I think you are selfish if you do an action, which MAIN goal is satisfy yourself. If you help somebody else, and your biggest goal is not to satisfy yourself, it is not persé selfish. Satisfying yourself might be a nice side effect of helping somebody else, but this does not make the act selfish.
By the way, I have never hated anybody because they hurt my ego My ego is not easily hurt I think that is a very ego-centric vision on hate, to view hatred as something that only comes from hurt ego´s.
1)I agree with you. But if you examine human behaviors you will see our main goal is always satisfy ourselves. You said yourself you feel joy when you see a smile on a child´s face. But you don´t feel any joy when you see a smile on a serial killer´s face. So you choose people you want to help. This is egoist. A serial killer is a human too. And his smile is not different from a child´s smile. If he is in jail, there is no obstacle to help him and make him smile. Because if you want to make a bad person good one you must help him. I am sure Jesus would approve this. You can see a lot of serial killers or rapers became good Christian believers in prisons. There are priests in prisons also helping criminals. So it is a moral thing to help them. According to common ethics you should not choose people you want to help.
2) You say you have never hated anyone who hurt your ego. Let me prove you are wrong with your words. You talk like you hate or don´t like serial killers? Have you ever asked yourself why? Because they hurt your ego.There are two types of ego. One is the normal ego, other is super ego. The superego is the aspect of personality that holds all of our internalized moral standards and ideals that we acquire from both parents and society--our sense of right and wrong. The superego provides guidelines for making judgments. According to Freud, the superego begins to emerge at around age five.(1) So we can say superego is a representative of society in ourselves. A serial killer´s crimes challenges our superego. We don´t accept them because we are taught they are bad. So we don´t like serial killers. Generally we hate them. Because thinking their crimes makes us sad and scared. They challenge our super ego. But you know soldiers also can kill a lot of people. But you don´t hate them. You love them.Why? Because you are taught they are the people who protect you. You think they will never harm you. You trust them. This pleases your superego.
3) So everything is about ego. Freud saw these and called humans evil or bad by nature. But i don´t agree with him. Being egoist is not always a bad thing.
(1)http://psychology.about.com/od/theoriesofpersonality/a/personalityelem.htm
I want to say something. You are objecting me with the arguments which my inner voice objected me. It is very interesting to hear same objections. I also objected myself with these arguments but i convinced myself. Hope i will convince you too. Bye.
And please read this article: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operant_conditioning
Edited (8/3/2010) by gokuyum
Edited (8/3/2010) by gokuyum
Edited (8/3/2010) by gokuyum
Edited (8/3/2010) by gokuyum
|