people need help.  I agree.  People do need help.  My office is located in the Emergency Room of a downtown hospital.  I see the need everyday.  But I am concerned that many aspects of the bill are not meant to help these people but to pay lip service to those of us who are demanding change.

42.       alameda
3499 posts
 21 Aug 2009 Fri 10:15 pm

 

Quoting Elisabeth

I will agree and disagree with you alameda -

 

On getting sick or injured in the US - We do have some of the finest medical centers in the world in the US.  We have places like MD Anderson where people come from all over the world to get cancer treatments they can´t get anywhere else.  Some of our level one trauma centers set the standards for traumatic injury treatments that occur all over the world.  We are and always have been on the cutting edge of transplant surgery technology, so on and so forth.  YES, we do have a lot of things wrong but we DO have a lot of things right.  

 

On nursing homes - Nursing homes are horrendous places but not just the US.  Nursing homes have older and/or sicker patients whose families for whatever reason, can´t or won´t take care of their family members.  Many of them are bed ridden and incontinent.  They are always sad places because most people go there to die or they are recovering from a devasting illness or trauma.  Many of these patients are on Medicare/Medicaid (government run programs) which reimburse very poorly.  Nursing homes have very high overhead and can´t afford to give quality care because they don´t get very much money for doing what a lot of family members won´t do for their loved ones. 

 

Many of these people either do not have family that CAN help them, or they work and can not help.

 

Don´t misunderstand me alameda, I know we need to improve our system and there are many good aspects to the healthcare bill that is currently on the table....however, I have worked in healthcare long enough (and worked in VA and military hospitals) to know that OUR government is probably not the best suited choice to run healthcare.   The insurance industry needs to be reformed, pharmaceutical companies need to be reformed (government grants them 20 year monopoly on all new drugs!!), but I think our government is far too corrupt to take care of the people I love. 

 

I do hear you when you say people need help.  I agree.  People do need help.  My office is located in the Emergency Room of a downtown hospital.  I see the need everyday.  But I am concerned that many aspects of the bill are not meant to help these people but to pay lip service to those of us who are demanding change.

 

 You are right Elisabeth; we do have some of the best and most cutting edge research.  We also have some amazing facilities, it´s just that not everyone can afford them, or even know about them or are able to get into them.

 

As for trusting our government, we are our government.  If it´s corrupt and inefficient, whose fault is it? I have been involved in grass roots programs and have noticed our main fault is our pass the buck syndrome.  We always seem to want someone else to take care of the problems.  

 

Maybe another issue is that some have an unrealistic idea of just what to expect.  However, I do think basic preventative care, and maintenance should be available to all.  By the time things get to the emergency level, a lot of productive time has been wasted, and what perhaps could have been a relatively inexpensive problem becomes very expensive.

I think we are drug crazy. We want symptomatic relief...and NOW....we don´t like to feel any pain.  Sometimes a little pain is good, it tells you where the problem is, you know? 

 

 I don´t think the private insurance industry would do any better at the job of keeping us healthy, and....they have the incentive of making money in the mix. 

 

The sicker we are...the more profits they can make.  This I have experienced first hand.  Give you this, that causes that, for which we can give you this...and on and on and on.....were as if they hadn´t given "thisnthat" in the first place none of the rest would have been necessary.  

43.       Elisabeth
5732 posts
 21 Aug 2009 Fri 10:23 pm

I am not sure what the percentage is, alameda, but as I am sure you know, only a very small percentage of Americans participate in our government.  Perhaps if more people where involved, we wouldn´t be in this mess. 

 

As for whether to put my health in the hands of the insurance companies or the government....tough call!  Government is big and will look to save money....insurance companies are smaller but look to make money!  The fact of the matter is, people need to be more concerned about government and their health and less concerned about the latest celebrity gossip (just my opinion!)

44.       alameda
3499 posts
 21 Aug 2009 Fri 11:01 pm

 

Quoting Elisabeth

I am not sure what the percentage is, alameda, but as I am sure you know, only a very small percentage of Americans participate in our government.  Perhaps if more people where involved, we wouldn´t be in this mess. 

 

As for whether to put my health in the hands of the insurance companies or the government....tough call!  Government is big and will look to save money....insurance companies are smaller but look to make money!  The fact of the matter is, people need to be more concerned about government and their health and less concerned about the latest celebrity gossip (just my opinion!)

 

 Perhaps if we had more education on healthy living it would help....things like eating healthy food, healthy life styles.  Things like food combinations, what´s in the food we eat.

 

You know, if I could, I´d make visiting nursing homes mandatory for everyone, but in particular young people.....so they can see what can happen.  Maybe having students do some simple tasks for credit could reduce the load?....but of course you get into labor laws....and all that...arghHead bang

 

As for the celebrity gossip.....I agree with you on that....however maybe seeing the results of some of the bad decisions those celebrities make could teach a lesson?  Anna Nicole Smith was a tragic story, Britney is another.  Sadly, it´s only the glamour that is focused on......and the recent story of Jasmin Fiore.....glamorous model suspected of being murdered by her reality show Megan Wants  a Millionaire contestent husband Ryan Jenkins.....

 

All that glitters is not gold....and maybe gold really is not that desirable anyway?



Edited (8/21/2009) by alameda [spell]

45.       alameda
3499 posts
 26 Aug 2009 Wed 10:21 pm

May  Senator Edward Kennedy rest in peace....

he understood the lesson from his parents.........

"much is expected of those to whom much has been given"

 

"This is the cause of my life. It is a key reason that I defied my illness last summer to speak at the Democratic convention in Denver—to support Barack Obama, but also to make sure, as I said, "that we will break the old gridlock and guarantee that every American...will have decent, quality health care as a fundamental right and not just a privilege." For four decades I have carried this cause—from the floor of the United States Senate to every part of this country. It has never been merely a question of policy; it goes to the heart of my belief in a just society. Now the issue has more meaning for me—and more urgency—than ever before. But it´s always been deeply personal, because the importance of health care has been a recurrent lesson throughout most of my 77 years. "

— Ted Kennedy

 

Ted Kennedy on Health Care

 

Thank you Ted....



Edited (8/26/2009) by alameda [add]

46.       catwoman
8933 posts
 26 Aug 2009 Wed 10:58 pm

This isn´t reform, it´s robbery!!

 

Capitalists, as my friend Father Michael Doyle says, should never be allowed near a health care system. They hold sick children hostage as they force parents to bankrupt themselves in the desperate scramble to pay for medical care. The sick do not have a choice. Medical care is not a consumable good. We can choose to buy a used car or a new car, shop at a boutique or a thrift store, but there is no choice between illness and health. And any debate about health care must acknowledge that the for-profit health care industry is the problem and must be destroyed. This is an industry that hires doctors and analysts to deny care to patients in order to increase profits. It is an industry that causes half of all bankruptcies. And the 20,000 Americans who died last year because they did not receive adequate care condemn these corporations as complicit in murder.

The current health care debate in Congress has nothing to do with death panels or public options or socialized medicine. The real debate, the only one that counts, is how much money our blood-sucking insurance, pharmaceutical and for-profit health services are going to be able to siphon off from new health care legislation. The proposed plans rattling around Congress all ensure that the profits for these corporations will increase and the misery for ordinary Americans will be compounded. The corporate state, enabled by both Democrats and Republicans, is yet again cannibalizing the Treasury. It is yet again pushing Americans, especially the poor and the working class, into levels of despair and rage that will continue to fuel the violent, proto-fascist movements leaping up around the edges of American society. And the traditional watchdogs—those in public office, the press and citizens groups—are as useless as the perfumed fops of another era who busied their days with court intrigue at Versailles. Canada never looked so good.

(...)

 

 

read more: This isn´t reform, it´s robbery!

47.       vineyards
1954 posts
 27 Aug 2009 Thu 03:19 am

The private hospitals in Turkey are generally well-built and well organized facilities usually designed for the needs of richer people or those with private healthcare coverage. Despite I have a right to use some of the more expensive ones, I opt for a modest hospital on account that they work like a geniune healthcare instution and not like a money trap unlike most others.  

 

Some time ago, I visited a fashionable hospitable which had just been acquired by a Jewish investment group. Since I had known the hospital which is notorious for its high prices, I had astounded at witnessing the numerous cost saving measures that involved things like poorer quality water being served to patients. They were acting as if they were trying to avoid an imminent bankruptcy. When it came to prices however, they were a couple of times more expensive than the average healthcare facility. The same hospital was in the headlines several times when they did nothing other than watching when say a pizza delivery guy was hit by a car just in front of them.

 

State hospitals are usually overcrowded. There is an appointment system in place. Say, your child has a hard to fix problem in his jaw, you have to plan forward and apply for an appointment when he is five-six years  old so that he can have an appointment when he becomes operable at the age of 9 or 10.

 

The national healthcare system in Turkey has been being abused by almost everyone involved in it. Remarkably, there are patients whose conditions would hardly justify coming to a hospital or medication. There are never ending lines of people waiting to benefit from a highly inefficient healthcare system.

Quoting catwoman

This isn´t reform, it´s robbery!!

 

Capitalists, as my friend Father Michael Doyle says, should never be allowed near a health care system. They hold sick children hostage as they force parents to bankrupt themselves in the desperate scramble to pay for medical care. The sick do not have a choice. Medical care is not a consumable good. We can choose to buy a used car or a new car, shop at a boutique or a thrift store, but there is no choice between illness and health. And any debate about health care must acknowledge that the for-profit health care industry is the problem and must be destroyed. This is an industry that hires doctors and analysts to deny care to patients in order to increase profits. It is an industry that causes half of all bankruptcies. And the 20,000 Americans who died last year because they did not receive adequate care condemn these corporations as complicit in murder.

The current health care debate in Congress has nothing to do with death panels or public options or socialized medicine. The real debate, the only one that counts, is how much money our blood-sucking insurance, pharmaceutical and for-profit health services are going to be able to siphon off from new health care legislation. The proposed plans rattling around Congress all ensure that the profits for these corporations will increase and the misery for ordinary Americans will be compounded. The corporate state, enabled by both Democrats and Republicans, is yet again cannibalizing the Treasury. It is yet again pushing Americans, especially the poor and the working class, into levels of despair and rage that will continue to fuel the violent, proto-fascist movements leaping up around the edges of American society. And the traditional watchdogs—those in public office, the press and citizens groups—are as useless as the perfumed fops of another era who busied their days with court intrigue at Versailles. Canada never looked so good.

(...)

 

 

read more: This isn´t reform, it´s robbery!

 

 



Edited (8/27/2009) by vineyards

48.       Elisabeth
5732 posts
 27 Aug 2009 Thu 10:08 pm

 

Quoting catwoman

 Canada never looked so good.

 

 

 

read more: This isn´t reform, it´s robbery!

 

 Things aren´t so perfect in Canada either.  What we need is a balanced system...something better than anything that is in place anywhere else in the world.  I hope that we can learn from other countries.  After our town hall meeting on Tuesday with our congresswoman, I get a little better feeling that our congress is at least LISTENING to physicians and hospitals about how to solve some of the issues. 

http://liveshots.blogs.foxnews.com/2009/08/26/u-s-hospitals-save-canadians-lives/

49.       vineyards
1954 posts
 28 Aug 2009 Fri 11:24 pm

 You are lucky then. In Turkey, politicians generally just listen to their local organizations in each town where they get the information about which doctor supports which party. Head doctors and administrators supporting other parties are immediately passivized, appointed to a hospital in a remote part of the country, forced to resign or ask for retirement. Those supporting their party on the other hand is usually given a quick promotion regardless of their merit or experience.

 

This unfortunately does not only apply to the healthcare system only. Upon rising to power, they usually spend the first year for undoing the favours done by the previous government to their own supporters. Once they are done with them, the new guys begin to ride the gravy train.

 

If it weren´t for these corrupt people, Turkey could have long been a wealthier and a much  more stable country.

Quoting Elisabeth

 

 

 Things aren´t so perfect in Canada either.  What we need is a balanced system...something better than anything that is in place anywhere else in the world.  I hope that we can learn from other countries.  After our town hall meeting on Tuesday with our congresswoman, I get a little better feeling that our congress is at least LISTENING to physicians and hospitals about how to solve some of the issues. 

http://liveshots.blogs.foxnews.com/2009/08/26/u-s-hospitals-save-canadians-lives/

 

 

50.       alameda
3499 posts
 29 Aug 2009 Sat 12:46 am

 The link doesn´t work.

 

 

 

(51 Messages in 6 pages - View all)
1 2 3 4 [5] 6
Add reply to this discussion




Turkish Dictionary
Turkish Chat
Open mini chat
New in Forums
Why yer gördüm but yeri geziyorum
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, makes perfect sense!
Etmeyi vs etmek
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much!
Görülmez vs görünmiyor
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, very well explained!
Içeri and içeriye
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much for the detailed ...
Present continous tense
HaydiDeer: Got it, thank you!
Hic vs herhangi, degil vs yok
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much!
Rize Artvin Airport Transfer - Rize Tours
rizetours: Dear Guest; In order to make your Black Sea trip more enjoyable, our c...
What does \"kabul ettiğini\" mean?
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much for the detailed ...
Kimse vs biri (anyone)
HaydiDeer: Thank you!
Random Pictures of Turkey
Most liked
Major Vowel Harmony

Turkish lesson by admin
Level: beginner