General/Off-topic |
|
|
|
Native Language
|
20. |
17 Nov 2009 Tue 05:11 pm |
Because they dont know their own native languages.
They have begun to learn a native language as a new citizen.
I think most of them were knowing street language only.
Your comment seems rather derogatory - some of the immigrants I am talking about are lawyers, doctors etc. NOT poor kids with "street language"!!!
|
|
21. |
17 Nov 2009 Tue 08:26 pm |
I think most of them were knowing street language only.
When I learned German, I didn´t learn "street language" (there are a million dialects in Germany) ... I learned the proper Grammar in school! It did, however, help alot that I was an English major in College and do know my own language very well.
|
|
22. |
17 Nov 2009 Tue 09:16 pm |
Last week I met a Turkish girl at ODTÜ in Ankara who was born and raised in the Netherlands and moved back to Turkey when she was 17. When she started speaking in Dutch to me, I realized I preferred to answer in Turkish and did so. Impossible? I may not dream flawless, but I definitely dream in fluent Turkish!
|
|
23. |
18 Nov 2009 Wed 05:30 pm |
- " You cannot dream in a foreign language."
Apperantly Angelina Jolie has never dropped in your dreams I can easily speak english in my dreams. what your teacher says is absolutely wrong.
|
|
24. |
18 Nov 2009 Wed 09:23 pm |
Actually, when I first started dreaming in Turkish, I didn´t speak much Turkish yet because I was too shy. However, the Turkish I spoke in my dreams was much more fluent than in real life since there were no inhibitions holding me back from speaking freely what I knew in the back of my mind.
Why do you believe one cannot dream in any language but its native one?
|
|
25. |
18 Nov 2009 Wed 09:30 pm |
There´s enough practical proof that it´s simply not true that you can only dream or think in your native language. I´m a native Dutchy but I also dream and think in English. It´s sometimes hard to make the switch. When I spend a long time talking in English, I´m still thinking in English when I start a Dutch conversation and it all comes out weird
|
|
26. |
18 Nov 2009 Wed 09:48 pm |
we can think in other languages if we was studying it when we are childern in my country we was learning English in age of 3 like our native language .
so we can think and dream in English like our native language
|
|
27. |
19 Nov 2009 Thu 02:31 am |
we can think in other languages if we was studying it when we are childern in my country we was learning English in age of 3 like our native language
I didn´t take German until I was in High School, then in college I took German as a second language for my English Degree and even with that small amount of German, I feel like I think in German just as well as I speak it...I don´t see the problem.
|
|
28. |
19 Nov 2009 Thu 06:00 am |
First one ought to have a command of one’s own language.
A person should learn his own language completely.
The language experts and psychologists say:
- "A person can solely think in his/her own language, can dream in his/her own language and can be happy in his/her own language.”
clo
Well, that is one school of thought. There is the language that has no boundries....all thoughts are complete, later they are given words.
Language is not only words, it is body language, facial expression, tone of voice. Words can actually confuse matters or clarify them. Too often they are used to cloud the issues. We have seen how lawyers can use words?
I really don´t think all dreams actually use words....
To be bound by only one language is sad indeed. Learning new languages expands our being. When we have the words to express our thoughts and feelings with more precision it helps actualize things.
|
|
29. |
19 Nov 2009 Thu 05:20 pm |
Well, that is one school of thought. There is the language that has no boundries....all thoughts are complete, later they are given words.
Language is not only words, it is body language, facial expression, tone of voice. Words can actually confuse matters or clarify them. Too often they are used to cloud the issues. We have seen how lawyers can use words?
I really don´t think all dreams actually use words....
To be bound by only one language is sad indeed. Learning new languages expands our being. When we have the words to express our thoughts and feelings with more precision it helps actualize things.
Very well put!!
|
|
30. |
19 Nov 2009 Thu 09:03 pm |
I don´t feel like I ever had a "native" language! We spoke 2 languages in my house and when I started going to school, I used a totally different language! I guess that means I have silent dreams (like old silent movies) and that I am incapable of thinking!
|
|
|