Welcome
Login:   Pass:     Register - Forgot Password - Resend Activation

Turkish Class Forums / Turkish Politics

Turkish Politics

Add reply to this discussion
Erdogan at Davos
(37 Messages in 4 pages - View all)
1 [2] 3 4
10.       CANLI
5084 posts
 31 Jan 2009 Sat 03:44 am

 

Quoting armegon

I have to confess i liked his attitude especially when he said to Peres "you know very well how to kill people" while he was looking at into Peres´s eyes. But then i remembered our PM´s hypocracy which made me dubious about his attitude. I know he wasnt sincere looking at his past. I wonder where he was while people were being killed in Iraq or while our citizens were being killed by terrorists. Btw AKP just rejected the proposal of comdemning Israel in parliament. Only this one is enough about his sincerety. Lets see if he is able to cancel military agreements with Israel. As far as i know Israeli pilots who were bombing Gaza are being trained in Turkey/Konya.

 

Then his reaction to Peres comes while Turkey is on the eve of elections which was a good show to impress sheeps and it seems its working. Another aspect of this reaction, he also tried to affect Arabs, maybe he wants to be the new slave khalif. With his idiomatic expression "bir taþla beþ kuþ" ...

 

So people wants to see some actions then a show of rowdiness maybe ...

 

Ýt is understandable that countries care more for their own interests first.

Sometimes by doing stupid things and sometimes by doing good things that get credit from many sides.

And i guess that is what Erdoðan did, and he has gained and still gaining credit from many sides, and on the top of that list is his own people !

Then comes the people of the countries around him .

He is winning people´s hearts ..

Yes, he wants to impress the Arabs today to use them tomorrow, and they wont mind it, on the contrary they will encourage him too...he already won their hearts !

 

Let me tell you...you have one a hell of a smart -strong too- man back there !

 

11.       femmeous
2642 posts
 31 Jan 2009 Sat 09:27 pm

 

Quoting Melek74

Why do we need to have 4 threads about this topic?

 

 if you listen to canli, we need 40 of them. not just for 4.

 

but when someone starts a thread on christmas she comes out with a warning that there was already an existing thread.

 

logiscs dont work on this site. welcome to canli´s regime a la egypt.

12.       CANLI
5084 posts
 31 Jan 2009 Sat 09:37 pm

The question would be, what would you expect to happen in the near future.

Ý mean the most powerful country in the world doesnt dare to annoye israel or even condemn it for anything even when its hands full of blood

But Erdoðan did it....!

And i dont think israel will let it go that smoothly as Perese call Erdoðan and peace !

So what would you think about it ?

Other than pushing the whole world to recognize the Armenian claim of course as a punishment for so daring Türkiye!

13.       thehandsom
7403 posts
 31 Jan 2009 Sat 10:17 pm

 

Quoting CANLI

Ýt is understandable that countries care more for their own interests first.

Sometimes by doing stupid things and sometimes by doing good things that get credit from many sides.

And i guess that is what Erdoðan did, and he has gained and still gaining credit from many sides, and on the top of that list is his own people !

Then comes the people of the countries around him .

He is winning people´s hearts ..

Yes, he wants to impress the Arabs today to use them tomorrow, and they wont mind it, on the contrary they will encourage him too...he already won their hearts !

 

Let me tell you...you have one a hell of a smart -strong too- man back there !

 

He might be winning people´s hearts but I am still doubtful about the real out come of his action in Davos..

I think some people think the same :

....

By abandoning the meeting and showing such an aggressive reaction, Erdogan put himself and his country in a risky position. 

 

Even though there was no need for it, he all of a sudden changed the Arab-Israeli fight into a Turkish-Israeli fight. In a international political arena he changed the issue into a street brawl. 

 

... If the prime minister insistently continues this approach, and does not choose to soften the incidence, then important changes might occur. 

 

For example: 

 

-Turkey will be progressively identified with the Hamas-Iran-Syria triangle. It will be interpreted as a slowly drifting away from Israel-United States- European Union-Egypt-Saudi Arabia camp. It will become impossible for Turkey to take on an impartial attitude in the region and play a moderating role. 

 

-Even if relations with Israel are not ceased, the color will start to change from now on and turn toward dislike. If not balanced immediately, relations between Israel and Turkey will not recover easily. The reflections will be seen in Washington and on the money markets. 

 

-Eyes will be on the Justice and Development Party, or AKP, from now on and the impression spread that Erdogan wants to carry Turkey in a different direction. Erdogan may receive applause and gain votes for this incident but he has taken on risk on an international platform. 

 

The prime minister does not see clearly when he becomes angry. 

 

Maybe he has done it on purpose. 

Maybe he has invested in elections

Maybe he was overrun by feelings.

 

http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/english/opinion/10895034.asp?yazarid=298&gid=260

14.       femmeous
2642 posts
 31 Jan 2009 Sat 10:52 pm

 

 

 an excellent analyses.

but one thing i disagree with is that i think that turkey and its foreign policy will not bear any consequences as many will consider it as a stupid emotional scene. i think even peres will let it go since israel doesnt want to lose a market such as turkey. most world politicians will ignore it for sure as a faux pais. nothing to worry.

 

as for arab world, this is too little to satisfy them, they will never forgive turkey the betrayal - "secularism". so this applause is just a minute success.

 

15.       CANLI
5084 posts
 01 Feb 2009 Sun 02:03 am

 

Quoting thehandsom

He might be winning people´s hearts but I am still doubtful about the real out come of his action in Davos..

I think some people think the same :

....

By abandoning the meeting and showing such an aggressive reaction, Erdogan put himself and his country in a risky position. 

 

Even though there was no need for it, he all of a sudden changed the Arab-Israeli fight into a Turkish-Israeli fight. In a international political arena he changed the issue into a street brawl. 

 

... If the prime minister insistently continues this approach, and does not choose to soften the incidence, then important changes might occur. 

 

For example: 

 

-Turkey will be progressively identified with the Hamas-Iran-Syria triangle. It will be interpreted as a slowly drifting away from Israel-United States- European Union-Egypt-Saudi Arabia camp. It will become impossible for Turkey to take on an impartial attitude in the region and play a moderating role. 

 

-Even if relations with Israel are not ceased, the color will start to change from now on and turn toward dislike. If not balanced immediately, relations between Israel and Turkey will not recover easily. The reflections will be seen in Washington and on the money markets. 

 

-Eyes will be on the Justice and Development Party, or AKP, from now on and the impression spread that Erdogan wants to carry Turkey in a different direction. Erdogan may receive applause and gain votes for this incident but he has taken on risk on an international platform. 

 

The prime minister does not see clearly when he becomes angry. 

 

Maybe he has done it on purpose. 

Maybe he has invested in elections

Maybe he was overrun by feelings.

 

http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/english/opinion/10895034.asp?yazarid=298&gid=260

 

 Actually no, i dont think so

And i dont agree that would be the case

Ý believe he tries to play another rule in the area, and that is what its all about

He doesnt seek to be part of any camp, he wants to make his own camp, actually not a camp...

He wants to play the big brother thing.

He wants to have all the ropes in his hands .

He wants to have a good relation with everyone, and also win the platform of the Arab public.

And he also wants to make sure that the dont mistake him ´Türkiye´ with any of the others capms around

Thats why he made/is making things none of the already existing camps did.

 

Ýf we calculate his benefits.

 

1. His own people...needless to say everone of them felt that he spoke by his/her tongue.

2. Arabs and people of the area ´not governments´ they are empressed, proud...and you can add as many as you wish to describe it

Some calling him the Osmanlý aslan !

Ottoman lion !

3.Ýn the EU and USA level, they will actually get the message, that being allay doesnt mean TOTALY obay you !

4.For israel, the relation will get affected but not in a way to take a clear or a direct action, because israel needs Türkiye too

BUT....they are waiting for the right moment and wish Erdoðan has more than he already show that will keep the equation in his favore

5.Being a country that the ME listen to it will put Türkiye in another place more stronger than she already is .

6.Economical effect...he got himself a good and big market ´Arabs´

Some already said they will buy the Turkish products

As boycott effecting some countries, supporting will effect others

7. His big challenge are the government of the ME...if he can manage them as well as the people, he could move as he planed

 

Türkiye and Egypt almost have same points of view but with some difference in methods sometimes, and Egypt is the biggest country that have a direct effect at both side in that conflict, so he seems take a good shot in that direction too.

16.       alameda
3499 posts
 01 Feb 2009 Sun 02:19 am

 

Quoting cynicmystic

My last topic was removed. I guess I shold have toned down the language and not have used ´kicked ass´ to refer to Erdogan. Anyway. How do you guys feel about Erdogan striking back at the Davos. I thought it was very appropriate and to the point.

 

I´m proud of him and I wish Obama would make such a statement. Enough!!! The parties HAVE to learn to live together, share resources. When will the killing stop? The area reminds me of a spreading gangrenous wound that threatens to spoil the whole world.

 

I think the Israil has really gone way over board. Someone has to call them on it. They have gotten like a spoilt child, IMHO.

17.       thehandsom
7403 posts
 01 Feb 2009 Sun 02:31 am

 

Quoting CANLI

 Actually no, i dont think so

And i dont agree that would be the case

Ý believe he tries to play another rule in the area, and that is what its all about

He doesnt seek to be part of any camp, he wants to make his own camp, actually not a camp...

He wants to play the big brother thing.

He wants to have all the ropes in his hands .

He wants to have a good relation with everyone, and also win the platform of the Arab public.

And he also wants to make sure that the dont mistake him ´Türkiye´ with any of the others capms around

Thats why he made/is making things none of the already existing camps did.

 

Ýf we calculate his benefits.

 

1. His own people...needless to say everone of them felt that he spoke by his/her tongue.

2. Arabs and people of the area ´not governments´ they are empressed, proud...and you can add as many as you wish to describe it

Some calling him the Osmanlý aslan !

Ottoman lion !

3.Ýn the EU and USA level, they will actually get the message, that being allay doesnt mean TOTALY obay you !

4.For israel, the relation will get affected but not in a way to take a clear or a direct action, because israel needs Türkiye too

BUT....they are waiting for the right moment and wish Erdoðan has more than he already show that will keep the equation in his favore

5.Being a country that the ME listen to it will put Türkiye in another place more stronger than she already is .

6.Economical effect...he got himself a good and big market ´Arabs´

Some already said they will buy the Turkish products

As boycott effecting some countries, supporting will effect others

7. His big challenge are the government of the ME...if he can manage them as well as the people, he could move as he planed

 

Türkiye and Egypt almost have same points of view but with some difference in methods sometimes, and Egypt is the biggest country that have a direct effect at both side in that conflict, so he seems take a good shot in that direction too.

 

You are misjudging him to be honest..

I think in the end he could not control his anger but the way he acted suited very well in the political arena internally and abroad..

I dont believe he calculated what he did there carefully but he was pleased with the outcome..

If he does not change his tone (I think he will change after the elections) he will demage Turkey´s foreign policies in the world..

It is deeply disturbing to see Turkey at the same axis as  Iran and Syria. 

Economical effect/ arabs etc is not realistic either..Because most of the arabs deeply connected with the west. Almost all arabic goverments are puppets of the west.

Those goverments can not survive without western support..

So nothing is going to change easily and quickly because our prime minister showed some kasimpasa gestures in Davos..

Countries foreign policies do not change with one incidents..Or should not change with one incidents..

18.       CANLI
5084 posts
 01 Feb 2009 Sun 03:14 am

 

Quoting thehandsom

You are misjudging him to be honest..

I think in the end he could not control his anger but the way he acted suited very well in the political arena internally and abroad..

I dont believe he calculated what he did there carefully but he was pleased with the outcome..

If he does not change his tone (I think he will change after the elections) he will demage Turkey´s foreign policies in the world..

It is deeply disturbing to see Turkey at the same axis as  Iran and Syria. 

Economical effect/ arabs etc is not realistic either..Because most of the arabs deeply connected with the west. Almost all arabic goverments are puppets of the west.

Those goverments can not survive without western support..

So nothing is going to change easily and quickly because our prime minister showed some kasimpasa gestures in Davos..

Countries foreign policies do not change with one incidents..Or should not change with one incidents..

 

 But that is exactly what i am saying

That Türkiye is not seen at the same axis as  Iran and Syria.

 

He didnt want it that way.

And people of the area also do NOT want it that way !

 

They believe both camps didnt do what they want...and they are looking for something else, new leader

You dont take the the situations in the county of the area into considerations

Yes i agree, most of them if not all are just tools at the West hands

But their people are not !

Change was going on for a long time, slow one but its there

So its not just changing with one incident

Ýt was an incident in a suitable time.

 

Dont underestimate the Arab public, they are a power of their own, not very much effective for now...but its getting there.

And he wanted to use that...and Arab public are open to him now.

 

Of course countries foreign policies but they can redirected within the countries interests

And also of cource his tone will be soften...as i told you he wants all ropes in his hands and that rope too he is keen to have

 

What he did...is granting himself a role in the area and not just the audience role.

And by a heaver weight nations got measure!

19.       Melek74
1506 posts
 01 Feb 2009 Sun 03:36 am

 

Quoting femmeous

 if you listen to canli, we need 40 of them. not just for 4.

 

but when someone starts a thread on christmas she comes out with a warning that there was already an existing thread.

 

logiscs dont work on this site. welcome to canli´s regime a la egypt.

 

There are, I believe, 7 of them now, so we´re getting there.

 

 

Panem et circenses.

20.       alameda
3499 posts
 01 Feb 2009 Sun 04:03 am

 

Quoting Melek74

There are, I believe, 7 of them now, so we´re getting there.

 

 

Panem et circenses.

 

it would be nice if they were all together in one thread.....is that possible?

(37 Messages in 4 pages - View all)
1 [2] 3 4
Add reply to this discussion




Turkish Dictionary
Turkish Chat
Open mini chat
New in Forums
Why yer gördüm but yeri geziyorum
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, makes perfect sense!
Etmeyi vs etmek
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much!
Görülmez vs görünmiyor
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, very well explained!
Içeri and içeriye
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much for the detailed ...
Present continous tense
HaydiDeer: Got it, thank you!
Hic vs herhangi, degil vs yok
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much!
Rize Artvin Airport Transfer - Rize Tours
rizetours: Dear Guest; In order to make your Black Sea trip more enjoyable, our c...
What does \"kabul ettiğini\" mean?
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much for the detailed ...
Kimse vs biri (anyone)
HaydiDeer: Thank you!
Random Pictures of Turkey
Most commented