Welcome
Login:   Pass:     Register - Forgot Password - Resend Activation

Turkish Class Forums / News articles, events, announcements

News articles, events, announcements

Add reply to this discussion
what is the opinion on this??
(151 Messages in 16 pages - View all)
<<  ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 [12] 13 14 15 16
110.       SuiGeneris
3922 posts
 21 Dec 2006 Thu 11:43 pm

Quoting femme_fatal:

Quoting SuiGeneris:

Quoting femme_fatal:


canli, you advise turks not to change? to stick to the old feudalistic customs and traditions? very odd! very unwise!
the person who doesnt interact, communicate or learn from others becomes a complete idiot whos very limited and awkward in relationships. it is the same with a nation (any nation, dont wanna give a reason to turks to use this as an attack as usual). the more you are closed and isolated and stuck with your own behavour the more emotional and social cripple you are!



may i ask you a question?
have you ever been to Turkey?
and what do you really know about this country?


never been to! then what? does it change anything?
never seen pharaos as well, but im fond of the history of egypt! i do read as well about the history of mongols and never been to mongolia. have i not right to speak about these issues? im not claiming i know everything, but i wouldnt join if i had no idea on the cultural, historical and religious topics.
why does my participation in this forum bother? why do take a defensive position all the time? why do u defend? it shows that u have things to hide and defend otherwise you would not bother yourself coming and argueing.

aha, i know, if i praise turks and tell that they absolute ideals, then your reaction would be different. why do you prefer a lie to the healthy criticism?



you are really so funny
who said that to you dont read and search about history or whatever you want to
but i see that as long as you search about history... you started to live with those things you read...
come to the world dear time is going on...
history is a part of life... but you cant live up to the history... as everything is changing...
i am not defending anything here dont worry... i just wondered...
may i ask you another question?
where are you from?

and another i hope i am not asking too much...
do you plan to visit Turkey?
i am asking because the tickets to time 1914-1918 are booked i am afraid...

111.       CANLI
5084 posts
 21 Dec 2006 Thu 11:50 pm

femme_fatal,

Thank you for enlightening me,that was very thoughtful of you .

And among the words that i should know its diffences ,is insult.
There is much difference between insult and attack.
İ don't need to wait to be insulted so then i consider this attack!
As i see,and from my point of view,attacking is a wide word contains disapproval and criticism too.

And if you didn't see those in this thread,so i'm sorry,i cann't do anything about it,but i did see it.

Maybe because me too,is some emotional,proud,brain washed Eastern !

False propaganda,brainwashed ,illusion ??!!!

İ'm sorry,but i really don't know what you are talking about.

15,20 years ago,i would have agreed with you on such terms,but now ?!!!

The only illusion exist in any country,is the one man doing for himself.

İf you have false propaganda,there are always satellites,Net,lots and many things would make you contact to the outside world.

İf you chose not,then its your own fault.
The world had become a small vellage,who want can know what is going in the other side,not to mention what is going inside too.

But note that,i said who wants.

And i adviced Turks of what ?!
İf you read my post,you can see exactly what i said.

But coming to that,first,i don't think Turk need any advice,because they have eyes,ears,brains just like others,and can see ,read and learn from their experinces and from others too,and decide what is good for them better than anyone else.

Second,yes,i really hope from my heart they don't lose their traditions,and customs too.

İf you follow what is happening in other West communities,you would understand what is the importance of traditions.

Of course there would be some re-evaluation to them,and only Turks can do it,not have it made for them!

And at the end,coming to the brain washed part,you know a TV news channel called Al-Gizera ?
Of course you must know it.
This channel has extended its waves,or whatever they call it,so it can reach till the USA,and they can watch it there.

You want to guess what have USA done ?

Now,talk about Eastern brain washing !

112.       MrX67
2540 posts
 21 Dec 2006 Thu 11:54 pm

i think some of friends thinking theirself very intellectual with their rich book collection???but i saw main of em who has a very shallow life perspective back of crowdede books...you can read many books,but thats not easy to get whats goin life with the words of others,so its better to catch realities with ur own without reading any line..

113.       femme_fatal
0 posts
 22 Dec 2006 Fri 12:28 am

canli, we are talking about turkey not usa and right now i dont wanna talk of usa and al-jazira (btw, congratulations on its extension!). it ll be sort of a off topic, some people hate off topics.
its my personal conclusion that when u release urself from the jail of traditions and start breathing fully with your lungs u become healthier, the air freshens up your blood circullation and bring more oxygen to your brain but when you are overloaded with all the customs and tradiotions you simply cant freely go ahead. have u seen those who lack the air? they say it became darker in their eyes.
probably the tradition makes you feel safe, your ancestors lived with it and you also live within the scheme. nothing new, no change, no innovation, no searching for new styles.

talking about the western countries that lost their traditions, it is very simple, since western countries hosted many many other nationalities, it became multi-cultural, it became impossible to keep people to the local traditions, so they got mixed up. actually, western slowly becomes eastern due to the strong traditional eastern immigrants.

hey, canli, thank you very much for your compliments.

114.       CANLI
5084 posts
 22 Dec 2006 Fri 12:39 am

Quoting femme_fatal:


hey, canli, thank you very much for your compliments.


Bir şey değil ,anytime

115.       Joey
0 posts
 22 Dec 2006 Fri 12:46 am

Quoting MrX67:

i think some of friends thinking theirself very intellectual with their rich book collection???but i saw main of em who has a very shallow life perspective back of crowdede books...you can read many books,but thats not easy to get whats goin life with the words of others,so its better to catch realities with ur own without reading any line..



Very well said MrX67.You cannot learn everything just by reading books.You have got to live somewhere to learn the culture.There are to many polarized views here. On another thread we had somebody criticizing the slaughter of a sheep for The Kurban Bayramı.We must show more respect for other peoples cultures.

116.       sophie
2712 posts
 22 Dec 2006 Fri 12:51 am

Quoting qdemir:

One should be cautious when talking about other's sensitive feelings, or about some issues unless s/he is well informed concerning an issues other than having some hearsay things. For istance:

Some years ago a Greek cypriot was shot dead by a Turkish soldier while he was trying to remove the Turkish flag from its post. The flag post was, of course, on the Turkish side. Some said that it wasnt worth for just a piece of cloth without knowing what the national flag means to the Turkish. The people who said it wasnt worth have their flags' design on their panties or shorts (we dont look down to them. It is their flag in the end). We have our flag above our heads or on our hearts. Every single Turkish soldier does the same thing if anyone dare to touch our flag with ill-intention.

After the independence of İzmir some tried to burn the Greek flag, but Atatürk prevented them from doing that and told them they were wrong. We respect other nations's flags as much as we respect ours...



Dear qdemir (apologies to the rest of you, for going off topic, but i had to reply )

I remember the incident with the Greek-Cypriot who was shot in his attempt to take down the Turkish flag although it was on Turkish ground (now how this ground became Turkish, is another story). If you ask me, it was rather silly of him and he lost his life cause he was behaving with fanatism. Maybe they could solve the issue without dropping blood, but it was their right to defend their flag and I respect it. I never saw this man as a hero, unlike the most Greeks who thought he was.

As for Izmir and the Asia Minor catastrophe, this is a long story and I can discuss it for days if you want. But to cut it short, I think that it was caused because of the Greek stupidity. They were living in peace with the Turks and they would probably be living still, if they were not asking for more. Their minds were flying over their heads and they were considering themselves strong enough to get Ankara. How stupid! It was your land and you were right to kick them out of it. My heart bleeds for the innocent people who lost their properties, their families and their own lives for the insanity of some empty headed politicians. And I respect and admire Ataturk, for saving his own country, for not attacking back (it would be easy to take all Trakya and Macedonia back, till Selanik) and saying that he only wanted his country safe. For that he was fighting. Was not looking to anyone else’s land.

Of course, I find other faults in things that Turks did to Greeks, such as the events of September 1955 and many others. But as you see, Im criticizing my own nation when needed, Im open to any kind of discussion and I m not spreading poison around, or even feel negatively about the Turks. The opposite actually.

I have read history, especially my country’s and, since it’s closely related to Turkey’s history, I can tell that I am also informed about both Ataturk and the Turkish society through the last centuries. And apart from what I read in the books, I have brains too, which I love to use. We all claim that a story has to be told by both sides so that someone can come to proper conclusions. The problem is that whenever I try to find out about the opinion of the “other side”, I always crash on thick walls. Very few of you are opened to any kind of comment, different than “Turkey is a paradise and everything Turks do, is brave and wise “. For one last time: by asking or commenting, we are not trying to insult your country. We are only trying to learn and understand it’s history and it’s present function.

p.s. as for India and the holly cows, of course I would never laugh on those people's belief, but I would definately ask how come and a cow is considered to be holly. They would probably laugh at my ignorance, but I don't think they would ask me to shut my mouth up and not dare to discuss such a sacred issue

117.       CANLI
5084 posts
 22 Dec 2006 Fri 12:56 am

Ok femme,
3 things here,

First,talking about USA,was same as this topic of the thread,but even deeper.
At least Türkiye got a law about it,but USA is preventing from hearing others point of view other than its own
So much for a democratic country , huh ?

Second,why you're feeling traditions and customs is like a jail ?
Why don't you see them as something coming from your own believes too,therefor,you can breath fresh air inside them too.
İts not a matter of being safe inside them,its a matter of organizing,system we believe in.
İf you are thinking this way,then that goes for all rules too which is rulling the countries.
Because traditions are just unwritten rules,an laws.
So if you want to free yourself from the rules dear,the world will become a jungle.

And that is one of the reasons USA and UK calaiming not drawing back from İraq,because there its like a jungle

All leads to everything dear,as i said before,it become a small vellage.

Third,i don't agree with you about the reason that the Western countries losing their traditions is the immigration of peoples from other countries.
Of course immigration has a big effect,but have a great effect in adding to traditions,not in lose them.
And if you watch the American society,it contains lots of nationalities,Chines,İtalians,Easterns,and all are keeping their traditions.
Except the Westerns,because they lost it,the reason ?
İ don't know,but i guess it was some thought same as you say,to breath fresh air !

And thx about your congrates,although its not mine,its arabian channel,i'm Egyptian

Btw,where are you from ?

118.       aenigma x
0 posts
 22 Dec 2006 Fri 12:57 am

Quoting KeithL:

Its not ironic. Ataturk purposely set it up this way. He made sure that no follower of his could take the powers he set up and lead Turkey the wrong direction. Additionally, this also assured that sympathizers of the Osmans or any other Islamic based government could not lead the country away from its secularism.
The military is the protector of the people, not the protector of the politicians.
Why do you think that the approval of Turkey's military and general staff is always between 95 and 99%?

What other country do you know where the military is so respected by its people?



Keith L – you have a strange way of arguing your point. I find increasingly that I am arguing with other members comments’, more than the issue under discussion. You ask “what other country do you know where military is so respected by its people?”. The answer is easy, any “police state”. Fascism is defended by such dedicated and respected forces too! Not a good example!

Ataturk did set up the country in this way because he was changing the country radically and rightly needed to protect both his ideals and Turkey. However, I feel it has been allowed to continue for two long. Ataturk was a liberal minded, forward thinking and inventive leader who I am sure would be horrified to find that his country’s policies have remained relatively stagnant since his death (apart from the forced hand of the EU application).

One of his 6 main fundamentals? REFORMISM!
“Positive science is the torch held aloft by the Turkish people as it progresses on the path of civilisation.”


119.       SuiGeneris
3922 posts
 22 Dec 2006 Fri 01:06 am

Quoting sophie:


And I respect and admire Ataturk, for saving his own country, for not attacking back (it would be easy to take all Trakya and Macedonia back, till Selanik) and saying that he only wanted his country safe. For that he was fighting. Was not looking to anyone else’s land.



Ataturk is one of the biggest leaders came to earth...
Cengiz Han, The Great Iskender etc.
and he was chosen as the leader of the "age"...

what makes him unique is,
cengiz han and iskender was about getting more and more land...

but what Ataturk did was for only defending his country...

anyway... did you know that "Latife Hanım"-the name of Ataturks wife and the book that author was sued-
herself said to her parents to shut their mouth and keep her letters as secret... for only because she was Ataturks wife?

120.       uYkuSuz
614 posts
 22 Dec 2006 Fri 01:23 am

Quoting Joey:


Very well said MrX67.You cannot learn everything just by reading books.You have got to live somewhere to learn the culture.There are to many polarized views here. On another thread we had somebody criticizing the slaughter of a sheep for The Kurban Bayramı.We must show more respect for other peoples cultures.


+1
You are absolutely right.

(151 Messages in 16 pages - View all)
<<  ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 [12] 13 14 15 16
Add reply to this discussion




Turkish Dictionary
Turkish Chat
Open mini chat
New in Forums
Why yer gördüm but yeri geziyorum
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, makes perfect sense!
Etmeyi vs etmek
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much!
Görülmez vs görünmiyor
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much, very well explained!
Içeri and içeriye
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much for the detailed ...
Present continous tense
HaydiDeer: Got it, thank you!
Hic vs herhangi, degil vs yok
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much!
Rize Artvin Airport Transfer - Rize Tours
rizetours: Dear Guest; In order to make your Black Sea trip more enjoyable, our c...
What does \"kabul ettiğini\" mean?
HaydiDeer: Thank you very much for the detailed ...
Kimse vs biri (anyone)
HaydiDeer: Thank you!
Random Pictures of Turkey
Most liked
Major Vowel Harmony

Turkish lesson by admin
Level: beginner