So many Turkish verbs are a combination of a noun and and auxiliary like etmek, vermek, olmak. In these verbs all the meaning is carried by the noun and the verb is needed only as a hanger of grammatical elements. Often they are so tightly joined that nothing seems to touch the noun: it stays in the same form always and the combination works as a unit in the sentence.
Banka tazminat ödemeyi kabul etti.
Evde kalmasını tavsiye ettim.
I have noticed that this is typical in the cases where the noun is an Arabicism which hasn´t adapted into Turkish language as an independent lexeme.
What is causing bigger trouble is that this group of verbs (I wish to find a word for them) is not homogenous. The most difficult cases for a learner in my opinion are those where the noun acts as an independent word also. I mean like devam etmek, karar vermek, söz vermek, farkına varmak, cevap vermek, ihtiyaç olmak etc. I can somehow handle them if they govern a simple noun (a dictionary helps to choose the correct case ending) but as soon as a complete sentence is inlayed as their modifier the trouble begins. It´s hard to choose 1) if the noun itself has to undergo changes and b) what is the relation between the inlayed sentence and the noun (adjectival modifier, izafet/compound: definite with genitive or undefinite with nominative).
For instance, fark seems to act as an independent noun in farkına varmak ´to notice´. The preceeding participle takes a genitive:
PKK savaşı kaybettiğinin farkına vardı.
I think this represents the other end of the continuum where the noun part conjugates and governs modifiers as a normal constituent, though at the same time part of this idiom, farkina varmak.
I´m lost also if the noun of this combination denotes a speech act, like in cevap or söz vermek where the noun looks like the usual object. But is it treated like one?
Sana söz verdim. (Why is there no accusative ending in söz - or is it indefinite?)
Gelmeye söz verdim. (You what??)
I´m sorry, my question is not well organized and it gives a bad headache. But it´s the best I can do right now. I hope it makes some sort of sense anyway. Maybe someone knows a good article which could tie these problems together somehow?
Edited (9/13/2011) by Abla
|