Welcome
Login:   Pass:     Register - Forgot Password - Resend Activation

Turkish Class Forums / Living - working in Turkey

Living - working in Turkey

Add reply to this discussion
Moderators: libralady, sonunda
N.B.
(34 Messages in 4 pages - View all)
1 2 3 4
1.       juliacernat
424 posts
 16 Mar 2007 Fri 12:52 pm

"All of us have done some things, some time, that we were told as children not to do. Or some of us do things on the holiday abroad we would not do at home. The number of Turks who have told me that when they went to Germany, England, America or Australia, they ate pork! They went to a bar! They had a drink! They went on a date with a foreigner! And so on…

We all know the expression when the cat’s away, the mice will play. When we come back home, or the cat comes home, so to say, things are different. I have received a few letters that ask the same question in a different way. Let me share one of them. It reads:

Dear Charlotte: I met my Turkish boyfriend in a bar when he was studying in my country. Since he has returned to Turkey, he calls me every night. We plan to marry and live in Turkey. One night when he called I was down at the bar with my girlfriends. The same bar where we met each other. When he realized that I was at the bar he got very angry. He jumped to conclusions and exclaimed that Europeans are too laid back about things and he told me that he does not want me to go to the bar without him. I still want my independence and I want him to be OK about this. He needs to trust me. Signed, Confused.

Dear Confused: There are two things going on here: one is called protection and possession and the other is known as a double standard. Your boyfriend believes he should be there to protect you from other guys who may approach you. In his culture a woman or group of women going to a bar unescorted, by at least one male, be it a man or younger brother, is not common. They must be “looking for fun.”

Have you heard of a double standard? Wikipedia defines a double standard as a standard applied more leniently to one group than to another. For example, the belief that it is permissible for teenage boys, but not teenage girls, to engage in premarital sex is a double standard. While double standards are generally condemned in the abstract, they are also very common. A double standard violates the principle of impartiality -- not everything goes for everyone. There is a fine line between double standard and hypocrisy. If a man believes it is his right to have extramarital affairs but that his wife does not have such a right, he holds a double standard. A man who condemns all adultery while maintaining a mistress is a hypocrite.

Your boyfriend is displaying a double standard: It was OK for you to go to this club to meet each other but not OK for you to go now. But it is more than just a double standard. Before, you were just “a girl.” What you did would not reflect on him or his family honor. Now you are “his girl,” and your behavior will affect the honor of all women in his family.

It seems to me you have some serious issues to think about before you jump into the relationship lock, stock and barrel.

Human beings want to be trusted and crave intimacy: Everyone needs to love and be loved. This is true of single culture relationships and is still true of cross cultural relationships. Because of the extra need to understand where each other are coming from, cross-cultural relationships need extra time and effort".

Charlotte McPherson, "Met in the Bar!If you love me you will trust me", Today`s Zaman, 16.03.2007

2.       libralady
5152 posts
 16 Mar 2007 Fri 02:15 pm

I bet that story will ring true in many ears.

3.       MrX67
2540 posts
 16 Mar 2007 Fri 02:50 pm

to be,seem like and to suppose,they all so different things.and thats certain there r many deep differences between life stilies and cultures.so i think the most important thing to recogize reasons of differences for to judging diferences

4.       robyn :D
2640 posts
 16 Mar 2007 Fri 07:01 pm

that post is soo true like when u met you can be sure he liked you in the nice, fitted clothes you wore, but now he thinks u are mother theresa ..yeh right

5.       Elisa
0 posts
 16 Mar 2007 Fri 09:34 pm

Quoting robyn :

that post is soo true like when u met you can be sure he liked you in the nice, fitted clothes you wore, but now he thinks u are mother theresa ..yeh right




I don't think that was the bottom line of the article..

6.       robyn :D
2640 posts
 16 Mar 2007 Fri 10:05 pm

Quoting Elisa:

Quoting robyn :

that post is soo true like when u met you can be sure he liked you in the nice, fitted clothes you wore, but now he thinks u are mother theresa ..yeh right




I don't think that was the bottom line of the article..



it wasn't..just another example of the same sort of thing

7.       azade
1606 posts
 16 Mar 2007 Fri 10:40 pm

Quoting robyn :

that post is soo true like when u met you can be sure he liked you in the nice, fitted clothes you wore, but now he thinks u are mother theresa ..yeh right



Oh I have seen so many examples of this in my time in Alanya.

Also turkish men who meet up with foreign girls on holiday and then when the girl leaves he promises her she's unique but the very next night look for new woman because he expect she's doing the same.

8.       robyn :D
2640 posts
 16 Mar 2007 Fri 10:43 pm

Quoting azade:

Quoting robyn :

that post is soo true like when u met you can be sure he liked you in the nice, fitted clothes you wore, but now he thinks u are mother theresa ..yeh right



Oh I have seen so many examples of this in my time in Alanya.

Also turkish men who meet up with foreign girls on holiday and then when the girl leaves he promises her she's unique but the very next night look for new woman because he expect she's doing the same.


yes that too

9.       metehan2001
501 posts
 17 Mar 2007 Sat 04:48 am

Well girls, I don't like the double-standard as well. On the other hand, we have an idiom in Turkish ' Vurun abalıya!'. I think what you are doing with your posts here suits to this idiom. I will not translate the idiom, but if you give a try yourselves to translate it,then you will understand what Turkish men feel after reading your posts in this thread.

10.       deli
5904 posts
 17 Mar 2007 Sat 04:57 am

Vur abalıya! Jump on him while he´s down! (a reproach).

11.       metehan2001
501 posts
 17 Mar 2007 Sat 05:03 am

Quoting deli:

Vur abalıya! Jump on him while he´s down! (a reproach).


Thanks for such a quick translation, deli. As a Turkish man, I just felt so, when I have read the above posts. Do you think that making such a generalization can be true for men (Turkish, or whatever)?

12.       Trudy
7887 posts
 17 Mar 2007 Sat 10:55 am

Quoting metehan2001:

Do you think that making such a generalization can be true for men (Turkish, or whatever)?



Some men, yes, some women too. Not all. Is that what you want to hear?

13.       azade
1606 posts
 17 Mar 2007 Sat 02:36 pm

Quoting metehan2001:

Quoting deli:

Vur abalıya! Jump on him while he´s down! (a reproach).


Thanks for such a quick translation, deli. As a Turkish man, I just felt so, when I have read the above posts. Do you think that making such a generalization can be true for men (Turkish, or whatever)?



No it's certaintly not true for all turkish men - only for a very small percentage. However I do believe the initial post in this thread is true for a larger part of turkish men. Still not all, but some. Generalizations are unfortunately sometimes hard to avoid - didn't mean to offend anyone.

14.       robyn :D
2640 posts
 17 Mar 2007 Sat 04:32 pm

Quoting azade:

Quoting metehan2001:

Quoting deli:

Vur abalıya! Jump on him while he´s down! (a reproach).


Thanks for such a quick translation, deli. As a Turkish man, I just felt so, when I have read the above posts. Do you think that making such a generalization can be true for men (Turkish, or whatever)?



No it's certaintly not true for all turkish men - only for a very small percentage. However I do believe the initial post in this thread is true for a larger part of turkish men. Still not all, but some. Generalizations are unfortunately sometimes hard to avoid - didn't mean to offend anyone.



I'm with azade, the commnts were not supposed to offend anyone and it isn't just Turkish men but just some men in general.Sorry if anyone misunderstood or took offence it certainly wasn't meant, just observations from experience. Apologies once again

15.       CARTEL
63 posts
 17 Mar 2007 Sat 04:49 pm

Quoting metehan2001:

Quoting deli:

Vur abalıya! Jump on him while he´s down! (a reproach).


Thanks for such a quick translation, deli. As a Turkish man, I just felt so, when I have read the above posts. Do you think that making such a generalization can be true for men (Turkish, or whatever)?



metehan is right

16.       juliacernat
424 posts
 17 Mar 2007 Sat 04:59 pm

please find below the continuation of the article:


"[...] lots of people want to understand better what a healthy relationship should be like.
Correspondents are unsure whether a characteristic they see in their partner and do not like is “cultural” or a “personal trait.” This works both ways; sometimes they are a non-Turk with a Turkish loved one, sometimes vice versa.

Writer Hara Estroff Marano has researched many sources and questioned many experts on this subject, thus culling some basic relationship rules. I came across these recently and thought they would be very helpful. The first I want to share with you is what I might term a “Golden Rule.”

If you don’t understand or like something your partner is doing, ask about it and why he or she is doing it. Talk and explore, don’t assume.
Talking together about how such and such a behavior is surprising for you, is it normal in his/her culture, etc. can help solve many misunderstandings.

Another pearl of wisdom from Marano is:

Solve problems as they arise. Don’t let resentments simmer.

If you wait until you have a whole list of issues then you will probably be past solving them! Either you will be so angry that you cannot talk together calmly and respectfully, or the behavior/attitude will be so engrained the other will be unable to change.

And if the problem is not raised by you, but your partner raises a problem they have with you, what does Marano advise?

Listen, truly listen, to your partner’s concerns and complaints without judgment. Empathy is crucial. Look at things from your partner’s perspective as well as your own.

Here are a few more of Marano’s ideas: They are universal, but will be influenced by culture. I suggest you print these rules off and work through them.

Choose a partner wisely and well. Evaluate a potential partner as you would a friend -- look at their character, personality, values, their generosity of spirit, the relationship between their words and actions, their relationships with others.

Know your partner’s beliefs about relationships. Make sure your ideas don’t conflict.

Know your needs and speak up for them clearly. Closeness cannot occur without honesty. Your partner is not a mind reader.

Respect, respect, respect. Mutual respect is essential to a good relationship.

View yourselves as a team, which means you are two unique individuals bringing different perspectives and strengths. That is the value of a team: your differences.

Know how to manage differences; this is the key to success in a relationship.

Learn to negotiate. Modern relationships no longer rely on roles cast by culture.

Don’t rush things. If you need time to understand each other better, then take it. Far better to get married a few months later, totally sure you are committing yourself to the person you can love for the rest of your life, than to walk down the aisle quickly with your fingers crossed hoping for the best.

“The path of true love never did run smooth.” Working through issues will make you stronger people and enable your relationship to grow. If you genuinely love, you will trust!"


Charlotte McPherson, "He loves me....He loves me not...", Today's Zaman, 17.03.2007

17.       vineyards
1954 posts
 03 Apr 2007 Tue 05:48 pm

18.       catwoman
8933 posts
 03 Apr 2007 Tue 06:45 pm

Quoting vineyards:

Note: All "yous" in this post refer to the persons featured in the original article.

Turks are Turks and Brits are Brits. Not all Turks are like the rest of the Turks and the same goes for the Brits.
If she is not happy with her Turkish boyfriend, she might consider dropping him.

There is no reason for making unnecessary analogies such as mouse going on holiday and tasting pork for a change and metamorphosing into his old self on returning to his hometown. You are the one chasing the poor mouse from one corner to another and what you are going through is the frustration that happens when one realizes that there is not just one culture in the world and it is the wrongest thing to try to judge a culture through the perspective of another.

You may point out to greater personal freedoms in your culture, I could be boastful of the fact that people are less inclined to suicide or I'd praise virtues of the lower violent crime rate in this country. You could claim that women enjoy more freedom in your country and I could point out to the fact that they won the suffrage first in Turkey and I might also want to draw your attention to the ever strong porn industry in the civilized part of the world and to all forms of exploitation of the female body by way of soft porn and other erotic publications. I could criticize the Catholic mind set on account that it doesn't allow divorces or abortions. If I want to compare, I can come up with millions of other examples.

The punchlne is : set the mouse free.



Yet, I didn't think that anybody "judged" Turkish culture or said that one is better then the other. However, issues like double standards in areas that aren't so common for western societies is a good topic to talk about, don't you think? I get the impression that any kind of criticism or even a statement about the reality meets with a lot of offended feelings. Whoever posts something uncomfortable about Turkish culture has to quickly apologize...

19.       vineyards
1954 posts
 03 Apr 2007 Tue 07:32 pm

20.       Trudy
7887 posts
 03 Apr 2007 Tue 07:38 pm

Quoting vineyards:

Quoting juliacernat:



Your boyfriend is displaying a double standard: It was OK for you to go to this club to meet each other but not OK for you to go now. But it is more than just a double standard. Before, you were just “a girl.” What you did would not reflect on him or his family honor. Now you are “his girl,” and your behavior will affect the honor of all women in his family.

It seems to me you have some serious issues to think about before you jump into the relationship lock, stock and barrel.



Who is the author 'judging' in the above paragraphs and what does she base her argument on? Turks have one kind of family and that is conservative, is that right? Maybe this guy is a very jealous man belonging to a very modern family. Everyone is deemed innocent unless proven guilty.



Does the author say that this jealous and 'double standard' behaviour is typical Turkish or exclusively Turkish? I don't read that, she just says that (some) men behave like this. And I think she's right. So why this defensiveness, Vineyards? No one says you're such a man.

21.       vineyards
1954 posts
 03 Apr 2007 Tue 07:45 pm

22.       Trudy
7887 posts
 03 Apr 2007 Tue 07:52 pm

Quoting vineyards:

If we rule out the "Turk" option what remains behind is still a stereotype sans cultural references.



Of course it is a stereotype. But again, no one says it is about ALL men, just some. Or would you deny that?

23.       catwoman
8933 posts
 03 Apr 2007 Tue 10:46 pm

Quoting vineyards:

If we rule out the "Turk" option what remains behind is still a stereotype sans cultural references.



Vineyards, I completely understand why you react like this when you read that Turkish men have double standards when it comes to what's ok to do for them vs their girlfriends/wifes/fiancees. I understand why something like this upsets you because you know that that's not the whole truth, yet you might get the impression that this is all that people might think of Turkish men. However, although this is not the whole truth, this is definitely part of it and you must trust that every person with half a brain will be (and is) aware of that. How do you react when you read about some single phenomenon from another culture? I'm sure you don't say "oh, those xxx are always yyy", and this is also how this article sounds to a foreign ear. Even if it is a stereotype, it's not a made-up stereotype, it is true for some group of Turkish people. Many people confirmed that they've witnessed such behavior as well as they witnessed a different kind of behavior.

Maybe we don't write about cultural differences in the best possible way, in a way that wouldn't leave it go guessing whether it's the whole truth or just part of it (especially for those who don't know anything about the culture in question from other sources). We usually have to end up defending our cultures saying 'that's not all there is'. However, you can trust that people here are more educated about Turkey then an average person is.
I guess my point is that even though it's upsetting to read such things about your culture, you may consider that this is both part of the reality as well as people reading it are aware that this is only a 'part'.

24.       aiça
posts
 03 Apr 2007 Tue 11:46 pm

Catwoman, I'm really impressed by the way you put this. Very well said and very fair.
Being Swiss the reactions here sometimes seem to be exaggerated to me, but I know it is only another kind of cultural difference... Swiss people tend to make themselves less in every aspect than they are, we don't boast with our culture. It can be difficult for us to bear those reactions sometimes, but on the other hand they are the expression of something beautiful, the love for someone's own country and culture...

25.       robyn :D
2640 posts
 03 Apr 2007 Tue 11:49 pm

i agree with you and catwoman also..i'm sure everyone with half a brain here is aware that steroetypes dont count for everyone from a particular race

26.       vineyards
1954 posts
 04 Apr 2007 Wed 12:56 am

27.       catwoman
8933 posts
 04 Apr 2007 Wed 02:36 am

Thank you Aica and Robyn .

Vineyards - yes, a person is a measure of everything, BUT don't let this quote make you self righteous instead of trying to learn, understand and communicate. Don't just ask us to understand YOU, but you also need to understand US, or whatever the other side of the conflict is, if you don't want to make it look like an 'us and them' situation.

28.       vineyards
1954 posts
 04 Apr 2007 Wed 04:36 am

29.       catwoman
8933 posts
 04 Apr 2007 Wed 06:17 am

unfortunately, to me this doesn't feel like a conversation Vineyards, but more like your monologues... you really should try to listen a bit more and not just expect everybody to agree with you.

30.       vineyards
1954 posts
 04 Apr 2007 Wed 01:04 pm

31.       libralady
5152 posts
 04 Apr 2007 Wed 01:34 pm

To me this discussion is rather like the Turkish reading our newspapers, and thinking what they read reflects what is a normal way of life in Britain today. (In particular what I call the "gutter press" Daily Mirror, Sun, Daily Star - you know, the ones adorned with hugely inflated breasts and liposuctioned thighs aka Jordan)

And thinking that all British women have illegitimate children by four different fathers, we all live on social security, we are all racist, that we all love Tony Blair. That all women will have sex with any man walking, or that we have no morals. All men stay in the pub til' all hours and drink themselves to oblivion on a daily basis and they are all football holigans.

Judge the person you know as you know them and not on what you read about a nation.

Sorry if this has gone a little off track.................

32.       vineyards
1954 posts
 04 Apr 2007 Wed 02:40 pm

33.       libralady
5152 posts
 04 Apr 2007 Wed 05:23 pm

I did say I had gone off track............. and I am implying that what you read is not always to be believed, I'll go back to sleep now

34.       catwoman
8933 posts
 05 Apr 2007 Thu 09:00 pm

Quoting vineyards:

I am looking forward to your answer. In other words, I am still listening to you.



Dear vineyards, I'm sorry it took me so long to reply, but I didn't know what to say because it really feels to me like we are not communicating about in these posts. That was the point in my last comment.
I don't know what else can be said here - I understand your reaction to this article, but I also think that you don't need to feel upset about it because nobody here will base their opinions on stereotypes.

(34 Messages in 4 pages - View all)
1 2 3 4
Add reply to this discussion




Turkish Dictionary
Turkish Chat
Open mini chat
New in Forums
Why yer gördüm but yeri geziyorum
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, makes perfect sense!
Etmeyi vs etmek
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much!
Görülmez vs görünmiyor
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, very well explained!
Içeri and içeriye
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much for the detailed ...
Present continous tense
HaydiDeer: Got it, thank you!
Hic vs herhangi, degil vs yok
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much!
Rize Artvin Airport Transfer - Rize Tours
rizetours: Dear Guest; In order to make your Black Sea trip more enjoyable, our c...
What does \"kabul ettiğini\" mean?
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much for the detailed ...
Kimse vs biri (anyone)
HaydiDeer: Thank you!
Random Pictures of Turkey
Most liked